How to judge whether a material price is evidently higher than the market level: setting the benchmark, unifying the basis of comparison, grading the deviation rate, and the dispute-resolution procedure
Judging whether a material price is evidently above the market level takes four steps: (1) set the benchmark - cross-verify through multiple channels in the order of priority: contract-agreed price > price approved by both parties > published price information > market price enquiry (at least 3 offers); published price information must not be applied directly; (2) unify the basis - before comparing, align taxes, delivery terms, specification and brand, unit of measurement, issue period, batch and other terms; (3) compute the deviation - deviation rate = (submitted price - benchmark price) / benchmark price: within ±5% normal; ±5%~10% attention and re-check; ±10%~20% evidently high, vouchers required; above 20% seriously abnormal, special verification (exemptions for special cases such as design parameters, project positioning and haul distance); (4) fix the procedure - for price-adjustable or provisional-sum materials, a three-party price enquiry shall be conducted and documented before procurement; where a dispute has arisen, the expert assessment determines the price in the order approved-and-signed price > contract-agreed price > price otherwise agreed by the parties.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 51262-2017 建设工程造价鉴定规范
- DBJ/T 15-153-2019 广东省建设项目全过程造价管理规范
- DB11/T 382-2017 建设工程监理规程
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准
- DB37/T 5161-2020 建设工程造价数据交换及应用标准
- GB/T 51095-2015 建设工程造价咨询规范
Topic Positioning
A standardised method for judging whether a material price is "evidently higher than the market level": set the benchmark -> unify the basis -> compute the deviation -> fix the procedure; for use in price review and verification, settlement gatekeeping and dispute handling.
Core Conclusions
- Set the benchmark: the "market level" must be cross-verified through multiple channels, in the reference order contract-agreed price > price approved by both parties > published price information > market price enquiry (comparison of at least 3 offers). Published price information is mostly the tax-inclusive delivered price and lags 1-3 months, so it must not be applied directly; in-house price libraries must keep the three channels of market prices, published price information and manufacturers' quotations strictly separate, never mixed.
- Unify the basis: before comparing, align everything onto the same basis - taxes (net of tax vs VAT-inclusive; the 13%/9%/3% differences are large), delivery terms (ex-works vs delivered), specification and brand (same product name but different grades; the gap between first-tier and second-tier brands can exceed 30%), units of measurement (t/kg, m3/m2), issue period (prices move monthly - compare the same period), and purchase batch and payment terms.
- Set the thresholds: deviation rate = (submitted unit price - benchmark price) / benchmark price x 100%; within ±5% pass as normal; ±5%~10% flag for re-check; ±10%~20% evidently high - purchase vouchers or enquiry records required; above 20% seriously abnormal - special verification. High design parameters (special materials), premium project positioning (imported brands) and long haul distances (high freight and handling charges) are legitimate high prices and must be distinguished from inflated ones.
- Fix the procedure: for contract-agreed price-adjustable or provisional-sum materials, the employer, contractor and supervising engineer (or cost consultant) shall jointly enquire market prices and agree them before procurement; the enquiry records are filed in a register for traceability; once a dispute has arisen, the expert assessment determines the price in the order approved-and-signed price > contract-agreed price > price otherwise agreed by the parties, the signed approval records themselves being the evidence.
Applicable Boundaries
The deviation thresholds (±5%/±10%/±20%) are empirical reference values to be adjusted to the project and the material category; the method is used only where the contract agrees no pricing method or the submitted price is in doubt - where the contract already agrees price terms, compare directly against the contract. Special materials, monopoly supply and emergency purchasing call for case-by-case judgement without mechanically applying the thresholds.
Further Reading
GB/T 51262-2017 "Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment of Construction Works" clause 5.6.4 (rules for the expert assessment of material price disputes); DBJ/T 15-153-2019 clause 7.6.2 (multi-party price enquiry and comparison; published price information must not be selected directly); DB11/T 382-2017 clause 5.3.3 (three-party price enquiry before procurement of price-adjustable / provisional-sum materials); GB/T 50500-2024 "Pricing Standard for Bill of Quantities of Construction Works" term 2.0.9 (the all-in unit rate excludes VAT); DB37/T 5161-2020 clause 5.2.3 (all-in unit rate = labour + materials + plant + overheads + profit); GB/T 51095-2015 clause 7.4.2 (price adjustment follows the contract and published cost information).