Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-29

Whether, after one member of an EPC general contracting consortium withdraws mid-term, the remaining members may continue performing the original contract: two requirements - employer consent to the change of contract party, and the remaining members' qualification basis (dual design and construction qualifications); the scenarios where overstepping constitutes contract transfer or unlawful subcontracting; the consequences of member substitution at the tendering stage (invalid tender) and the rules for valuing the completed works

Continuation is not automatic; two requirements must be met together: (1) the employer (construction unit) consents to the withdrawing party's exit and to the remaining members succeeding to the contract position (a wholesale transfer of contractual rights and obligations, which under Civil Code Articles 555 and 551 requires the consent of the other party / the creditor); (2) the remaining members themselves still meet the qualification conditions in the tender documents and the state provisions (EPC requires both design and construction qualifications, see Jianshigui [2019] No. 12, Article 10, paragraph 1). If either requirement fails, they cannot continue and the contract can only be terminated and re-tendered; without the employer's consent the withdrawing party remains a contract party and bears joint and several liability to the employer under Tendering and Bidding Law Article 31, paragraph 3 and Jianshigui [2019] No. 12, Article 10, paragraph 2 - the remaining members' unilateral 'carrying on' cannot cut off that liability. Moreover, transferring the withdrawing party's work wholesale to a third party while collecting only a management fee without actually organising and managing the works is treated as contract transfer (Jianshigui [2019] No. 1, Article 8, final paragraph): the contract is void and the employer may terminate.

Applicable Codes

  • 《中华人民共和国招标投标法》(2017修正,主席令第86号)第三十一条
  • 《中华人民共和国招标投标法实施条例》(2019修订,国务院令第709号)第三十七条
  • 《房屋建筑和市政基础设施项目工程总承包管理办法》(建市规〔2019〕12号)第六条至第十六条
  • 《建筑工程施工发包与承包违法行为认定查处管理办法》(建市规〔2019〕1号)第八条、第十二条;https://www.nra.gov.cn/xxgk/gkml/ztjg/jgxx/gkgc/202204/t20220405_290233.shtml
  • 《中华人民共和国民法典》(主席令第45号)第五百五十一条、第五百五十五条、第七百九十一条、第八百零六条
  • 《中华人民共和国建筑法》(2019修正,主席令第29号)第二十七条、第二十九条
  • 《建设工程质量管理条例》(2019修订,国务院令第714号)第七十八条
  • 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》(法释〔2020〕25号)第一条
  • 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》(法释〔2026〕12号,2026年6月30日施行)第六条、第十条、第二十三条
  • 《中华人民共和国政府采购法》(2014修正)第二十四条
  • 《中华人民共和国政府采购法实施条例》(国务院令第658号)第二十二条

Positioning of the topic

Addresses an EPC general contracting consortium formed of design + construction members where, after award and during performance, one member withdraws mid-term: whether the remaining members may continue performing the original general contract, the statutory requirements that must be met together, the red line beyond which the arrangement constitutes contract transfer / unlawful subcontracting, the differing consequences of member changes at the tendering stage versus party changes during performance, and the basis for valuing the works completed after withdrawal.

Core conclusions

1. Continuation is not automatic; two requirements must be met together.

  1. Requirement 1: the employer consents to the withdrawing party's exit and to the remaining members succeeding to the contract position. A member's withdrawal is in substance a change of contract party (transfer of rights and obligations together); under Civil Code Article 555, 'a party may, with the consent of the other party, transfer its rights and obligations under the contract together to a third party'; a transfer of debt is further governed by Article 551: 'where a debtor transfers all or part of its debt to a third party, the consent of the creditor is required. The debtor or the third party may urge the creditor to consent within a reasonable period; if the creditor makes no expression, it is deemed to disagree.' Oral acquiescence is insufficient; a tripartite (or multipartite) variation agreement between the employer and all original consortium members should be signed, fixing the valuation of the completed works and the cut-off point for the division of liabilities.
  2. Requirement 2: the remaining members themselves still meet the qualification conditions in the tender documents and the state provisions. Tendering and Bidding Law, Article 31, paragraph 2: 'All parties to a consortium shall have the corresponding capability to undertake the tendered project; where state provisions or the tender documents prescribe qualification conditions for tenderers, all parties to the consortium shall meet the prescribed corresponding qualifications. A consortium formed of units in the same trade takes its qualification grade from the unit with the lower grade.' Measures for the Administration of General Contracting for Building and Municipal Infrastructure Projects (Jianshigui [2019] No. 12), Article 10, paragraph 1: 'The general contracting unit shall hold both design and construction qualifications commensurate with the scale of the works, or be a consortium of a design unit and a construction unit holding the corresponding qualifications.' If the withdrawing party was the holder of the design or the construction qualification, the remaining member alone lacks the dual qualifications; the qualification basis fails, continuation is barred, and the contract should be terminated and re-tendered (for government procurement projects, re-procured); Construction Law Articles 27 and 29 likewise provide that joint contracting is limited to the business scope permitted to the lower-qualified unit, and that contracting beyond one's qualification grade or in another's name is prohibited.

2. Unilateral continuation without the employer's consent: not contractual continuation. Under Tendering and Bidding Law Article 31, paragraph 3, 'where a consortium wins the tender, all parties to the consortium shall jointly sign the contract with the tenderee and bear joint and several liability to the tenderee for the awarded project', and Jianshigui [2019] No. 12, Article 10, paragraph 2, 'all parties to the consortium shall jointly sign the general contracting contract with the construction unit and bear joint and several liability for the general contracting project'. The withdrawing party remains a contract party; the employer may still require it to bear joint and several liability for the whole of the works, and it answers for the works completed before withdrawal and for its own breaches. One distinction is essential: continued construction in fact is not the same as contractual continuation in law. Further, Tendering and Bidding Law Article 31, paragraph 4 provides 'the tenderee may not force tenderers to form a consortium to tender jointly, nor restrict competition among tenderers' - the employer likewise may not compel the original consortium members to take over another party's work.

3. The red line: transferring the withdrawing party's work wholesale while collecting only a management fee is treated as contract transfer. Measures for the Identification and Handling of Illegal Acts in Construction Contract Awarding and Contracting (Jianshigui [2019] No. 1), Article 8, final paragraph: 'Where two or more units form a consortium to contract works, and under the consortium's division-of-work agreement or in the actual implementation of the project one party to the consortium carries out no construction and does not organise or manage the construction activity, and collects a management fee or other similar charge from the other parties to the consortium, that party is treated as having transferred the works it contracted to the other parties of the consortium.' Paragraph 1 of that article lists nine contract-transfer scenarios (including transferring all the works to others; splitting the works and transferring the parts to different units in the name of subcontracting; not stationing a project manager or other principal management personnel, or the personnel having no labour contract or social insurance relationship with the contractor; having others purchase the principal materials and equipment that the agreement requires the contractor to purchase; the trade works contractor collecting the whole price apart from a management fee; disguised transfer under names such as cooperation, joint operation, or personal contracting). Consequences: the contract is void under Civil Code Article 153, paragraph 1 and Article 791 and Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, Article 1, paragraph 2 ('construction contracts signed by the contractor with others after transferring or unlawfully subcontracting the construction works shall be found void under Article 153, paragraph 1 and Article 791, paragraphs 2 and 3 of the Civil Code'); the employer may terminate under Civil Code Article 806, paragraph 1 ('where the contractor transfers or unlawfully subcontracts the construction works, the employer may terminate the contract'); the definitions of contract transfer and unlawful subcontracting are further in the Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects (2019 revision), Article 78 (four scenarios of unlawful subcontracting; the definition of contract transfer).

4. Member exit at the tendering stage (after prequalification, before the tender deadline): Implementation Regulations of the Tendering and Bidding Law, Article 37, paragraph 2: 'where the tenderee accepts consortium tenders and conducts prequalification, the consortium shall be formed before submitting the prequalification application documents. Where the consortium adds, reduces, or substitutes members after prequalification, its tender is invalid'; paragraph 3: 'where the parties to a consortium tender separately in their own name in the same tender, or join other consortia in tendering, the relevant tenders are all invalid.' That is, substituting a member after prequalification = an invalid tender; the only paths are re-tendering or re-forming a consortium - it is not a question of 'continuing the original contract'.

5. The lawful outlet preserved: where the withdrawing party undertook only non-main, non-critical, non-qualification-bearing work, that part may, with the employer's approval, be lawfully subcontracted to a unit with the corresponding qualifications - under Civil Code Article 791, paragraph 2, 'the general contractor or the survey, design, or construction contractor may, with the employer's consent, entrust part of the work it contracted to a third party. The third party and the general contractor or the survey, design, or construction contractor bear joint and several liability to the employer for the work results the third party completes', together with the subcontracting rules of Construction Law Article 29. This is lawful subcontracting, not a change of member; but main structural construction must be performed by the contractor itself, and re-subcontracting is prohibited.

6. Payment for the completed works after withdrawal / termination: where a fixed-price lump-sum contract is terminated and the price of the acceptable-quality part is neither agreed nor settled by negotiation, under Interpretation (II) (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12), Article 10, the pricing standards and pricing methods published by the construction administration authority at the place of the works at the time of contract conclusion, or the relevant norms in the construction sector, may be used by reference to fix the ratio of the price of the completed part to the total price, and that ratio is then applied to the fixed lump sum agreed in the contract.

7. The benchmark for government procurement projects: Government Procurement Law Article 24 allows two or more citizens, legal persons, or other organisations to form a supplier consortium, which must submit a consortium agreement stating the work and obligations each party undertakes; all parties jointly sign the contract with the purchaser and bear joint and several liability. Implementation Regulations of the Government Procurement Law, Article 22: 'where suppliers in a consortium holding qualifications of the same category undertake the same work under the consortium's division of labour, the qualification grade follows the supplier with the lower grade. Parties joining procurement activities in the form of a consortium may not separately participate, or form another consortium with other suppliers, in the government procurement activities under the same contract item.'

Scope of application

  • Jianshigui [2019] No. 12 applies to general contracting for building and municipal infrastructure projects; general contracting in highways, water conservancy, railways, and other sectors is governed by separate ministerial rules and sector measures - the consortium qualification and member-change rules must be checked against the corresponding provisions.
  • The requirements above concern the performance stage after award and contract signing; consortium formation at the tendering stage, and the addition, reduction, or substitution of members, follow Implementation Regulations Article 37, with the consequence of an invalid tender rather than a contract variation.
  • Interpretation (II) (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12) takes effect on 30 June 2026 and under its Article 23 applies to first-instance construction contract cases newly accepted after that date; cases accepted or decided before that are not covered, and earlier interpretations conflicting with it yield to it.
  • 'Remaining members continuing construction' is lawful continuation only where the employer consents in writing to the change of contract party and the qualifications still hold; mere de facto acquiescence by the employer or verbal approval by the supervising engineer produces no change-of-party effect.
  • Findings of contract transfer / unlawful subcontracting turn on actual organisation and management and the substance of the charges, not on the label of the consortium agreement or the wording of its internal division of work.

Further reading

  • Tendering and Bidding Law of the PRC (2017 amendment, Presidential Decree No. 86), Article 31 (consortium formation, qualifications, joint and several liability, no forced consortium)
  • Implementation Regulations of the Tendering and Bidding Law (2019 revision, State Council Decree No. 709), Article 37
  • Measures for the Administration of General Contracting for Building and Municipal Infrastructure Projects (Jianshigui [2019] No. 12), Articles 6 to 16: Article 6 choice of delivery method, Article 7 completion of approvals before award, Article 8 tendering method, Article 9 content of tender documents, Article 10 dual qualifications and consortium joint liability, Article 11 ineligibility of agency-construction, project management, supervision, cost consultancy, and tendering agency units, Article 15 risk allocation, Article 16 lump-sum contract and contract price form
  • Measures for the Identification and Handling of Illegal Acts in Construction Contract Awarding and Contracting (Jianshigui [2019] No. 1), Article 8 (nine transfer scenarios; a consortium party that does no construction and collects only a management fee is treated as transferring), Article 12 (unlawful subcontracting); text at the National Railway Administration government website https://www.nra.gov.cn/xxgk/gkml/ztjg/jgxx/gkgc/202204/t20220405_290233.shtml
  • Civil Code of the PRC (Presidential Decree No. 45), Articles 551, 555, 791, and 806
  • Construction Law of the PRC (2019 amendment, Presidential Decree No. 29), Articles 27 and 29
  • Regulation on Quality Management of Construction Projects (2019 revision, State Council Decree No. 714), Article 78
  • SPC Interpretation (I) on Construction Contract Disputes (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25), Article 1; SPC Interpretation (II) on Construction Contract Disputes (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12), Articles 6, 10, and 23
  • Government Procurement Law of the PRC (2014 amendment), Article 24; Implementation Regulations of the Government Procurement Law (State Council Decree No. 658), Article 22

Keywords

  • 联合体成员退出
  • EPC联合体
  • 合同主体变更
  • 权利义务概括转让
  • 设计施工双资质
  • 招标投标法第三十一条
  • 工程总承包管理办法
  • 联合体转包认定