Whether wages of site management personnel and time-related overheads during suspension can be included in an idle-cost claim: determining recoverable and non-recoverable scenarios, the calculation basis and the procedural limits
Yes, but only when handled as two separate cost heads passing three gates. (1) Wages of site management personnel are claimable: GB/T 51262-2017 Clause 5.8.3(2) lists 'wages of site production workers and management personnel' directly among the costs the employer bears when suspension of the works arises from the employer's cause. (2) Suspension overheads are calculable: T/YJXB 0001-2023 Clause 4.0.8 provides that 'reasonable suspension overheads shall be accrued over the suspension period ... they shall be no higher than the overheads amount during normal construction, nor reduced straight to zero', and Clause 5.0.8 computes them as daily average overheads x a reasonable percentage x suspension days (daily average overheads = total contract overheads / contract duration); the clause states only the method and no fixed percentage, and the head must not be double-billed with idle costs. (3) Suspension caused by the contractor is borne by the contractor (Clause 5.8.3(3)); under force majeure only 'wages of the necessary management and security personnel the employer requires to remain on site' are borne by the employer (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 8.11.12(4)); where government authorities order a stoppage each party bears its own losses (Clause 8.11.13); wages of personnel already dismissed and not actually paid are not counted (Clause 4.0.5); the claim is bound by the duty to mitigate under Civil Code Article 591 and the 28-day claim period; and suspension and idle losses carry no priority right of payment out of the works (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, Article 17(2)).
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 51262-2017 · Code for Construction Cost Appraisal 第5.8.3条
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第8.11.3、8.11.9、8.11.10、8.11.12、8.11.13条
- T/YJXB 0001-2023《建设工程停工承包人费用计算标准》第2.0.7、3.0.9、4.0.5、4.0.8、5.0.8条
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第584条、第591条、第803条、第804条
- 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》(法释〔2026〕12号)第十七条、第二十三条 https://www.court.gov.cn/fabu/xiangqing/504221.html
- 建市〔2020〕96号《建设项目工程总承包合同(示范文本)》GF-2020-0216 通用合同条款第19条
Scope
During a suspension of the works, can the contractor claim wages of site management personnel and suspension overheads (time-related overheads during suspension) as idle-cost losses - scenario-by-scenario recoverability by cause of the stoppage, with the calculation formula, the actually-paid basis, and mitigation and procedural limits. For use in construction claim negotiations, construction cost expert assessment and final account review.
Core conclusions
1. Overall approach: two cost heads, three gates
Management wages and suspension overheads are two parallel claim heads, but neither may be double-billed against 'idle costs', nor paid in full for the entire payroll. The three gates: attribution (whose cause) -> actually incurred (whether the cost arose) -> procedure (whether raised in time).
2. Recoverable scenarios and textual basis
GB/T 51262-2017 (Standard for Construction Cost Expert Assessment) Clause 5.8.3, original text: 'Where the parties dispute the claim costs for suspension of the works, the expert assessor shall determine as follows: 1 where the contract provides who bears the above costs, the assessment follows the contract; 2 where the suspension arises from the employer's cause, the costs are borne by the employer, including the cost of protecting the completed works, the safekeeping costs of materials and equipment delivered to site, plant hire charges, wages of site production workers and management personnel, and the contractor's costs of preparing for resumption; 3 where the suspension arises from the contractor's cause, the costs are borne by the contractor.'
GB/T 50500-2024 (China national pricing standard for BOQ) Clause 8.11.9: where a stoppage, waiting, loss of efficiency or extended duration arises from causes not attributable to the contractor and causes the contractor economic loss, additional costs and/or delay, the contractor may raise a claim; losses of labour, materials and plant caused by stoppage, waiting, loss of efficiency or extended duration include '(1) idle costs of personnel already mobilised who cannot work; (2) losses on materials already delivered that cannot be put to use; (3) standby costs of construction plant already on site that cannot work; (4) other cost losses'. Clause 8.11.10(6) lists 'delay caused by the employer, suspension of the works, or failure to resume on time after suspension' among employer-responsibility causes, for which the contractor may additionally claim profit on top of the Clause 8.11.9 claim.
Civil Code Article 803: 'Where the employer fails to provide raw materials, equipment, the site, funds or technical data at the agreed times and to the agreed requirements, the contractor may postpone the construction date and claim compensation for stoppage, idle time and other losses.' Article 804: 'Where the works are stopped or slowed mid-course for reasons attributable to the employer, the employer shall take measures to remedy or reduce the loss and compensate the contractor for the stoppage, idle time, re-handling, relocation of plant and machinery, accumulation of materials and components and other losses and actual costs thereby caused.'
3. Calculation basis (no unified rate; fixed by evidence and contract)
- Suspension overheads - T/YJXB 0001-2023 (Standard for Calculating the Contractor's Costs on Suspension of Construction Works) Clause 4.0.8: 'Reasonable suspension overheads shall be accrued over the suspension period. For a short stoppage, to keep the site health, safety and environmental provisions in place and to prepare for resumption, the contractor's management personnel are generally not dismissed. The 15 secondary cost heads of overheads covering management wages, office expenses and the like continue to accrue daily as actually incurred. Site management during a suspension differs from management during normal construction, so the overheads for the suspension period should be no higher than the amount during normal construction, nor reduced straight to zero and left unaccrued.'
- Calculation method - Clause 5.0.8: 'Calculated as a reasonable percentage of the daily average overheads multiplied by the number of suspension days. The daily average overheads are the total contract overheads divided by the contract duration.' 'Where the overheads were actually expended, they are calculated by the actual-expenditure method; where that method cannot be applied, the rule-based method applies with a suitable percentage.' The clause gives only the 'reasonable percentage' method and fixes no percentage; any assertion of accrual 'at X%' must rest on a contract agreement or a certified site record.
- Management personnel as a separate head - limited to those genuinely needed on site during the suspension and the portion actually paid; T/YJXB 0001-2023 Clause 4.0.5: 'If the wages of production workers must be paid during the stoppage, the resulting cost increase shall be calculated. If objectively no payment is due and none was in fact made, it is not counted.'
- Wages of site watchkeepers - Clause 2.0.7 defines the term as 'wages of the personnel watching the site during the stoppage'; the site must be watched during a suspension with enough personnel kept on for safety, and the wages of these retained watchkeepers shall be calculated.
4. Non-recoverable or restricted scenarios
- Contractor-caused suspension: costs borne by the contractor (GB/T 51262-2017 Clause 5.8.3(3)).
- Force majeure: GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 8.11.12(2) 'damage to the contractor's plant, suspension losses and the costs of damage to, clearance and repair of preliminary items ... shall be borne by the contractor'; paragraph (4) is the only recoverable gateway - 'where force majeure causes suspension, the costs of watching, clearing and repairing the works as the employer requires, the wages of the necessary management and security personnel the employer requires to remain on site, and the wages of personnel kept standing by on site at the employer's request shall be borne by the employer'. Personnel retained on the contractor's own initiative, without the employer's request, cannot be claimed.
- Government-ordered stoppages: Clause 8.11.13 - where delay arises from exceptional events such as unrest and riots, stoppage, suspension (deferment) or interrupted construction required by state or local government authorities, regional construction controls, safety and environmental protection requirements, or health and epidemic-control requirements, the affected duration is extended accordingly and the employer and the contractor each bear their own losses (unless the contract provides otherwise, or under Section 8.8 and Clause 8.11.12(4) and (5)); the closing paragraph of Clause 8.11.9 is to the same effect: for economic loss and/or delay caused by government authorities, the duration is extended accordingly and each party bears its own economic loss.
- Personnel already dismissed, objectively not due and not actually paid: not counted (Clause 4.0.5; Clause 4.0.8, 'continue to accrue daily as actually incurred').
- Failure to mitigate: Civil Code Article 591 'After one party breaches, the other party shall take appropriate measures to prevent aggravation of the loss; where it fails to take appropriate measures and the loss is aggravated, it may not claim compensation for the aggravated part'; T/YJXB 0001-2023 Clause 3.0.9 'Where the stoppage is not caused by the contractor, the contractor is under a duty to keep the loss from growing; where it fails to take measures and the loss grows, it shall bear the aggravated part and may not claim it from the other party.'
- Procedural time limits: GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 8.11.3(1) - a written Notice of Claim must be submitted within the period agreed in the contract after the claim event (28 days if nothing is agreed); closing paragraph: 'where the injured party fails to raise the claim within the agreed time after the event, it may be deemed to have abandoned the relevant works claim, unless otherwise agreed in the contract or otherwise provided by laws and regulations'. GF-2020-0216 general conditions Clause 19.1: (1) a claiming party that fails to issue its Notice of Claim within 28 days loses the right to additional or reduced payment, extension of the defects liability period and/or extension of time; 19.2(2) where the Engineer fails to respond to the claim report within 42 days, the claim is deemed approved.
- Priority right: Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 17(2) 'where the contractor claims a priority right of payment out of the construction works for stoppage, idle-time and other losses caused by the employer, the people's court shall not uphold the claim' - the debt may be pursued, but without priority ranking.
Boundaries of application
- Applies to idle and stoppage claims, construction cost expert assessment and final account review under main-contract or EPC contracts; where the contract allocates these costs, the agreement prevails (GB/T 51262-2017 Clause 5.8.3(1)).
- Where management wages and suspension overheads coexist, avoid double billing: where the 15 secondary cost heads accrued as overheads already include management wages, the separately claimed wages must be deducted from the overheads accordingly.
- The 'reasonable percentage' is fixed case by case from the suspension length, the number of staff retained, the particular contract conditions and certified site records; T/YJXB 0001-2023 is an association standard, binding where cited in the contract and otherwise a reference for the calculation method.
- For force majeure and government-ordered stoppages, management wages are claimable only within the scope of 'retained at the employer's request'; the remaining losses are borne by each party.
- Losses from stoppage and idle time carry no priority right of payment, which does not affect their pursuit as ordinary debts in settlement or litigation.
- Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 takes effect on 30 June 2026 and applies to first-instance construction contract disputes newly accepted after that date (Article 23); cases accepted earlier follow the former rules.
Further reading
- GB/T 51262-2017 (Standard for Construction Cost Expert Assessment) Clause 5.8.3 (assessment rules on who bears claim costs for suspension of the works).
- GB/T 50500-2024 (China national pricing standard for BOQ) Clause 8.11.3 (28-day Notice of Claim and deemed abandonment), Clause 8.11.9 (heads of loss from causes not attributable to the contractor), Clause 8.11.10 (employer-responsibility causes permitting an added profit claim), Clause 8.11.12 (loss sharing for force majeure, notably paragraphs 4 and 5), Clause 8.11.13 (exceptional events such as government controls).
- T/YJXB 0001-2023 (Standard for Calculating the Contractor's Costs on Suspension of Construction Works) Clause 2.0.7 (wages of site watchkeepers), Clause 3.0.9 (duty to mitigate), Clause 4.0.5 (actually-paid basis for site production workers' wages), Clause 4.0.8 (suspension overheads), Clause 5.0.8 (calculation method).
- Civil Code of the PRC Article 584 (foreseeability rule), Article 591 (duty to mitigate), Articles 803 and 804 (employer liability for stoppage and idle-time losses).
- SPC Interpretation (II) on Construction Contract Disputes (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12) Article 17 (no priority right for stoppage and idle losses), Article 23 (effective 30 June 2026); original text at https://www.court.gov.cn/fabu/xiangqing/504221.html .
- Jian Shi [2020] No. 96 Model Contract for Project EPC (GF-2020-0216), general conditions Clause 19 'Claims' (19.1 raising a claim, 19.2 procedure for handling contractor claims, 19.4 time limits for claims).
Keywords
- time-related overheads during suspension
- 管理人员工资
- 窝工损失
- 暂停施工索赔
- T/YJXB 0001-2023
- GB/T 51262-2017
- 不可抗力停工
- 停工费用承担