Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-11-08

Checking order when pipe specifications on the drawings conflict with the BOQ description: the dimension figures on drawings govern and conflicts are clarified through drawing review; at pricing level, unit-rate contracts follow the bill of quantities and lump-sum contracts follow the contract drawings and specifications

The test runs on two levels. (1) Annotation level: dimensions on drawings are governed by the dimension figures and shall not be scaled directly off the drawing (GB/T 50001-2017 Clause 11.2.1); design documents must be qualified and valid, and survey briefings, design disclosure and drawing review must be carried out with records kept (GB 55032-2022 Clause 3.1.1). The review checks drawing validity, compliance of content with national technical codes, and coordination among disciplines and between general drawings and details -- a pipe bore contradiction must be clarified through the review and recorded, not resolved by unilateral choice. (2) Pricing level: for works under unit-rate contracts, where the contract drawings are inconsistent with the tender work-item BOQ during performance, the bill of quantities governs; under lump-sum contracts, where the contract drawings and specifications are inconsistent with the priced BOQ, the contract drawings and specifications govern (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 3.4.5). BOQ item descriptions must state specification, installation location, medium and the like item by item; one and the same pipe must not be listed twice under both DN and de designations.

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第3.4.5条、第2.0.27条、第8.2节
  • GB/T 50856-2024 通用安装工程工程量计算标准 第4.2.4条、App. K Table K.1.1
  • GB/T 50106-2010 建筑给水排水制图标准 第2.4.2条
  • GB/T 50114-2010 暖通空调制图标准 第4.5.7、4.5.8条
  • CJJ/T 78-2010 供热工程制图标准 第3.3.2条
  • GB 50235-2010 工业金属管道工程施工规范 第2.1节
  • GB/T 50297-2018 电力工程基本术语标准 第2.10.3、2.10.4条
  • GB/T 50001-2017 房屋建筑制图统一标准 第11.2.1条
  • GB 55032-2022 建筑与市政工程施工质量控制通用规范 第3.1.1条

Scope of the topic

Two conflicts recur in piping works: within-drawing conflicts (design notes say DN while detail drawings say De, or specifications differ between sheets) and drawing-to-BOQ conflicts (construction drawing specifications vs BOQ item descriptions). The former is a design-document calibre problem, settled by the drawing rules and review clarification; the latter is a pricing-basis problem, settled by the order of precedence attached to the contract type. The two must not be conflated -- first decide 'which document governs', then decide 'error liability and price adjustment'.

Core conclusions

1. Annotation level: dimension figures govern, review clarification is the procedure

  1. Taking dimensions from drawings (GB/T 50001-2017 Clause 11.2.1): 'dimensions on drawings shall be governed by the dimension figures and shall not be scaled directly from the drawing.' Pipe bores thus follow the annotated figures (DN25, de110 and the like) and must not be scaled by drawing proportion and converted.
  2. Precondition for design documents (GB 55032-2022 Clause 3.1.1): 'the construction drawings and other relevant design documents used in a project shall be qualified and valid. Before construction, survey briefings, design disclosure and drawing review shall be carried out, and records shall be kept.' The commentary cites Article 30 of the Regulations on the Administration of Construction Survey and Design (2017): the survey and design entity shall before construction explain the design intent to the contractor and the supervising entity, interpret the design documents, and promptly resolve survey and design problems arising in construction; the contractor may ask the survey and design entity to clarify doubts.
  3. Specific review checklist (DB11/T 1745-2020 Clause 5.1.1): before the drawing review the project technical director shall organise technical, quality, production, safety, materials, commercial and subcontractor personnel to examine the drawings, consolidate them by discipline and report to the employer. The review covers: confirming drawing validity (whether the mandatory review stamp is affixed; whether unstamped sets carry the 'this set matches the reviewed set' stamp plus the employer's corporate seal); whether the drawings are complete and whether title blocks, scales, overall dimensions and setting-out data are complete and accurate; whether the construction drawing content complies with the relevant national technical codes and standards; whether the methods and requirements for the main sub-divisional and elemental works are clear, code-compliant and suited to the works; coordination among disciplines, sub-divisions and elemental works and between general drawings and details; whether key locations and critical links of works involving significant hazards, major construction processes and workmanship requirements for structural safety, and new technology applications are annotated; and whether restricted or banned building materials are used. A pipe bore contradiction falls squarely under the 'coordination between general drawings and details' item: the path is a written request for clarification, a review record, and the designer's reply as the final calibre -- not a cost engineer choosing unilaterally and pricing straight away.

2. Pricing level: the order of precedence forks by contract type (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 3.4.5)

Key points of the clause: for works under a unit-rate contract, the contract total price shall include all costs needed to complete the BOQ of the contract works as the tender documents require; where the work-item BOQ contains errors, the contract price shall be adjusted per Section 8.2; the priced BOQ forms part of the contract documents and its unit rates may be used in pricing contract price adjustments, but work-item and preliminary sections priced per item follow the lump-sum contract provisions. 'Where, during performance of a unit-rate contract, the contract drawings are inconsistent with the tender work-item BOQ, the bill of quantities governs; where, during performance of a lump-sum contract, the contract drawings and contract specifications are inconsistent with the priced BOQ, the contract drawings and contract specifications govern.' Practical meaning: under a unit-rate contract, a drawing-to-BOQ calibre mismatch is priced per the BOQ, and the employer then bears the adjustment liability for the BOQ error; under a lump-sum contract the contract drawings and specifications govern instead, so the calibre risk sits with the contractor. Contradictions between tender documents and drawings found at tender stage should be raised for clarification within the statutory time limit.

3. Consistency within the BOQ: one calibre per pipe

GB/T 50856-2024 Appendix K (water supply, drainage, heating and gas piping, code 031001), Table K.1.1, sets out the pipe item structure, item description content, units of measurement and measurement rules. Its explanatory notes require the installation location of every pipe to be described as indoor or outdoor; the medium of every pipe to be described as water supply, drainage, reclaimed water, rainwater, heat-transfer medium, gas, air-conditioning water and the like; cast-iron pipe specifications to cover socket-and-spigot cast iron, ductile iron and flexible anti-seismic cast iron; composite pipes to cover plastic-aluminium stabilised, steel-plastic composite, aluminium-plastic composite and steel-framework composite pipes; and plastic pipes to cover UPVC, CPVC, PVC, PP-C, PP-R, PE, PB, ABS and the like. Item descriptions should therefore be written as a full set of 'material + specification + connection type + installation location + medium', with one bore designation used consistently across the schedule (convert all to DN, or annotate de throughout) -- otherwise one pipe is listed twice under 'DN100' and 'de110' and measured twice.

Applicable boundaries

  • This card settles 'which document to check against' and 'who bears the calibre mismatch'; the quantity and price adjustment once an error is established follows the dedicated BOQ-error rules (the 15% band and the like), not covered here.
  • The unit-rate rule that the BOQ governs presupposes that the BOQ is the tender work-item BOQ; work-item and preliminary sections priced per item follow the lump-sum calibre.
  • The lump-sum rule that the contract drawings and specifications govern yields to contrary agreement on items such as provisional quantities.
  • The rule that dimension figures govern resolves only in-drawing values and cannot replace the design change or clarification procedure; conversions made without designer confirmation cannot serve as a basis for settlement.
  • The review checklist items come from a local construction technology management regulation; other regions follow their own equivalent review requirements.
  • Unifying the specification calibre does not change the binding between pipe designation and material (steel pipe DN, plastic pipe dn/De); conversions must keep a documented basis.

Further reading

  • GB/T 50500-2024, Standard for BOQ-based Pricing of Construction Works: Clause 3.4.5 (order of precedence between drawings and BOQ under unit-rate and lump-sum contracts); Section 8.2 (contract price adjustment for BOQ errors).
  • GB/T 50856-2024, Standard for Measurement of General Installation Works: Appendix K Table K.1.1 (water supply, drainage, heating and gas piping, code 031001) and the K.9.6 explanatory notes.
  • GB 55032-2022, General Code for Quality Control of Building and Municipal Construction: Clause 3.1.1 (valid design documents, disclosure and review) and its commentary citing Article 30 of the Regulations on the Administration of Construction Survey and Design (2017).
  • GB/T 50001-2017, Unified Standard for Building Drawings: Clause 11.2.1 (dimensions governed by figures).
  • DB11/T 1745-2020, Regulation for Construction Technology Management of Building Works: Clause 5.1.1 (organisation and content of drawing review).

Keywords