Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-29

Allocating liability when employer-cause and contractor-cause events delay completion concurrently or in succession: attribution by time segment, extension of time only for the net delay on the critical path, overlapping periods shared in proportion to responsibility, and delay damages charged only on the residual delay left after extension

Neither a 50/50 split nor full liability on either party: the governing approach is 'attribution by segment + sharing in proportion to causative weight + no double counting'. Where responsibility can be separated by time segment, each segment is attributed to its own cause; only genuinely simultaneous, inseparable overlap periods are shared between the parties in proportion to their respective responsibility (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 cl. 4.9.7 para 4). The extendable time equals the net delay caused on the critical path by employer-cause events (and relief events): where the delaying event affects a critical activity, the delay time itself is the extension claimed; where a non-critical activity overruns its total float and becomes critical, the extension is 'delay time minus total float'; where it remains non-critical, no extension claim arises (GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 8.11.8). Delay damages / liquidated damages are charged only for the days by which the actual completion date is later than the extended completion date, because the very base of delay damages is 'the contract time for completion (including extensions approved by the employer)' (GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 2.0.33).

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第2.0.33、8.7.4、8.11.7、8.11.8、8.11.10、8.11.15、8.11.18、8.11.19条
  • GB/T 51262-2017 建设工程造价鉴定规范 第5.7.4、5.7.6条
  • T/ZBD 100.4-2023 建设工程造价鉴定作业指引 第4.9.7条
  • GF-2017-0201 建设工程施工合同(示范文本)第7.5.1、7.5.2、7.8.1、7.8.2项
  • 中华人民共和国民法典 第五百七十七条
  • 中华人民共和国民法典 第五百九十二条
  • 中华人民共和国民法典 第八百零三条
  • 中华人民共和国民法典 第八百零四条
  • 法释〔2020〕25号 最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)第十条
  • http://www.court.gov.cn/
  • https://www.gov.cn/
  • http://www.npc.gov.cn/

Positioning

This card resolves how the three ledgers - extension of time, cost losses, and delay damages (liquidated damages) - are split and computed when employer-cause and contractor-cause events delay completion concurrently or in succession, and gives workable rules for the time account, the cost account and the damages account, with a calculation-elements table and a legal-basis table. It applies to claims, interim settlement by construction stage, and construction cost / duration expert assessment during the performance stage of construction contracts.

Core conclusions

I. General principle: attribution by segment + sharing by causative weight + no double counting

Conclusion: neither an even 50/50 split nor full liability on one party. The extendable time = net delay days caused on the critical path by employer-cause events (and contractual relief events); the contractor's own delay = actual duration - contract duration - extendable time, and only that part triggers delay damages / liquidated damages for late completion. Legal basis: Civil Code Article 592 - 'Where both parties breach the contract, each shall bear the corresponding liability. Where one party's breach causes the other losses and the other party was at fault in the occurrence of the losses, the compensation payable may be reduced accordingly.' Article 577 - 'Where a party fails to perform its contractual obligations, or its performance does not conform to the agreement, it shall bear liability for breach such as continued performance, remedial measures, or compensation for losses.'

II. The five-step working rule

Step 1 Fix the facts: run from the commencement date stated in the notice of commencement to the date of actual completion (acceptance / handover) and compare with the contract duration to obtain the total delay days. In expert assessment 'the actual duration shall be determined first and then compared with the contract duration, so as to determine whether delay occurred and the specific length of the delay' (GB/T 51262-2017 cl. 5.7.6).

Step 2 Split into periods (must not be skipped): cut the delay period into four categories - employer-cause periods, contractor-cause periods, 'true concurrent delay' periods where both causes act simultaneously on the same critical activity within the same period, and relief periods attributable to neither party (force majeure, causes attributable to government authorities, etc.). In practice much of what is called 'concurrent delay' is in fact successive; successive delay is attributed segment by segment and needs no proportioning.

Step 3 Time account: extension recognises only the net critical-path effect (as GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 8.11.8 provides): where the delaying event affects an activity on the critical path, the delayed time is the extension claimed; where the event affects an activity off the critical path and the delay exceeds its total float so that the activity becomes critical, the difference between the delay time and the total float is the extension claimed; where the activity remains off the critical path after the delay, no extension claim arises. Suspension follows the same logic: where the employer causes suspension, the time is extended accordingly; where the contractor causes suspension, no extension is granted; where work halts pending a quality assessment before completion, the works pass the assessment and the contractor is not at fault, the assessment period counts as extension time (GB/T 51262-2017 cl. 5.7.4). Overlap periods must not be extended twice: the employer's claim costs for all contractor-caused delays (or extensions) shall be assessed independently for each claim event and shall not include cost claims for the effect of earlier delays on later works (cl. 8.11.7).

Step 4 Cost account: attribute by period; proportion the overlap. Where the employer's breach (such as re-letting contract works to another contractor, late provision of drawings or the site, provision of non-conforming materials, additional restrictions on the site, interference with the construction sequence, premature occupation of the works, etc.) causes economic loss, added cost and/or prolongation, the contractor may claim profit in addition to the loss costs; the claimable labour, material and plant losses include idle-labour costs of personnel already mobilised, losses on materials already delivered that cannot be brought into use, standby costs of plant already on site that cannot work, and other cost losses (cl. 8.11.10). For the overlap of concurrent delay, the costs 'shall, on the basis of the duration assessment report or the delay time accepted by both parties, be computed so that each party bears its share in proportion to the apportioned responsibility determined by the commissioning client'; for delay caused by the contractor, the contractor's own cost losses are not counted (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 cl. 4.9.7 paras 1 and 4). On attribution of delay responsibility, the assessor may put forward suggestions from the angle of professional discernment, but the final determination is made by the commissioning client on the parties' evidence (GB/T 51262-2017 cl. 5.7.6).

Step 5 Damages account: extend first, then charge for breach. Delay damages means the money the contractor must pay the employer under the contract where the contractor fails to construct to the planned progress so that the actual duration exceeds the contract duration or the contract duration of phased completion (including extensions of time approved by the employer) (cl. 2.0.33). It is therefore charged only for the days where 'actual completion date - extended completion date > 0', at the daily rate and cap agreed in the particular conditions (GF-2017-0201 cl. 7.5.2: where delay is caused by the contractor, the particular conditions may agree the method of computing liquidated damages for late completion and their cap; paying them does not relieve the contractor of the duty to complete the works and remedy defects). The employer may choose one or more of extending the defects warranty period, requiring payment of the extra costs incurred, requiring payment of delay damages, and requiring liquidated damages as agreed in the contract (cl. 8.11.19).

III. Calculation-elements table

Item Calculation base Period Rate / standard Clause basis
Total delay days Actual duration From the commencement date in the notice to actual completion (acceptance / handover) Compared with the total calendar days agreed in the contract GB/T 51262-2017 cl. 5.7.6
Extendable time (critical activity) Delay time of that event Period of actual effect Full extension GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 8.11.8
Extendable time (non-critical turned critical) Delay time - total float Effect period beyond the float The difference only; only the excess is extended ditto
Extendable time (still non-critical) - - No extension claim arises ditto
Idle labour / plant standby / material losses Standstill days (per the time fixed in the approved duration claim report) Employer-cause periods Idle labour cost, idle plant cost + related overheads and profit, plus other cost losses such as rises in material and equipment prices T/ZBD 100.4-2023 cl. 4.9.7 para 2; GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 8.11.10
Costs of the concurrent-delay overlap Total loss as determined True overlap period Shared in the responsibility ratio determined by the client T/ZBD 100.4-2023 cl. 4.9.7 para 4
Delay damages / late-completion liquidated damages Days by which actual completion is later than the extended completion date After the extended completion date Daily rate agreed in the particular conditions, capped as agreed GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 2.0.33; GF-2017-0201 cl. 7.5.2
Price adjustment after extension of time Quantities of the works executed after the planned progress date After the planned progress date Employer cause: the higher of the prices at the planned and actual progress dates; contractor cause: the lower; cause of neither party: per cl. 8.7.2 GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 8.7.4

IV. Legal-basis table

Instrument Clause Version / effect Core content
Civil Code of the PRC (Presidential Decree No. 45) Article 577 effective 2021-01-01 Forms of breach liability: continued performance, remedial measures, compensation for losses
ditto Article 592 effective 2021-01-01 Both parties in breach each bear the corresponding liability; fault of the other party in the loss reduces the compensation
ditto Article 803 effective 2021-01-01 Employer failing to provide raw materials, equipment, the site, funds or technical data at the agreed time and to the agreed requirements: the contractor may extend the date of the works and claim suspension, idle-resource and similar losses
ditto Article 804 effective 2021-01-01 Employer cause halting or slowing the works mid-course: the employer must take remedial measures and pay suspension, idle-resource, re-handling, plant relocation and material and component stockpiling losses and actual costs
Judicial Interpretation [2020] No. 25, Construction Interpretation (I) Article 10 effective 2021-01-01 Without an extension confirmation, timely application with qualifying grounds is still supported by the court; an agreed 'failure to apply in time means no extension' is enforced, unless the employer consents afterwards or the contractor raises a reasonable justification
GB/T 50500-2024, pricing standard for BOQ of construction works cl. 2.0.33, 8.7.4, 8.11.7, 8.11.8, 8.11.10, 8.11.15, 8.11.18, 8.11.19 2024 edition (current) Source of all pricing rules in this card
GB/T 51262-2017, code of construction cost expert assessment cl. 5.7.4, 5.7.6 2017 edition Extension rules for suspension; fix the actual duration before comparing with the contract duration
T/ZBD 100.4-2023, working guideline for construction cost expert assessment cl. 4.9.7 2023 edition Four scenarios for computing delay losses by responsible cause
GF-2017-0201, model construction contract cl. 7.5.1, 7.5.2, 7.8.1, 7.8.2 2017 edition Employer-cause delay: time, cost and profit; contractor-cause delay: LD computation method and cap; allocation of suspension responsibility

Boundaries

  • Where the delay is wholly attributable to one party, the single-party rule applies directly and no proportioning is entered; proportioning is reserved for overlap periods where both causes act simultaneously on the same critical activity and cannot be separated.
  • Where the client has not determined the parties' responsibility, or has not confirmed the duration assessment report, the assessor must not fix a ratio on its own; it may only 'compute the delay losses and their composition in full on the premise that the delay time has been determined, put forward alternative opinions and explain them in the assessment opinion for the client's use' (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 cl. 4.9.7 final para).
  • Force majeure interwoven with delay: where a party's cause produces delay and force majeure occurs within the extended time, the force majeure loss is borne by the party whose delay caused the extension; where both parties are responsible for the delay, liability may be borne in proportion to the responsibility (cl. 8.11.15). Relief-period costs are in general shared as 'losses of the permanent works and of materials for them borne by the employer; losses of plant and of construction preliminaries facilities borne by the contractor'.
  • Economic loss and/or delay caused by government authorities: the time is extended accordingly, and the economic losses of the employer and the contractor are borne by each party itself (cl. 8.11.10).
  • Where the contractor causes the employer loss, the employer may claim one or more of extra costs or expenses, losses to main contractor attendance and coordination services, fines and third-party compensation, delay losses, and quality non-conformity losses (cl. 8.11.18).
  • Procedural precondition: extension claims are subject to the Notice of Claim within the contractually agreed period (28 days where the contract is silent); failure to obtain a confirmation does not automatically forfeit the right, provided the contractor proves it applied in time on grounds conforming to the contract (Judicial Interpretation [2020] No. 25 Article 10).
  • Where the interface with the Construction Interpretation (II) (Judicial Interpretation [2026] No. 12) and Judicial Interpretation [2020] No. 25 is concerned, application is defined by the new interpretation's effective date and its transitional clauses; that is outside this card's computation rules.
  • This card is set in the national standard / Civil Code context; the FIDIC system (EOT and Delay Damages as separate regimes) differs in terminology and evidentiary structure and must not be transplanted directly.

Further reading

  • GB/T 50500-2024 Chapter 8 'Adjustment of the contract price', section 8.11 (8.11.7 independent assessment, 8.11.8 critical path and total float, 8.11.9-8.11.10 claim scope and profit, 8.11.15 delay and force majeure, 8.11.18-8.11.19 employer claims and remedies); Chapter 2 term 2.0.33 delay damages; cl. 8.7.4 price adjustment after extension of time.
  • GB/T 51262-2017 cl. 5.7.1-5.7.6 (duration assessment and extension); T/ZBD 100.4-2023 cl. 4.9.7 (assessment of delay losses).
  • GF-2017-0201 cl. 7.5 [delay in completion], cl. 7.6 [adverse physical conditions], cl. 7.7 [abnormally adverse climate], cl. 7.8 [suspension of the works].
  • Civil Code Articles 577, 592, 803 and 804; Judicial Interpretation [2020] No. 25 Article 10. Official texts can be verified at the Supreme People's Court http://www.court.gov.cn/ , the Chinese Government https://www.gov.cn/ and the NPC http://www.npc.gov.cn/
  • Further reading: identification of total float and the critical path in network programmes, limits on idle-resource costs and time-related overheads during suspension, and the normative evolution of the 28-day claim procedure.

Keywords

Cited By