Claimable scope and profit-claim boundary under GB/T 50500-2024: the nine event classes of Article 8.11.9 with the four-way split of suspension losses, the eight employer-fault situations where Article 8.11.10 adds profit, and the independent-assessment rule for EOT claims in Article 8.11.7
GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.11.9 lists nine claimable event classes for non-contractor causes (losses of labour, materials, plant and utilities from stoppage, waiting and reduced efficiency; direct costs of cost fluctuation from programme adjustment; site-protection measures on suspension and resumption; direct costs of rework, alteration and scrapped materials; extra inspection and testing costs; losses from price not paid as agreed; suspension effects from unearthing antiquities; other provable losses and VAT; and reasonable extension of time), with suspension losses split into idle labour, unusable mobilised materials, plant standby and other losses; save as the contract provides otherwise, only claims arising from the employer's breach may include profit (Article 8.11.10 lists eight such situations), losses caused by government authorities being borne by each party with time extended accordingly.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第8.11.1、8.11.2、8.11.7、8.11.9、8.11.10、8.11.11、8.11.12~8.11.14条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第8.7.4条
Scope of the question
The substantive claim scope defined by Articles 8.11.9 and 8.11.10 of GB/T 50500-2024: the list of cost and time items claimable when events occur for non-contractor reasons, and which employer-fault situations additionally attract profit; plus the independent-assessment rule for EOT claims in Article 8.11.7 - for judging whether a loss enters the claim list.
Core conclusions
1. Scope precondition (Article 8.11.9 opening) Where events not caused by the contractor cause economic loss, cost increase and / or delay, the contractor may claim one or more items per the losses and delay suffered; contractor losses caused by the employer follow Articles 8.11.10 and 8.11.11, and force majeure events follow Articles 8.11.12 to 8.11.14.
2. The nine claimable classes (Article 8.11.9 items 1-9)
- cost losses of labour, materials, plant and utilities from stoppage, waiting, reduced efficiency or delay (authority-ordered suspension may follow 8.11.13);
- direct costs of cost fluctuations of labour, materials and plant arising from programme adjustment, except where adjusted under 8.7.4;
- necessary measures for suspension, resumption and site protection (including provision, use and removal);
- direct costs of rework, alteration and repair, and direct losses of scrapped materials;
- costs of additional inspection, checking and testing;
- losses from contract price not paid as agreed;
- effects of suspension or interruption from unearthing relics, ruins, and remains, fossils, coins or objects of geological or archaeological value;
- other provable losses of the contractor and VAT;
- reasonable delay (extension) caused by the events.
3. The four-way split of suspension losses (Article 8.11.9 closing) Losses of labour, materials and plant from stoppage, waiting, reduced efficiency or delay comprise: (1) idle costs of mobilised personnel unable to work; (2) losses of mobilised materials unusable; (3) standby costs of mobilised plant unable to work; (4) other cost losses.
4. The profit boundary (Article 8.11.9 closing, Article 8.11.10) Headline rule: save as the contract provides otherwise, claims arising from the employer's breach may include profit, the employer compensating the contractor's losses; for economic loss or delay caused by government authorities, time is extended and each party bears its own loss. Article 8.11.10: for events caused by the employer's fault causing loss, cost increase and / or delay, the contractor may claim profit in addition to Article 8.11.9:
- the employer transfers an item of the works to another contractor;
- the employer is late providing drawings or the site;
- employer-supplied materials are substandard, late, or delivered elsewhere, causing non-conformity;
- the employer causes setting-out errors and rework;
- the employer restricts the site, delays approvals or disrupts the working sequence;
- the employer causes delay, suspension, or failure to resume on time after suspension;
- the employer takes over the works before completion;
- the employer causes defects or damage within the defects liability period requiring repair.
5. EOT assessment rule (Article 8.11.7, key sentences) When computing delay (extension) and the resulting claim costs, the work corresponding to the claimed extension must be on the critical path, or be work whose critical path is altered by the event; the extension granted is the extension of contract time. The employer shall assess each EOT claim of the contractor independently, not including claims for the knock-on effect of earlier delay on later works; extension-induced claim costs are accounted per event, without claiming their effect on later works.
6. Exclusivity against price adjustment (Articles 8.11.1, 8.11.2) Claims address events not caused by oneself, outside the adjustment scope of Sections 8.2 to 8.10, causing loss, cost increase and / or delay and chargeable to the other party; events within those sections adjust under them, the rest under this section. Events already price-adjusted under the contract (other than claims) are not claimed again. Claims comprise economic compensation and time adjustment, raised together when concurrent.
Applicability limits
- Precondition: non-contractor cause; the contractor's own losses are outside this list.
- Profit limited to employer-breach causes (save as otherwise agreed); authority causes extend time only, losses borne by each; force majeure follows 8.11.12 to 8.11.14.
- No double counting: item 2's price fluctuations excluded by 8.7.4 follow 8.7.4; events already adjusted (non-claim) are not claimed again.
- EOT claims are bounded by the critical path, each event assessed and accounted independently; 8.11.7 equally binds the employer's EOT cost claims against the contractor (earlier delay not re-counted in later works).
- Substantive scope is only one element of an established claim: procedure (contract period, 28 days at two nodes absent agreement) and evidence (contract basis, records and proofs, cost computation schedules) also apply - see the claims procedure card.
Further reading
- GB/T 50500-2024: Articles 8.11.1 (application and nature), 8.11.2 (making the claim), 8.11.7 (EOT assessment), 8.11.9 (claimable events), 8.11.10 (profit situations), 8.11.11 (employer-cause claims), 8.11.12 to 8.11.14 (force majeure), 8.7.4 (price-fluctuation exclusions).
- Computing specific items: suspension overheads and idle costs, plant standby and mobilisation rules, critical-path determination for design-change delay, supplier-delay stoppage losses and foreseeability limits.
- Procedure and time limits, claim line items at final account, and evidence-chain checking: companion cards.
Keywords
- 可索赔范围
- 索赔利润
- 窝工费用
- 施工机具停滞费
- 停工措施费
- 发包人责任索赔
- 工期索赔关键线路
- 8.11.9
- 8.11.10