Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-25

Deciding situations where a claim succeeds but only an extension of time is granted without cost compensation: allocation of suspension losses between force majeure and government-mandated stoppages, abnormally adverse climatic conditions, the three requirements for cost claims, negative tests for idle costs, allocation of responsibility for concurrent delay, and the link to delay damages

Under GB/T 50500-2024, 'the claim succeeds but only time is extended, without cost compensation' is not a single event type: (1) force majeure (clause 8.11.12) and stoppages required by government authorities, stoppages required by state or local authorities for safety or environmental protection, stoppages under health and epidemic control requirements, and commotions and riots (clause 8.11.13) operate as 'extension of time plus each party bearing its own losses', but the opening words of clause 8.11.13 expressly exclude policy-based price adjustment under section 8.8 and paragraphs 4 and 5 of clause 8.11.12 (wages of management and security personnel required to remain on site by the employer, wages of idle personnel, and care, clearance and repair costs; acceleration costs required by the employer) - these three heads remain claimable; (2) abnormally adverse climatic conditions (GF-2017-0201 item 7.7) extend time and carry 'the increased costs of reasonable measures taken', but suspension idle losses are outside the item's listed scope; (3) a cost claim must simultaneously satisfy three requirements: a cause not attributable to the contractor (a risk recognised by the contract), actual loss actually incurred, and causation; (4) idle costs fail where no idling actually occurred, or where the delay did not affect the critical path or the total float; (5) concurrent delay is allocated under clause 8.11.15: 'the party responsible for causing the delay bears it; where both parties are responsible, in proportion to their shares of responsibility'; (6) an approved extension of time raises the baseline for calculating delay damages; only unapproved delay triggers delay damages under clause 2.0.33.

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第2.0.33条、第8.11.7条、第8.11.8条、第8.11.9条、第8.11.10条、第8.11.12条、第8.11.13条、第8.11.15条、第8.11.18条
  • GF-2017-0201 建设工程施工合同(示范文本)第7.5项、7.6项、7.7项、7.8项、17.2~17.4项、第18条、19.1项
  • GB/T 51262-2017 建设工程造价鉴定规范 第5.8.1条
  • T/ZBD 100.4-2023 建设工程造价鉴定作业指引 第4.9.7条
  • T/YJXB 0001-2023 建设工程停工承包人费用计算标准 第4.0.5条、4.0.8条及第15章
  • DB13(J)/T 8161-2019 建设工程监理工作标准 第9.2.4条

Topic positioning

This card addresses the frequently misjudged family of questions in which a claim succeeds, time may be extended, but costs are not compensated or only specific heads are compensated. It lists item by item the situations and clause numbers where only time is extended, gives the requirements for a cost claim to succeed, the negative tests under which idle costs fail, the allocation of responsibility for concurrent (crossing) delays, and the link to delay damages on the contractor side. It is based mainly on section 8.11 of GB/T 50500-2024, Standard for Valuation with Bill of Quantities of Construction Works, and on GF-2017-0201, Model Construction Contract.

Core conclusions

1. Situations granting only an extension of time, without cost compensation (or compensating only specific heads)

1. Force majeure (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.11.12) Allocation in the original text: paragraph 1: 'damage to the permanent works and to materials already delivered to site, together with the costs of repair, and third-party personal injury and property loss within the site and to the works caused by the force majeure event, shall be borne by the employer'; paragraph 2: 'damage to the contractor's plant, the contractor's suspension costs, and damage to preliminary items and their clearance and repair costs, and third-party personal injury and property loss caused by the contractor, shall be borne by the contractor'; paragraph 3: 'the employer and the contractor shall each bear the loss of its own personnel and of the other property beyond paragraphs 1 and 2 of this clause'; paragraph 5: 'where force majeure affects the contractor's performance of its contractual obligations and causes delay to the works, the time shall be extended; where the employer requires acceleration, the increased acceleration costs thereby caused shall be borne by the employer'. Paragraph 4 (borne by the employer): 'where construction is suspended due to force majeure, the costs of care, clearance and repair of the works as required by the employer during the suspension, the wages of the necessary management and security personnel required to remain on site by the employer, and the wages of personnel required by the employer to remain on site idle shall be borne by the employer'. -> Conclusion: force majeure is by no means 'no compensation across the board'. What the contractor bears itself is damage to its plant, plant suspension costs, and damage, clearance and repair costs of preliminary items; the employer bears damage to the permanent works and to materials already on site, third-party personal injury and property loss, the wages of personnel required to remain on site and the care, clearance and repair costs, and the acceleration costs it requires. Time is extended in all cases.

2. Stoppages attributable to government authorities (clause 8.11.13) The affected time is extended correspondingly and each party bears its own losses, in four categories: (1) 'events such as commotions and riots (excluding those occurring at the site)'; (2) 'effects caused by stoppages, suspensions (deferments) or intermittent construction, or regional construction control required by state or local government authorities'; (3) 'effects of stoppages required by state or local government authorities for safety and environmental protection'; (4) 'effects of stoppages required by state or local government authorities for health and epidemic prevention control'. Consistent with the closing passage of clause 8.11.9: 'for events of economic loss and/or delay caused by government authorities, the time shall be extended correspondingly, and the economic losses suffered by the employer and the contractor shall be borne by each party itself.' Key exception (do not apply 'each bears its own' as a blanket cut): the opening words of the clause are 'except as otherwise agreed in the contract and as provided in section 8.8 and paragraphs 4 and 5 of clause 8.11.12 of this standard'; that is, policy-based price adjustment (section 8.8), wages of site management and security personnel and of idle personnel required to remain by the employer, care, clearance and repair costs, and acceleration costs required by the employer remain within the claimable scope. Also: commotions and riots occurring within the site do not fall under paragraph 1 of this clause and are handled under the contract and under liability for fault or breach.

3. The insurance fallback (shared closing passage of clauses 8.11.12, 8.11.13 and 8.11.15) 'Where the contract provides that the employer insures against all risks of the works and third-party liability, amounts recoverable under the relevant insurance provisions may be claimed from the insurer, deductibles and amounts exceeding the insurance proceeds being borne by the employer and the contractor respectively, and the insurance proceeds received by the employer may be paid to the contractor out of progress payments and interim settlement by construction stage payments.' 'Losses of plant and construction provision facilities used on site for the works are borne by the contractor; where the contract provides that the employer insures them, amounts recoverable under the relevant insurance provisions may be claimed from the insurer through the employer, deductibles and amounts exceeding the insurance proceeds being the contractor's responsibility.'

4. Abnormally adverse climatic conditions (GF-2017-0201 item 7.7) Definition: 'climatic conditions encountered during construction that an experienced contractor could not have foreseen when entering the contract, which materially affect performance of the contract, but which do not yet amount to a force majeure event.' The contractor 'shall take reasonable measures to overcome the abnormally adverse climatic conditions and continue construction, and shall promptly notify the employer and the supervising engineer'; the consequence is that 'the increased costs incurred by the contractor in taking reasonable measures and/or the delay thereby caused shall be borne by the employer'. -> That is: time is extended and reasonable measure costs are compensable; the item does not list suspension idle losses among the employer's burdens, so idle costs normally fail. If the particular conditions merge this situation into force majeure, revert to item 1 above. Compare item 7.6, 'adverse physical conditions' (subsurface physical conditions, hydrological conditions, non-natural physical obstructions and contaminants, excluding climatic conditions): the employer likewise bears 'the increased costs of reasonable measures taken and/or the delay caused', but the nature is compensation of employer risk; the dividing line is 'physical conditions carry money, climatic conditions carry only extension plus measure costs'.

2. The three requirements of a cost claim (all must be met)

  1. Cause requirement: the event is not attributable to the contractor and constitutes a compensable risk recognised by the contract or the pricing standard. GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.11.9: 'where events not attributable to the contractor cause the contractor economic loss and increased costs and/or delay, the contractor may claim one or more items for the economic loss and increased costs suffered and/or the delay affected' - listing nine items: costs of suspension, idling, reduced efficiency and extended time; direct costs of changes in prices of labour, materials and plant caused by adjustment of the contract time (except as adjusted under 8.7.4); measure costs of suspension, resumption and site maintenance; rework, demolition, alteration, repair and scrapped material losses; additional inspection and testing costs; losses caused by non-payment of the contract price as agreed; suspension effects caused by unearthing of cultural relics, historic sites, artefacts or fossils; other losses the contractor can prove, plus VAT; and the reasonable time delayed or extended. The local standard is to the same effect: DB13(J)/T 8161-2019 clause 9.2.4 requires that 'the claim event is caused by reasons not attributable to the contractor and complies with the construction contract', 'it is raised within the period agreed in the construction contract' and 'the claim event has caused direct economic loss to the contractor' all be satisfied simultaneously.
  2. Actual occurrence requirement: T/YJXB 0001-2023 chapter 15: 'calculation of suspension costs follows the principles of seeking truth from facts and not enlarging the loss; each cost is calculated on the premise of objective actual occurrence; losses and costs that did not occur are not calculated'; clause 4.0.5: 'production workers idling on site during the suspension shall be credited with their on-site wages. If the wages of production workers during the suspension must be paid, the resulting cost increase shall be calculated. If objectively they need not be paid and in fact were not paid, they are not counted.'
  3. Causation requirement: GB/T 51262-2017 clause 5.8.1 - 'where the parties are in dispute over a claim, the expert assessor shall ask the commissioning party to determine the cause and the loss of the claim event; where the commissioning party confirms that the cause, the loss and the time limit of the claim are all established, the expert assessor shall apply professional knowledge to judge causation and issue an assessment opinion for the commissioning party's use.' An additional threshold for profit: profit may be added only for causes attributable to the employer - clause 8.11.10 lists eight categories (the employer reallocating work to another contractor; delayed provision of drawings or the site; providing non-conforming materials or late delivery; measurement and setting-out errors and rework caused by the employer; additionally restricting the site or failing to approve in time and disturbing the construction sequence; delay and suspension caused by the employer and failure to resume on schedule; occupation of the works before completion; defect repair within the defects liability period caused by the employer), where the contractor 'may, in addition to claiming economic loss and increased costs and/or delay under clause 8.11.9 of this standard, also claim profit'.

3. Negative tests: when idle costs fail

  • Time dimension (clause 8.11.8): 'if the delaying event lies on the critical path, the delay is the claimable time; if it lies off the critical path but the delay exceeds the total float and the activity becomes critical, the claimable time is the excess of the delay over the total float; if after the delay the event still lies off the critical path, no extension of time arises.'
  • Cost dimension: where the effective construction window is unaffected, the work front is not interrupted, and the parts that can proceed normally still advance per plan, there is no idling fact - personnel not mobilised to wait, wages not actually paid, plant not standing idle, provisions not actually deployed - so the premise of objective actual occurrence is unmet and idle costs fail (the principle of not enlarging the loss).
  • Independence dimension (clause 8.11.7): 'the employer shall independently assess the claim costs of the contractor for each delay or extension event, and shall not include cost claims for the delays (or extensions) caused to the works carried out later by delays (or extensions) that occurred earlier.' Multiple events are thus neither stacked nor chain-amplified.
  • Expert assessment dimension (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.9.7 paragraphs 1 and 3): for delays caused by the contractor, the contractor's cost losses are not calculated; for stoppages caused by force majeure or other excepted events beyond employer causes, only the cost losses of idle workers for that period or other direct losses are calculated.

4. Allocating responsibility for concurrent (crossing) delays

  • Clause 8.11.15, original text: 'where a delay is caused by one of the parties and a force majeure event occurs within the extended time, the losses from the force majeure event shall be borne by the party responsible for causing the delay. Where both parties are responsible for the delay and a force majeure event occurs within the extended time, responsibility may be borne in proportion to each party's share. Where a force majeure event occurs within the contract time, clauses 8.11.9 and 8.11.12 of this standard apply.'
  • The closing passage of GF-2017-0201 item 17.3.2 points the same way: 'where a party delays performance of its contractual obligations and encounters force majeure during the delayed performance, it is not relieved of its liability for breach.'
  • Expert assessment position (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.9.7 paragraph 4): 'for delays caused by concurrent delays or multi-factor events, the expert assessor shall, on the basis of a delay assessment report or a delay duration agreed by both parties, calculate each party's share of the costs in the corresponding proportions according to the division of responsibility determined by the commissioning party.' Where the commissioning party has not determined responsibility or there is no delay assessment report, the assessor may fully calculate the delay losses and their composition on the premise of an ascertained delay duration, and issue alternative opinions stating so in the assessment opinion. -> Decision order: first determine whose cause produced that period of extended time (the responsible party bears the force majeure consequences within it) -> where both parties are responsible, share in proportion to responsibility. In practice, 'the initial delaying party bears first' is only one operational restatement of the above; the determinate propositions of the standard texts are the two: 'the party responsible for causing the delay bears it' plus 'in proportion to the shares of responsibility'.

5. Link to delay damages

  • Term (clause 2.0.33): 'costs the contractor shall pay the employer as compensation under the contract where the contractor fails to construct according to the planned progress of the contract works, causing the actual time to exceed the contract time or the contract time of phased completion works (including extensions approved by the employer). For works contractually completed and handed over in phases, delay damages means the compensation calculated per the contract according to the delay time of the works concerned.' Phased works are calculated separately.
  • Link point: 'including extensions approved by the employer' - once an extension is approved, the contract time baseline rises with it and the starting point for calculating delay damages moves back accordingly; only unapproved delays (attributable to the contractor) fall within the compensation range.
  • The employer's reverse claims for contractor-caused events (clause 8.11.18): the employer may claim one or more items for 'additional costs or expenditure incurred by the employer due to the contractor's failure to perform its obligations or to execute instructions as agreed in the contract', 'losses caused to the employer by the contractor's failure to perform main contractor's attendance and coordination as required by the contract', 'fines paid to government departments or compensation paid to third parties due to contractor-responsible events', 'losses caused to the employer by delay of the contract works attributable to the contractor', 'losses caused to the employer by work completed not conforming to the contractual requirements', and 'other losses the employer can prove'.
  • Model text counterpart (GF-2017-0201 item 7.5.2): 'where delay is caused by the contractor, the particular conditions may provide the method of calculating, and the cap on, liquidated damages for delayed completion. Payment of the liquidated damages does not relieve the contractor of the obligation to complete the works and to remedy defects.'

Applicable boundaries

  • GB/T 50500-2024 is a recommended national standard and GF-2017-0201 a model contract form; both bind a specific project only when incorporated by the contract; most of the clauses above open with 'except as otherwise agreed in the contract' or 'except as otherwise provided in the particular conditions', and the particular conditions prevail.
  • The two documents allocate force majeure consequences differently: GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.11.12 paragraph 2 assigns 'suspension costs' to the contractor; GF-2017-0201 item 17.3.2 sub-item (4) provides that 'where force majeure affects the contractor's performance of its contractual obligations and has caused or will cause delay to the works, the time shall be extended; the contractor's cost losses from suspension caused thereby shall be reasonably shared between the employer and the contractor, and the wages of workers that must be paid during the suspension shall be borne by the employer'. On conflict, the document actually incorporated by the contract governs; the two must not be mixed.
  • 'Abnormally adverse climatic conditions' and 'force majeure' are two levels: the former does not yet amount to force majeure; its allocation depends on how the particular conditions provide.
  • The government-stoppage clause carries three express exclusions (policy-based price adjustment under section 8.8, and paragraphs 4 and 5 of clause 8.11.12); all costs must not be swept into 'each bears its own'.
  • This card contains no specific rates, amounts or project data; the concrete charging of costs (idle labour costs, plant standby costs, suspension overheads, idle turnover material bases) belongs to suspension cost calculation rules and local cost rules, and no amounts are given here.

Further reading

  • GB/T 50500-2024, Standard for Valuation with Bill of Quantities of Construction Works: clause 8.11.7 (independent assessment per event), clause 8.11.8 (critical path and total float), clause 8.11.9 (nine claimable events not attributable to the contractor), clause 8.11.10 (eight employer-responsibility events carrying added profit), clause 8.11.12 (force majeure allocation, especially paragraphs 4 and 5), clause 8.11.13 (four categories of excepted events including government control), clause 8.11.15 (force majeure within a delay period), clause 8.11.18 (six employer claims for contractor causes); clause 2.0.33 (term: delay damages); section 8.8 (policy-based price adjustment).
  • Section 9.13 of GB 50500-2013 was the old edition's provision on delay damages; it has been superseded by GB/T 50500-2024, whose current counterparts are clause 2.0.33 and clause 8.11.18 paragraph 4; do not continue to cite the old clause numbers.
  • GF-2017-0201, Model Construction Contract: item 7.5 (delay caused by the employer or the contractor), item 7.6 (adverse physical conditions), item 7.7 (abnormally adverse climatic conditions), item 7.8 (suspension of the works), items 17.2 to 17.4 (force majeure notice, consequences, termination), clause 18 (insurance), item 19.1 (the contractor's 28-day claims procedure).
  • GB/T 51262-2017, Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment, clause 5.8.1 (causation in claim disputes).
  • T/ZBD 100.4-2023, Guidelines for Construction Cost Expert Assessment Practice, clause 4.9.7 (loss calculation tiered by delay cause; concurrent delay by shares of responsibility).
  • T/YJXB 0001-2023, Standard for Calculating Contractor Costs during Suspension of Construction Works: clause 4.0.5 (idle workers' wages counted only if actually paid), clause 4.0.8 (reasonable suspension overheads no higher than in normal periods, not reduced to zero) and chapter 15 (seek truth from facts; do not enlarge the loss).
  • DB13(J)/T 8161-2019, Standard for Construction Supervision Work, clause 9.2.4 (three approval conditions for cost claims).

Keywords

  • 只顺延工期不补偿费用
  • 不可抗力损失分担
  • 政府管制停工
  • 异常恶劣气候条件
  • 费用索赔成立要件
  • 共同延误
  • 误期赔偿费
  • GB/T 50500-2024

Cited By