Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-29

Six statutory grounds of collusion between tenderer and bidder and the legal consequences: invalid award, fines of 0.5%-1.0% of the awarded amount and 5%-10% on responsible persons, confiscation of unlawful gains, bidding disqualification for 1-2 years, revocation of the business licence, and the quantitative threshold of serious circumstances (direct loss of RMB 300,000 or more)

The six statutory grounds of collusion between tenderer and bidder are in Article 41 of the Implementation Regulation under the Tendering and Bidding Law (opening bid documents before bid opening and leaking information; leaking the base price or the members of the tender evaluation committee; expressly or impliedly directing a bidder to lower or raise its price; instigating withdrawal or alteration of bid documents; making things easy for a particular bidder to win; other collusive conduct to secure a particular award). The consequences: the award is invalid (and with it the construction contract), with a fine of 0.5%-1.0% (5-10 per mille) of the awarded project amount, 5%-10% of that fine on responsible persons, and confiscation of unlawful gains; where the circumstances are serious (seeking the award by bribery, colluding twice or more within 3 years, causing direct loss of RMB 300,000 or more, etc.), disqualification from bidding for 1-2 years with announcement, and for recidivism or especially serious circumstances, revocation of the business licence; a bidder that did not win is fined on the contract amount of the tendered project.

Applicable Codes

  • 中华人民共和国招标投标法(主席令第86号,2017修正)第五十三条、第五十五条
  • 中华人民共和国招标投标法实施条例(国务院令第709号,2019修订)第四十一条、第六十七条
  • 工程建设项目施工招标投标办法(七部委第30号令)第八十六条
  • 中华人民共和国民法典第一百五十四条、第七百九十三条

Topic scope

The six statutory grounds of collusion between tenderer and bidder, the consequence of the invalid award, the scale and targets of the fines, the conditions for bidding disqualification and revocation of the business licence, and the quantitative thresholds of serious circumstances (including direct loss of RMB 300,000 or more).

Core conclusions

1. Grounds (original text of Article 41 of the Implementation Regulation under the Tendering and Bidding Law)

'Collusion between tenderer and bidder is prohibited. Any of the following circumstances constitutes collusion between tenderer and bidder: (1) the tenderer opens the bid documents before the bid opening and leaks the relevant information to other bidders; (2) the tenderer directly or indirectly leaks to a bidder the base price, the members of the tender evaluation committee or other such information; (3) the tenderer expressly or by implication directs a bidder to lower or raise its bid price; (4) the tenderer instigates a bidder to withdraw or alter its bid documents; (5) the tenderer expressly or by implication directs a bidder to make things easy for a particular bidder to win the award; (6) other collusive conduct by the tenderer and a bidder to secure the award to a particular bidder.' Item (6) is a catch-all clause; its substantive test is the subjective purpose of 'securing the award to a particular bidder' plus the corresponding objective conduct.

2. Civil consequence: the invalid award

Article 53 of the Tendering and Bidding Law, first part: 'Where bidders collude with one another or with the tenderer, or a bidder seeks the award by bribing the tenderer or members of the tender evaluation committee, the award is invalid'; Article 67(1) of the Implementation Regulation restates: 'Where bidders collude with one another or with the tenderer, or a bidder seeks the award by bribing the tenderer or members of the tender evaluation committee, the award is invalid; where a crime is constituted, criminal responsibility is pursued according to law; where no crime is constituted, punishment is imposed under Article 53 of the Tendering and Bidding Law.'

Invalidity of the award feeds into the evaluation of contract validity through item (3) of Article 1 of Interpretation (I) on construction contract disputes (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25): for works subject to mandatory tendering by law, an invalid award means an invalid construction contract. Where the collusion also harms the lawful rights of others, invalidity may independently be found under Article 154 of the Civil Code: 'a civil juristic act by which an actor and the counterparty maliciously collude to harm the lawful rights of others is void'.

3. Administrative liability (original text of Article 53 of the Tendering and Bidding Law)

'Where bidders collude with one another or with the tenderer, or a bidder seeks the award by bribing the tenderer or members of the tender evaluation committee, the award is invalid, and a fine of 0.5% to 1.0% (5 to 10 per mille) of the awarded project amount shall be imposed; the persons in charge who are directly responsible and the other persons directly responsible in the unit shall be fined 5% to 10% of the fine imposed on the unit; where unlawful gains exist, they shall be confiscated in addition; where the circumstances are serious, the bidder shall be disqualified for 1 to 2 years from bidding for projects subject to mandatory tendering by law and the disqualification shall be announced, until the administrative department for industry and commerce revokes its business licence; where a crime is constituted, criminal responsibility is pursued according to law. Losses caused to others shall be compensated according to law.'

Bottom-line rule for the fine base: the last sentence of Article 67(1) of the Implementation Regulation: 'where the bidder did not win the award, the fine on the unit shall be calculated on the contract amount of the tendered project at the rate prescribed by the Tendering and Bidding Law' - not winning does not mean no fine; the base changes to the contract amount of the tendered project, at 0.5%-1.0%.

4. Serious circumstances and revocation of the business licence (Article 67(2) and (3) of the Implementation Regulation)

Paragraph 2, original text: 'A bidder committing any of the following acts falls under the serious circumstances of Article 53 of the Tendering and Bidding Law, and the relevant administrative supervision department shall disqualify it for 1 to 2 years from bidding for projects subject to mandatory tendering by law: (1) seeking the award by bribery; (2) colluding in bidding twice or more within 3 years; (3) collusive bidding harming the lawful interests of the tenderer, other bidders, or the state, collectives or citizens, causing direct loss of RMB 300,000 or more; (4) other collusive bidding conduct of serious circumstances.' Paragraph 3, original text: 'Where a bidder, within 3 years from the day the enforcement period of the penalty under paragraph 2 expires, again commits one of the acts listed in that paragraph, or where collusive bidding or seeking the award by bribery is of especially serious circumstances, the administrative department for industry and commerce shall revoke its business licence.' That is: recidivism (re-offending within 3 years after expiry of the disqualification) or especially serious circumstances escalates to revocation of the business licence. Paragraph 4 adds: 'where other laws or administrative regulations provide otherwise for the punishment of collusive bidding-price conduct, those provisions apply.'

5. Follow-up treatment of the invalid award

Order No. 30 of the seven ministries and commissions, Article 86: 'Where a project subject by law to mandatory tendering for construction violates the law and the award is invalid, a new winning bidder shall be determined from the remaining bidders according to the statutory award conditions, or the tender shall be re-run according to law. Where the award is invalid, the letter of acceptance issued and the contract concluded have no legal binding force from the beginning, without prejudice to the validity of the clauses in the contract that independently exist on methods of dispute resolution.'

Where the contract is found invalid but the works pass taking-over, Article 793(1) of the Civil Code applies: 'the contractor may be compensated by reference to the agreement on the price of the works'; where taking-over is failed, the matter is handled according to whether repair achieves acceptance (repair costs borne by the contractor / the contractor has no right to price compensation), and the employer bears corresponding liability for losses from the substandard works to the extent of its fault.

6. Stacking of liabilities

The same act of collusion can produce three layers of consequence: (1) civil: the invalid award and the invalid contract, plus, under the last sentence of Article 53, 'losses caused to others shall be compensated according to law'; (2) administrative: fines (0.5%-1.0% on the unit, 5%-10% of the unit's fine on the responsible persons), confiscation of unlawful gains, disqualification for 1-2 years from bidding with announcement, revocation of the business licence; (3) criminal: where a crime is constituted, criminal responsibility is pursued according to law. Administrative liability is not extinguished by the contract being found invalid, nor is civil liability by an administrative penalty already suffered.

Boundaries of application

  • This card lists the six statutory grounds of collusion between tenderer and bidder; collusion among bidders, and the other circumstances deemed collusive bidding, are governed by other articles of the Implementation Regulation and are outside this card.
  • The fine percentages are computed on the 'awarded project amount'; only where the bidder did not win is the base switched to the 'contract amount of the tendered project'; the two must not be mixed.
  • Among the four criteria of serious circumstances, 'direct loss of RMB 300,000 or more' is the quantitative threshold and requires evidence of the amount of the loss; narrative description cannot substitute for it.
  • This card does not expand on the constitutive elements and sentencing of criminal offences, nor on findings of mitigation or aggravation within specific discretionary ranges.
  • Quality liability after invalidity of the contract, sharing of repair costs and computation of damages are handled under Articles 793 and 157 of the Civil Code.

Further reading

  • Tendering and Bidding Law of the PRC (Presidential Decree No. 86, 2017 revision), Articles 43, 53 and 55
  • Implementation Regulation under the Tendering and Bidding Law of the PRC (State Council Order No. 709, 2019 revision), Articles 41 and 67
  • Interpretation (I) of the Supreme People's Court on Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trial of Construction Contract Dispute Cases (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25), Article 1
  • Civil Code of the PRC, Articles 154 and 793
  • Measures for Tendering and Bidding in Construction Project Works (Order No. 30 of seven ministries and commissions), Article 86

Keywords

  • 串通投标
  • 招标投标法第五十三条
  • 实施条例第四十一条
  • 实施条例第六十七条
  • 中标无效
  • 情节严重
  • 取消投标资格
  • 罚款千分之五