Liability and pricing basis for plant standby (idle machine-shift) costs: a comparison of four scenarios, employer-caused, contractor-caused, force majeure and abnormally adverse weather, with the code and contract clause authority and the rate-reduction rules for standby machine-shifts
Who bears the plant standby cost is decided by who caused the standstill, not by whether the plant stands on site: for an employer-caused standstill the employer bears the cost and profit may additionally be claimed (GB/T 50500-2024 Articles 8.11.9 and 8.11.10; GF-2017-0201 clause 7.8.1); for a contractor-caused standstill the contractor bears it alone (GB/T 51262-2017 Article 5.8.3 paragraph 3; T/YJXB 0001-2023 Article 1.0.3); under force majeure, 'damage to the contractor's construction plant and its costs of suspension' are borne by the contractor while the time for completion is extended (Article 8.11.12 paragraphs 2 and 5); abnormally adverse weather follows the contract, the extra cost of reasonable measures being borne by the employer (GF-2017-0201 clause 7.7). In pricing, the standby machine-shift rate = depreciation + labour cost (idle machine operators) + other charges, excluding overhaul, maintenance and fuel and power, with no uniform percentage discount.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第8.11.9、8.11.10、8.11.12、8.11.13条
- GB/T 51262-2017 · Code for Construction Cost Appraisal 第5.8.3、5.8.4条
- GF-2017-0201《建设工程施工合同(示范文本)》通用合同条款第7.7、7.8.1、7.8.2项
- T/YJXB 0001-2023《建设工程停工承包人费用计算标准》第1.0.3、3.0.7、5.0.3条
- 各省施工机具台班费用定额编制说明(机械停滞台班费的组成与适用边界)
Positioning
Answers 'who bears the cost of plant standing idle (standstill machine-shifts)': for each of the four scenarios, employer-caused, contractor-caused, force majeure and abnormally adverse weather, it gives the bearer of the cost, the code and contract clause authority, the chargeable content and the rate-reduction basis for standby machine-shifts, plus two pricing routes for owned and rented plant. Applicable to the pricing of suspension and idle-cost claims, to construction cost expert assessment, and to the review of interim settlements by construction stage.
Core conclusions
General principle: the standby cost is decided not by whether the plant stands on site but by who caused the standstill; in pricing there is no blanket percentage discount, and running costs are excluded item by item.
1. Liability table for standstill (four scenarios)
| Standstill scenario | Bearer | Pricing authority (clauses) | Chargeable content and machine-shift rate reduction | Time / profit |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| (1) Employer-caused (late drawings, site or start conditions not ready, payment not made as agreed, instructed suspension, failure to resume on time after suspension, etc.) | Borne by the employer | GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.11.9 (the 'standstill costs of construction plant mobilised to site but unable to work' enter the claim among suspension, waiting and reduced-efficiency losses); Article 8.11.10 (events due to the employer's responsibility, including 'suspension of the works and failure to resume on time after suspension', may additionally ground a profit claim); GB/T 51262-2017 Article 5.8.3 paragraph 2 ('construction plant hire charges' borne by the employer); GF-2017-0201 general conditions clause 7.8.1 | Owned plant: standby machine-shift rate = depreciation + idle operator labour on the machine + other charges (vehicle and vessel tax, insurance, annual inspection), excluding overhaul, maintenance, fuel and power, and erection/dismantling and off-site haulage; rented plant: the hire charges actually incurred during the suspension (hire contract plus settlement statements plus site instruction records), deducting fuel and power and on-machine labour, with idle labour cost claimed separately | Extension of time; reasonable profit may additionally be claimed (8.11.10). No further overheads or profit are loaded on the standby machine-shift rate, to avoid double counting with the profit claim |
| (2) Contractor-caused (own site organisation, quality rework, equipment breakdown, labour, plant or materials not in place) | Borne by the contractor; no claim against the employer | GF-2017-0201 clause 7.8.2; GB/T 51262-2017 Article 5.8.3 paragraph 3; T/YJXB 0001-2023 Article 1.0.3 | Compensation is zero: depreciation of owned plant continues to amortise and the hire of rented plant continues to be paid, all absorbed by the contractor | No extension of time; where work has not resumed within 84 days after the resumption instruction, this is treated as a situation in which the contractor cannot continue to perform the contract (GF-2017-0201 clause 7.8.2) |
| (3) Force majeure (earthquake, flood, epidemic, war, martial law, etc.) | The standstill and damage losses of construction plant are borne by the contractor; the wages of personnel retained on site and the costs of care, clearing and repair are borne by the employer | GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.11.12 paragraphs 2, 4 and 5 | The standstill costs of owned or rented plant are in principle not compensated; what is chargeable is 'the wages of the necessary management and security personnel retained on site at the employer's request and the wages of personnel kept waiting on site at the employer's request' and 'the costs of caring for, clearing and repairing the works during the suspension at the employer's request', reimbursed at actual cost against the employer's written request | Extension of time; where the employer requires acceleration, the acceleration cost is borne by the employer (paragraph 5). Where the contract has the employer insure the works against all risks and third-party liability, the plant losses may be recovered through the employer from the insurer, the deductible and any excess being for the contractor's account |
| (4) Abnormally adverse weather (not yet force majeure) | The agreed contract prevails; absent agreement, the extra cost of reasonable measures and the time lost are borne by the employer, while pure idle losses are contested | GF-2017-0201 clause 7.7; GB/T 51262-2017 Article 5.8.4; T/YJXB 0001-2023 Article 3.0.7 (special provisions or agreements prevail; absent them, the stoppage costs are calculated under that standard) | Chargeable are measure-type increments: relocating, anchoring or protecting plant, additional entries to and exits from site, covering and thermal protection, inspection and testing before resumption, etc.; depreciation or hire for simply 'standing still' is treated under most contracts as the contractor's construction risk and charged as standby machine-shifts only where the contract or a local rule so provides. The reduction basis is as in (1) | Time generally extended; where the employer fails to reply in time, the assessor may exercise professional judgement (GB/T 51262-2017 Article 5.8.4 paragraph 2) |
Supplementary scenario (exceptional events caused by government authorities): under GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.11.13, riots and disturbances (excluding those occurring on the construction site), stoppages, suspensions or intermittent construction required by the authorities, regional construction control, stoppages required by safety and environmental protection, and stoppages required by health and epidemic control extend the time for completion accordingly, the employer and the contractor each bearing their own losses, so plant standby costs are in principle self-borne. But the article opens 'except as otherwise agreed in the contract and as provided in Article 8.8 and paragraphs 4 and 5 of Article 8.11.12 of this Standard', so policy-driven price adjustment, the wages of retained personnel, the costs of care, clearing and repair, and employer-required acceleration costs remain claimable; the article must not be applied wholesale as 'each party bears its own'. The same position closes Article 8.11.9: 'for events of economic loss and/or delay caused by government authorities, the time for completion shall be extended accordingly, and the economic losses suffered by the employer and the contractor shall be borne by each party itself.'
2. Key clause texts (citable directly)
GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.11.9: 'Where events not attributable to the contractor cause the contractor economic loss and additional cost and/or delay in the time for completion, the contractor may claim one or more items according to the economic loss and additional cost and/or the delay suffered... the losses of labour, materials and construction plant caused by suspension, waiting, reduced efficiency, prolonged duration and the like include: (1) the idle labour costs of personnel already mobilised who cannot work; (2) the loss costs of materials already delivered to site that cannot be put to use; (3) the standstill costs of construction plant already on site that cannot work; (4) other costs lost.'
GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.11.10: for events arising from causes for which the employer is responsible, 'besides claiming economic loss and additional cost and/or delay under Article 8.11.9 of this Standard, the contractor may also claim profit'; eight situations are listed (including item 6, 'delay caused by the employer, suspension of the works, and failure to resume on time after suspension of the works'). 'Unless otherwise provided in the contract, claims arising from causes of the employer's default may include profit, and the employer shall compensate the contractor for its loss.'
GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.11.12 paragraph 2: 'Damage to the contractor's construction plant and its costs of suspension, and the costs of damage to, clearing of and repair of preliminary items, as well as personal injury and property loss of third parties occurring for contractor-caused reasons, shall be borne by the contractor.' Paragraph 4: 'Where force majeure causes the suspension of the works, the costs of caring for, clearing and repairing the works during the suspension at the employer's request, the wages of the necessary management and security personnel retained on the construction site at the employer's request, and the wages of personnel kept waiting on site at the employer's request shall be borne by the employer.' Paragraph 5: 'Where force majeure affects the contractor in performing its obligations under the contract and causes delay in the time for completion, the time for completion shall be extended; where the employer requires acceleration, the additional acceleration cost so caused shall be borne by the employer.'
GB/T 51262-2017 Article 5.8.3: '1. Where the contract provides for the bearing of the above costs, the assessment shall be made according to the contract. 2. Where the suspension is caused by the employer, the costs are borne by the employer, including the cost of protecting the completed works, the safekeeping costs of the materials and equipment delivered to site, the construction plant hire charges, the wages of the site production workers and the management personnel, and the costs incurred by the contractor in preparing for resumption. 3. Where the suspension is caused by the contractor, the costs are borne by the contractor.'
T/YJXB 0001-2023 Article 1.0.3: 'This standard does not apply to the pricing activities of stoppages in the course of the works caused by the contractor.' Its exposition: 'losses caused by a contractor-caused stoppage shall be borne by the contractor itself and shall not be claimed against the employer.' Article 5.0.3: 'The standstill cost of construction plant may be calculated by the following methods. The actual-expenditure method: calculated on the hire charges of construction plant actually expended during the stoppage. The rule-standard method: the standstill cost of construction plant during the stoppage is calculated on the basis of, or by reference to, the machine-shift cost norms of the same period. Standstill cost of construction plant: for rented plant, on the hire charges actually incurred; for owned plant, on the machine-shift norms.'
GF-2017-0201 general conditions: clause 7.8.1, 'for suspension caused by the employer, the employer shall bear the additional costs and/or the delay so caused and pay the contractor a reasonable profit'; clause 7.8.2, 'for suspension caused by the contractor, the contractor shall bear the additional costs and/or the delay so caused, and where the contractor has still not resumed work within 84 days after receiving the engineer's resumption instruction, this is treated as... a situation in which the contractor cannot continue to perform the contract'; clause 7.7 defines abnormally adverse climatic conditions as 'adverse climatic conditions encountered in the course of construction which an experienced contractor could not have foreseen when signing the contract, which materially affect the performance of the contract, but which do not yet constitute an event of force majeure', and 'the additional costs incurred by the contractor in taking reasonable measures, and/or the delay, are borne by the employer'.
3. Rate-reduction basis for standby machine-shifts (owned versus rented)
- Owned plant: the standby machine-shift rate = depreciation + other charges (vehicle and vessel tax, insurance, annual inspection) + labour cost, the labour cost being calculated on the number of idle machine-operator workdays caused by the standstill. Reasons for the exclusions: during a standstill the plant is not overhauled or maintained and consumes no fuel or power, so overhaul, maintenance and fuel and power are excluded; the plant has not entered or left the site and has not been erected or dismantled, so erection/dismantling and off-site haulage are excluded.
- Rented plant: no conversion into standby machine-shifts; charge directly the hire actually incurred during the suspension (hire contract plus settlement statements plus reconciliation statements), deducting fuel and power and on-machine labour, with the idle labour cost claimed separately to avoid double counting with the idle-labour claim; the costs of the attachments running with the plant during the standstill are calculated on certified records.
- Boundary of the basis: the provincial machine-shift cost norms serve to compile rates on the depreciation-and-amortisation basis of owned plant over its total durable machine-shifts, and do not apply to determining the market hire prices of plant; the standby machine-shift price and quantity for rented plant are calculated by the parties from the hire contract and the site instruction records.
- Quantity and procedure: the number of standby machine-shifts and the number of idle operating and directing personnel during the standstill are determined on the records signed by both parties; within the standby rate no further overheads or profit are charged.
Boundaries of application
- Agreed terms prevail: GB/T 51262-2017 Article 5.8.3 paragraph 1 itself requires that 'where the contract provides for the bearing of the above costs, the assessment shall be made according to the contract'; where a force majeure clause such as GF-2017-0201 clause 17.4 provides that 'the cost losses of the suspension shall be reasonably shared by the employer and the contractor', the sharing agreed in the contract applies, which differs from the default allocation under scenario (3) above.
- Contractor-caused stoppages attract no suspension costs at all: T/YJXB 0001-2023 excludes them expressly; there is no room for charging at a reduced level.
- Force majeure and government control must not be applied wholesale: the opening exceptions of Article 8.11.13 and paragraphs 4 and 5 of Article 8.11.12 remain claimable channels; riots and disturbances occurring within the construction site are not within Article 8.11.13 item 1 and are handled under the contract and fault liability.
- Abnormally adverse weather is not force majeure: below that threshold only 'the additional costs of taking reasonable measures' are compensated; whether pure idle depreciation or hire losses are compensated depends on the contract, a high-frequency dispute point.
- Boundary of quota machine-shift rates: the provincial machine-shift cost norms serve the depreciation-and-amortisation basis for owned plant, not the market hire price; the hire price is fixed by the hire contract and the certified records.
- No double counting: plant standby costs must be de-duplicated against idle on-machine labour, overheads and profit; where the standby machine-shift rate already contains the labour cost, no further idle labour cost is charged.
- Time limits: the claim must be raised by Notice of Claim and claim report within the period agreed in the contract (28 days where the contract is silent), late claims being handled under the relevant provisions of Article 8.11; the time limits and the evidentiary requirements are covered by the claim-procedure cards.
Further reading
- GB/T 50500-2024, the China national pricing standard for BOQ: Article 8.11.9 (scope of claims for losses from causes not attributable to the contractor), Article 8.11.10 (eight situations of employer responsibility that carry profit), Article 8.11.12 (six-paragraph allocation of force majeure losses), Article 8.11.13 (exceptional events caused by government authorities).
- GB/T 51262-2017 Code for Construction Cost Expert Assessment: Article 5.8.3 (assessment rules on the bearing of suspension claim costs), Article 5.8.4 (assessment treatment of adverse physical conditions or abnormally adverse climate).
- GF-2017-0201 Model Construction Contract Text, general conditions: clause 7.7 (abnormally adverse climatic conditions), clause 7.8.1 (employer-caused suspension), clause 7.8.2 (contractor-caused suspension and the consequence of 84 days without resumption); the allocation agreed in the force majeure clause 17 is to be compared clause by clause.
- T/YJXB 0001-2023 Standard for Calculating the Contractor's Costs of Work Stoppage in Construction Works: Article 1.0.3 (scope of exclusion), Article 3.0.7 (order of application for abnormally adverse climate), Article 5.0.3 (two calculation methods for the standstill cost of construction plant).
- The clauses on the composition of the plant standstill machine-shift rate in the compilation notes of the current provincial machine-shift cost norms: standstill machine-shift rate = depreciation + other charges + labour cost (labour calculated on the number of idle operator workdays caused by the standstill); the standby machine-shift price of rented plant is determined by the hire contract and the certified records, less fuel and power and labour.
- The concrete determination of the standby machine-shift rate and quantity (the composition items, whether overheads and profit are included, the conversion coefficient of standby machine-shifts) is covered by the referenced cards; the full picture of employer-caused stoppage costs, and the position that force majeure and government control 'extend time without compensating cost', are covered by related cards.
Keywords
- 机械停滞费
- 停置台班
- 施工机具停滞费
- 停置责任归属
- 暂停施工费用承担
- 不可抗力机具损失
- 异常恶劣气候条件
- 折旧费加人工费