Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-09-25

Variance analysis between the construction-drawing based budget (pre-tender estimate) and the winning tender budget: a five-step method (total price → cost composition → item-by-item all-in unit rates → attribution → conclusions)

The two budgets share the same quantities (both measured per the tender BOQ); differences concentrate in all-in unit-rate composition and cost levels — the main battleground is the unit-rate and percentage-rate layers. Analyze in five steps: ① total price comparison to size the difference (the winning tender price may not be below cost nor above the tender price ceiling); ② four-block cost composition positioning (work sections / preliminaries / other items / statutory levies and fees plus taxes and duties); ③ item-by-item all-in unit rate comparison to spot unbalanced rates / rate loading and labour, materials and machinery anomalies; ④ attribution into reasonable / noteworthy / non-compliant; ⑤ issue conclusions (focus = tender pricing level and unbalanced rates / rate loading).

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 51095-2015 建设工程造价咨询规范
  • GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准
  • GB/T 50875-2013 工程造价术语标准
  • T/ZBD 100.5-2023 建设工程结算审核作业指引

Topic Positioning

A systematic method for analyzing differences between the construction-drawing based budget (pre-tender estimate), which is the tender price ceiling (employer's maximum acceptable price) prepared by the employer, and the winning tender budget (the winning tenderer's priced bill of quantities (BOQ)) — first locate differences, then judge their nature (reasonable / anomalous), then decide handling, for tender review and normalization (arithmetic and compliance check), tender-return analysis and performance risk control.

Core Conclusions

The two budgets share the same quantities (both measured per the BOQ issued with the tender documents); differences concentrate in all-in unit-rate composition and cost levels — the analysis battleground is the unit-rate and percentage-rate layers. Five steps: ① Total price comparison: compute the difference, difference ratio, and downward float rate; the winning tender price may not be below cost nor above the tender price ceiling — anomalies require deeper checks; ② Cost composition comparison: position across the four blocks of work-section costs / preliminaries / other-item costs (provisional sums, provisional sums for specified materials/nominated works, dayworks, main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions) / statutory levies and fees plus taxes and duties. Preliminaries differences point to the construction method statement; other-item differences to responses to provisional sums for specified materials/nominated works and dayworks; differences in statutory levies and fees plus taxes and duties should converge (GB/T 50500-2024 has removed the separate statutory levies and fees item, folding it into labour rates and the management fee percentage rate); ③ Item-by-item all-in unit rate comparison: identify unbalanced rates / rate loading — deviations from the corresponding item rates in the tender price ceiling beyond the agreed threshold (e.g., ±15%, per the tender documents) and deviations unrelated to construction methods are priorities; for large deviations, split into labour, materials and machinery to check selected prices and abnormal consumption; ④ Attribution: reasonable differences (independent rate build-up, contractor's in-house norm levels, competitive concessions, construction method statement differences) — record and explain; noteworthy differences (excessive unbalanced rates, clearly below cost, zero preliminaries) — list as items for clarification in tender review and normalization; non-compliant differences (understated non-competitive fees, below-cost tendering) — handle per tender review and normalization requirements; ⑤ Issue the analysis conclusions, with the focus on the tender pricing level and unbalanced rates / rate loading.

Applicable Boundaries

Applies to tender review and normalization / tender-return analysis in the construction tendering and contracting stage, premised on re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts and same-source quantities; where errors and omissions in the BOQ exist (the employer bears responsibility under re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts, the contractor under lump-sum contracts, and the contractor always for preliminary items), responsibility must first be defined per GB/T 50500-2024 before analysis. Empirical values such as the unit rate deviation threshold are subject to the tender documents; without agreement they are for reference only.

Further Reading

See GB/T 51095-2015 Clauses 5.3.8, 5.3.9 (all-in unit rate composition and rate build-up principles) and Clause 5.1.5 (five audit methods); GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 3.2.2 (all-in unit rate coverage) and Clause 6.2.1 (basis of preparation for tenders, allowing contractor's in-house norms + market prices); GB/T 50875-2013 Section 2.3 (quota norms terminology: budget quota norms, contractor's in-house norms); T/ZBD 100.5-2023 Clauses 3.2.3, 3.2.4 (audit priorities: quantity correlation and rate build-up); Article 13 of the Interim Measures on the Administration of Budget Review of Construction Works (review content).

Keywords

Cited By