Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-29

Order of satisfaction and participation in distribution upon concurrence of monetary claims in enforcement: where several creditors apply separately, satisfaction follows the order of enforcement measures; claims based on ownership and security interests rank ahead of monetary claims; multiple creditors under one instrument share pro rata; the first-seizure court conducts the distribution; and ordinary claims are satisfied pro rata to the amounts participating in distribution

Where multiple creditors holding separate effective legal instruments apply to enforce against the same judgment debtor and none holds a security interest over the subject property, satisfaction follows the order in which the enforcement courts took enforcement measures; where the claims differ in kind, claims based on ownership and security interests are satisfied before monetary claims, and multiple security interests are satisfied in the order of their creation; where multiple creditors under one and the same effective legal instrument cannot be fully satisfied out of the enforced property, those without security interests are satisfied pro rata to their claims (Provisions on Enforcement Work, Article 55). Distribution of the judgment debtor's property is conducted by the court that first seized, attached or froze; where the first seizure was taken to enforce a property preservation ruling, distribution must await the conclusion of the trial in that court (Article 56). In distribution, enforcement costs are deducted first and priority claims are satisfied, then ordinary claims are in principle satisfied pro rata to their share of all claims participating in distribution, and unsatisfied parts remain payable (Interpretation on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law, Article 508).

Applicable Codes

  • 《最高人民法院关于人民法院执行工作若干问题的规定(试行)》(2020修正)第55条、第56条
  • 《最高人民法院关于适用〈中华人民共和国民事诉讼法〉的解释》(法释〔2015〕5号,2022修正)第五百零八条

Subject Positioning

When multiple creditors apply concurrently or successively to enforce against the property of the same judgment debtor (typical: a contractor facing simultaneous enforcement by several material suppliers, subcontractors and banks), who is satisfied first and in what proportion, and which court conducts the distribution. This is the preliminary question whether a due claim can actually be recovered.

Core Conclusions

I. Order of satisfaction (Provisions on Enforcement Work, 2020 revision, Article 55)

Text of the provision:

'55. Where multiple creditors, under multiple effective legal instruments determining the payment of money, apply separately to enforce against the same judgment debtor, and none of the creditors holds a security interest over the subject property of enforcement, they are satisfied in the order in which the enforcement courts took enforcement measures. Where the claims of multiple creditors differ in kind, claims enjoyed on the basis of ownership and security interests are satisfied before monetary claims. Where there are multiple security interests, they are satisfied in the order of their creation. Where multiple creditors under one effective legal instrument determining the payment of money apply to enforce against the same judgment debtor and the property enforced is insufficient to satisfy all debts, and none of the creditors holds a security interest over the subject property, they are satisfied pro rata to their claims.'

Unpacked into three rules:

  1. Multiple creditors none of whom holds a security interest (multiple instruments, separate applications) -> satisfaction in the order of the enforcement measures taken by the enforcement court (first to seize is first to be paid).
  2. Claims of different kinds -> claims based on ownership and security interests are satisfied before monetary claims; among multiple security interests, in the order of their creation.
  3. Multiple creditors under one effective legal instrument (e.g. group litigation, joint creditors) -> where the enforced property is insufficient, those without security interests are satisfied pro rata.

II. The court conducting participation in distribution (same Provisions, Article 56)

'56. Distribution of the property of the judgment debtor in which creditors participate shall be conducted by the court that first seized, attached or froze. Where the measures taken by that court of first seizure, attachment or freezing were taken to enforce a property preservation ruling, the distribution shall take place after the trial of the case in that court is concluded.'

Key points: the power of distribution belongs to the court of first seizure (first attachment, first freezing); if the first seizure was taken to enforce a property preservation ruling, distribution must await the conclusion of the trial in that court - that is, at the preservation stage property can only be controlled, not distributed in advance.

III. Satisfaction ratio of ordinary claims in distribution (Interpretation on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law, Article 508)

Text of the provision: 'In participation in distribution, after the proceeds of enforcement deduct enforcement costs and satisfy the claims entitled to priority, ordinary claims are in principle satisfied pro rata to their share of the total amount of claims participating in distribution. For the remaining debts after satisfaction, the judgment debtor shall continue to repay. Where a creditor discovers other property of the judgment debtor, it may at any time request the people's court to enforce.'

Order of satisfaction: enforcement costs -> priority claims (security interests, the statutory priority of the construction project price claim and the like) -> ordinary claims pro rata (in principle). Unsatisfied parts are not extinguished; upon discovery of new property, enforcement may be requested again at any time.

Scope of Application

  • Each of the three rules of Article 55 has its own premise: rule 1 requires that none of the creditors holds a security interest over the subject property and that there be multiple instruments applied separately; rule 3 is limited to multiple creditors under one effective legal instrument where the enforced property is insufficient to satisfy all debts; the two must not be conflated.
  • Satisfaction in the order of enforcement measures presupposes that the measures (seizure, attachment, freezing) are valid and continuous; where a seizure is released or a seizure queued in rotation has not yet taken effect, the ranking changes accordingly.
  • Participation in distribution is a mechanism within enforcement proceedings; where the judgment debtor meets bankruptcy grounds, debts should be cleaned up through bankruptcy, and the first-come-first-served rule of individual enforcement yields to the avoidance rules and collateral-based priority in bankruptcy.
  • The statutory priority of the construction project price claim and security interests belong to the claims entitled to priority here; their scope and ranking are determined under Article 807 of the Civil Code and related judicial interpretations, outside the ordinary-claims-pro-rata category.
  • These rules resolve concurrence of monetary claims, not title objections by outsiders to the subject property - the latter must go through enforcement objections by outsiders and suits of objection to enforcement.

Further Reading

  • Provisions of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Enforcement Work of People's Courts (for trial implementation) (2020 revision), Part IX 'Enforcement by Multiple Creditors against One Debtor and Participation in Distribution', Articles 55 and 56.
  • Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on the Application of the Civil Procedure Law (Fa Shi [2015] No. 5, 2022 revision), Article 508 (participation in distribution) and Article 499 (enforcement against claims due; see the dedicated topic on enforcement of due claims and triage of third-party objections).
  • Article 807 of the Civil Code and the judicial interpretations on the statutory priority of construction project price claims carried in the national law database, for fixing the scope and ranking of the priority claims.

Keywords

  • 参与分配
  • 受偿顺序
  • 执行竞合
  • 首封法院主持分配
  • 按债权比例受偿
  • 执行措施先后顺序
  • 担保物权优先
  • 执行工作规定55条

Cited By