Rapid completeness review of a budget document: four-layer quick check — document set integrity, scope consistency, inter-table cross-checks, and content elements
Review budget completeness with a four-layer quick check: ① document set integrity — tick off per the industry depth-of-preparation provisions (cover, signature page, contents, explanatory notes of the estimate, summary budget table, discipline summary tables, unit-work budget tables, other-cost tables and appendices); one missing item means incomplete, with the explanatory notes the most frequently missing; ② scope consistency — the "three-way check" of contract documents, software, and explanatory notes to find omissions and over-inclusions; ③ inter-table cross-checks — upper and lower summary levels equal, cost chains closed, sampled unit rate × quantity = amount, figures in words and numerals consistent; ④ content elements — no empty-price/zero-price items, no unitless list entries, quantity magnitudes reasonable, mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions accrued as prescribed, comparison against the approved preliminary estimate, and unit-cost indicator benchmarking. Suspicious parts are then confirmed item by item with the five audit methods.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 51095-2015 建设工程造价咨询规范
- T/ZBD 100.5-2023 建设工程结算审核作业指引
- DL/T 5591-2021 20kV及以下配电网工程建设预算编制导则
- T/CBDA 77-2023 建筑装饰装修工程设计-采购-施工管理标准
- DL/T 5569-2020 配电网施工图设计文件内容深度规定
Topic Positioning
This card covers how to quickly review the completeness of a construction-drawing based budget (pre-tender estimate): instead of recomputing item by item, complete the first screening through the four layers "document set integrity → preparation-scope consistency → inter-table cross-checks → content elements", then focus rechecks on suspicious spots.
Core Conclusions
Four-layer quick check: ① Document set integrity — tick off per the industry depth-of-preparation provisions: cover, title/signature page, contents, explanatory notes of the estimate, summary budget table, discipline summary tables, unit-work budget tables, other-cost tables, appendices and attachments; one missing item means incomplete, and the explanatory notes are the most frequently missing. ② Scope consistency — perform the "three-way check": contract documents, software, and explanatory notes, verifying that the budgeted scope matches the commission/briefing and detecting obvious omissions or over-inclusions. ③ Inter-table cross-checks — total budget = Σ discipline summaries = Σ unit works; work-sections + preliminaries + other items + statutory levies and fees + taxes and duties = total cost; sample that unit rate × quantity = amount (guarding against Excel formula/link errors); amounts in words and numerals consistent across cover, summary table, and explanatory notes. ④ Content elements — no empty-price/zero-price items, no unitless list entries; quantity magnitudes reasonable; mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions accrued as a non-competitive item per regulations; the construction-drawing based budget should stay within the approved preliminary estimate with consistent scope; unit-cost indicators benchmarked against similar projects, with large deviations explained.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to completeness screening and review of construction-drawing based budgets and design estimates (approved cost ceiling); the scope-consistency and cross-check layers make a good ~ten-minute first pass, followed by comprehensive audit of anomalous parts. Budget document compositions differ slightly by industry (e.g., electric power distribution networks and heritage buildings have their own provisions) — follow the depth-of-preparation provisions of the project's industry. This card is positioned as "quick screening + locating suspicion"; suspicious items still require item-by-item confirmation by the comprehensive audit or key-point sampling methods; final account reviews and tender-list audits have different emphases — see the related cards.
Further Reading
Five audit methods and audit priorities: GB/T 51095-2015 Clauses 5.1.5 and 5.3.8 (all-in unit rate covering labour/materials/machinery, management fee, profit, statutory levies and fees, taxes and duties); review checklist: T/ZBD 100.5-2023 Clause 5.0.11 (three-way check, preliminaries, claim accrual, etc.); budget document table composition: DL/T 5591-2021 Clause 3.3.3, DL/T 5569-2020 Clause 7.0.2; preparation and review requirements: T/CBDA 77-2023 Clause 9.4.3; heritage building budget composition: DB11/T 1597-2018 Clause 6.4.4.
Keywords
- 预算书完整性
- 预算复核
- 施工图预算审核
- 文件成套性
- 表间勾稽
- 三核对
- 预算书组成
- explanatory notes of the estimate