Innovation-type topics - 'propose schemes and determine the best scheme': overall and hierarchical schemes, layer-by-layer decomposition into implementable specific schemes, evaluation one by one on measured and tested data, like-for-like comparison with compliance in view (T BCAT 0003-2024 clause 4.2.4)
Per T BCAT 0003-2024 clause 4.2.4: proposing schemes shall put forward and organise every scheme that may reach the topic goal, schemes comprising overall and hierarchical schemes - the overall schemes innovative and relatively independent, the hierarchical ones comparable for choice; in fixing the best scheme, decomposition unfolds layer by layer down to implementable specific schemes, each evaluated and chosen on facts and data from site measurement, testing and investigation. Commentary: a single borrowed core technology or path gives one overall scheme decomposable directly into hierarchical schemes; several give several overall schemes - choose the best first, then decompose; 'specific scheme' means the terminal layer; comparisons at every level watch compliance, evaluate from multiple angles and compare data on like conditions.
Applicable Codes
- T BCAT 0003-2024《北京市工程建设质量管理小组活动准则》第4.2.4条
Positioning
The compliance requirements of the 'propose schemes and determine the best scheme' step of innovation-type topics (QC circle activity): how schemes arise, how overall and hierarchical schemes divide, how decomposition runs down to implementable specifics, and how data completes the selection. Basis: T BCAT 0003-2024 (Beijing construction QC circle activity code) clause 4.2.4 and its commentary.
Core conclusions
1. Proposing schemes (4.2.4 item 1): for the topic goal, drawing on what is borrowed, the circle shall - (1) put forward every scheme that may reach the goal and organise them all; (2) let schemes comprise overall and hierarchical schemes, the overall innovative and relatively independent, the hierarchical comparable for choice.
2. Fixing the best scheme (4.2.4 item 2): evaluating and comparing all organised schemes to fix the best - (1) decomposition unfolds layer by layer to implementable specific schemes; (2) each scheme is evaluated and chosen one by one on facts and data from site measurement, testing and investigation analysis.
3. Commentary (equally binding): (1) one borrowed core technology or path - a single overall scheme, decomposed directly into hierarchical schemes; several - several overall schemes: choose the best overall first, then decompose layer by layer; (2) 'specific scheme' is the terminal layer of an overall scheme; (3) comparisons at every level watch compliance, evaluate from multiple angles, and compare data on like conditions.
4. Reporting points: the scheme part must form a tree - overall -> hierarchical -> terminal specific schemes; comparison evidence must be verifiable site measurement, testing or survey data (test counts, means, ranges); comparison conditions (working cases, loads, crews, judgement indices) unify across schemes; 'innovative and relatively independent' demands substantive differences between overall schemes - not spec tweaks of one principle; 'compliance' is a precondition screened at every level - schemes must meet the standards and safety rules, never only performance and cost.
Applicable boundaries
- For innovation-type topics under T BCAT 0003-2024; problem-solving topics have no such step - never apply it there.
- 'Keep only one scheme per level' is not a rule: the clause asks only for layer-by-layer unfolding to implementable specifics, each evaluated, ending in one best scheme; the number of layers and parts follows the object developed.
- Evaluation data must come from the project's own measurement, testing or investigation - literature figures or makers' claims never substitute.
- The code serves Beijing construction QC circles; other sectors check their own codes first.
Further reading
- T BCAT 0003-2024 clause 4.2.4 and commentary; the preceding clause 4.2.2 (topic selection, wide borrowing) and the following 4.2.5 (countermeasures - chosen schemes enter the countermeasure table, Table 2); the national parallel in T/CAQ 10201-2020.
Keywords
- 提出方案
- 确定最佳方案
- 总体方案
- 分级方案
- 具体方案
- 方案分解
- 方案比选
- T BCAT 0003-2024