Commissioning of power supply and distribution apparatus systems - unit of measurement and the rules for splitting the number of 'systems': division per the electrical schematic diagram, systems counted by qualifying circuit breakers (rated tripping current no less than 100 A, etc.), circuits from distribution boards direct to motors counting only motor commissioning, and cable tests and insulation withstand already included
Commissioning of power supply and distribution apparatus systems is measured in 'systems' (GB/T 50856-2024 Table D.16.1 electrical testing and commissioning, code 030416, quantities per the design drawings), the systems being divided on the electrical schematic diagram; the items up to 10 kV apply to low-voltage supply circuits from distribution apparatus to sub-distribution boards, the quantity being the number of circuit breakers in the works meeting all of: rated tripping current no less than 100 A; not a breaker on the HV or LV side of a transformer or inside a motor control board or cabinet; not a breaker serving only maintenance isolation with no protective role in the design - and each unit works counts at least one circuit; circuits from a distribution board direct to a motor count only motor commissioning; cable tests and insulation withstand are already inside system commissioning and are not counted again.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50856-2024 通用安装工程工程量计算标准 App. D Table D.16.1(电气调整试验,code 030416)
- SJG 181.7-2024 市政工程消耗量标准 Vol. 7 电力通道、通信管道及照明工程 Ch. 8 电气调整试验
- SJG 111.3-2022 城市地下综合管廊工程消耗量标准 Vol. 3 附属设施安装工程 电气设备调试工程说明与工程量计算规则
- TB/T 10829-2024 铁路工程预算定额 Vol. 8 电力工程 Ch. 15 电气系统调试
- DB11/T 2000-2022 建筑工程消防施工质量验收规范 第10.4.5条
What this card covers
How the 'systems' are counted for commissioning of power supply and distribution apparatus systems (the core line item of the electrical testing and commissioning chapter): unit of measurement, basis of division, the breaker-counting conditions, the overlap boundaries with motor commissioning and cable tests, and the measurement rules of neighbouring line items for transformers, busbars and protection devices.
Core conclusions
1. Unit of measurement and basis of division.
GB/T 50856-2024 Annex D Table D.16.1 'Electrical testing and commissioning (code 030416)' uses unit / group / system as units of measurement, quantities being calculated per the numbers shown on the design drawings; note 4 to Table D.16.1 states that 'motor load commissioning means commissioning the motor together with the machinery and equipment it drives, counted per unit according to the motor's control mode and power', and notes 5 to 8 define the computer monitoring system, the 'five-prevention' system, commissioning of other items and the motor types.
How systems are divided: SJG 181.7-2024 Chapter 8, verbatim: 'The division of electrical commissioning systems shall follow the electrical schematic system diagram. Type tests of electrical equipment components are included in the commissioning of the corresponding system and are not counted separately.' Measurement rule 1 of SJG 111.3-2022 likewise provides that 'electrical commissioning systems are divided per the electrical system diagram in combination with the work content of the commissioning line items, and quantities are calculated per the unit of measurement of the line item'.
2. Scope and system count for commissioning of power supply and distribution apparatus systems (graded by voltage).
SJG 181.7-2024 Chapter 8, verbatim: 'The power supply and distribution commissioning line items apply to system commissioning of supply and distribution circuits below 10 kV (such as supply circuits from distribution apparatus to sub-distribution boards); supply circuits from distribution boards to motors are already included in the motor system commissioning line items; system commissioning includes the full set of commissioning work for the system - cable tests, insulation withstand of insulators, insulation testing of circuits, and testing of all circuit breakers, protective relays and measuring instruments in the primary or secondary circuits.'
SJG 181.7-2024 measurement rules, verbatim: 'Commissioning of power supply and distribution systems shall be counted in systems. The quantity is the number of circuit breakers in the works meeting all of the following conditions, and each unit works shall count at least one supply system commissioning circuit. 1 Circuit breakers with a rated tripping current of 100 A or more. 2 Breakers that are not on the HV or LV side of a transformer or inside a motor control board or cabinet. 3 Breakers that serve only maintenance isolation and provide no protection in the design.'
Note 7 of SJG 111.3-2022 gives the equivalent low-voltage wording: 'In commissioning of power transmission and distribution apparatus systems, the items at voltage levels up to 1 kV apply to low-voltage supply circuits, such as supply circuits from low-voltage distribution apparatus to sub-distribution boards (including lighting supply circuits). Any supply circuit carrying commissioning components such as instruments, relays or electromagnetic switches (excluding knife switches and fuses) is counted as a commissioning system. Supply circuits from distribution boards direct to motors are already included in the motor load system commissioning line items. Commissioning of power transmission and distribution apparatus systems includes cable tests, insulation withstand tests and other commissioning work within the system.'
Counting rules for graded LV distribution apparatus (SJG 111.3-2022 measurement rule 4):
- supply circuits of first-level LV distribution apparatus carrying commissioning components are counted as commissioning systems (except breakers connected to transformers);
- for supply circuits of second- and third-level LV distribution apparatus carrying commissioning components, breakers with a rated tripping current (not frame current) of 100 A or more are counted as commissioning systems;
- for supply circuits from distribution boards direct to motors, only motor commissioning is counted, without further counting of commissioning of power transmission and distribution apparatus systems;
- first-level LV distribution apparatus means the boards receiving supply from the LV side of a transformer; second-level LV distribution apparatus means the boards receiving supply from first-level LV distribution apparatus.
3. Conversion between breaker count and systems (against over- and under-counting).
SJG 111.3-2022 measurement rules:
- commissioning of power transmission and distribution apparatus systems assumes one breaker on one side; where both sides have breakers, two systems are counted;
- transformer system commissioning assumes one breaker per voltage side; where there is more than one breaker, commissioning of power transmission and distribution apparatus systems at the corresponding voltage level is counted separately;
- protection device system commissioning takes the protected object as one set: transformer protection per unit; busbar protection per the number of busbars protected as shown on the design; line protection per the number of incoming and outgoing circuits protected; small-current earth-fault protection per the number of such protection devices installed;
- automatic transfer devices: standby power automatic transfer devices are counted in systems per the number of interlocking mechanisms; automatic reclosing per the number of circuit breakers on the lines using the device;
- DC monitoring systems take one system per battery bank; UPS systems are counted per unit installed;
- intelligent distribution system commissioning is counted in systems by the number of bays, one system per station;
- unit-type switching stations are counted as 'stations' by the number of switch bay units and the number of individual enclosures; unit-type box substations are counted as 'stations' by transformer capacity and the number of individual enclosures;
- earthing system tests: the earthing network is counted in 'systems' per the design (the line items already include earth electrodes - electrode tests must not be counted again); independent earthing devices are counted in 'groups' per the design; where the whole project forms one mother network it counts as one system, and an independent earthing network of a single-item / unit works forming its own mother network and not connected to the project network counts as a separate system.
4. The hard rule of no duplicated test charges.
SJG 181.7-2024 Chapter 8, verbatim: 'Cable tests, insulating oil tests, insulator tests and tests of other equipment components are all listed within the relevant system commissioning line items and are not counted separately.' Likewise, type tests of components are included in the commissioning of the corresponding system (see the division basis quoted above). So once cable insulation megger tests, circuit insulation tests or insulation withstand of insulators have been charged under supply and distribution system commissioning, a separate 'cable test' item must not be created.
5. Factors and exclusions of neighbouring line items (error-prone list).
SJG 111.3-2022 notes:
- the commissioning line items are compiled on the current construction and acceptance code series; the sub-system commissioning of transformers, busbars and lines includes the corresponding protection commissioning; the 'protection device system commissioning' items apply to commissioning a protection system alone; the individual commissioning of control and relay panels is included in sub-system commissioning;
- the line items already cover familiarisation with documents, preparing the commissioning plan, checking equipment, site commissioning, completing commissioning records and compiling the commissioning report;
- they exclude drying of equipment and replacement or repair of components due to defects in the equipment itself, and take no account of the effect of poor component quality or poor installation on commissioning - where these occur they are counted separately;
- the items assume new and acceptable equipment; when commissioning equipment that has been replaced or modified, or relocated second-hand equipment, the line item is multiplied by 1.10;
- the electricity consumed in electrical system commissioning is included and must not be counted separately;
- sub-system commissioning includes system joint running after installation of the electrical equipment, checking and correcting the individual commissioning of electrical equipment, and routine tests of primary and secondary equipment;
- micro motors are motors with a rated output below 0.75 kW, counted without class distinction under the micro-motor commissioning items;
- when commissioning power transformers with on-load tap changers, labour and plant consumption are multiplied by 1.12; dry-type transformers take the transformer commissioning item of the corresponding capacity with labour and plant consumption multiplied by 0.80;
- the 1 kV to 10 kV busbar system commissioning items include one set of voltage transformers; the up-to-1 kV items do not; commissioning of dense bus duct at transformer outlets is included in transformer commissioning, and bus duct between power distribution boards and motors is included in the motor commissioning items;
- dual-source changeover devices take the standby power commissioning items with labour and plant consumption multiplied by 0.20;
- the intelligent substation system commissioning items cover only the three remote functions (remote control, remote signalling, remote measurement); where remote setting adjustment is added, labour and plant consumption are multiplied by 1.20;
- complete plant start-up commissioning is counted separately under the sectoral quota manuals.
Railway practice (TB/T 10829-2024 Volume 8 Chapter 15 Electrical system commissioning):
- the chapter covers line commissioning, substation commissioning, automation system commissioning, LV distribution apparatus and LV electrical apparatus commissioning, and similar items;
- 'surge arrester commissioning' is counted in 'groups', 1 group per 3 phases; where arresters are installed on only one or two phases, 1 group is still counted;
- the 35 kV substation commissioning items are compiled for a substation with one main transformer; with two or more transformers, each additional unit adjusts the quota consumption by a factor of 0.8; the 10 kV distribution station commissioning items are compiled for one incoming supply; with two or more incoming supplies, each additional supply adjusts by 0.8;
- the transformer commissioning items are compiled for oil-immersed transformers; with dry-type transformers the labour, material and plant consumption is adjusted by a factor of 0.8;
- 'overhead line commissioning' is counted in km; 'power cable line commissioning' is counted in 'sections', the cable between two break points being one section.
6. Fire / emergency circuits versus ordinary supply and distribution commissioning: how the systems are told apart.
Three-step test:
- Which system owns the commissioning object: automatic fire alarm and fire linkage is an independent commissioning system with its own family of items - TB/T 10829-2024 Volume 8, Section 3, automation system commissioning, item 2, 'automatic fire alarm system commissioning', is graded by points and stations and counted in 'systems' (within 500 points, per 100 points; from 500 points upward, per additional 50 points; above 1000 points, per additional 50 points; system integration commissioning graded at up to 40 stations / up to 80 stations / above 80 stations);
- Whether commissioning components are present: note 7 of SJG 111.3-2022 - any supply circuit carrying commissioning components such as instruments, relays or electromagnetic switches (excluding knife switches and fuses) is counted as a commissioning system. Circuits carrying fire alarm / fire linkage commissioning components fall within the fire-protection commissioning system and are not counted again under supply and distribution system commissioning;
- The type of end load: circuits from distribution boards direct to motors (including motor loads such as fire pumps and fans) count only motor load commissioning, without further counting of commissioning of power transmission and distribution apparatus systems (SJG 111.3-2022 measurement rule 4, item 3).
The division on the fire-protection acceptance side cross-confirms this: DB11/T 2000-2022 clause 10.4.5 provides that 'commissioning of the fire linkage control system shall divide inspection lots by controller type, detector type, other field device type, household fire safety system, fire dedicated telephone system, combustible gas detection and alarm system, electrical fire monitoring system, fire equipment power monitoring system, fire equipment emergency power, fire alarm and fire emergency broadcast system, fire shutter system, fire door monitoring system, gaseous extinguishing system, automatic sprinkler system, fire hydrant system, smoke control and extraction system, fire emergency lighting and evacuation indication system, lifts (including escalators), non-fire power supplies and other related systems' - acceptance is by linked system, matching the division of commissioning systems, one controlled system to one commissioning / inspection-lot unit.
Applicable boundaries
- BOQ measurement follows GB/T 50856-2024 Annex D Table D.16.1 (code 030416); the item descriptions and units in the table must be checked against the original; the numbers of specific line items (such as 'commissioning of power supply and distribution apparatus systems, up to 1 kV' and '1 kV to 10 kV') must be taken from the item tables of the consumption standard in use.
- The counting rules sit in the notes and measurement rules of regional / sectoral consumption standards; cross-region tenders must switch to the current standard of the project location; the same question may differ between standards (railway counts cable line commissioning in 'sections' and adjusts substation factors by main transformer count and incoming supply count) and the standards must not be mixed.
- 'At least one circuit' is a floor, not a licence to count every circuit; the rated tripping current is the trip rating, not the frame current.
- Complete plant start-up commissioning is outside these items (counted separately under sectoral quota manuals); component type tests and cable tests are included and must not be split out again.
Further reading
- GB/T 50856-2024 (Standard for Calculation of Quantities of General Installation Works) Annex D Table D.16.1 Electrical testing and commissioning (code 030416) and its notes (definitions of complete start-up systems, special project systems, motor load commissioning, the 'five-prevention' system and commissioning of other items);
- SJG 181.7-2024 (Consumption Standard for Municipal Works, Volume 7: Power Ducts, Communication Ducts and Lighting) Chapter 8 Electrical testing and commissioning: notes (scope, the basis of supply and distribution commissioning) and measurement rules (system count from breaker conditions);
- SJG 111.3-2022 (Consumption Standard for Urban Utility Tunnels, Volume 3: Ancillary Installation Works) notes on electrical equipment commissioning (clauses 1 to 14) and measurement rules (clauses 1 to 13);
- TB/T 10829-2024 (Railway Works Budget Quota Manual, Volume 8: Power Works) Chapter 15 Electrical system commissioning, notes 1 to 5, and Section 3, automation system commissioning, item 2, automatic fire alarm system commissioning (DY-1444 to DY-1449);
- DB11/T 2000-2022 (Code for Acceptance of Fire Protection Construction Quality of Building Works) clause 10.4.5 (inspection-lot division for commissioning of the fire linkage control system).
Keywords
- 送配电装置系统调试
- 电气调整试验
- 030416
- 系统数量划分
- 脱扣器额定电流100A
- 电动机负载调试
- 火灾自动报警系统调试