Rules for scheme comparison reports in cost consultancy: choosing comparison methods and indicators by project type (single or multiple function, non-commercial or commercial), with value engineering selecting the scheme of higher value coefficient
GB/T 51095-2015 clause 3.1.9 (same source as DB37/T 5130-2018 clause 3.1.7) requires a scheme comparison report: non-commercial projects of single function and broadly equal scale, standard and design life prefer the scheme of lower cost or unit cost; where scale, standard or design life differ, compare whole-life-cycle total cost; commercial projects fix investment scale and cost from financial indicators - payback period, internal rate of return, net present value; under value engineering select the scheme with the higher value coefficient and propose improvements cutting redundant function and cost.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 51095-2015 建设工程造价咨询规范 第3.1.9条
- DB37/T 5130-2018 建设工程造价咨询服务规范 第3.1.7条
Positioning
The clause basis when cost consultancy firms compile scheme comparison reports: not only compare cost, but choose methods and indicators by project nature (single or multiple function, non-commercial or commercial), landing on the report's conclusions and improvement proposals.
Core conclusions
Basis: GB/T 51095-2015 clause 3.1.9 and DB37/T 5130-2018 clause 3.1.7 are of the same source - "cost consultancy firms carrying out scheme comparison shall submit a scheme comparison report" - with five items:
- Non-commercial projects of single function with broadly equal scale, standard and life: prefer the scheme of lower works cost or unit cost per square metre; analyse the technical indicators of each unit works and main element works per the project composition, compare, and propose the preferred scheme with improvements. (The DB37 version analyses at "single-project, unit-works and main element-works" level.)
- Single function but differing scale, standard or design life: comprehensively evaluate the one-off construction investment and the costs during operation (maintenance) and compare whole-life-cycle total cost, then compare and propose.
- Commercial projects: analyse technical advancement and economic rationality; given the design function and technical advancement, and within the funding capacity, fix the investment scale and works cost from financial indicators - payback period, IRR, NPV - then compare and propose.
- Under value engineering: "comprehensively select the scheme with the higher value coefficient as preferred, analyse the ways of cutting its redundant functions and costs, and propose improvements."
- Sustainability and policy: balance near-term and long-term functional needs and construction scale for sustainable development; DB37/T 5130-2018 adds national and provincial policy considerations (green building, sponge city, prefabricated construction).
Applicability in the commentary: for ordinary building works or works of similar single use, with equal or near construction scale, standard and design life, comparison may rest on the one-off works cost or unit cost alone, further analysing unit-works and element-works indicators; works of multiple use or production/commercial projects may use value analysis and economic evaluation; non-quantifiable long-term and social aspects are weighed qualitatively.
Differences between the two versions (do not mix): GB/T reads "broadly equal" (item 1) and "differing in scale, standard or design life" (item 2); DB37 reads "equal or near" and "differing in scale, standard and design life", adds the single-project level in item 1 and the local-policy item 5.
Method-selection logic: comparable single cost indicator (single function, near scale/standard/life) - compare cost / unit cost; conditions differ - compare whole-life total cost; commercial nature - add financial evaluation (payback, IRR, NPV); function and cost to be weighed together - value engineering (value coefficient); non-quantifiables - qualitative note.
Applicable boundaries
- For scheme comparison reports by cost consultants at decision and design stages (scheme design, preliminary design) - not for tender evaluation method design (that follows the bidding laws and evaluation rules).
- Conclusions presuppose aligned boundaries: functional targets, scale, standard, price level and cost composition comparable; align or convert before comparing.
- Financial indicators (payback, IRR, NPV) apply to commercial projects only; non-commercial projects rest on cost, unit cost or whole-life cost.
- "One-off cost alone" is a limited basis, valid only for single-function projects of equal or near scale, standard and life - comparing cost alone under differing conditions misleads.
Further reading
- GB/T 51095-2015 clause 3.1.9 (text and commentary); DB37/T 5130-2018 clause 3.1.7; for value-engineering computation (0-4 scoring, function/cost/value indices, target-cost allocation) see the related card.
Keywords
- 方案比选报告
- 方案比选
- 全寿命周期费用
- 单方工程造价
- 价值系数
- 财务评价指标
- 投资回收期
- 内部收益率
- 净现值