Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-25

Selection differences between thermal insulation materials (open-cell fibrous types) and cold insulation materials (closed-cell foam types) and their qualifying performance indices: thermal conductivity, density, hydrophobicity ratio and moisture absorption by mass, closed-cell rate, water absorption by volume, water vapour permeability coefficient, water vapour resistance factor mu, plus moisture barrier and adhesive indices (GB 50264-2013 Clauses 4.1.2~4.1.5, 4.2.1 and 4.4.1; GB 50019-2015 Clause 13.1.4)

The selection line between cold insulation and thermal insulation materials lies in whether water vapour can enter and stay: cold insulation must use closed-cell foam types (PUR/PIR closed-cell rate no less than 90%, water absorption by volume no greater than 5.0%/4.0% respectively, foam glass no greater than 0.5%, flexible elastomeric foam no greater than 0.2%), while thermal insulation uses open-cell fibrous types controlled by hydrophobicity and moisture absorption (where waterproofing is required, rock wool moisture absorption by mass no greater than 1.0% and hydrophobicity ratio no less than 98%; slag wool/glass wool/aluminium silicate wool moisture absorption no greater than 4.0%/3.0%/4.0% respectively, hydrophobicity ratio each no less than 98%). Thermal conductivity thresholds are checked at different temperature points: thermal insulation materials at mean temperature 70C no greater than 0.080W/(m.K); cold insulation foamed plastics at 25C no greater than 0.044W/(m.K); elastomeric foam at 0C no greater than 0.036W/(m.K); Class I foam glass at 25C no greater than 0.045W/(m.K) and Class II no greater than 0.064W/(m.K). Density limits: rigid insulation products no greater than 220kg/m3, semi-rigid 200, flexible 150; cold insulation foamed plastics no greater than 60kg/m3, elastomeric foam 95, foam glass 180. Moisture barrier materials: water absorption no greater than 1.0%; cold insulation adhesives: bond strength at ambient temperature above 0.15MPa and softening temperature above 65C (foam glass at -196C: bond strength above 0.05MPa).

Applicable Codes

  • GB 50264-2013 第4.1.2条
  • GB 50264-2013 第4.1.3条
  • GB 50264-2013 第4.1.4条
  • GB 50264-2013 第4.1.5条
  • GB 50264-2013 第4.2.1条
  • GB 50264-2013 第4.4.1条
  • GB 50019-2015 第13.1.4条
  • GB/T 4272 设备及管道绝热技术通则
  • GB/T 8175 设备及管道绝热设计导则

Positioning

This card explains why thermal insulation and cold insulation follow different selection logics: thermal insulation uses open-cell fibrous types (rock wool, slag wool, glass wool, aluminium silicate wool, calcium silicate, compound silicate), while cold insulation uses closed-cell foam types (PUR, PIR, foam glass, flexible elastomeric foam), and it gives the qualifying thresholds for thermal conductivity, density, hydrophobicity ratio, closed-cell rate, water absorption by volume and the water vapour permeability coefficient (GB 50264-2013 Clauses 4.1.2~4.1.5 and Clauses 4.2.1, 4.4.1; GB 50019-2015 Clause 13.1.4).

Core conclusions

1. The physical reason for the selection divide: can water vapour get in, and can it get out

GB 50019-2015 Clause 13.1.4 commentary, original text: 'The requirements of cold insulation differ from those of thermal insulation: cold insulation particularly stresses a large water vapour resistance factor mu and low water absorption of the material... For low-temperature piping, a temperature and humidity difference persists between the inner and outer faces of the material; under the persistent action of the water vapour partial pressure difference, water vapour will inevitably penetrate into the cold insulation material; since the thermal conductivity of water [0.56W/(m.K)] is a dozen or more times the initial thermal conductivity of the material, the thermal conductivity of the material will gradually rise, rendering the cold insulation thickness selected on the initial thermal conductivity insufficient and causing condensation. The water vapour resistance factor mu of the cold insulation material - its ability to resist water vapour penetration - is therefore crucial and directly governs the service life of the material.'

Key points of items 3, 6 and 7 of the same clause: thermal insulation materials should be materials and products with low thermal conductivity, low density, low cost and easy installation; cold insulation materials should be materials and products with low thermal conductivity, low moisture absorption, low water absorption, low density, good low-temperature performance, easy installation and high overall economic benefit; cold insulation materials for ice storage systems 'should be of closed-cell type and of materials convenient for cold insulation of irregular parts'. Item 1 requires the main performance of insulation materials to comply with GB/T 8175; item 2 requires the combustion performance to comply with GB 50016.

Inference (engineering decision rule): the water vapour risk inside the thermal insulation layer comes mainly from external liquid water (kept off by the cladding), and the open-cell, breathable material resists water by hydrophobicity; the interior of the cold insulation layer is a low-temperature interface where entered vapour cannot escape, so closed cells + low water absorption + high vapour resistance must keep the water vapour 'outside the door'.

2. Thermal conductivity qualifying thresholds (Clause 4.1.2, original text)

'1 The thermal conductivity of thermal insulation materials at a mean temperature of 70C shall be no greater than 0.080W/(m.K). 2 The thermal conductivity of foamed plastics and their products used for cold insulation at a mean temperature of 25C shall be no greater than 0.044W/(m.K). 3 The thermal conductivity of elastomeric foam products at a mean temperature of 0C shall be no greater than 0.036W/(m.K). 4 The thermal conductivity of Class I foam glass products at a mean temperature of 25C shall be no greater than 0.045W/(m.K), and that of Class II foam glass products at a mean temperature of 25C shall be no greater than 0.064W/(m.K).' Note the different bases of comparison: thermal insulation is checked at a mean temperature of 70C and cold insulation at 25C (elastomeric foam at 0C) - the lambda of the two material families is tested at different temperature points, so the values must not be compared directly across the divide.

3. Density limits (Clause 4.1.3, original text)

'The density of rigid thermal insulation products shall be no greater than 220kg/m3, that of semi-rigid thermal insulation products no greater than 200kg/m3, and that of flexible thermal insulation products no greater than 150kg/m3. The density of foamed plastics for cold insulation shall be no greater than 60kg/m3, that of elastomeric foam products no greater than 95kg/m3, and that of foam glass products no greater than 180kg/m3.' Commentary: the density values for thermal insulation materials align with DL/T 776 and GB 50126 and were set on 'performance data of upper-middle level products', to eliminate backward products while accommodating mid-range ones; the density values for cold insulation materials align with GB/T 4272 and GB/T 8175.

4. Specific performance thresholds for fibrous and foam types (key points of Clause 4.1.4)

Fibrous types (thermal insulation) - water absorption and hydrophobicity indices where waterproofing is required:

  • Rock wool products: average fibre diameter no greater than 5.5 microns; slag shot content for particles >0.25mm no greater than 6.0%; organic matter content no greater than 4.0% (5.0% for pipe sections); hydrophobic type preferred; where waterproofing is required, 'moisture absorption by mass no greater than 1.0% and hydrophobicity ratio no less than 98%'; acidity coefficient no less than 1.6.
  • Slag wool products: average fibre diameter no greater than 6.5 microns, slag shot content no greater than 8.0%; where waterproofing is required, moisture absorption by mass no greater than 4.0% and hydrophobicity ratio no less than 98%.
  • Glass wool products: average fibre diameter no greater than 7.0 microns, slag shot content no greater than 0.2%; where waterproofing is required, moisture absorption by mass no greater than 3.0% and hydrophobicity ratio no less than 98%.
  • Aluminium silicate wool products: slag shot content no greater than 18%; where bonded, hydrophobic type preferred, tensile strength above 0.05MPa; where waterproofing is required, moisture absorption by mass no greater than 4.0% and hydrophobicity ratio no less than 98%; needled blankets: tensile strength above 0.035MPa.
  • Magnesium silicate fibre blankets: slag shot content no greater than 16%, tensile strength above 0.04MPa.
  • Calcium silicate products: asbestos-free products containing high-temperature-resistant fibre shall be used; moisture content by mass no greater than 7.5%; compressive strength no less than 0.6MPa; flexural strength no less than 0.3MPa; linear shrinkage no greater than 2.0%.
  • Compound silicate products: hydrophobic type preferred; moisture content by mass no greater than 2.0%; hydrophobicity ratio no less than 98%; compression recovery rate of the felt no less than 70%. Foam types (cold insulation) - water absorption by volume, water vapour permeability coefficient, closed-cell rate:
  • Foam glass: 'compressive strength no less than 0.8MPa, flexural strength no less than 0.4MPa, water absorption by volume no greater than 0.5%, water vapour permeability coefficient no greater than 5x10^-11 g/(Pa.m.s)'.
  • Polyisocyanurate (PIR) foam: compressive strength no less than 0.22MPa, 'closed-cell rate no less than 90%, water absorption by volume no greater than 4.0%', water vapour permeability coefficient no greater than 5.8x10^-9 g/(Pa.m.s).
  • Polyurethane (PUR) foam: compressive strength no less than 0.2MPa, 'closed-cell rate no less than 90%, water absorption by volume no greater than 5.0%', water vapour permeability coefficient no greater than 6.5x10^-9 g/(Pa.m.s).
  • Flexible elastomeric foam: 'water absorption by volume no greater than 0.2%, water vapour permeability coefficient no greater than 1.3x10^-10 g/(Pa.m.s)', no cracks on axial bending. Commentary: the insulation materials covered by this code serve industrial equipment and piping, so some parameter values are higher than the minimum requirements of the product standards; the parameters derive mainly from GB/T 11835, GB/T 13350, GB/T 16400, GB/T 10699, GB/T 17371, JC/T 990, JC/T 647, GB/T 21558, GB/T 17794 and GB/T 25997. Rock wool and slag wool are regulated separately (different raw materials, and service temperature and high-temperature thermal conductivity differ considerably), as are polyurethane and polyisocyanurate (low-temperature stability and service temperature differ considerably).

5. Thresholds for accessory materials

  • Moisture barrier materials (Clause 4.2.1, original text): 'The moisture barrier material shall be selected for good resistance to vapour penetration, waterproofness and damp-proofness, and its water absorption shall be no greater than 1.0%.'
  • Cold insulation adhesives (Clause 4.4.1, original text): 'The adhesive shall be selected according to the performance of the cold insulation material and the service temperature; adhesives used for cold insulation shall retain their bonding performance within the low-temperature range of use, with a bond strength above 0.15MPa at ambient temperature and a softening temperature above 65C. Foam glass should use elastic adhesives or sealants, with a bond strength above 0.05MPa at -196C.'
  • Rigid cold insulation load blocks (Clause 4.1.5): HDPIR closed-cell rate no less than 90%, water absorption by volume no greater than 4.0%, water vapour permeability coefficient no greater than 5.8x10^-9 g/(Pa.m.s).

6. Selection difference quick reference (engineering judgement)

Item Thermal insulation (open-cell fibrous) Cold insulation (closed-cell foam)
Water vapour risk mechanism Mainly external liquid water; material breathable, resists water by hydrophobicity Vapour penetrates inward with the heat flow and cannot get out
Key indices Hydrophobicity ratio no less than 98%; moisture absorption by mass 1.0%~4.0% Closed-cell rate no less than 90%; water absorption by volume no more than 0.2%~5.0%; water vapour permeability coefficient limits; high water vapour resistance factor mu
Allowable temperature Maximum service temperature shall be above the maximum normal operating medium temperature Minimum service temperature shall be below the minimum normal operating medium temperature
Test temperature point Lambda checked at a mean temperature of 70C Lambda checked at 25C (elastomeric foam 0C)
Dedicated components Standard supports and cladding Rigid cold insulation load blocks (HDPIR etc.), moisture barrier, thermal bridge treatment

Boundaries of application

  • This card follows the GB 50264-2013 scope of industrial equipment and piping; building HVAC and ice storage systems are further governed by GB 50019-2015 Clause 13.1.4, the energy efficiency standards and the GB/T 17794 water vapour resistance factor system, whose index systems are not fully identical.
  • The clause values are qualifying thresholds (no greater than / no less than), not recommended optimisation values; exceeding a threshold is better, but selection must also check the allowable service temperature, combustion performance (GB 50016) and chemical compatibility.
  • The hydrophobicity and moisture absorption indices of fibrous materials are mandatory only 'where waterproofing is required'; without such a requirement, hydrophobic products should still be preferred.
  • The closed-cell rate and water absorption by volume of foam materials must not be substituted for each other under the single term 'water absorption', nor conflated with the 'water absorption no greater than 1.0%' of moisture barrier materials (the latter is an index of the barrier membrane material).
  • The parameter values are higher than the minimum requirements of the corresponding product standards; acceptance on delivery shall be judged under this code (and Annex A) rather than the product standards alone.
  • This card does not cover specific product prices or brands; a change of material does not alter the measurement formulas for insulation volume and cladding area (the material forms only part of the item description).

Further reading

GB 50264-2013 (code for insulation design of industrial equipment and pipes), Chapter 4 'Selection of insulation materials': Clause 4.1.2 (thermal conductivity), Clause 4.1.3 (density), Clause 4.1.4 (main physical and chemical properties of the product types), Clause 4.1.5 (HDPIR cold insulation load blocks), Clause 4.2.1 (water absorption of moisture barrier materials), Clause 4.4.1 (adhesives), and Annex A 'Main properties of common insulation materials and their products'; GB 50019-2015 Design code for heating, ventilation and air conditioning of industrial buildings, Clause 13.1.4 and its commentary; product standards GB/T 11835, GB/T 13350, GB/T 16400, GB/T 10699, GB/T 21558, GB/T 17794 (water vapour resistance factor) and GB/T 25997; the general code GB/T 4272 and the guideline GB/T 8175.

Keywords

  • 绝热材料选型
  • 闭孔率
  • 体积吸水率
  • 憎水率
  • 湿阻因子
  • 导热系数限值
  • 泡沫玻璃
  • 聚异氰脲酸酯
  • GB 50264-2013