Legality of labour-and-material subcontracting for site temporary facilities (temporary works): the four elements of unlawful subcontracting, the line between specialist-works and labour-operations subcontracting, and the absence of any special exemption for temporary works
"Labour and materials" is itself neither the test of unlawful subcontracting nor one of the statutory cases; site temporary facilities (temporary works) enjoy no special exemption from the unlawful-subcontracting rules - the same tests as permanent works apply, on party qualification, procedure (contract terms or employer approval), object (main structure? re-subcontracting?) and substance (transfer in disguise). The key line: classed as specialist-works subcontracting with matching qualification and self-completion, labour and materials are lawful; classed as labour-operations subcontracting where the contractor charges, beyond labour fees, principal material sums and large / medium plant and principal turnover material costs, it is unlawful (JJSG [2019] No. 1, Article 12 item (6)).
Applicable Codes
- 《建设工程质量管理条例》(国务院令第714号,2019修订)第七十八条
- 《房屋建筑和市政基础设施工程施工分包管理办法》(建设部令第124号)第五条、第九条、第十三条、第十四条
- 《建筑工程施工发包与承包违法行为认定查处管理办法》(建市规〔2019〕1号)第十二条
- https://dohurd.ah.gov.cn/zmhd/cjwt/jzscjg/54606271.html
Topic Positioning
Whether subcontracting site temporary facilities (prefab site offices, steel canopies, hoarding, temporary roads, temporary water and power) on a labour-and-material basis constitutes unlawful subcontracting. The statutory cases, the classing line for labour-and-material contracts, and whether temporary works carry an exemption - for subcontract planning, contract review and compliance self-checks.
Core Conclusions
Finding: labour-and-material contracting is itself neither the test nor a statutory case of unlawful subcontracting; temporary works carry no special exemption - the same rules as permanent works, on four elements: party qualification (a qualified unit, never an individual), procedure (agreed in the general contract or approved by the employer), object (main structure? re-subcontracting?), substance (transfer in disguise).
The key classing line:
- As specialist-works subcontracting: letting the temporary works as a specialist package to a qualified enterprise that carries labour and materials and completes them itself - LAWFUL. Labour-and-material is the norm of specialist subcontracting; the premises are agreement in the general contract or employer approval, and self-completion by the subcontractor.
- As labour-operations subcontracting: a labour operations contractor charging, beyond labour fees, principal material sums and large / medium plant and principal turnover material costs - UNLAWFUL. This is the line "labour and materials" most often crosses, and the main compliance risk of the "temporary works + labour gang on labour and materials" model.
Statutory cases (Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works, 2019 revision, Order No. 714, Article 78): "Divided award means the employer splitting works that one contractor should complete into parts awarded to different contractors. Unlawful subcontracting means: (1) the general contractor subcontracting works to units without matching qualifications; (2) the contractor letting other units complete part of the works, where the general contract is silent and the employer has not approved; (3) the construction general contractor subcontracting the construction of the works' main structure to other units; (4) a subcontractor re-subcontracting the works it has contracted. Transfer means the contractor, after contracting, failing to perform its contractual duties and passing all the works to another, or splitting all the works and passing the parts to others in the name of subcontracting."
Subcontract types and procedure (Measures for the Administration of Subcontracting of Works of Building and Municipal Infrastructure, MOC Order No. 124): Article 5: "Subcontracting of building and municipal infrastructure works divides into specialist-works subcontracting and labour-operations subcontracting. Specialist-works subcontracting means the general contractor letting the specialist works it has contracted to other qualified construction enterprises. Labour-operations subcontracting means the general or specialist contractor letting the labour operations of its works to a labour subcontracting enterprise." Article 9: "Specialist-works subcontracting must be approved by the employer unless agreed in the general contract. The specialist subcontractor must complete the works itself. Labour-operations subcontracting is agreed by labour contract between the parties. The labour subcontractor must complete its tasks itself." Article 13: "Transfer of contracted works is prohibited. Passing all the works to others, or splitting all the works and passing the parts in the name of subcontracting, is transfer. Where, contrary to Article 12, the letting party after subcontracting sets up no project management body on site with no staffing and organises none of the construction, it is DEEMED transfer." Article 14: "Unlawful subcontracting is prohibited. The following are unlawful: (1) letting specialist works or labour operations to subcontractors without matching qualifications; (2) letting part of the specialist works to others where the general contract is silent and the employer has not approved."
Current enforcement (Measures for Identifying and Investigating Unlawful Acts in Awarding and Contracting of Construction Works, JJSG [2019] No. 1, Article 12): "Any of the following is unlawful subcontracting: (1) the contractor subcontracting works to an individual; (2) the general or specialist contractor subcontracting to units without matching qualifications; (3) the general contractor subcontracting the main-structure construction within its scope to others - steel structures excepted; (4) a specialist subcontractor re-subcontracting the non-labour part of its works; (5) a labour operations contractor re-subcontracting its labour; (6) a labour operations contractor charging, beyond labour fees, principal material sums and large / medium plant and principal turnover material costs."
Applicability Boundaries
- The findings address temporary works within the contractor's scope let out by it. Where the employer lets them directly (outside the general contract), the subcontracting rules do not apply - judge under direct-award rules.
- Labour-and-material is not per se unlawful; lawfulness turns on the four elements - never infer "labour and materials = unlawful" or "small, short temporary works are exempt from qualification and procedure".
- "Labour-operations subcontracting plus principal materials, large plant and principal turnover materials" is the enforcement handle - review the subcontract's price make-up as evidence.
- After subcontracting, no on-site management body, no staffing and no organisation of construction is DEEMED transfer under Article 13 - temporary works subcontracted casually for being small and short trigger it alike.
- No penalties, fine amounts or local rules here; no substitute for reviewing the individual contract and settlement documents.
Further Reading
Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works (Order No. 714, 2019), Article 78; MOC Order No. 124, Articles 5, 9, 13 and 14; JJSG [2019] No. 1, Article 12 (Anhui DOHURD Q&A "what is unlawful subcontracting in construction", https://dohurd.ah.gov.cn/zmhd/cjwt/jzscjg/54606271.html ). Beyond: the linkage of subcontract filing, qualification licences and the general contract's scope.
Keywords
- 临建
- 包工包料
- unlawful subcontracting
- 专业工程分包
- 劳务作业分包
- 建设部令第124号
- 建设单位认可
- 视同转包