Economic comparison and mode selection between centralized procurement and project self-procurement
There is no absolutely optimal mode; the mature practice is graded, classified mixed procurement: for bulk, generic, standardized principal materials (steel, cement, ready-mix concrete, etc.) centralized procurement is more economical (scale effects lower unit prices); for local, non-standard, urgent, and sundry materials project self-procurement is more economical (flexible response, no regional price differentials lost). Decision formula: compare "centralized unit price saving × quantity" against "added management cost + regional differential loss + response delay loss". The enterprise sets a centralized procurement catalog with tiered authorization; project self-procurement must stay within the enterprise's authorized scope.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50358-2017 建设项目工程总承包管理规范
- GB 50722-2011 城市轨道交通建设项目管理规范
- T/SCIA 002-2020 建设工程全过程质量控制管理规程
- RISN-TG 012-2011 建设工程项目经理执业导则
- GB/T 50430-2017 工程建设施工企业质量管理规范
- GB/T 50326-2017 建设工程项目管理规范
- GB/T 50502-2009 建筑施工组织设计规范
Topic Positioning
Answers the mode-selection question of "which is more economical for construction projects, centralized procurement or project self-procurement", giving a graded, classified mixed-procurement decision framework based on scale effects and transaction costs, for construction/EPC enterprises designing procurement strategies.
Core Conclusions
No one-size-fits-all optimum exists; classify materials by attribute:
- Where centralized procurement is more economical: bulk, generic, standardized principal materials (steel, cement, ready-mixed concrete, formwork, standard pipes, etc.). The economic core is the scale effect — GB/T 50358-2017, Clause 6.3.3 defines centralized procurement as consolidated purchasing of similar materials within the same enterprise/group to cut costs; GB 50722-2011, Clause 10.2.3 gives the boundary: materials and equipment with uniform design standards that are mature and reliable suit centralized procurement, preferably on a centralized procurement management platform (T/SCIA 002-2020, Clause 7.3.1).
- Where project self-procurement is more economical: local, non-standard, urgent, and sundry materials (sand and gravel, local bricks, emergency replenishment, etc.). The legality precondition is enterprise authorization — RISN-TG 012-2011, Clause 12.0.1 confirms the project manager is responsible for procurement management within the enterprise's authorized scope.
- Decision formula: compare "centralized unit price saving × procurement quantity" against "added management cost + regional differential loss + response delay loss" — choose the larger.
- Practice points: the enterprise sets a centralized procurement catalog (Class A bulk materials) with tiered authorization; off-catalog items are self-procured within authorized limits, with approval beyond them; centralized procurement uses "framework agreement + project orders" to lock prices while staying flexible; project-procured materials go into the enterprise's approved supplier list to prevent quality loss of control.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to material/equipment procurement mode decisions of construction enterprises and EPC projects. Note: project self-procurement must stay within the enterprise's authorization and follow its procurement system; centralized procurement presupposes uniform design standards and maturity — forcibly centralizing materials with large standard differences or strong locality can lose on regional differentials. Not applicable to single-point queries such as regional price comparisons of specific material prices.
Further Reading
GB/T 50358-2017, Code for Management of Engineering Procurement Construction (EPC) Projects, 6.3.3 (procurement execution plan and centralized procurement definition); GB 50722-2011, Code for Management of Urban Rail Transit Construction Projects, 10.2.3; RISN-TG 012-2011, Guideline for the Practice of Construction Project Managers, 12.0.1; T/SCIA 002-2020, Rules for Whole-Process Quality Control Management of Construction Works, 7.3.1; GB/T 50430-2017, Code for Quality Management of Construction Enterprises, 8.2.1 (procurement plan preparation and approval); GB/T 50326-2017, Code for Construction Project Management, 6.2.1 (procurement plan content); GB/T 50502-2009, Code for Project Execution Plan of Building Engineering, 4.4.5 (material allocation plan).
Keywords
- 集中采购
- 项目自行采购
- 采购模式选择
- 采购经济性
- 分级分类采购
- 合格供应商名录
- procurement management
- 大宗材料采购