Internal recourse within an EPC (design + construction) consortium where a design error causes rework: the two-layer structure of joint and several liability outwardly and shared liability in proportion inwardly, three claim paths, the computation recoverable amount = amount actually borne - own share, fault-based reduction and the situations where recourse fails
Recourse lies, but not automatically in full: limited to actual loss, computed on internal shares, reduced in proportion to any fault of the contractor. Core reasoning: outwardly the consortium members are jointly and severally liable (Bidding Law Article 31(3); Measures for the Administration of EPC in Building and Municipal Infrastructure Projects, Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12, Article 10(2)); inwardly liability is shared - 'the shares of jointly and severally liable persons follow their respective responsibility, or are equal where responsibility is hard to determine; a person who has borne more than its share may seek recourse against the others' (Civil Code Article 178(2)); 'where the shares among joint and several debtors are hard to determine, the shares are presumed equal' (Article 519(1)). Outward joint and several liability does not extinguish inward share-based recourse, and the joint bidding agreement or consortium agreement in addition constitutes a parallel contractual claim between the members (Articles 465 and 509). Recoverable amount = amount actually borne (outward compensation + direct cost of rework performed by the contractor + reasonable expenses incurred to mitigate the loss) - the share the contractor should bear for its own fault.
Applicable Codes
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》(主席令第45号)第一百七十八条、第一百八十八条、第四百六十五条、第五百零九条、第五百一十九条、第五百七十七条、第五百八十四条、第五百九十一条、第五百九十二条、第八百条、第八百零一条、第一千一百六十五条
- 《中华人民共和国招标投标法》(主席令第21号)第三十一条
- 《房屋建筑和市政基础设施项目工程总承包管理办法》(建市规〔2019〕12号)第十条、第十五条、第十六条
- 《建设工程质量管理条例》(2019修订,国务院令第714号)第十九条、第二十八条、第六十三条
- 《中华人民共和国建筑法》(2011修正)第五十六条、第五十八条
- 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第二十四条、第三十四条
- 《最高人民法院关于适用〈中华人民共和国民事诉讼法〉的解释》第二十八条
- 《中华人民共和国仲裁法》(2025修订,2026年3月1日施行)第二十七条、第三十条、第三十一条
- 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》(法释〔2026〕12号)第二十三条 —— 原文来源:https://www.court.gov.cn/fabu/xiangqing/504221.html
Scope
This card addresses a frequent dispute inside an EPC (design + construction) consortium: a design error by the designer causes rework, and after the contractor has compensated the employer outwardly or paid for the rework itself, can it recover from the designer, how much, along which claim path, and in which situations the courts refuse. The key is to separate the two legal layers: outward joint and several liability and inward shares.
Core conclusions
1. Conclusion and core reasoning
Recourse lies, but not 'automatically in full' - limited to actual loss, computed on internal shares; reduced for the contractor's own fault.
The reason is the two-layer structure: outwardly, the consortium members are jointly and severally liable to the employer; inwardly, they are liable in shares. Outward joint and several liability does not extinguish inward share-based recourse, and the joint bidding agreement or consortium agreement binds the members and supplies a parallel contractual claim.
- Outward joint and several liability: Bidding Law Article 31(3) 'where a consortium wins the bid, its members shall jointly conclude the contract with the tenderer and bear joint and several liability to the tenderer for the awarded project'; Measures for the Administration of EPC in Building and Municipal Infrastructure Projects (Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12) Article 10(2) 'where a design institute and a contractor form a consortium ... the members shall jointly conclude the EPC contract with the employer and bear joint and several liability for the EPC project'.
- Inward shares: Civil Code Article 178(2) 'the shares of jointly and severally liable persons follow their respective responsibility, or are equal where responsibility is hard to determine; a person who has borne more than its share may seek recourse against the others'; Article 519(1) 'where the shares among joint and several debtors are hard to determine, the shares are presumed equal'.
- Binding force of contract: Civil Code Article 465 'a contract formed in accordance with law is protected by law and binds only the parties'; Article 509 'the parties shall perform their obligations fully as agreed'.
2. Three claim paths (the path chosen fixes the proof structure)
| Path | Preconditions | Relief sought | Main basis |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 Breach action under the consortium or joint bidding agreement (first choice) | The agreement has division-of-work, cost-allocation or liability-sharing clauses | The designer compensates losses caused by design defects within its division of work | Civil Code Articles 465, 509, 577, 584 |
| 2 Inward recourse on joint and several liability | The contractor has actually borne more than its share outwardly (to the employer) | Recourse from the designer for the excess | Civil Code Articles 178(2), 519(2) |
| 3 Tort action (alternative) | No direct contractual clause applies; the design fault directly caused the contractor property loss | Compensation for direct losses such as rework, demolition and idle time | Civil Code Article 1165 'a person who at fault infringes another's civil-law rights and interests and causes harm bears tort liability' |
Key point: path 2 requires that liability has been 'actually borne'. If the contractor has not yet compensated the employer and merely funded the rework itself, it should take path 1 (or 3): in substance an internal share-allocation claim, not recourse in the strict sense.
3. Recourse amount calculation
Recoverable amount = amount actually borne by the contractor (outward compensation + direct cost of self-performed rework + reasonable expenses to prevent aggravation of loss) - the share the contractor should bear for its own fault
- Fixing shares: by respective responsibility, or equally / presumed equal where hard to determine (Article 178(2), Article 519(1)). With proof that 'the designer is fully responsible and the contractor faultless', 100% of the actual loss may be claimed; without proof of the shares, claim 50%.
- Fault reduction: Civil Code Article 592(2) 'where one party's breach causes the other loss and the other is at fault in the occurrence of the loss, the compensation may be reduced accordingly.'
- Scope and foreseeability: Article 584 'compensation shall equal the loss caused by the breach, including the benefit obtainable on performance, but must not exceed the loss the breaching party foresaw or should have foreseen at the time of contract formation.'
- Duty to mitigate: Article 591 'after breach, the other party shall take appropriate measures to prevent aggravation of the loss; failing that, it may not claim the aggravated part. Reasonable expenses incurred to prevent aggravation are borne by the breaching party.'
- Risk of failed recovery in consortia of three or more: Article 519(3) 'where a joint and several debtor pursued cannot perform the share it should bear, the other joint and several debtors shall bear it in proportion within the corresponding range.'
- Passing-on of defences: Article 519(2) 'defences that the other joint and several debtors have against the creditor may be asserted against that debtor.'
- Loss compensation: where rework costs were already inside the EPC lump sum, or the employer has separately paid for the rework, the contractor has no actual loss and no compensation arises.
4. Positive and negative scenarios
| Scenario | Outcome | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Design error confirmed by assessment and within the designer's division of work | Supported: recourse per share of responsibility | Civil Code Art. 178(2), 519(2); Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12 Art. 10(2) |
| Contractor built to the drawings, faultless, has compensated the employer or actually paid for rework | Supported: amount = amount borne - own share | Civil Code Art. 577, 584, 178(2) |
| Consortium agreement expressly allocates design defects to the designer (wholly or mainly) | Supported per the agreement (valid inwardly, not opposable to the employer) | Civil Code Art. 465, 509; Bidding Law Art. 31(3) |
| Designer failed to design to the mandatory standards for project construction, or failed to design on the basis of the survey results | Supported; clues of administrative liability may be referred to the housing authority (correction ordered, fine of RMB 100,000 to 300,000) | Construction Quality Management Regulations Art. 19, Art. 63 items (2) and (4); Construction Law Art. 56 |
| Contractor is the consortium leader and settles the employer's overall claim outwardly | Recourse for the excess over its own share | Civil Code Art. 178(2) |
| Designer delayed issuing variations or handling plans, aggravating the loss | Losses arising before the aggravation are recoverable; reasonable mitigation expenses are borne by the designer | Civil Code Art. 591 |
| No direct contractual clause, but the design fault directly caused the contractor property loss | The tort route is additionally available (alternative path) | Civil Code Art. 1165 |
| Contractor found errors in the design documents and drawings during construction but continued without written notice | Reduced liability or partly rejected (contributory fault) | Construction Quality Management Regulations Art. 28(2); Civil Code Art. 592(2) |
| Contractor altered the design or did not build to the drawings | Rejected (rework due to its own cause) | Construction Law Art. 58; Regulations Art. 28(1); Civil Code Art. 801 |
| Design error stems from data provided by the employer, requirements raised by the employer, or unforeseeable ground conditions | Designer exempt; claim against the employer instead | Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12 Art. 15 items (3) and (4) |
| Agreement says 'each bears its own, no mutual recourse' or caps compensation | Handled per the agreement between the members; not opposable to the employer; the validity of exclusion or cap clauses is reviewed case by case | Civil Code Art. 465, 509; Bidding Law Art. 31(3) |
5. Legal basis table
| Instrument | Article | Version and effect | Core content |
|---|---|---|---|
| Civil Code of the PRC (Presidential Decree No. 45) | Art. 178 | effective 1 January 2021 | Outward joint and several liability; inward shares by responsibility, equal where undeterminable; recourse for the excess |
| same | Art. 519 | same | Shares presumed equal where undeterminable; recourse for the excess; passing-on of defences; proportional sharing where recovery fails |
| same | Art. 584, 591, 592 | same | Scope of loss compensation and foreseeability; duty to mitigate; contributory fault reduction |
| same | Art. 465, 509, 577 | same | Binding force of contract; full performance and good faith; forms of breach liability |
| same | Art. 800, 801 | same | Reduced or waived fee and compensation for substandard survey and design (toward the employer); gratuitous rework and delay liability for contractor-caused quality failure |
| same | Art. 1165, 188 | same | Fault-based tort; three-year limitation |
| Bidding Law of the PRC (Presidential Decree No. 21) | Art. 31 | current | Consortium member qualifications, lower grade where the same speciality, joint bidding agreement, joint contracting after award with joint and several liability, no forced consortium |
| Measures for the Administration of EPC in Building and Municipal Infrastructure Projects (Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12) | Art. 10, 15, 16 | current | EPC contractor qualifications or a design + construction consortium; joint contracting and joint and several liability; risk allocation; the lump-sum price is not adjusted outside the agreed adjustment events |
| Construction Quality Management Regulations (State Council Decree No. 714) | Art. 19, 28, 63 | 2019 revision | Survey and design to the mandatory standards with responsibility for quality; build to the drawings and raise objections on finding errors; RMB 100,000-300,000 fine for design violations plus compensation |
| Construction Law of the PRC | Art. 56, 58 | 2011 revision | Survey and design units responsible for their quality; contractors build to the drawings and shall not alter the design |
| Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Interpretation (II) | Art. 23 | effective 30 June 2026 | Applies to newly accepted first-instance construction contract disputes; earlier SPC interpretations inconsistent with it yield to it |
6. Procedure and proof points
- Limitation: three years to request judicial protection of civil rights, from when the right-holder knew or should have known of the harm and of the obligor; beyond 20 years from the harm the court will not protect the right, extendable on application in special circumstances (Civil Code Art. 188). Recourse or compensation claims should be raised promptly after outward payment or rework expenditure.
- Jurisdiction: internal consortium disputes are generally handled as contract disputes, before the court of the defendant's domicile or of the place of performance (Civil Procedure Law Art. 24); if characterised as a construction contract dispute, jurisdiction is exclusive to the court where the works are located (Civil Procedure Law Art. 34(1), SPC CPL Interpretation Art. 28(2)).
- Arbitration: where the consortium agreement provides for arbitration, the arbitration agreement must contain the intent to arbitrate, the matters referred and the chosen institution (Arbitration Law Art. 27); the arbitration agreement stands independent of the formation, variation, ineffectiveness, termination or avoidance of the contract (Art. 30); objections to its validity must be raised before the first hearing of the tribunal; where one party asks the arbitration institution or the tribunal to decide and the other asks the court, the court decides (Art. 31).
- Proof points: (1) the assessment conclusion on the design defect or design confirmation documents; (2) the division of work (joint bidding or consortium agreement clauses); (3) proof of actual expenditure (rework confirmations, certified records, invoices, cost ledgers); (4) proof of payment to the employer (essential for path 2); (5) written records of objections raised to drawing errors during construction (to defeat contributory-fault defences).
Boundaries of application
- No survey or design contract exists between the contractor and the designer: Civil Code Art. 800 (reduced or waived survey and design fee plus compensation for substandard quality) is the designer's liability toward the employer; the contractor cannot invoke it directly; its inward claim rests on the joint bidding or consortium agreement plus the internal-share rules of joint and several liability.
- Inward agreements cannot bind the employer: any exclusion, cap or 'no mutual recourse' clause operates only between the members and does not alter the outward joint and several liability (Bidding Law Art. 31(3); Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12 Art. 10(2)).
- 'Actually borne' is the precondition of the inward recourse path; before outward payment, or before the rework cost has actually been incurred, only inward share allocation or prior fixation of the shares is available.
- No double counting without actual loss; where the rework was inside the contract price or has been paid separately by the employer, the claim fails.
- 50% is only the fallback where 'shares are hard to determine', not the default conclusion; causation (whether the rework truly flowed from the design defect), the contributory fault ratio, and the validity of exclusion or cap clauses are all examined case by case.
- The designer's administrative fine (RMB 100,000-300,000) is a sanction by the administrative authority, parallel to and no substitute for the civil recourse between the members, and cannot be counted into the contractor's claim.
- Note the effective date of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12: it takes effect on 30 June 2026 and applies to first-instance construction contract disputes newly accepted after that date; earlier SPC interpretations inconsistent with it yield to it.
Further reading
- Civil Code Articles 178 (shares and recourse in joint and several liability), 519 (shares, recourse, passing-on of defences, sharing where recovery fails), 584, 591, 592, 465, 509, 577, 800, 801, 1165, 188.
- Bidding Law Article 31 (consortium and joint bidding agreement).
- Jian Shi Gui [2019] No. 12 Article 10 (consortium qualifications and joint and several liability), Article 15 (risks borne by the employer: major fluctuation in the prices of key materials, equipment and labour, changes in laws, regulations and policy, unforeseeable ground conditions, employer-related causes, force majeure), Article 16 (lump-sum contracts are suitable for enterprise-invested projects; under a lump-sum contract the price is generally not adjusted apart from the situations agreed to be adjustable; measurement rules and pricing methods may be agreed).
- Construction Quality Management Regulations (2019 revision, State Council Decree No. 714) Articles 19, 28 and 63; Construction Law (2011 revision) Articles 56 and 58.
- Civil Procedure Law (2023 revision) Articles 24 and 34; SPC CPL Interpretation Article 28; Arbitration Law (2025 revision, effective 1 March 2026) Articles 27, 30 and 31.
- Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 Article 23, original text at https://www.court.gov.cn/fabu/xiangqing/504221.html ; Arbitration Law 2025 revision text: https://policy.mofcom.gov.cn/claw/clawContent.shtml?id=103718
Keywords
- EPC联合体
- 连带责任
- 内部追偿
- 责任份额
- 设计错误
- 返工损失
- 共同投标协议
- 与有过失