Multi-project horizontal cost benchmarking: sample homogeneity screening and indicator system construction
The first priority in multi-project cost benchmarking is sample homogeneity: discipline subdivided to specialist works, similar scale magnitude, identical cost type, same region class, with at least 10 comparable samples preferred; then unify calibers / clean data / adjust time differences; build indicators by the three-way classification of value - quantity - consumption indicators, drill down from comprehensive -> unit -> ratio -> price indicators, following the principles of completeness, accuracy, and applicability with unified cost-allocation rules.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 51290-2018 建设工程造价指标指数分类与测算标准
- T/ZBD 100.1-2022 建设工程造价数据建设通用标准
- DBJ/T 15-153-2019 广东省建设项目全过程造价管理规范
Topic Positioning
The complete methodology of multi-project horizontal cost benchmarking, answering "which projects can be compared, with what, and how": sample homogeneity screening, indicator system construction, and level-by-level drill-down analysis.
Core Conclusions
Six benchmarking steps: define samples -> unify calibers -> clean data -> adjust time differences -> build indicators -> analyze. (1) Four hard conditions for samples: same project type subdivided to specialist works/specialist subdivisions (benchmarking takes these as its object; industry/discipline aggregates cannot serve as a pricing basis); similar scale magnitude (area, floors, structural form); identical cost type (estimate != approximate estimate != control price != contract price != settlement price — never mixed); same region class (indicators are measured across region - project type - cost type - time, region precise to county/district level). Prefer at least 10 comparable samples; with fewer, downgrade to rough analogy estimation without statistical conclusions. (2) Three-way indicator classification: value indicators (monetary, e.g., cost per square meter), quantity indicators (physical, e.g., concrete content m3/m2), consumption indicators (labor/material/machinery, e.g., labor days per square meter); analysis drills down level by level from comprehensive -> unit -> ratio -> price indicators, characterized by maximum, minimum, average, and dispersion. (3) Analysis principles: completeness, accuracy, applicability; unified cost-allocation templates to keep indicator scope and content consistent for same-type projects; results entered into an information-management database.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies only where cost data are comparable; data of different disciplines, regions, or cost types cannot be directly compared; with fewer than 10 samples conclusions are for reference only; the six-dimension caliber unification framework, data cleaning, and index adjustment are detailed in the cited cards and not repeated here.
Further Reading
GB/T 51290-2018 Clauses 3.0.2, 3.0.3 (cost-type time basis and four-dimension measurement); T/ZBD 100.1-2022 Clause 3.1.5 (benchmarking objects), Clause 7.3.3 (indicator statistical characteristics); DBJ/T 15-153-2019 Clauses 8.3.2~8.3.4 (indicator classification, allocation unification, and analysis principles).
Keywords
- 多项目成本对标
- 横向对标
- 成本对标
- 样本同质性
- 标杆管理
- 造价指标体系
- 价值指标
- 工程量指标
- 消耗量指标
- 指标可比性