Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-09-25

Second review of AI-generated cost (profit-loss) analysis: four gates — input authenticity, quantity-price decomposition, cross-period caliber, and traceable conclusions

AI-generated cost analysis is only a drafting aid; second review passes four gates: (1) input authenticity — all data must point back to real ledgers (requisition slips, payroll, shift records, measurement sign-offs); figures of unknown origin are treated as fabricated; (2) quantity-price decomposition — labor/materials/machinery/subcontracting each split into quantity variance + price variance, not just total differences; (3) cross-period caliber — check cost-rate jumps, month-end concentrated booking, broken three-synchronization (physical progress / output-value statistics / cost aggregation must synchronize); cost accounting on the accrual basis with actual costs; (4) traceable conclusions — every conclusion must point back to its data source, with a written monthly cost-analysis report.

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 50326-2017 建设工程项目管理规范
  • GB/T 50358-2017 建设项目工程总承包管理规范
  • T/ZSQX 023-2023 城镇给排水项目工程总承包管理规程
  • RISN-TG 012-2011 建设工程项目经理执业导则

Topic Positioning

A second-review method for AI-generated project cost (profit-loss) analysis: treat AI output as a "compilation-aid draft", review it by human-review rules, then add four AI-specific checks — input authenticity, quantity-price decomposition, cross-period caliber, and traceable conclusions. It belongs to the AI-deliverable second-review series alongside AI budget review and AI scheme review.

Core Conclusions

(1) Input authenticity: the credibility of cost-analysis conclusions depends on inputs; all data must come from real ledgers (requisition slips, payroll, shift records, measurement sign-offs, price-confirmation slips); figures of unknown origin are treated as fabricated. (2) Quantity-price decomposition: labor/materials/machinery/subcontracting each split into quantity variance + price variance; conclusions giving only total differences are unacceptable (T/ZSQX 023-2023, Clause 14.4.2 analyzes savings/overruns from both price and quantity sides). (3) Cross-period and caliber: check V-shaped cost-rate jumps, month-end concentrated booking, and broken three-synchronization — physical progress, output-value statistics, and cost aggregation must synchronize (GB/T 50326-2017, Clause 11.4.3); cost accounting follows the accrual basis with actual costs; planned/estimated/quota costs must not substitute. (4) Traceable conclusions: every conclusion must point to specific data sources and calculation paths, not "derived from comprehensive analysis"; form a written cost-analysis report monthly or by construction milestone (RISN-TG 012-2011, Clause 8.3.2), based on cost plans, accounting records, and accounting/statistical/business data (GB/T 50326-2017, Clause 11.5.1).

Applicable Boundaries

Applies to reviewing AI-assisted project cost/profit-loss analysis; it does not replace dedicated review methods such as quick budget-completeness checks, AI budget misapplication prevention, or construction-scheme sign-off, and should be executed alongside them. Scenarios involving employer-supplied material consumption and quality-price confirmation disputes are handled separately under judicial-appraisal and settlement-review rules.

Further Reading

Cost-management chapter: GB/T 50326-2017 Clause 11.3.2 (cost-control procedure), Clauses 11.4.2~11.4.3 (cost accounting), Clause 11.5.1 (analysis basis); GB/T 50358-2017 Clause 12.4.3 (cost control check-compare-analyze-correct); RISN-TG 012-2011 Clauses 8.3.2, 8.4.1; T/ZSQX 023-2023 Clause 14.4.2 (six-category analysis of labor/materials/machinery/equipment/commissioning/indirect costs); accrual basis in "Accounting Standards for Enterprises" and Guo Fa [1984] No. 34 Article 17 (actual-cost accounting).

Keywords

  • AI成本分析审查
  • 成本分析二次审查
  • 盈亏分析
  • cost accounting
  • 量价拆解
  • 三同步
  • AI幻觉
  • 成本分析