Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-09-25

Audit of pricing by applying quota line items: identifying over-application, misapplication, and duplicate application via the three-way comparison

Identify problems of pricing by applying quota line items using the "three-way comparison": actual works (drawings / construction method statement) ↔ the work content of the quota line item ↔ the quota chapter notes and calculation rules. For over-application, check specifications, machinery, process, haul/height brackets, and unsupported coefficients; for misapplication, check cross-volume applications, wrong pairings, unsupported borrowings (missing items require supplementary unit-rate build-up schedules), conversions lacking the "换" (converted) mark, and superseded versions; for duplicate application, check work-content coverage (cast-in-place concrete already includes formwork, etc.), line-item splitting, and double-counted preliminaries. Rank items by amount to lock high-value items for focused audit.

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 51095-2015 建设工程造价咨询规范
  • DL/T 5468-2013 输变电工程施工图预算编制导则
  • DBJ51/T 048-2015 四川省建设工程造价电子数据标准
  • GB 50861-2013 城市轨道交通工程工程量计算规范
  • DB14/T 1319-2021 公路工程标准工程量清单及计量规范
  • TB/T 10831-2024 铁路工程预算定额 房屋工程
  • DB11/T 638-2016 房屋修缮工程工程量计算规范
  • 关于审查建设工程预算管理暂行办法

Topic Positioning

How to identify the three problem classes of quota item application — over-application (pricing high), misapplication, and duplicate application — in budget / estimate / settlement audits, giving the overall method and type-by-type identification points, highly operable.

Core Conclusions

The overall method is the "three-way comparison": compare against the actual works (drawings / design notes / construction scheme) → against the quota item work content → against the quota chapter notes and calculation rules; application is correct only when all three agree (Interim Measures on the Administration of Budget Review of Construction Works, Article 13; GB/T 51095-2015 Clause 5.1.5).

  1. Over-application (rounding up): check specification upgrades (C25 priced as C30), machinery upgrades (small machines priced as large), process/soil upgrades (ordinary soil as rock, ordinary plaster as premium), haul/height brackets taken at the top, and unsupported coefficients (e.g., the height-increase fee is keyed to work points above 25 m — not accruable below that, DB11/T 638-2016). Countermeasure: for high-value items, read back each item name + work content + technical conditions against the drawings one by one.
  2. Misapplication (wrong pairing): check cross-volume misapplication (installation items priced from building volumes), item names not matching members, improper borrowing (for missing quota items a supplementary unit valuation table must be prepared per the budget quota compilation principles, GB/T 51095-2015 Clause 5.3.12; borrowing from another volume requires a basis, disclosure in the preparation notes, and fee accrual per the borrowed volume, DL/T 5468-2013 Clauses 4.1.4/4.1.12), conversion errors (conversions must follow the quota notes; the converted code gains the suffix "换" with the conversion described, DBJ51/T 048-2015 Clause 6.5.6 — a base price changed without the "换" mark is always a problem), and application of superseded versions.
  3. Duplicate application: check work-content coverage (cast-in-place concrete already includes formwork, GB 50861-2013 Clause 4.2.7; the quota already covers on-site transport, small material handling, incidental labor, DB63/T 2006-2021), item-splitting duplication (external scaffolding already aggregates ramps and loading platforms, TB/T 10831-2024), measure-fee duplication (costs already priced via separate list items must not be recomputed, DB14/T 1319-2021 Clause 4.4), and overlaps between work-sections and measures.

Applicable Boundaries

Applies to budget, estimate, and settlement audits under the quota-pricing mode. Under the BOQ pricing mode, missing/wrong/duplicate items are screened separately per the GB/T 50500 series; volume divisions, item contents, and notes differ across industries (railway, power, building, highway) — the current local quota volume notes of the project govern the specific criteria.

Further Reading

GB/T 51095-2015 Clause 5.1.5 (audit methods) and Clauses 5.3.8–5.3.12 (work-section cost composition and supplementary unit valuation tables); DL/T 5468-2013 Clauses 4.1.4, 4.1.12; DBJ51/T 048-2015 Clause 6.5.6 (conversion marking); GB 50861-2013 Clause 4.2.7; DB14/T 1319-2021 Clause 4.4; TB/T 10831-2024 building works volume notes.

Keywords

Cited By