Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-18

Static deterioration-value method for equipment economic life (N0 = sqrt(2(P-L)/lambda)) and the year-by-year tabulation: composition of the average annual cost, the tabulated comparison rule and the rule that the minimum-average-cost year is the economic life / most economical replacement year (trialling Ln where residual value varies by year)

Under the static mode, equipment economic life uses the deterioration-value method: N0 = sqrt(2(P-L)/lambda), where P is the purchase cost, L the expected net residual value and lambda the annual increment of repair / running cost. The more general test is average annual cost = annual equipment cost + annual running cost = (P-L_N)/N + sum(C_t)/N, tabulated year by year; the year with the minimum AC is the economic life and the most economical replacement point. Where the residual value varies with age, each year-end residual Ln must be trialled - the simplified formula cannot be used (worked example: constant residual gives N0 = sqrt(2 x 9000/400) = 6.71 years, minimum AC at year 7; declining residuals move the minimum AC to year 4). The dynamic mode takes the optimum year by net annual value NAV or annual cost AC.

Applicable Codes

  • RISN-TG022-2016《生活垃圾清洁焚烧指南》附录1 经济寿命评估方法(含附表1-1 建构筑物经济寿命参考年限表、附表1-2 部分设备经济寿命参考年限表)
  • 一级建造师《建设工程经济》1Z101050 设备更新分析·设备经济寿命估算

Positioning

Two assessment bases for equipment economic life: the static deterioration-value method (formula and year-by-year tabulation) and the dynamic net-annual-value / annual-cost method, answering "how many years, and in which year is replacement cheapest". The framework follows the first-class constructor textbook, Construction Engineering Economics, 1Z101050 "equipment renewal analysis"; variable definitions and mode division follow Appendix 1 of RISN-TG022-2016 (Clean Waste Incineration Guide), "economic life assessment methods".

Core conclusions

1. Two modes. Static-mode economic life ignores the time value of money and is computed by the deterioration-value method. The deterioration value means: the longer the equipment runs, the worse its physical and obsolescent wear, so maintenance costs rise; this annual increment lambda is the equipment's deterioration. Dynamic-mode economic life considers the time value of money, computing the net annual value NAV or annual cost AC and fixing N0 by comparing average annual benefit or average annual cost: cost-dominated equipment takes the year of minimum average annual cost (NAVmin); revenue-dominated equipment takes the year of maximum average annual value (AVmax).

2. Formula and variables. N0 = sqrt(2(P-L)/lambda)

  • P: purchase cost (original value) of the equipment;
  • L: expected net residual value;
  • lambda: the deterioration value - the annual increment of repair (running) cost;
  • N0: economic life (years). Preconditions: residual value L treated as constant across years; running cost rising from first use by a constant arithmetic step lambda.

3. Composition of average annual cost. AC_N = annual equipment cost + annual running cost AC_N = (P - L_N)/N + (sum of C_t)/N (t = 1...N) Annual equipment cost (capital consumption) = (P - L_N)/N, with L_N the residual at end of year N; annual running cost = cumulative running cost over N years / N. If C_t = lambda x t, annual running cost = lambda(N+1)/2, and minimising AC_N returns N0 = sqrt(2(P-L)/lambda).

4. Step rules for the tabulated comparison.

  1. List years N = 1, 2, ... with end-of-year residual L_N and that year's running cost C_N (from ledgers or forecasts);
  2. compute (P - L_N)/N row by row;
  3. accumulate running costs sum(C_t) and divide by N for the annual running cost;
  4. add the two columns for the year's AC_N;
  5. the year with minimum AC_N is the economic life N0 and the most economical replacement point;
  6. after any correction to the residual curve, lambda or the running-cost ledger, recompute - old conclusions must not be carried over.

5. Worked comparison of the two bases. Simplified basis (L constant): P = 10000, L = 1000, lambda = 400, N0 = sqrt(2 x 9000/400) = 6.71 years; tabulated AC: N=1 gives 9400, N=2 gives 5100, N=3 gives 3800, N=4 gives 3250, N=5 gives 3000, N=6 gives 2900, N=7 gives 2885.71, N=8 gives 2925 - minimum at N=7, matching the formula's 6.71 rounded up to 7. Actual basis (declining residual): L_N = 7000, 5500, 4400, 3500, 2800, 2200, 1700, 1300; running cost 800 rising by 400 per year (800, 1200, ..., 3600); AC: N=1 gives 3800, N=2 gives 3250, N=3 gives 3066.67, N=4 gives 3025, N=5 gives 3040, N=6 gives 3100, N=7 gives 3185.71, N=8 gives 3287.5 - minimum at N=4: economic life and best replacement year both year 4. Conclusion: the same equipment runs about 7 years if the residual is held constant but only 4 years on its true declining-residual curve - plugging a constant L into the simplified formula systematically overstates economic life where residuals fall quickly.

Applicable boundaries

  • The static mode does not discount; where the cost of money is material (high rates, long lives) switch to the dynamic mode and fix N0 by NAV or AC.
  • The formula N0 = sqrt(2(P-L)/lambda) suits only near-constant residuals and a fixed arithmetic step lambda; with major overhauls, step-jumps in repair cost or steep residual decline, only the tabulated trial works.
  • Economic life is only the cost optimum of "keep versus replace"; it excludes functional obsolescence from technical progress, retrofit gains, taxes and disposal costs - a full renewal decision also needs option comparison (annual-cost or net-annual-value methods, incremental comparison).
  • RISN-TG022-2016 Tables 1-1 and 1-2 are reference lives compiled from industry data; calibrate to actual maintenance and energy ledgers - they are not statutory lives.
  • Consistency: P, L_N, C_t and lambda must share currency and VAT-deductibility treatment, or the AC comparison distorts.

Further reading

  • RISN-TG022-2016 Appendix 1: static deterioration-value definitions and variables (P, Ln, lambda), dynamic NAV/AC criteria, and Tables 1-1 / 1-2 reference lives.
  • First-class constructor, Construction Engineering Economics, 1Z101050: wear and renewal strategy, economic-life estimation (deterioration method and tabulated trial), renewal option comparison (AC / NAV).
  • In use, rebuild the trial table from the two columns (P-L_N)/N and sum(C_t)/N and take the minimum-AC row.

Keywords

  • 设备经济寿命
  • 低劣化值法
  • 低劣化数值法
  • 年均使用成本
  • 年度费用比较
  • 设备更新分析
  • 净年值NAV
  • 经济寿命评估