Validity limits of "all risks borne by the contractor" clauses and statutory exclusions (GB/T 50500-2024 + Civil Code)
"All risks borne by the contractor" clauses are "uncapped risk allocation to one party" agreements prohibited by GB/T 50500-2024 Article 3.3.1—not automatically void wholesale, but limited in effect: valid for the contractor's own operational, technical, and managerial risks (Article 3.3.3, eight items); not waivable for statutory events—force majeure (Civil Code 590), personal injury and intentional/gross negligence (506), unfairly one-sided standard clauses (497), change of circumstances (533), legislative/policy changes and unforeseeable abnormal cost fluctuations at signing (8.7.3)—which judicial practice reallocates under the equitable risk allocation principle.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准
- 中华人民共和国民法典
Topic Positioning
Answers whether "all risks borne by the contractor" clauses in construction contracts are valid: drawing the validity boundary from both the pricing standard and the Civil Code, distinguishing "which risk allocations are valid and which are statutorily excluded," directly usable for contract review and dispute prediction.
Core Conclusions
(1) Pricing standard level: GB/T 50500-2024 Article 3.3.1 expressly prohibits agreeing measurement/pricing risks with "uncapped risk allocation to one party, all risks, or similar language," requiring stated risk content, scope, or band, reflecting equitable risk allocation. (2) Risks the contractor should indeed bear (Article 3.3.3, eight items): accuracy and completeness of the bill of preliminaries; BOQ errors/omissions under lump-sum contracts; all costs needed to complete the BOQ and work content; cost increases from its own schemes/equipment/process/management; self-caused acceleration or stoppage; cost fluctuations within the agreed band—these should be considered in the tender (priced offer); but the contractor does not bear risks of changes in laws, regulations, and policies. (3) Statutory boundaries not excludable even if agreed: Civil Code Article 590 force-majeure exemption; Article 506—exemption clauses for personal injury or property loss by intent/gross negligence are void; Article 497—standard clauses unreasonably exempting one's own liability, aggravating the other's, or excluding the other's main rights are void; Article 533—change of circumstances allows requesting modification or rescission. GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.7.3: for abnormal material price movements unforeseeable at signing where continued performance is obviously unfair, both parties may negotiate sharing under the equitable risk allocation principle. (4) Judicial approach: courts distinguish the contractor's self-borne operational/technical risks from owner-caused, force-majeure, and policy-change risks—the latter are reallocated under fairness even despite "all risks" agreements.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to judging the validity of pricing risk clauses in owner-contractor contracts; such clauses are not automatically void wholesale—the part covering the contractor's own controllable risks is valid; case-by-case validity also depends on whether it is a standard clause, foreseeability, and obvious unfairness.
Further Reading
See GB/T 50500-2024 (China national pricing standard for BOQ), Articles 3.3.1, 3.3.3, and 8.7.3; Civil Code Articles 497, 506, 533, and 590; may be read together with the cards on fixed-total-price lump-sum boundaries, quantity vs price risk comparison across three contract types, and material price adjustment rules.