Mandatory review checklist for final account review deliverables (T/ZBD 100.5-2023 clause 5.0.11, 14 items)
Final account review deliverable review follows T/ZBD 100.5-2023 5.0.11's 14 mandatory checks: three-way check of the compilation scope (contract documents, software, explanatory notes of the estimate); lump-sum items within the preliminaries priced per the contract, with the mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions calculated per state or provincial/sectoral construction-authority rules; order-of-magnitude quantity errors or mismatches and unitless bill items; Excel calculation/link errors; complete valid signatures on documents forming the basis for settlement; deduction of provisional sums and dayworks; rate build-up for new items complying with the contractual quota norms (prescribed resource consumption standards) pricing rules and every sub-item price determined; reasonableness of material prices in new rate build-ups; contractual de-minimis thresholds below which technical changes are not counted; cross-deductions verified; claims carrying taxes and duties only (VAT under the current standard; management fee and profit not charged, subject to contract); consistency of report, tables and software data and letter case; other-items review principles; other issues. Review requires self-review and cross-review record sheets per Tables 5.0.10-1/5.0.10-2.
Applicable Codes
- T/ZBD 100.5-2023 建设工程结算审核作业指引
Topic Positioning
The mandatory checklist (T/ZBD 100.5-2023 "Guidelines for Final Account Review Practice" clause 5.0.11, 14 items) for the "deliverable review and quality management" step of final account review — usable directly as a quality-control checklist, complementing cards on quantity anomaly identification and budget completeness review.
Core Conclusions
Final account review may be performed by project-department staff or the company's technical-quality department; the project leader assigns reviewers for each discipline per company rules and project organization; each discipline reviewer fully reviews the quality of that discipline's deliverables, feeds issues back to the preparer for correction, and completes self-review and cross-review record sheets per Tables 5.0.10-1 and 5.0.10-2. The 14 main review items:
- Whether the compilation scope matches the work brief and the contractor's submitted settlement scope — obvious omissions or extras — through a three-way check (contract documents, software, explanatory notes of the estimate).
- Lump-sum items within the preliminaries shall strictly follow the contractually agreed pricing method; if adjusted, calculate per the amounts confirmed by both parties; the mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions must be calculated per the provisions of the state or provincial/sectoral construction authorities.
- Whether there are order-of-magnitude quantity errors or mismatches; whether there are unitless bill items.
- Whether there are calculation errors or link errors in Excel.
- Whether all documents forming the basis for settlement are completely and validly signed when the construction payment settlement report is issued.
- Whether provisional sums and dayworks in other items are deducted.
- Whether the rate build-up for each new bill item complies with the contractual quota norms (prescribed resource consumption standards) pricing rules; whether the price of every sub-item has been determined.
- Whether the same material prices in new rate build-ups are reasonable.
- Whether the contract provides that technical changes below a certain amount are not counted.
- Whether cross-deductions have been verified.
- Whether claims are charged taxes and duties only (VAT under the current standard); note that management fee and profit should not be charged (subject to contract).
- Whether the report, tables and software data are consistent, and whether letter case is consistent.
- Other-items review principles: whether dayworks are calculated on the basis of matters actually confirmed by the employer's site instructions / variation records; whether provisional sums for specified materials / nominated works are measured and priced by the employer and contractor in accordance with the relevant provisions of the current BOQ pricing standard; the main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions shall be calculated on the basis of the amount agreed in the contract, and if adjusted, calculated on the amount confirmed by both parties; provisional sums at settlement shall be calculated after deducting the amount of contract price adjustments (including claims and site instructions / variation records), and any balance belongs to the employer.
- Other possible problems or errors.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to final account review deliverable review per T/ZBD 100.5-2023; this checklist is a mandatory item for internal quality management of final account review and does not replace the construction payment settlement verification procedure between the employer and contractor. Item 11 "claims are charged taxes and duties only" is subject to contract — where the contract provides otherwise, that provision prevails. Specific amounts and calculation rules for bill items remain subject to the current BOQ pricing standard and contract; this card does not set out specific quantity anomaly identification methods (see referenced card).
Further Reading
See T/ZBD 100.5-2023 "Guidelines for Final Account Review Practice" clause 5.0.11 (deliverable review and quality management) and Tables 5.0.10-1/5.0.10-2 (self-review and cross-review record sheets); together with clause 3.2.3 (priority review of high-volume, high-value items such as foundations, walls, columns, doors and windows, and reinforced-concrete beams and slabs); for screening methods for quantity order-of-magnitude errors/unitless bill items see the "Method for Identifying Abnormal Quantities in Bills of Quantities" card; for closed-loop verification of the all-in unit rate cost composition see DB37/T 5161-2020 clause 5.2.3 (Price = Labor + Material + Machine + Overhead + Profit).
Keywords
- final account review
- 成果复核
- 复核清单
- 自审互审
- 三核对
- 审核记录单
- 数量级错误
- 无单位清单