Determining below-cost tendering and identifying post-award performance risks (five risk signals + two-stage monitoring)
Below-cost tendering shall be rejected at evaluation (Bidding Law Article 33 as the superior basis; MOHURD Order 43 Article 42; MOT Order 2018 No. 13 Article 32); once awarded, the consequence is invalid award, not repricing—low tenderers can only recoup losses via the 11 lawful contract price adjustment events of GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.1.1, precisely where performance risk clusters. Identification = pre-award inverted-margin ledger diagnosis + in-performance monitoring of three lines (cash chain, variations and claims, quality and safety): five signals—cash break, scrimping, safety-spending cuts, malicious variations/claims, mid-way exit and delay; responses: settlement blocking per 8.7.6, payment control, intensified quality/safety oversight, approve variations before implementation.
Applicable Codes
- 中华人民共和国招标投标法(2017修正)第三十三条
- 房屋建筑和市政基础设施工程施工招标投标管理办法(住建部令第43号,2018修正)第四十二条
- 铁路工程建设项目招标投标管理办法(交通运输部令2018年第13号)第三十二条
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第6.1.3条、第8.1.1条、第8.7.6条
- GB 50652-2011 第8.3.1条
Topic Positioning
Compliance characterization of below-cost tendering (evaluation rejection; invalid award, not repricing) + two-stage identification of post-award performance risks (ex-ante tender price-structure diagnosis, in-process monitoring), with five risk signals and response levers. Answers "when a tender price is below corporate cost, how to identify subsequent performance risks."
Core Conclusions
- Superior law: Bidding Law Article 33: "Tenderers may not compete with tenders below cost, submit tenders in another's name, or win tenders by fraud in other ways"—a mandatory provision and the master source for below-cost tendering governance.
- Evaluation characterization: where a tender is obviously lower than others and may be below the tenderer's corporate cost, the evaluation committee may demand a written explanation with supporting materials (MOHURD Order 43 Article 42); "where the evaluation committee determines through deliberation that the tender is below the tenderer's corporate cost, it shall not recommend the tenderer as a successful candidate or successful tenderer." Railway works (MOT Order 2018 No. 13, Article 32) goes further: "where the tenderer cannot prove the reasonableness of its price, the evaluation committee shall determine it as below-cost tendering and reject the tender."
- Award characterization: once awarded, the consequence is invalid award, not repricing—the tenderer cannot mark up because it "tendered low"; its own miscalculations and errors are in principle not re-priced at settlement. GB/T 50500-2024 Article 6.1.3: "the tenderer's tender price shall not be below cost, nor above the tender price ceiling published by the employer."
- Loss-recoupment logic: a below-cost project loses cash with every step; the only lawful recoupment channel is the 11 contract price adjustment events of GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.1.1 (errors and omissions in the BOQ, provisional sums, provisional sums for specified materials/nominated works, main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions, dayworks, changes in costs, laws/regulations/policy changes, variations, additional works, claims, other adjustments agreed by both parties)—identifying performance risk means watching these recoupment moves, and the chain reaction when recoupment fails.
- Two-stage identification:
- Stage 1 (bidding period, most effective ex ante): price each BOQ item using the contractor's in-house norms (individual cost) to produce a "tender price vs cost" inverted-margin ledger—locate inverted items (tender price below cost), loss amounts and shares; focus on whether three categories are squeezed to the limit: preliminaries (scaffolding/formwork/temporary works and site establishment costs), allocated overhead, statutory levies and fees (China's non-competable social insurance and housing fund charges) and taxes and duties (VAT under the current standard); whether the risk reserve is zero; the more the inversion concentrates in the main structure and in work billable only near closeout, the higher the risk.
- Stage 2 (performance period, three parallel monitoring lines): (1) cash chain—abnormal progress payment applications (early/bunched/mismatched to actual progress), supplier demands and stoppages, migrant-wage arrears, performance security calls; (2) variations and claims—variations clustering on loss-making items, abnormal quantity inflation on loss items, material substitution downgrades, derivation of new built-up rates for low-price items under the guise of "additional works"; (3) quality and safety—scrimping, concrete/rebar grade downgrades, abnormal inspection lots, cuts to mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions (a non-competable fee in China; GB 50652-2011 Article 8.3.1—risk-management fees must not be discounted), non-cooperation with concealed works acceptance.
- Five risk signals: (1) cash-chain break (contractor advance financing capacity exhausted, wage/supplier arrears, diverted progress payments); (2) scrimping (delivery documents mismatched with budget, downgraded mix designs, shoddy substitutions); (3) cuts to mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions (HSE funds diverted to other uses, missing protections—the most dangerous signal, directly tied to accident liability); (4) malicious variations/claims (dense variations/claims on loss items attempting to "lawfully recoup" via 8.1.1—distinguish genuine variations from recoupment-driven ones); (5) mid-way exit and delay (slowing construction citing funding difficulty, demanding advances or repricing, halting and exiting if refused).
- Response levers: (1) settlement blocking—GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.7.6 lists 8 cost categories not adjusted for changes in costs (consumables, small tools, preliminaries, out-of-band price moves, overhead and profit, contractor-fault costs), blocking a second recoupment via inflation; (2) payment control—progress payments strictly tied to physical progress, adequate retention money, no advance payment; (3) quality and safety—more standing supervision, material re-testing, concealed works acceptance, imagery evidence; (4) variation control—variations strictly "approve first, implement later," review each variation's rationale and rate build-up basis, refuse recoupment-driven variations.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to construction tendering and performance risk management. Not applicable to lawful low tenders at or above cost (valid; no repricing on losses); breach cannot be presumed from a low price alone—the signals are an experiential early-warning framework, not mandatory norms, and must be validated with on-site evidence (documents, imagery, test records) before triggering. Below-cost determination uses the contractor's individual cost as the basis, requiring written explanation and cost-calculation support.
Further Reading
Bidding Law (2017 revision), Article 33; Implementation Regulations, Article 51 (rejection for below cost or above the tender price ceiling); MOHURD Order 43 (2018 revision), Article 42 (written justification and rejection of obviously low tenders); MOT Order 2018 No. 13, Article 32 (railway: failure to prove price reasonableness = below-cost tendering, reject); GB/T 50500-2024 Article 6.1.3 (tender price not below cost / not above the tender price ceiling), Article 8.1.1 (11 adjustment events), Article 8.7.6 (8 cost categories not adjusted for changes in costs); GB 50652-2011 Article 8.3.1 (risk-management fee not discountable).
Keywords
- below-cost tendering
- 低于成本竞标
- 履约风险识别
- 风险信号
- 否决投标
- 成本价
- 倒挂台账
- adjustment of the contract price