How to keep construction diaries so that they serve as evidence in claims and disputes
For a construction diary to constitute valid claim evidence, it must record six categories of fact along the line "event - cause - impact - loss": the event itself, its consequences, instructions and correspondence, resources deployed, the responsibility process, and cross-corroboration leads; and it must follow the disciplines of consecutive daily entries, written up the same day, no back-filling, no alteration and no signing on behalf of others, no stoppage of entries during suspension of the works, corroboration with the supervising engineer's diary, and simultaneous written fixation of major events. But the diary is only evidence: the dual 28-day-node claim procedure must still be followed.
Applicable Codes
- TB 10443-2010 铁路建设项目资料管理规程
- TB 10402-2019 铁路建设工程监理规范
- GB/T 50326-2017 建设工程项目管理规范
- GB/T 51262-2017 建设工程造价鉴定规范
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准
Topic Positioning
What a construction diary (on railway projects, the construction diary within the C5 construction-record file series) should record, and how, so that it becomes valid evidence in time and cost claims and disputes - covering the six categories of "claim facts" to be recorded and the disciplines for evidentiary force.
Core Conclusions
A claim stands on three conditions: basis, evidence and procedure (GB/T 50326-2017 clause 7.5.8), and he who claims must prove. The construction diary is the first-hand site record proving when an event occurred, how it continued and the state of the site; but a single document has limited probative force and must be mutually corroborated with other documentary evidence (GB/T 51262-2017 clause 5.8). Six categories of claim facts to be recorded: (1) the event itself (date and time, location, course, cause, site state); (2) its consequences (start and end of suspension or idle time, comparison with daily progress, weather and geological changes); (3) instructions and correspondence (verbal and written instructions, design changes, consultation records, meeting decisions - verbal instructions above all must be recorded the same day and confirmed in writing afterwards); (4) resources deployed (labour, plant machine-shifts, quantities and condition of materials brought onto site - the computation base for cost claims); (5) the responsibility process (inspections and acceptances, rectification, handling of problems); (6) cross-corroboration leads (correspondence with site instructions, the supervision diary, photographs and video). Recording disciplines: consecutive daily entries, written up the same day, no back-filling, no alteration, no signing on behalf of others; during suspension of the works the diary must not stop (TB 10443-2010 clause 7.5.2 item 8); keep the diary consistent with the supervising engineer's diary (TB 10402-2019 clause 10.1.1) - facts on which the two records agree are hard to overturn; fix major events the same day or the next day in writing through a site letter / working contact form - the diary is only the working draft.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to contractors preparing site evidence for claims or for meeting counter-claims; on railway projects the items of TB 10443-2010 clause 7.5 must be implemented one by one (the twelve items of the construction diary, and the fifteen classes of mandatory construction records such as driven piles, bored piles and prestressing). The diary cannot replace formal written documents such as site instructions and letters, nor the procedural notices of claims; the dual 28-day nodes (Notice of Claim -> claim report, GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 8.11.3 to 8.11.5) must still be followed, failing which the claim is deemed waived; where the contract agrees other claim periods, the contract prevails.
Further Reading
TB 10443-2010 "Rules for Documentation Management of Railway Construction Projects" clause 7.5 (7.5.1 fifteen classes of mandatory construction records; 7.5.2 contents of the construction diary); TB 10402-2019 "Specification for Supervision of Railway Construction Works" clause 10.1.1 (contents of the supervision diary); GB/T 50326-2017 "Code for Construction Project Management of Construction Works" clause 7.5.8; GB/T 51262-2017 clause 5.8; GB/T 50500-2024 "Pricing Standard for Bill of Quantities of Construction Works" clauses 8.11.3-8.11.5.
Keywords
- 施工日志
- 索赔证据
- 监理日记
- 施工记录
- claim
- chain of evidence
- 现场记录
- 举证