Contract price adjustment for changes in laws, regulations and policies: the base date (28 days before the tender deadline / 28 days before contract signature) and the rule for contractor-caused delay that 'upward adjustments are denied, downward adjustments are granted' (GB 50500-2013 Section 9.2; GB/T 50500-2024 Section 8.8)
GB 50500-2013 Clause 9.2.1: for tendered works the base date is 28 days before the tender submission deadline, and for non-tendered works 28 days before contract signature; where changes in State laws, regulations, rules and policies afterwards increase or decrease the construction cost, the contract price is adjusted per the provisions issued accordingly by the provincial or sectoral construction authority or its authorised construction cost administration. Clause 9.2.2: where the time is delayed for reasons attributable to the contractor, upward adjustment of the contract price after the originally scheduled completion time is denied and downward adjustment is granted. Changes in laws and policies are a risk borne by the employer (Clause 3.4.2 item 1). GB/T 50500-2024 carries this forward in Clause 8.8.1 (four categories: newly added, amended, repealed, re-interpreted) and Clause 8.8.2 (during delay, increases denied, decreases granted).
Applicable Codes
- GB 50500-2013 第9.2.1条
- GB 50500-2013 第9.2.2条
- GB 50500-2013 第3.4.2条
- GB 50500-2013 第9.8.3条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第8.8.1条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第8.8.2条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第8.1.1条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第3.3.2条
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023 第4.4.1条
- 《民法典》第153条、第465条
- 《价格法》第12条
Scope of the topic
This card sets out the working rules for the pricing risk category of 'changes in laws, regulations and policies': how the base date for adjustment is fixed (GB 50500-2013 Clause 9.2.1), how increases and decreases are treated differently during contractor-caused delay (Clause 9.2.2), the current equivalents in GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 8.8.1/8.8.2, and the expert-assessment position. It applies to settlement disputes driven by policy price changes, rate or tax adjustments, and published labour cost adjustments.
Core conclusions
1. Premise: who bears the risk
GB 50500-2013 Clause 3.4.2 provides that contract price adjustment caused by 'changes in State laws, regulations, rules and policies', by 'labour cost adjustments published by the provincial or sectoral construction authority (except where the contractor's quote for labour cost or labour rates exceeds the published one)' and by 'price adjustments to raw materials and the like subject to government pricing or government guidance pricing' shall be borne by the employer -- that is, changes in laws and policies are a risk the contractor does not bear at all, consistent with the commentary to Section 3.4 that 'the risk not borne at all is that of changes in laws, regulations, rules and policies'.
2. The base date (text of Clause 9.2.1)
'For tendered works the base date is 28 days before the tender submission deadline, and for non-tendered works 28 days before contract signature. Where changes in State laws, regulations, rules and policies after that date increase or decrease the construction cost, the employer and the contractor shall adjust the contract price per the provisions issued accordingly by the provincial or sectoral construction authority or its authorised construction cost administration.' Key points: (1) the line is drawn at '28 days before the tender submission deadline' (for non-tendered works, '28 days before contract signature'); (2) only changes after the base date adjust, and the adjustment basis is 'the provisions issued accordingly' by the provincial or sectoral construction authority or its authorised construction cost administration, not a fresh bargain between the parties; (3) tendered and non-tendered works take different base dates, so first check the procurement route.
3. Adjustment restricted during delay (text of Clause 9.2.2)
'Where the time for the works is delayed for reasons attributable to the contractor, then, at the adjustment time fixed by Clause 9.2.1 of this code, after the originally scheduled completion time of the contract works, upward adjustment of the contract price shall not be made, and downward adjustment of the contract price shall be made.' The party responsible for the delay thus bears the one-sided downside of the time risk: for contractor-caused delay, legal changes occurring after the originally scheduled completion time bring no favourable upward adjustment, while unfavourable downward adjustments apply as usual. The rule shares its logic with the price-selection rule for changes in costs -- Clause 9.8.3: where the delay is not attributable to the contractor, prices for work after the planned progress date take the higher of the planned and actual progress dates; where it is attributable to the contractor, the lower of the two.
4. The current edition (GB/T 50500-2024 Section 8.8)
Clause 8.8.1: during execution of the contract works, where the following changes in laws, regulations and policies after the contract base date cause changes in the contract price and (or) delay to the time, the employer and the contractor shall adjust the contract price and (or) the time per the contract and the provisions issued accordingly by State, provincial or sectoral construction authorities and their authorised construction cost administrations -- (1) newly added laws, regulations and policy provisions; (2) amendments to existing laws, regulations and policy provisions; (3) repeal of existing laws, regulations and policy provisions; (4) changes in the government's interpretation of the relevant laws and regulations. It adds: where changes in laws, regulations and policies cause material extension of the time and market prices for work after the planned progress date change or fluctuate abnormally, the parties shall adjust the affected contract price under the provisions on changes in costs. Clause 8.8.2: where the time is extended for reasons attributable to the contractor and changes in laws, regulations and policies as defined in Clause 8.8.1 occur during the extension, 'upward adjustment of the contract price shall not be made, and downward adjustment of the contract price shall be made'. Differences from 2013: the 2024 edition itemises legal and policy changes into four categories -- added, amended, repealed, re-interpreted -- and styles the base date the 'contract base date' (its price baseline calibre per Annex A.2.4: 28 days before the tender submission deadline, or for non-tendered works 28 days before the contract signature date); the treatment during delay is identical in both editions.
5. Where this sits among the adjustable events
Clause 9.1.1 of the 2013 edition lists 'changes in laws and regulations' as the first adjustable event (the others being variations, item description mismatch, omitted BOQ items, quantity deviation, dayworks, changes in costs, provisional prices, force majeure, earlier completion (acceleration compensation), delay damages, claims, site instruction records, provisional sums, and other events agreed by both parties); the corresponding 2024 Clause 8.1.1 lists 'changes in laws, regulations and policies' as the seventh event. In practice, place the event in the right category first, then take the adjustment method and evidence from the matching clause.
6. Disputes and the expert-assessment position
T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Clause 4.4.1: where a party seeks contract price adjustment on the ground that government-priced or government-guidance-priced items, policy rates, or mandatory national standards changed after the tender deadline, the assessor shall seek the entrusting party's view; absent an express view, 'the contract price of works executed after the point when such prices, rates or standards changed shall be adjusted, with an alternative opinion issued and explained'. The explanation cites Article 12 of the Price Law and Articles 153 (a civil juristic act violating mandatory provisions of laws or administrative regulations is void) and 465 of the Civil Code, and states that 'whether or not the contract so provides, the assessor shall adjust the price of the works executed after the point of such changes'; however, 'where the parties have expressly agreed in the contract how the risk of element prices under government pricing or government guidance pricing is borne, the agreed risk allocation shall still be followed'.
Applicable boundaries
- Clause numbers must be distinguished by edition: 9.2.1/9.2.2 belong to GB 50500-2013 (repealed); the current equivalents are GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 8.8.1/8.8.2.
- Adjustment presupposes a change arising 'after the base date' that moves the cost; the legal state before the base date is already reflected in the tender or contract price and cannot be adjusted retrospectively.
- The scale and method of adjustment follow 'the provisions issued accordingly by the provincial or sectoral construction authority or its authorised construction cost administration'; without such published provisions no other calibre may be applied.
- The delay rule constrains only the time dimension (adjustments arising after the originally scheduled completion time) and does not change liability itself; for delays not attributable to the contractor, Clause 9.8.3 takes the higher value -- the opposite direction.
- This card does not cover the computation of tax rate or policy rate adjustments, nor the determination of adjustment amounts for a specific project.
Further reading
- GB 50500-2013 Clauses 9.2.1, 9.2.2 and 9.8.3, plus Clause 3.4.2 and Clause 9.1.1.
- GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 8.8.1, 8.8.2, 8.1.1 and 3.3.2; Annex A.2.4 (the baseline price takes the published price information of 28 days before the tender submission deadline / 28 days before the contract signature date).
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023, Working Guidelines for Construction Cost Expert Assessment, Clause 4.4.1 and its explanation; Civil Code Articles 153 and 465; Price Law Article 12.
- Entry point for verifying the original judicial interpretation text (Supreme People's Court official page): https://www.court.gov.cn/zixun/xiangqing/419382.html
Keywords
- 法律法规变化
- 政策性变化
- 基准日
- 28 days
- 工期延误调价
- 9.2.1
- 8.8.1
- adjustment of the contract price