Whether profit is claimable in works claims: the dividing line is the nature of the liability (breach / non-breach) - claims arising from the employer's breach of contract may include profit (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 8.11.9 and 8.11.10; GF-2017-0201 items 7.5.1, 7.8.1, 10.4.1), while adverse physical conditions, abnormally adverse climatic conditions and force majeure carry cost and time only, without profit
Whether profit can be claimed depends on the nature of the event's liability, not on the size of the loss: works claims arising from causes for which the employer is in breach may include profit (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.11.9, final paragraph). Clause 8.11.10 lists 8 employer-liability events for which profit may additionally be claimed (transferring work to another contractor; late supply of drawings or the site; defective or late materials; setting-out errors and rework; extra site restrictions or interference with the works sequence; delay, suspension and failure to resume on time; occupying the works before completion; repair of defects within the defects liability period). GF-2017-0201 item 7.5.1 expressly provides that 'the employer shall bear the delayed time and/or extra cost thus caused, and shall pay the contractor a reasonable profit'; item 7.8.1 'and pay the contractor a reasonable profit'; item 10.4.1(3) prices variations on the basis of 'a reasonable composition of cost and profit'. By contrast, item 7.6 (adverse physical conditions) and item 7.7 (abnormally adverse climatic conditions) only provide that 'the extra cost and/or delayed time shall be borne by the employer', without profit; force majeure is shared under item 17.3.2, likewise without profit; events caused by government authorities give only an extension of time, each party bearing its own economic loss. GB 50500-2013 clause 9.13.4 (that edition superseded) listed 'reasonable expected profit' as one optional remedy without drawing the line by nature of liability; the current basis is GB/T 50500-2024 section 8.11 plus the contract.
Applicable Codes
- GF-2017-0201 建设工程施工合同(示范文本)通用合同条款 7.5.1、7.6、7.7、7.8.1、10.4.1、17.3.2、19.1
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第8.11.9条、第8.11.10条
- GB 50500-2013 建设工程工程量清单计价规范 第9.13.4条(已废止,已被替代)
Scope of the Topic
In a works claim report, can the 'profit' head be claimed at all, and where is the line drawn - listing profit indiscriminately under every claim head is one of the items most commonly struck out on review. This card focuses on the profit head itself: the test is the nature of the event's liability (breach vs non-breach), with a two-level comparison across the standard clauses and the model contract text.
Core Conclusions
General rule: profit follows the nature of the liability, not the size of the loss
GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.11.9, final paragraph, reads: 'Unless otherwise provided in the contract, works claims arising from causes attributable to the employer's breach may include profit, and the employer shall compensate the contractor's loss; for economic loss and/or time delay events caused by government authorities, the time shall be extended accordingly, and the economic losses suffered by the employer and the contractor shall be borne by each party itself.' That is: employer breach / attributable cause -> profit may be included; government-authority cause -> extension of time only, each party bearing its own loss, no profit.
The profit watershed at standard level: 8.11.9 (claimable scope) and 8.11.10 (profit additionally claimable)
Clause 8.11.9 first gives the scope of losses claimable for causes not attributable to the contractor (labour, material, plant, water and electricity consumption losses from suspension, waiting and reduced efficiency; labour, material and plant cost changes arising from time adjustment; necessary preliminaries for suspension, resumption and maintaining the site; direct costs of rework, alteration and repair plus the direct loss of scrapped materials; extra inspection and testing costs; losses caused by failure to pay the contract price as agreed; effects of suspensions caused by the discovery of relics; other losses the contractor can evidence and the VAT thereon; the reasonable time extended), and only in the final paragraph opens the general gate that 'works claims arising from causes attributable to the employer's breach may include profit'. Clause 8.11.10 makes the gate concrete with 8 employer-liability events in which profit may additionally be claimed: 'where the following events occur for causes attributable to the employer and cause the contractor economic loss and extra cost and/or time extension, the contractor may, in addition to claiming economic loss and extra cost and/or time delay under clause 8.11.9 of this standard, also claim profit':
- the employer transfers an item of work under the contract to another contractor;
- the employer supplies the construction drawings or the site late;
- materials supplied by the employer are defective, late, delivered elsewhere or otherwise cause the works to be defective;
- setting-out errors by the contractor caused by the employer, and rework of the works;
- extra restrictions imposed by the employer on the site, failure to perform approvals on time, interference with the normal works sequence, and the like;
- delay, suspension of the works, or failure to resume on time after suspension, caused by the employer;
- the employer occupies the works before completion;
- repair of defects or damage to the works within the defects liability period caused by the employer.
'With profit / without profit' comparison at model-contract level (GF-2017-0201 general conditions)
- With profit: item 7.5.1 (delay caused by the employer) - 'the employer shall bear the delayed time and/or extra cost thus caused, and shall pay the contractor a reasonable profit'; its listed events include (1) failure to supply drawings as agreed or supply of non-conforming drawings; (2) failure to provide the site, site conditions, base data, permits, approvals and other commencement conditions as agreed; (3) errors or omissions in the survey benchmarks, base lines and level points and their written data; (4) failure to issue the commencement notice within 7 days of the planned commencement date; (5) failure to pay advance payments, progress payments or final account payments on the agreed dates; (6) failure of the supervising engineer to issue instructions, approvals and other documents as agreed; (7) other events agreed in the particular conditions. Item 7.8.1 (suspension caused by the employer) - 'the employer shall bear the extra cost and/or delayed time thus caused, and pay the contractor a reasonable profit'. Item 10.4.1(3), the third tier of variation valuation - the unit rate of the varied work is determined on the principle of 'a reasonable composition of cost and profit', i.e. the profit on a design change is embedded in the variation valuation and not separately claimed.
- Without profit: item 7.6 (adverse physical conditions) - the extra cost and/or delayed time incurred by the contractor in taking reasonable measures is borne by the employer, with no mention of profit; item 7.7 (abnormally adverse climatic conditions) - likewise only 'extra cost and/or delayed time' borne by the employer, no mention of profit. Although these two risks sit with the employer, they are 'risk allocation' rather than 'breach', so the profit head fails; only cost plus time can be claimed.
- Force majeure: item 17.3.2 allocates the consequences - damage to the permanent works and to materials and engineering equipment delivered to site, and third-party personal injury and property loss caused by such damage, are borne by the employer; damage to the contractor's construction plant is borne by the contractor; each party bears its own personnel injuries and property losses; the time is extended, suspension costs are shared reasonably between the parties, and workers' wages that must be paid during suspension are borne by the employer; acceleration costs required by the employer are borne by the employer; the costs of care, cleaning and repair of the works during suspension as required by the employer are borne by the employer. Every item is a sharing of cost/loss, without profit.
Historical edition basis (mind the citation)
GB 50500-2013 clause 9.13.4 (that edition is superseded): 'When the contractor seeks compensation, it may obtain compensation by one or several of the following means: 1 extension of time; 2 requiring the employer to pay the extra costs actually incurred; 3 requiring the employer to pay a reasonable expected profit; 4 requiring the employer to pay liquidated damages as agreed in the contract.' That clause drew no line by the nature of the event's liability and was general in terms; projects contracted under it may still invoke it, while contracts signed in 2026 should follow the contract agreement plus GB/T 50500-2024 section 8.11.
Operational points
Before listing claim costs item by item, first test the nature of the liability: employer breach / liability events (late drawings or site, suspension, occupying the works before completion, transferring work to another contractor, extra site restrictions and the like) -> cost plus profit; adverse physical conditions, abnormally adverse climatic conditions, force majeure -> cost only (adverse physical conditions limited to 'extra cost from taking reasonable measures') plus time; government-authority causes -> time only, each party bearing its own loss. The profit on a design change is already embedded in the variation valuation; when derivative losses are claimed separately, profit does not automatically follow, and the part already counted in the variation valuation must be deducted to avoid double counting.
Applicability Boundaries
- Whether the profit head 'stands' depends only on the nature of the event's liability, not on the size of the loss or the weight of the evidence; but a standing profit head does not mean a standing claim - the three elements of a valid claim and the procedural requirements still apply (e.g. GF-2017-0201 item 19.1: a Notice of Claim within 28 days of knowing or of ought to have known of the claim event, a claim report within 28 days of the notice, failing which the right to additional payment and/or extension of time is lost).
- The base and rate of any profit are set by the contract or by agreement / determination; this card decides only 'whether profit is claimable' and does not deal with the profit rate.
- GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.11.9 opens with 'unless otherwise provided in the contract'; where the particular conditions provide otherwise, those provisions prevail (a wider or narrower profit scope may be agreed).
- GB 50500-2013 has been replaced by GB/T 50500-2024: contracts signed in 2026 cite section 8.11 of the current edition, and clause 9.13.4 of the 2013 edition remains valid only for projects contracted under it.
Further Reading
- GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.11.9 (the list of claimable event classes, the breakdown of suspension and standby losses, the general clause that profit may be included) and clause 8.11.10 (the 8 employer-liability events with additional profit); the procedural clauses within the same section 8.11 (Notice of Claim -> claim report -> reply -> payment).
- GF-2017-0201 general conditions: 7.5.1 (delay caused by the employer); 7.6 (adverse physical conditions); 7.7 (abnormally adverse climatic conditions); 7.8.1 (suspension caused by the employer); 10.4.1 (third tier of variation valuation including cost and profit); 17.3.2 (consequences of force majeure); 19.1 to 19.4 (claims procedure).
- GB 50500-2013 clause 9.13.4 (four remedies, superseded; the current basis is GB/T 50500-2024 section 8.11).
Keywords
- 可索赔利润
- 利润索赔
- 发包人违约责任
- 不利物质条件
- 异常恶劣气候条件
- 8.11.10
- 9.13.4
- 暂停施工利润