Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-09-30

Whether "labour and materials" subcontracting is unlawful: specialist-works subcontracting (materials allowed) versus labour-operations subcontracting (charging principal materials is unlawful) - the line (Article 78 of the Regulation + Article 12 of JJSG [2019] No. 1)

"Labour and materials" is not the statutory test of unlawful subcontracting; lawfulness turns on the four elements - party qualification, procedure (employer approval), object (main structure? re-subcontracting?) and substance (transfer in disguise). The key line: specialist-works subcontracting allows labour and materials; per Article 12 item (6) of the Measures for Identifying and Investigating Unlawful Acts in Awarding and Contracting of Construction Works (JJSG [2019] No. 1), a labour operations contractor (labour subcontract) charging, beyond labour fees, principal material sums and large / medium plant and principal turnover material costs is unlawfully subcontracting. Site temporary works carry no special exemption - the same rules.

Applicable Codes

  • 《建设工程质量管理条例》(国务院令第279号,2019年修订)第七十八条
  • 《房屋建筑和市政基础设施工程施工分包管理办法》(建设部令第124号)第五条、第九条、第十三条、第十四条
  • 《建筑工程施工发包与承包违法行为认定查处管理办法》(建市规〔2019〕1号)第十二条
  • 《建筑法》第二十九条
  • https://zjj.yanan.gov.cn/ggfw/zcfg/flfg/1574237851900448770.html
  • https://zjt.jiangxi.gov.cn/jxszfhcxjst/flfgg/pc/content/content_1765229961181589504.html

Topic Positioning

How "labour and materials" relates to unlawful subcontracting: labour-and-material is not among the cases of Article 78 of the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works; lawfulness turns on the subcontract type (specialist-works or labour-operations), the contractor's qualification, employer approval, main-structure involvement, re-subcontracting and transfer in disguise. For legality calls on site temporary works (temporary roads, hoarding, temporary water and power, canopies, site offices and living quarters, access roads and bridges) and general construction subcontracts.

Core Conclusions

1. The statutory cases (original text) Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Works (Order No. 279, 2019 revision), Article 78:

Unlawful subcontracting in this Regulation means: (1) the general contractor subcontracting works to units without matching qualifications; (2) the contractor letting other units complete part of the works, where the general contract is silent and the employer has not approved; (3) the construction general contractor subcontracting the construction of the works' main structure to other units; (4) a subcontractor re-subcontracting the works it has contracted.

Commentary points:

  • Item (1) covers lacking qualifications and over-grade taking.
  • Item (3): the general contractor must itself complete the main structure even with employer consent; "itself" means organising and arranging the main-structure production itself - labour operations, concrete supply and formwork fabrication and erection may still be subcontracted.
  • Item (4): one round of subcontracting only - more layers add management links, weaken control, raise costs, harm quality.
  • Transfer versus subcontracting: in transfer the original contractor passes all its work and performs no duties; in subcontracting it passes part or parts and remains answerable for every duty.

2. The watershed: specialist subcontracting allows labour and materials; labour subcontracting charging principal materials is unlawful

  1. MOC Order No. 124, Article 5: subcontracting divides into specialist-works and labour-operations subcontracting - the specialist kind lets specialist works to other qualified enterprises; the labour kind lets labour operations to a labour subcontracting enterprise.
  2. Order No. 124, Article 9: specialist subcontracting needs employer approval unless agreed in the general contract, and the specialist subcontractor completes the works itself; labour subcontracting is agreed by labour contract (labour subcontracting rests on the labour contract, not on employer approval), and the labour subcontractor completes its tasks itself.
  3. JJSG [2019] No. 1, Article 12 - unlawful subcontracting:

(1) the contractor subcontracting works to an individual; (2) the general or specialist contractor subcontracting to units without matching qualifications; (3) the general contractor subcontracting the main-structure construction within its scope to others - steel structures excepted; (4) a specialist subcontractor re-subcontracting the non-labour part of its works; (5) a labour operations contractor re-subcontracting its labour; (6) a labour operations contractor charging, beyond labour fees, principal material sums and large / medium plant and principal turnover material costs. Hence: specialist subcontractors bringing their own labour, materials and plant is the norm - labour-and-material is not thereby unlawful; while labour subcontracting must not absorb principal materials, large / medium plant or principal turnover materials - charging any of these beyond labour fees falls under item (6) and is unlawful. A labour subcontract's price should run to labour remuneration plus necessary consumables, small tools and low-value turnover materials.

3. The matching clauses of Order No. 124 (building and municipal)

  • Article 14: unlawful subcontracting covers letting specialist works or labour operations to unqualified subcontractors, and letting part of the specialist works to others without contract terms or employer approval.
  • Article 13: transfer prohibited - passing all the works, or splitting all and passing the parts in the name of subcontracting; subcontracting followed by no on-site management body, no staffing and no organisation of construction is deemed transfer. In practice: subcontracting in name, transfer or affiliation in substance - whatever the contract says ("labour subcontract", "labour and materials") - treats as transfer / unlawful subcontracting; who actually organises materials, funds, staff and plant decides.

4. Application to temporary works Site temporary works (temporary roads, hoarding, temporary water and power, canopies, offices and quarters, access roads and bridges) carry no exemption from the unlawful-subcontracting rules - the four elements apply unchanged; they usually price under preliminaries / temporary facilities, which has no bearing on the legality of labour-and-material. Judge each temporary-works subcontract by its true legal nature - specialist or labour - then apply the rules above.

Applicability Boundaries

  • The rules address construction subcontracting (building and municipal infrastructure); survey and design subcontracting has its own rules.
  • Order No. 124 covers building and municipal works; highway, railway and water works also check sector rules and contract terms.
  • JJSG [2019] No. 1 Article 12 item (3) sets the steel-structure exception to the main-structure bar.
  • "Self-completion" of the main structure does not bar subcontracting labour operations, concrete supply or formwork fabrication and erection (per the commentary).
  • Conclusions rest on contract terms, the BOQ basis and actual performance (site management body and staffing, materials and funds supply, organisation of construction) - the words "labour and materials" alone decide nothing.
  • Penalties, contract validity, settlement and non-measurement consequences sit outside.

Further Reading

Keywords

Cited By