Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-25

Comparative review of the all-in unit rate of one BOQ item under two construction methods: the three-identity sameness test, quantity-price separated line-by-line comparison sheets, attribution on unit output (machine-shift consumption), build-up compliance anchors, method-price consistency checks, and detection of unbalanced rates

First run the three-identity test (BOQ code + item description + unit of measurement) to confirm it is the same BOQ item; if not, price under the GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.9.1 variation valuation rules. Then attribute the rate gap line by line, quantity separated from price, to consumption and price gaps in labour, materials and plant and to overhead and profit rate gaps; plant cost must be reduced to unit output (machine-shift rate x machine-shift consumption per unit of quantity), not compared on machine-shift rates alone, and machine models and shifts must also close against the plant allocation in the method. Compliance anchors: the analysis sheet fully consistent with the priced BOQ rate (clause 3.1.7), not below cost and not above the tender price ceiling (clause 6.1.3), deviation from the evaluation benchmark price (DB37/T 5161-2020 clause 5.3.4). The standards set no uniform deviation-percentage threshold; judging 'unreasonably low or high' and any magnitude threshold must be agreed in the tender documents and evaluation rules.

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第3.1.7条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第3.5.2条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第3.5.3条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第3.5.4条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第6.1.2、6.1.3、6.1.5、6.2.6条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第8.9.1条
  • GB/T 51095-2015 · Code for construction cost consultation 第5.3.9条及App. C
  • GB/T 51095-2015 第6.3.2条
  • DB37/T 5161-2020《建设工程造价数据交换及应用标准》第5.2.3、5.2.6、5.3.4条及第5章
  • DB37/T 5130-2018《建设工程造价咨询服务规范》第6.7.2条
  • DBJ/T 15-153-2019《广东省建设项目全过程造价管理规范》第6.10.3条
  • T/HAEC 011-2024《工程监理资料管理标准化与信息化工作指南(铁路工程)》第9.13.3条

Scope and purpose

An operable three-layer review framework for reviewing the all-in unit rate difference of one BOQ item under two construction methods (or two bids): comparability test, then quantity-price separated line-by-line attribution, then build-up compliance and unbalanced-rate judgment. It suits tender review (qingbiao), method cost comparisons, bid price verification, and rate-level checks before variation valuation.

Core conclusions

1. Comparability first: the three-identity test for the same BOQ item

Before comparing, check that the item code, item description and unit of measurement (quantity checked alongside) are all identical. If any differs (pile diameter, haul distance, retention form, concrete strength class), it is not the same BOQ item, the rates must not be compared directly, and the rate is fixed under GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.9.1:

For works on unit-rate contracts, where variation or BOQ errors change the BOQ items (additions or deletions), or where BOQ quantities change by up to 15% (15% inclusive), the employer and contractor shall, on the varied quantities confirmed under sections 7.1, 7.2 and 7.4, fix all-in unit rates and adjust the contract price as follows: 1 BOQ items with the same item description under the same construction conditions shall adopt the corresponding contract rate; 2 items with similar item descriptions under the same conditions, or the same item description under similar conditions, shall adopt the all-in unit rate converted and adjusted from the contract rate of a similar BOQ item; 3 items with different item descriptions under the same conditions, or the same item description under different conditions, may be priced by negotiating a market-reasonable all-in unit rate with reference to the contract-rate pricing rules of similar items and the bid level; 4 items with different item descriptions under different conditions may be priced by negotiating with reference to the all-in unit rates of similar BOQ items in comparable works; 5 where variation by deleting or cancelling items materially changes the construction conditions, the varied rate may be negotiated per the actual circumstances, market prices, the contract-rate pricing rules and the bid level.

The clause also gives two classes of price-influencing factors: item-description side - material changes, construction method changes, effects on other divisional and sub-divisional items, other description changes; construction-condition side - foundations, working heights, member sizes (steel structures), construction season, protection of completed works in finished areas, site access restrictions, material transport modes, plant usage, coordination fees within the main contractor's attendance provisions (specialist subcontract quantity changes), other condition changes.

2. Three review layers not to be conflated

Layer What is compared The question answered Judgment anchor
L1 method difference Method A build-up vs Method B build-up Can the rate gap be explained by construction method, plant allocation and preliminaries differences Reasonable if the difference is explainable
L2 within-method compliance Each method itself: quota line items, labour-material-plant, charges Any over-application, mis-application, omissions, double counting, unfounded conversions Budget quota manuals and companion on-costs / charging standards
L3 pricing strategy Rate vs evaluation benchmark price / tender price ceiling / cost Unbalanced rates? below cost? Tender document criteria, the contractor's own cost

3. Item-by-item comparison on the analysis sheet (formats)

Table A, item-level overview (sets review priority first)

BOQ code Item name / description Unit Quantity Method A all-in rate Method B all-in rate Difference Deviation d = (P_A - P_B) / P_B Price weight Main driver
Rank by d x price weight, largest first; do not spread effort evenly.
Table B, line-by-line rate comparison (the quantity-price separation core sheet)
Level Element name / spec Unit Q_A consumption P_A price A amount Q_B consumption P_B price B amount Quantity effect P_B x (Q_A - Q_B)
--- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- --- ---
Fixed row order: labour (unskilled/skilled, subtotal), materials (principal, auxiliary, amortised consumables), plant (principal machine-shifts, other plant cost), overheads (charging base x percentage rate), profit (charging base x percentage rate), total all-in rate; the overheads and profit rows carry no consumption - compare percentage rates and charging bases only.
Decomposition (cross term isolated, so quantity and price do not bleed into each other):
dP = Sum[P_B,i x (Q_A,i - Q_B,i)] + Sum[Q_B,i x (P_A,i - P_B,i)] + Sum[(Q_A,i - Q_B,i) x (P_A,i - P_B,i)]
Reading: quantity-driven with small price gaps points to method/process/plant allocation differences; price-driven with small quantity gaps points to price-source differences (published price information, market enquiry, provisional prices, brand tiers); overhead/profit rate gaps point to charging-standard or charging-base differences (local on-cost norms, company charging). Items with provisional material prices carry a separate provisional-price row at the tender BOQ value.
Plant cost must never be compared on machine-shift rates alone: the plant row must land on unit output - plant cost per unit of quantity = machine-shift rate x machine-shift consumption per unit of quantity. Similar shift rates but divergent unit cost means the gap is in shift consumption (machine count, efficiency, duty fit); identical shift consumption but divergent cost means the problem is the shift-rate source (depreciation vs rental basis, fuel and power prices, labour-plant double charging). Shift rates alone miss findings; total plant cost alone loses attribution; read the two in pairs.

4. Build-up compliance anchors (layer L2)

  1. The analysis sheet and the BOQ rate must be fully consistent (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 3.1.7):

The all-in unit rate analysis sheet shall make clear the cost make-up calculation method of each BOQ item's all-in unit rate and of each lump-priced item's price, and those rates and prices shall be completely consistent with the corresponding BOQ item all-in unit rates and prices in the bill of quantities ...

  1. Build-up principle and pricing basis (GB/T 51095-2015 clause 5.3.9):

The all-in unit rate of each line item may be determined through the budget quota manuals and their companion on-cost norms. Labour, material and plant costs rest on the labour-material-plant consumptions of the corresponding budget quota line items and on market prices of the reporting period; overheads, profit, statutory levies and taxes rest on the companion on-cost norms or charging standards and on the actual circumstances and market levels of the proposed project in the reporting period. An all-in unit rate analysis sheet shall be compiled together with the building works budget. This clause fixes the build-up principle of the all-in unit rate; the concrete build-up format may follow the all-in unit rate analysis sheet in Appendix C.

  1. Closure check of the rate cost make-up (DB37/T 5161-2020 clause 5.2.3 for divisional items, clause 5.2.6 for unit-rate preliminaries items, same calculation rule):

The all-in unit rate of each divisional BOQ item must equal the sum of its component elements. If not equal, flag it red, compute the deviation and describe it in the status column. Calculation rule: Price = Labor + Material + Machine + Overhead + Profit.

  1. Correction direction when the sheet and the BOQ disagree (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 3.5.2 item 5): where the all-in unit rate of a rate-priced BOQ item entered by a bidder differs from the rate in its analysis sheet, or the price of a lump-priced BOQ item differs from its make-up detail sheet, the rate and (or) price in the priced BOQ governs and the sheet is corrected. (The same clause also provides: words and figures differ - the amount in words governs; lump total vs accumulated BOQ prices inconsistent - the tender total governs, the accumulation corrected; provisional sums, specialist-works provisional prices and provisional material prices vs the tender BOQ - the tender BOQ values govern; item price vs quantity x all-in unit rate - the rate governs, the price corrected, except where item price / quantity reproduces the rate of the same BOQ item, or the rate has an obvious decimal-point error or is obviously unreasonable - then the item price governs, the rate corrected; the total error is spread over the item rates and prices in proportion over the divisional BOQ total (provisional-material-price items excluded), provisional material prices inside the rates staying at tender BOQ values; VAT is corrected by the tax rate on the corrected arithmetic totals. None of these corrections adjusts the tender total.)

5. Reasonableness anchors (layer L3) and deviation thresholds

  • Price band limits (clause 6.1.3): a bid must not be below cost nor above the published tender price ceiling; the cost of the works may reasonably be fixed by reference to comparable projects.
  • Clarification triggers for comparability/reasonableness doubts (clause 3.5.3):

1 the all-in unit rate of a BOQ item with provisional material prices is unreasonably low or high against the rate of a similar BOQ item; 2 the all-in unit rate of an item where the contractor installs employer-supplied (free-issue) materials is unreasonably high or low; 3 the all-in unit rate of a divisional BOQ item is unreasonably low or high against contemporaneous market-competitive prices of the same class of works - the bidder may be required to show its rate is not below cost or the price reasonable; and, without changing the tender total, to provide corrected reasonable rates for quantity-change pricing and variation pricing, submitted per clause 3.5.1 item 1 to the evaluation (or award) committee for reference.

  • Deviation calculation basis (DB37/T 5161-2020 clause 5.3.4): the divisional BOQ shall state item code, name, description, unit, quantity, all-in unit rate and benchmark price (per the evaluation rules), and the deviation and deviation ratio of each item's rate against the benchmark price computed separately.
  • Handling of threshold values: the current standards fix only the algorithmic basis of 'unreasonably low/high' and of the deviation ratio, not a uniform deviation-percentage threshold; concrete thresholds must be pre-agreed in the tender documents, evaluation rules or unbalanced-rate criteria; absent agreement, deviation only ranks suspicions and cannot by itself support a negative conclusion.
  • Responsibility boundary (clause 6.1.2): bidders price autonomously under section 6.2 and answer for the consistency and reasonableness of the prices in the priced BOQ, bearing the risks of unreasonable pricing and of BOQ errors under lump-sum contracts.

6. Checks that the construction method and the price agree

  1. The method is a pricing basis, not a post-hoc explanation (clause 6.2.6): bidders shall price the preliminaries BOQ autonomously on their own implementation method for the works, the tender period and the preliminaries items drawn up under clause 6.1.5, with the statutory safety provisions complying with state, provincial and sector rules. The preliminaries pricing shall satisfy the price effects of: (1) the character of the tendered works, lot divisions and completion handover standard; (2) ground conditions, neighbouring buildings, site facilities, surrounding roads, traffic, hydrology, environment; (3) the contract duties stated in the tender documents; (4) the contractor risks fixed in the tender documents; (5) goods supply of employer-provided materials, specialist subcontract works, and main contractor's management and attendance services for directly let specialist works (main-contract tendering only); (6) apart from preliminaries adjustments caused by variation, works within provisional sums not fully foreseeable, additional works and claims under chapter 8, the contractor risk from lump-sum preliminaries pricing.
  2. Completeness and accuracy of the preliminaries BOQ rest with the bidder (clause 6.1.5): bidders shall, within the stated time after receiving the tender documents, re-examine the completeness and fit of the listed preliminaries items from the character of the works, the contract requirements and the site walkover; queries or objections may be raised in writing for clarification or correction, additions listed and priced; under both unit-rate and lump-sum contracts the completeness and accuracy of the preliminaries BOQ rest with the bidder, who bears the risk of its pricing reasonableness.
  3. Machine model and machine-shift cross-check: machine names, models, specs and shift counts in the plant rows must trace to the method's plant allocation table and construction programme (shift count = machine count x working days x shifts per day x utilisation) and must not double count against the preliminaries (large plant entry/exit and erection/dismantling, vertical transport). Four checks: do the models match the method; unit-output shift consumption vs the quota shift contents and the reasons; the same machine charged both in divisional plant cost and the preliminaries; standby/auxiliary machines in the method inflated.
  4. Preliminaries pricing versus the construction method (DB37/T 5130-2018 clause 6.7.2): (1) are the tender document requirements met and assured; (2) do the preliminaries content and price agree with the construction method and process technology.
  5. The same closure check during performance (T/HAEC 011-2024 clause 9.13.3.2 item a): the number, models, specs, capacity and serviceability of plant mobilised to site (including planned mobilisations) shall match the contractor's bid - a later verification that 'price, method and site' close in three points.

7. Detecting and correcting unbalanced rates

  • Tender review work content (GB/T 51095-2015 clause 6.3.2; DB37/T 5130-2018 clause 6.7.2 the same): (1) substantive response to the tender documents; (2) error and omission analysis; (3) reasonableness analysis of divisional BOQ item all-in unit rates; (4) completeness and reasonableness analysis of the preliminaries BOQ and correctness analysis of its non-competitive costs; (5) completeness and reasonableness analysis of the other items BOQ; (6) unbalanced rate analysis; (7) correctness verification of provisional sums and provisional prices; (8) arithmetic verification of totals and item prices with correction proposals; (9) other matters needing analysis and clarification.
  • Four technical instruments of tender review (DB37/T 5161-2020 chapter 5): compliance check (comparison against the tender documents, consolidating inconsistencies), computational check (logic analysis, flagging arithmetic errors), reasonableness check (horizontal comparison against benchmark prices, listing high and low prices), similarity analysis (statistical consistency of BOQ build-up results across bids), producing the tender review report; similarity analysis is the supplementary dimension for spotting 'same-source pricing / cover bidding'.
  • Criteria must be fixed in advance (DBJ/T 15-153-2019 clause 6.10.3): the criteria for judging unbalanced rates and the adjustment methods must be stated in the tender documents so bidders know them in advance; the scope where adjusted rates apply must be fixed in the tender and contract documents. Adjusted rates serve mainly two uses: the whole project, or only works outside the contract BOQ.
  • Effect of corrected rates (clause 3.5.4): corrected rates and prices from tender-stage clarification may be applied to pricing during performance, but do not materially change the tender total.

Applicability limits

  1. Align the bases before comparing: the two all-in unit rates must share one basis - the same cost scope (a partly inclusive rate excluding statutory levies and taxes must not be netted against a fully inclusive one), the same price base period (levelled first by price indices or published price information), the same VAT treatment. Comparing before alignment invalidates every deviation ratio.
  2. Compare unit output, not machine-shift rates: plant and labour differences must be reduced to per-unit-of-quantity terms (plant cost per unit of quantity, labour days per unit of quantity); shift/day rates themselves vary with rental mode, brand and crew mix, and subtracting them horizontally invites wrong conclusions.
  3. Deviation thresholds are not code numbers: GB/T 50500-2024 and the tender-review standards give the judgment elements and the deviation-ratio algorithm, not a uniform percentage threshold; never present a rule-of-thumb percentage as a code requirement, nor reject a bid on deviation ratios alone where the tender documents are silent.
  4. Rate comparison does not replace total-price conclusions: multiply by quantities to form price weights before ranking; an item with high deviation but low weight only logs a suspicion and earns no equal review effort.
  5. Adjustment of unbalanced rates must not change the tender total (clause 3.5.4), and the scope of adjusted rates (whole project / works outside the contract BOQ only) must be pre-agreed, else the pricing scope during performance invites disputes.
  6. Stage matters: this method serves the tender/review/evaluation stage (L3 anchored on the evaluation benchmark price and the tender price ceiling) and the performance stage (anchored on contract rates, cost and market prices of comparable works); the anchors differ and must not be mixed - benchmark prices must not negate signed contract rates; adjusting signed contract rates goes through the clause 8.9.1 rules.
  7. Non-competitive costs are not negotiable: the statutory safety provisions and the like must comply with the rules of the state, provinces and sector authorities and can be neither an object of 'method difference' explanation nor a target of price squeezing.

Further reading

  • GB/T 50500-2024: clauses 3.1.7, 3.5.2, 3.5.3, 3.5.4, 6.1.2, 6.1.3, 6.1.5, 6.2.6, 8.9.1 (five rate rules on variation and BOQ errors).
  • GB/T 51095-2015 (cost consultancy code): clause 5.3.9 (rate build-up principle), Appendix C (analysis sheet format); 6.3.2 (nine tender review items).
  • DB37/T 5161-2020 (cost data exchange standard): chapter 5 (compliance/computational/reasonableness/similarity checks), 5.2.3 + table 5.2.3 (divisional rate make-up, Price = Labor + Material + Machine + Overhead + Profit), 5.2.6 + table 5.2.6 (preliminaries rate make-up), 5.3.4 + table 5.3.4 (deviation and deviation ratio vs the benchmark price).
  • DB37/T 5130-2018 (cost consulting services): clause 6.7.2 (tender review content, preliminaries pricing vs the construction method).
  • DBJ/T 15-153-2019 (Guangdong whole-process cost management): clause 6.10.3 (advance agreement on unbalanced-rate criteria).
  • T/HAEC 011-2024 (railway supervision records guide): clause 9.13.3 (mobilised plant quantity/model/spec/capacity/serviceability vs the bid).

Keywords