Suspension caused by the employer: claim basis and accrual limits for on-site management staff wages (suspension management fee)
Where construction is suspended for employer causes, on-site management staff wages are claimable: GB/T 51262-2017 Clause 5.8.3 expressly includes "wages of on-site production workers and management staff" in the cost schedule; GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 8.11.9/8.11.10 list idle-labor costs as a claimable loss and additionally allow profit to be claimed. Accrual follows T/YJXB 0001-2023 Clause 4.0.8 "reasonable suspension management fee" — not higher than in the normal construction period, not zeroed out, based on actual occurrence. It is subject to three limits: the duty to mitigate (necessity of retained staff), cost vouchers, and the 28-day claim procedure; contrary contract agreements prevail.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 51262-2017 建设工程造价鉴定规范
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准
- T/YJXB 0001-2023 建设工程停工承包人费用计算标准
- 民法典
Topic Positioning
Whether the contractor's on-site management staff wages (suspension management fee) are claimable when construction is suspended for employer causes, how to accrue them, and what limits apply — a directly reusable set of standard interpretations and compliance reasoning.
Core Conclusions
- Claimable, with national-standard basis: GB/T 51262-2017 Code for Cost Expert Determination of Construction Works, Clause 5.8.3, provides that suspension costs caused by the employer are borne by the employer, and its cost schedule expressly lists "wages of on-site production workers and management staff"; GB/T 50500-2024 Standard for Valuation of Construction Works with Bills of Quantities, Clause 8.11.9, lists "idle-labor costs of mobilized personnel unable to proceed with construction" as a claimable loss, and Clause 8.11.10 additionally allows profit to be claimed for employer-responsibility causes (including suspension and failure to resume on time).
- Accrual basis: per T/YJXB 0001-2023 Standard for Calculation of Contractor's Suspension Costs, Clause 4.0.8, a "reasonable suspension management fee" shall be accrued over the suspension — for short suspensions management staff are generally not dismissed; wages, office expenses, etc. occur per actual day; the amount shall be no higher than the management fee of the normal construction period, nor zeroed out outright.
- Three limits: ① duty to mitigate (Civil Code + T/YJXB Clause 3.0.9) — expanded losses from failure to take loss-prevention measures cannot be claimed, and the necessity of retention determines the compensable headcount; ② accrual per actual occurrence, evidenced by payroll vouchers, attendance records, social insurance, etc.; ③ procedurally, per the contract, issue the claim notice within 28 days after the event and submit the claim report within a further 28 days — late submission is deemed waiver.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to suspension claims caused by the employer (or borne by the employer per contract); suspension costs caused by the contractor are self-borne; force majeure is handled separately per GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 8.11.12–8.11.14. Not applicable to single-point price queries or case-specific computation; actual amounts must be determined against suspension duration, the retained-staff roster, and the special conditions of the contract.
Further Reading
GB/T 51262-2017 Clause 5.8.3; GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 8.11.9, 8.11.10 (and force majeure clauses 8.11.12–8.11.14); T/YJXB 0001-2023 Clauses 2.0.9, 3.0.9, 4.0.8; mitigation rules of the Civil Code; claim procedure in the general conditions of GF-2017-0201.
Keywords
- 停工索赔
- 管理人员工资
- suspension of the works
- time-related overheads during suspension
- idle (standby) costs of labour and plant
- 减损义务
- 51262
- T/YJXB 0001-2023
Related Cards
- →
Evolution of the 28-day time limit for construction claims: GB 50500-2013 'forfeiture of the right to claim' vs GB/T 50500-2024 'may be deemed waived', and the 28-day fallback where the contract is silent
GB 50500-2013 (abolished), Clause 9.13.2: the contractor shall submit a Notice of Claim within 28 days after knowing, or ought to have known, of the claim event; 'if the contractor fails to issue the Notice of Claim within the time limit, it forfeits the right to claim' (hard forfeiture). GB/T 50500-2024 (current, recommendatory), Clause 8.11.3, changes this to submission of the Notice of Claim 'within the period agreed in the contract (28 days if not agreed)', and where overdue, it 'may be handled as agreed in the contract' (soft treatment - the strength of forfeiture is delegated to the contract), plus a catch-all clause: 'where the aggrieved party fails to lodge a claim within the agreed time after the claim event arises, it may be deemed to have waived the relevant construction claim, unless otherwise agreed in the contract or provided by laws and regulations.' Where the contract sets no period, the 28-day limit still applies as fallback (Notice of Claim then report, dual nodes), and the overdue consequence falls under 'may be deemed waived', leaving room for exemption through contrary contract agreement, other provisions of laws and regulations, and the discretionary word 'may'.
- →
A verification framework for judging the completeness of a construction claim evidence chain: three-factor multiplication, four fact links, four-question checks
A claim holds = the multiplicative product of basis + evidence + procedure — any factor at zero zeroes the result; the evidence chain must link by link support the four fact links "event occurred → cause attributable → consequence → loss quantified", with each document checked by four questions — timeliness, competent party, relevance, and corroboration; procedurally, absent contract terms, claims proceed on the 28-day two-node basis, and late submission is deemed waiver.
- →
Settlement of works variations without signed instructions (qianzheng): five-tier determination rules, substitute evidence chains, and variation pricing principles
Signed instructions are not the only settlement basis. Whether an un-instructed variation can be settled depends on "who proposed the variation and whether traces of employer/supervisor approval exist": if not proposed by the contractor and instructions/drawings exist, or proposed by the contractor with either the employer's or the supervisor's consent → a determinate opinion can be issued and the amount settled; proposed by the contractor with drawings only and no confirmation → only an elective opinion, with risk; no confirmation and no drawings → costs should not be adjusted. Substitute evidence — design variation sheets, meeting minutes, supervisor records, photos/videos, etc. — can be collected; the deemed-acceptance rule for late verification and variation pricing principles can also be invoked.
Cited By
- ←
Suspension of the works in four categories (employer-caused / contractor-caused / force majeure / government-ordered suspension): comparison of cost treatment - entitlement rules for personnel wages, time-related overheads during suspension, idle plant costs and suspension profit, extension of time and evidentiary requirements (clause-level comparison)
Suspension is classified by responsible party into three categories, with administrative suspension listed separately. (1) Employer-caused (GB/T 51262-2017 clause 5.8.3 item 2; GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 8.11.9/8.11.10): workers' wages, reasonable time-related overheads during suspension, idle plant costs, and the costs of protection, safekeeping and resumption preparations are all recoverable, profit may additionally be claimed, and time is extended. (2) Contractor-caused (clause 5.8.3 item 3; clause 5.7.4 item 2): all costs are self-borne with no extension of time, and T/YJXB 0001-2023 clause 1.0.3 expressly excludes such pricing. (3) Force majeure (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.11.12): losses are allocated by statute - only 'the wages of necessary management and security personnel required by the employer to remain on site and the wages of idle workers', together with the costs of care, clearance and repair and the acceleration costs, fall on the employer, while damage to construction plant and the suspension losses fall on the contractor; time is extended. (4) Government-ordered suspension (clause 8.11.13): time is extended and each party bears its own losses, with Section 8.8 policy-based price adjustment and clause 8.11.12 items 4 and 5 retained as exceptions. Each cost item is calculated under T/YJXB 0001-2023 Chapter 5 on the principle of 'actual-expenditure method first, rule-and-standard method as fallback', with evidence prepared under clauses 6.0.3/6.0.5/6.0.8/6.0.9.
- ←
Liability and pricing basis for plant standby (idle machine-shift) costs: a comparison of four scenarios, employer-caused, contractor-caused, force majeure and abnormally adverse weather, with the code and contract clause authority and the rate-reduction rules for standby machine-shifts
Who bears the plant standby cost is decided by who caused the standstill, not by whether the plant stands on site: for an employer-caused standstill the employer bears the cost and profit may additionally be claimed (GB/T 50500-2024 Articles 8.11.9 and 8.11.10; GF-2017-0201 clause 7.8.1); for a contractor-caused standstill the contractor bears it alone (GB/T 51262-2017 Article 5.8.3 paragraph 3; T/YJXB 0001-2023 Article 1.0.3); under force majeure, 'damage to the contractor's construction plant and its costs of suspension' are borne by the contractor while the time for completion is extended (Article 8.11.12 paragraphs 2 and 5); abnormally adverse weather follows the contract, the extra cost of reasonable measures being borne by the employer (GF-2017-0201 clause 7.7). In pricing, the standby machine-shift rate = depreciation + labour cost (idle machine operators) + other charges, excluding overhaul, maintenance and fuel and power, with no uniform percentage discount.
- ←
Organising evidence for suspension cost claims: itemised proof lists for labour, plant and overheads, and the three conditions of an established claim (T/YJXB 0001-2023 Chapter 6; GB/T 50326-2017 Article 7.5.8)
A suspension cost claim must satisfy three conditions at once: claiming per the contract (failing or unclear terms, per laws and regulations), collecting claim materials comprehensively, and giving notice of claim intention and the report within the agreed or statutory periods - the three indispensable conditions (GB/T 50326-2017 Article 7.5.8). Proof is itemised by cost: production workers' wages need minutes, construction logs, labour / service contracts, attendance sheets, payroll, payment records and site clock-ins, plus proof of the necessity and objectivity of the wages having to be paid; plant standby needs entry / exit acceptance sheets, hire contracts, plant lists, hire settlements and reconciliation statements; suspension overheads need documents proving total overheads and contract duration - tender documents, budgets, drawings, contract - and one must provide sufficient evidence of the overhead amount for each day (T/YJXB 0001-2023 Articles 6.0.5, 6.0.3, 6.0.8). Where site certifications exist they govern (Article 3.0.3).
- ←
Where the employer serves a notice of termination, the contractor promptly vacates, and the court later finds the termination invalid: whether the contractor's evacuation constitutes breach (stopping work and vacating the site characterised separately; three conditions of exemption), scenario comparison, loss sharing, and the effective dates of the legal bases
In principle the evacuation is not a breach by the contractor, but 'vacating the site' must be split into two acts: where the termination is invalid the contract still subsists, so if the employer merely served a termination notice it had no right to serve, without suspension or demobilisation instructions, the contractor that stops work on its own and removes its mobilised plant and materials may be found in breach for unauthorised suspension; by contrast, vacating on the strength of the employer's written termination notice and express instructions to stop work, demobilise and hand back the site is the creditor's refusal to accept performance plus a mitigation measure, is not attributable to the contractor, and the evacuation costs and suspension losses are claimable from the employer under Articles 803 and 804 of the Civil Code. Three conditions of exemption: a written notice or instruction as basis; evacuation proportionate to the instruction; prompt resumption once the employer withdraws the notice or requires resumption. Termination by notice does not take effect of itself: without a right to terminate, 'no effect of termination arises' (Fa Shi [2023] No. 13, Article 53), and the same holds even if the other party fails to sue within the objection period (Conference Minutes, Fa [2019] No. 254, Article 46).
- ←
Checklist of elements of proof for an employer claiming liquidated damages for delay (late completion) and the measurement of the days of delay: the liquidated damages clause; the commencement date and the contract period; determination of the actual completion date under three scenarios; deduction of approved extensions; attribution of the delay and apportionment of concurrent delay; and the rule of sharing concurrent delays in proportion to liability
Claimable, but the amount is not fixed directly by 'how many days late it actually was': days of delay = actual completion date - (commencement date + contract period + extension approved by the employer), multiplied by the contractually agreed daily rate (subject to any cap). Civil Code Article 585(1) is the basis of the claim, and the employer bears the burden of proof under Civil Procedure Law Article 67(1); where the contractor proves statutory or agreed grounds for extension, or that it applied for an extension within the agreed period, the days are reduced (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Articles 9 and 10). The employer need not first prove actual loss - the burden of proving that 'the liquidated damages are excessively higher than the loss' lies on the defaulting party - but to withstand a judicial reduction the employer should still have loss evidence ready.
- ←
Whether wages of site management personnel and time-related overheads during suspension can be included in an idle-cost claim: determining recoverable and non-recoverable scenarios, the calculation basis and the procedural limits
Yes, but only when handled as two separate cost heads passing three gates. (1) Wages of site management personnel are claimable: GB/T 51262-2017 Clause 5.8.3(2) lists 'wages of site production workers and management personnel' directly among the costs the employer bears when suspension of the works arises from the employer's cause. (2) Suspension overheads are calculable: T/YJXB 0001-2023 Clause 4.0.8 provides that 'reasonable suspension overheads shall be accrued over the suspension period ... they shall be no higher than the overheads amount during normal construction, nor reduced straight to zero', and Clause 5.0.8 computes them as daily average overheads x a reasonable percentage x suspension days (daily average overheads = total contract overheads / contract duration); the clause states only the method and no fixed percentage, and the head must not be double-billed with idle costs. (3) Suspension caused by the contractor is borne by the contractor (Clause 5.8.3(3)); under force majeure only 'wages of the necessary management and security personnel the employer requires to remain on site' are borne by the employer (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 8.11.12(4)); where government authorities order a stoppage each party bears its own losses (Clause 8.11.13); wages of personnel already dismissed and not actually paid are not counted (Clause 4.0.5); the claim is bound by the duty to mitigate under Civil Code Article 591 and the 28-day claim period; and suspension and idle losses carry no priority right of payment out of the works (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 17(2)).
- ←
Allocating liability when employer-cause and contractor-cause events delay completion concurrently or in succession: attribution by time segment, extension of time only for the net delay on the critical path, overlapping periods shared in proportion to responsibility, and delay damages charged only on the residual delay left after extension
Neither a 50/50 split nor full liability on either party: the governing approach is 'attribution by segment + sharing in proportion to causative weight + no double counting'. Where responsibility can be separated by time segment, each segment is attributed to its own cause; only genuinely simultaneous, inseparable overlap periods are shared between the parties in proportion to their respective responsibility (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 cl. 4.9.7 para 4). The extendable time equals the net delay caused on the critical path by employer-cause events (and relief events): where the delaying event affects a critical activity, the delay time itself is the extension claimed; where a non-critical activity overruns its total float and becomes critical, the extension is 'delay time minus total float'; where it remains non-critical, no extension claim arises (GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 8.11.8). Delay damages / liquidated damages are charged only for the days by which the actual completion date is later than the extended completion date, because the very base of delay damages is 'the contract time for completion (including extensions approved by the employer)' (GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 2.0.33).
- ←
Start and end dates for calculating standby rent and standby costs of standing construction plant (hired or owned): to which date they run absent a demobilisation site record, the presumption of the due demobilisation date, and the boundary set by the duty to mitigate
Absence of a demobilisation site record does not defeat the standby-cost claim; it only changes the mode of proof (T/YJXB 0001-2023, Art. 3.0.3: a site record governs where one exists; otherwise the standard applies). Standby rent claimable against the employer runs to the earlier of the 'actual demobilisation date' and the 'due demobilisation date': the due date = suspension date + about 30 days + a reasonable removal period (Art. 4.0.12 takes 'a fairly long suspension, generally more than 30 days' as the yardstick for when demobilisation should occur); where the employer instructs in writing that plant remain on site or demobilisation is objectively impossible, the boundary is the date the instruction ends or the actual demobilisation date; any overstay beyond that is enlarged loss under Article 591 of the Civil Code, borne by the contractor itself. Towards the lessor, rent runs under the hire contract until the plant is actually returned.
- ←
Bases of claim and evidentiary elements for suspension caused by late delivery of employer-supplied (free-issue) materials: the claim bases in Civil Code Arts. 803/804, costs and profit under GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 3.6.1/3.6.5, judicial relief where extension of time is uncertified, an elements table with itemised evidence, the 28-day claim procedure, and exclusion from the priority right
Yes, a claim lies, and it goes beyond an extension of time: under Civil Code Art. 803 the contractor may extend the works date and claim damages for suspension, idle time and like losses; Art. 804 lists the recoverable scope as 'losses and actual costs from suspension, idle labour and plant, double handling, relocation of plant and machinery, and accumulation of materials and components'; GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 3.6.5 goes further: where delivery dates are delayed for reasons attributable to the employer, the affected duration shall be reasonably extended and 'the contractor's losses compensated, including profit' (cl. 8.11.10 likewise allows profit to be claimed for events within the employer's responsibility). The claim must prove three links of causation (late employer-supplied delivery -> suspension of critical-path activities -> losses actually incurred). The elements are: (1) the employer-supply scope and delivery deadlines are defined; (2) the employer actually delivered late; (3) the delay falls on the critical path and caused suspension; (4) the start and end of the suspension are fixed; (5) the losses are real and quantifiable (actual-expenditure method first, rule-based standard method as fallback); (6) the contractor mitigated; (7) the claim was lodged under the 28-day two-stage procedure. Even without a certified extension of time, the contractor may still claim the extension if it applied within the contract period and the ground qualifies under the contract (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25 Art. 10). Suspension and idle-time losses are payable on action but enjoy no priority right of payment out of the works price (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Art. 17(2)).
- ←
Whether losses from suspension of the works and idle time can be brought within the priority right of repayment of the construction project price (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 17(2): not supported; the debt claim may be pursued but enjoys no priority ranking)
No. Article 17(2) of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 reads: 'Where a contractor claims the priority right of repayment of the construction project price for losses such as suspension of the works or idle time caused by reasons attributable to the employer, the people's court shall not support the claim.' In character such losses are economic loss caused by the employer's breach (claim money), of the same category as the interest, liquidated damages and damages excluded by Article 40(2) of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25: the debt itself is established, can be sued for and paid, but enjoys no ranking ahead of mortgages and other claims; the character is not changed by the loss being certified in a site instruction record or included in the settlement total, and under Article 17(1) of the same interpretation the court must state in the operative part of the judgment 'the amount of the construction price enjoying the priority right of repayment and the corresponding works'.
- ←
The turnover-material supplement for works suspended on site: definition, scope limits and the two calculation bases of hired versus owned (T/YJXB 0001-2023 clause 4.0.4)
Turnover materials of the contractor remaining on site during suspension earn a turnover-material supplement (T/YJXB 0001-2023 clause 4.0.4). Turnover materials are those usable repeatedly while keeping their form and transferring value gradually - chiefly forms, square timbers, steel pipes, clips and jacks; in that standard the term covers only turnover materials serving scaffolding works and concrete formwork and supports (falsework), excluding the pipes and clips of HSE provisions. Hired turnover materials charge the hire payable over the suspension per the hire contract; owned materials incur standby costs over the suspension, computed by reference to the relevant documents.
- ←
Deciding situations where a claim succeeds but only an extension of time is granted without cost compensation: allocation of suspension losses between force majeure and government-mandated stoppages, abnormally adverse climatic conditions, the three requirements for cost claims, negative tests for idle costs, allocation of responsibility for concurrent delay, and the link to delay damages
Under GB/T 50500-2024, 'the claim succeeds but only time is extended, without cost compensation' is not a single event type: (1) force majeure (clause 8.11.12) and stoppages required by government authorities, stoppages required by state or local authorities for safety or environmental protection, stoppages under health and epidemic control requirements, and commotions and riots (clause 8.11.13) operate as 'extension of time plus each party bearing its own losses', but the opening words of clause 8.11.13 expressly exclude policy-based price adjustment under section 8.8 and paragraphs 4 and 5 of clause 8.11.12 (wages of management and security personnel required to remain on site by the employer, wages of idle personnel, and care, clearance and repair costs; acceleration costs required by the employer) - these three heads remain claimable; (2) abnormally adverse climatic conditions (GF-2017-0201 item 7.7) extend time and carry 'the increased costs of reasonable measures taken', but suspension idle losses are outside the item's listed scope; (3) a cost claim must simultaneously satisfy three requirements: a cause not attributable to the contractor (a risk recognised by the contract), actual loss actually incurred, and causation; (4) idle costs fail where no idling actually occurred, or where the delay did not affect the critical path or the total float; (5) concurrent delay is allocated under clause 8.11.15: 'the party responsible for causing the delay bears it; where both parties are responsible, in proportion to their shares of responsibility'; (6) an approved extension of time raises the baseline for calculating delay damages; only unapproved delay triggers delay damages under clause 2.0.33.
- ←
Whether profit is claimable in works claims: the dividing line is the nature of the liability (breach / non-breach) - claims arising from the employer's breach of contract may include profit (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 8.11.9 and 8.11.10; GF-2017-0201 items 7.5.1, 7.8.1, 10.4.1), while adverse physical conditions, abnormally adverse climatic conditions and force majeure carry cost and time only, without profit
Whether profit can be claimed depends on the nature of the event's liability, not on the size of the loss: works claims arising from causes for which the employer is in breach may include profit (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.11.9, final paragraph). Clause 8.11.10 lists 8 employer-liability events for which profit may additionally be claimed (transferring work to another contractor; late supply of drawings or the site; defective or late materials; setting-out errors and rework; extra site restrictions or interference with the works sequence; delay, suspension and failure to resume on time; occupying the works before completion; repair of defects within the defects liability period). GF-2017-0201 item 7.5.1 expressly provides that 'the employer shall bear the delayed time and/or extra cost thus caused, and shall pay the contractor a reasonable profit'; item 7.8.1 'and pay the contractor a reasonable profit'; item 10.4.1(3) prices variations on the basis of 'a reasonable composition of cost and profit'. By contrast, item 7.6 (adverse physical conditions) and item 7.7 (abnormally adverse climatic conditions) only provide that 'the extra cost and/or delayed time shall be borne by the employer', without profit; force majeure is shared under item 17.3.2, likewise without profit; events caused by government authorities give only an extension of time, each party bearing its own economic loss. GB 50500-2013 clause 9.13.4 (that edition superseded) listed 'reasonable expected profit' as one optional remedy without drawing the line by nature of liability; the current basis is GB/T 50500-2024 section 8.11 plus the contract.
- ←
Calculation of plant standby costs when the works stand suspended for reasons attributable to the employer: standby cost = standby rate per machine-shift x number of standby machine-shifts, the cost components of the standby machine-shift rate, whether overheads and profit are taken, and the difference in compensation scope between contractor-owned plant (priced on machine-shift rate norms) and hired plant (priced on hire charges)
Plant standby cost = sum of (standby rate per machine-shift x number of standby machine-shifts); the number of standby machine-shifts is fixed as 'idle plant units x days of suspension x machine-shift conversion factor per day (an 8h working day = 1 machine-shift per unit per day)'. Under T/YJXB 0001-2023 Clause 5.0.3: hired plant is priced on the hire charges actually incurred during the suspension, and contractor-owned plant on the machine-shift rate norms. The standby rate per machine-shift is built up from depreciation + labour cost + other charges (the Shandong and Jiangsu scope); the Hunan scope takes machine-shift depreciation only, with idle operator and banksman costs calculated separately per certified site records; repair, maintenance and power charges are excluded. The standby rate carries no uplift for overheads or profit; where the employer is liable, profit may be claimed separately under GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 8.11.10 (listed alone under the suspension-profit rule, not duplicated inside the machine-shift rate).
- ←
Computing and compensating suspension and idle-resource losses caused by the employer: idle labour costs, plant standby costs (hired vs owned plant), suspension overheads and suspension profit
Where the employer causes the suspension, the employer bears the costs (GB/T 51262-2017 Article 5.8.3); the contractor may claim, under GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.11.9, idle costs of mobilised labour, losses of mobilised materials, plant standby costs and other losses, and Article 8.11.10 allows a further profit claim for employer-fault causes (including suspension and failure to resume on time). Computation per T/YJXB 0001-2023: the actual-outlay method first for wages with the rule-based method as fallback, and outlays objectively unnecessary are not counted (5.0.5 / 4.0.5); plant standby costs - hired plant at the hire charges actually incurred, owned plant at the machine-shift quota (5.0.3); suspension overheads = daily overheads (total contract overheads / contract duration) x reasonable ratio x suspension days, neither above normal construction nor zero (5.0.8 / 4.0.8); suspension profit = daily profit x reasonable ratio x suspension days, being loss of expectation interest (5.0.9 / 4.0.9).
- ←
Claimable scope and profit-claim boundary under GB/T 50500-2024: the nine event classes of Article 8.11.9 with the four-way split of suspension losses, the eight employer-fault situations where Article 8.11.10 adds profit, and the independent-assessment rule for EOT claims in Article 8.11.7
GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.11.9 lists nine claimable event classes for non-contractor causes (losses of labour, materials, plant and utilities from stoppage, waiting and reduced efficiency; direct costs of cost fluctuation from programme adjustment; site-protection measures on suspension and resumption; direct costs of rework, alteration and scrapped materials; extra inspection and testing costs; losses from price not paid as agreed; suspension effects from unearthing antiquities; other provable losses and VAT; and reasonable extension of time), with suspension losses split into idle labour, unusable mobilised materials, plant standby and other losses; save as the contract provides otherwise, only claims arising from the employer's breach may include profit (Article 8.11.10 lists eight such situations), losses caused by government authorities being borne by each party with time extended accordingly.
- ←
Loss handling for demolition of completed works caused by design changes: the three-way method (completed works paid as measured + demolition costs priced separately + losses claimed)
Demolishing completed works for a design change is itself a variation (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 2.0.28 includes "demolition and removal from site of completed works"), with losses handled by the three-way method: (1) portions completed and of accepted quality before demolition are paid per the contractual measurement rules (Clause 7.4.1); (2) demolition and debris removal are re-measured and re-priced as new variation BOQ items per Clauses 8.9.1/8.9.2; (3) scrapped materials, direct rework/reconstruction costs, idle (standby) costs of labour and plant, plant standing time, and preliminaries for suspension and resumption are claimed per Clause 8.11.9, with profit additionally claimed per Clause 8.11.10 where the cause is the employer's responsibility. The 28-day claim procedure is the red line; demolition costs arising from the contractor's own causes (quality failing acceptance) are borne by the contractor (Clause 8.11.18).
- ←
Claiming idle-labor and standstill machinery losses after cancellation of business-line construction plans (blockades/windows): elements, cost composition, calculation, procedure and time limits
Where a business-line blockade/window plan is cancelled for reasons not attributable to the contractor, the contractor may claim idle-labor costs and machinery standstill costs: rented machinery at actual rent, owned machinery at machinery-shift cost quotas (T/YJXB 0001-2023, Clause 5.0.3); costs include idle labor, management and protection staff wages, materials/equipment safekeeping, resumption-preparation costs, etc. (GB/T 51262-2017, Clause 5.8.3); three elements must be met — direct loss + non-contractor cause + claim pursued per procedure (TB 10402-2019, Clause 9.3.1); notice of claim within 28 days, claim report within a further 28 days (GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 8.11.3).
- ←
FIDIC Red Book 2017 EOT (8.5/20.2) vs GB/T 50500-2024 Section 8.11 delay-claim regime: the 28-day cadence, cost-and-time in one case, three-way liability, and the critical-path causation threshold
FIDIC 2017 Red Book EOT (Sub-Clause 8.5; procedure per 20.2) and GB/T 50500-2024 Section 8.11 share one skeleton: (1) both three-stage - "notice ASAP/within 28 days -> periodic supplements for continuing events -> final report within the period" - with FIDIC 20.2.1's 28-day hard bar ("shall not be entitled to any additional payment") against GB 8.11.3's contractual-period-first, 28-day-default, "handled per contract" and general waiver clause; (2) cost and time claimed in one case (FIDIC 20.2 titled "Payment and/or EOT"; GB 8.11.3(3) "shall be asserted together"); (3) three-way liability: employer causes -> time + cost (listed cases plus profit); government/force-majeure-type events -> time extended, losses borne separately; contractor causes -> no extension plus delay damages; (4) causation: FIDIC 8.5's "in the extent that completion is delayed" lands as the critical-path rule (GB 8.11.8: critical-path delay = claimable; non-critical delay exceeding total float turns critical, the difference claimable; still non-critical = no claim), 8.11.7 requiring event-by-event assessment excluding knock-on delays. Main procedural differences: FIDIC notices go to the Engineer who determines; GB runs directly between employer and contractor; FIDIC's 28 days are fixed, GB's 28 days only a default.
- ←
Work suspension caused by suppliers' delayed delivery: the contractor's loss composition, calculation methods, and legal boundaries (T/YJXB 0001-2023)
A supplier's delayed delivery is a breach of the sales contract; suspension losses are calculated item by item as "idle labor + plant standby + material losses + suspension management fee + suspension profit + site maintenance + increased statutory fees": the actual-expenditure method first, the rule-standard method as fallback (T/YJXB 0001-2023, Chapters 4, 5; GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 8.11.9). Claims are triple-limited by the Civil Code's foreseeability rule (Article 584), the duty to mitigate (Article 591), and the evidence chain, and the contractor simultaneously runs the 28-day extension procedure with the employer.
- ←
Panorama of suspension cost items for non-contractor-caused stoppages (T/YJXB 0001-2023: protection / standstill / wages / management / profit / demobilization / price rises / statutory fees)
For non-contractor-caused stoppages, the contractor may claim suspension costs (= cost increases + reasonable profit): completed-works protection (only if measures taken), construction machinery standstill, on-site production worker wages (only if actually paid), reasonable suspension management fees (not above normal, not zero), reasonable suspension profit, suspension demobilization (generally > 30 days), labor/machinery price rises where the extension crosses them, and increased statutory fees. Attribution follows the contract first; employer-caused stoppages are borne by the employer (GB/T 51262-2017 §5.8.3).
- ←
Settlement during suspension: completed qualified work settled as normal + suspension costs shared by cause (employer/contractor/force majeure)
Suspension settlement splits into two ledgers: qualified completed work is measured per actual completion up to the suspension date and settled as normal (disputed portions — undisputed paid first, labor costs never withheld); suspension costs follow the cause — employer-caused: the employer bears all reasonable costs (protection, custody, machinery standstill, wages of workers and managers, resumption preparation, profit, demobilization, etc., GB/T 51262-2017 §5.8.3 + T/YJXB 0001-2023); contractor-caused: self-borne; force majeure/government control shared per GB/T 50500-2024 §8.11.12/13 (permanent works and delivered materials on the employer, machinery and measure losses on the contractor, retained-site wages and care/cleaning/repair on the employer, with extension of time). Contract agreement governs; termination after suspension settles per §10.4.4.