Preliminaries bid at zero - can an increase be claimed at final account? (principle-plus-exception framework, with clarification of Clause 10.3.3)
Ordinary preliminaries bid at zero constitute a lump-sum price and are not reimbursed at final account (GB/T 50500-2024, 6.2.3, 6.1.5, 7.3.1); judicial practice treats this as a concession. 'Recalculation and determination' at final account under 10.3.3 only means recalculating all preliminaries contained in the executed works under Section 7.3 and Chapter 8 - amounts listed in interim settlement by construction stage are not a basis, and the zero bid remains effective. However, a zero bid for mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions (railway term: statutory work safety levy (earmarked funds)) violates the non-competitive rule (3.2.5) and must be topped up at the standard rate; substantive changes caused by variations (7.4.4, implementation plan subject to employer approval) or employer-caused deferred use, dismantling/re-erection, addition or re-provision of preliminary items (3.3.7) may be adjusted through the prescribed procedure.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准(第3.2.5、3.3.7、6.1.5、6.2.3、6.2.6、7.3.1、7.4.4、10.3.3条)
- TB 10801-2024(铁路口径安全生产费,第3.11.11条)
Topic Positioning
Whether preliminaries bid at zero at tender can be recovered at final account is a high-frequency issue in final account audits and cost disputes. This card sets out the complete principle-plus-exceptions framework with the supporting clauses and clarifies the common misreading of the 'recalculation and determination' of preliminaries under Clause 10.3.3.
Core Conclusions
General principle: preliminaries are on a lump-sum basis (Clause 3.3.7: 'the preliminaries are on a lump-sum basis, and the contractor shall bear the risk of increases in preliminaries caused by its own adjustments to the construction method statement ... except for variations, works within provisional sums that could not be fully foreseen or specified, and deferred use, dismantling/re-erection, addition or re-provision of preliminary items provided by the contractor caused by the employer ... no other adjustment shall be made'); item-priced items are lump-sum and shall not be adjusted in construction payment settlement (interim + final) (Clause 6.2.3, 'unless otherwise agreed in the contract'); the completeness and accuracy of the bill of preliminaries and the risk of its pricing being unreasonable rest with the bidder (Clause 6.1.5); preliminary items in the priced bill of quantities (BOQ) shall not be measured or adjusted (Clause 7.3.1, with only five exceptions: (i) preliminary works listed in the divisional BOQ and items contractually subject to measurement; (ii) statutory safety provisions per the contract; (iii) changes in preliminary items caused by variations; (iv) changes in preliminary items caused by errors and omissions in the BOQ; (v) changes in preliminary items caused by works within provisional sums that could not be fully foreseen or specified; the preliminaries of specialist subcontracted works within provisional sums for nominated specialist subcontract works are already included in the subcontract total and shall not be measured again). Judicial practice is consistent: a zero bid is deemed to have been absorbed into other prices or a voluntary concession, and later claims for an increase are generally not supported; a zero bid is not an omission from the BOQ and cannot be recovered on the ground of an 'omission'.
Key clarification (Clause 10.3.3): at final account 'the employer and contractor shall recalculate and determine the preliminaries and the main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions in the documents for interim settlement by construction stage', but the same clause provides that 'preliminaries listed in interim settlement by construction stage shall not serve as the basis for final account' - the recalculation computes all preliminaries contained in the executed works (including adjustments to statutory safety provisions) under Section 7.3 and Chapter 8; it does not change the effect of a zero bid, i.e. a lump sum of zero, and cannot be invoked to recover zero-bid preliminaries.
Three exceptions allowing an increase: (i) a zero bid for statutory safety provisions (railway term: statutory work safety levy (earmarked funds)) - Clause 3.2.5 makes it a non-competitive item whose pricing must comply with national, provincial and sectoral regulations; Clause 6.2.6 likewise provides that when the bidder prices autonomously, 'statutory safety provisions shall comply with national, provincial and sectoral regulations'; a zero bid violates the non-competitive rule and must be topped up at the standard rate; (ii) changes in preliminary items caused by variations - under Clause 7.4.4, measured per 'the implementation plan prepared by the contractor specifically for the variation and approved by the employer, or the content actually occurring'; new measures are measured per the types, actual quantities and usage durations of new temporary works and the models, numbers and consumed plant-shifts of new construction plant in the approved plan; the increased costs of deferred use of existing preliminary items and management staff caused by variations off the critical path may be left unmeasured (deemed included in the contract total); before a variation, the implementation plan must be submitted in writing and approved by the employer - late submission may be deemed a waiver of rights; (iii) employer-caused deferred use, dismantling/re-erection, addition or re-provision of preliminary items - the increased costs shall be borne by the employer per Clause 3.3.7.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to general employer-contractor projects priced on a bill of quantities basis (GB/T 50500-2024); where the contract expressly provides a lump sum or otherwise regulates adjustment of preliminaries, ordinary preliminaries have virtually no room for increase (Clauses 6.2.3 and 7.3.1 both yield to contrary agreement). The exception for mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions presupposes that they are separately listed as required and are a non-competitive cost; sectoral works such as railway works follow sectoral pricing rules (for the railway treatment of the statutory work safety levy, see TB 10801-2024). GB/T 50500-2024 is a recommendatory standard; specific contractual agreements prevail; determination follows the tender documents, contract clauses and the text of the standard.
Further Reading
See GB/T 50500-2024, Clauses 3.2.5, 3.3.7, 6.1.5, 6.2.3, 6.2.6, 7.3.1, 7.4.4 and 10.3.3 and Chapter 8 (Section 8.9 valuation of variations; 8.2.2/8.2.3 adjustment for errors and omissions in the BOQ; 7.7.2 provisional sums); for measurement exceptions for preliminary items and procedural time limits, see Clauses 7.2.1/7.2.2 and 8.9.4-8.9.7; for the railway treatment of the statutory work safety levy, see TB 10801-2024, Clause 3.11.11; for judicial positions, compare the Supreme People's Court Interpretation (I) on Legal Issues Concerning the Trial of Cases of Construction Project Construction Contract Disputes and related judgments.
Keywords
Cited By
- ←
Comparing mandatory HSE provisions (statutory work safety levy) rates with the statutory work safety funding standard correctly: the three-step method - align the base, align the scope, separate the levels - and why a single-item rate converted below 3% is method failure, not non-compliance
A safe-construction rate sitting on a labour-plus-machine base, multiplied by the labour-and-machine share and converted to a cost-of-works denominator, falling below the statutory 3% does not show the rate deficient: first, the bases differ (labour plus machine costs versus the construction and installation cost of works) - for the single 5.19% item the conversion reaches 3% only at a labour-and-machine share of 57.8% or more, forever out of reach for building works at 20% to 30%: method failure; second, the scopes differ (safe-construction provisions carry only two classes of spending - safety protection facilities and equipment, and site workers' protective gear - while training, emergency preparedness, testing and examination, work safety liability insurance and hazard rectification sit elsewhere, in overheads or statutory levies or outside construction cost entirely); third, the levels differ (the 3% of Cai Zi [2022] No. 136 is an enterprise accrual on output progress, not the same level as the HSE provisions singled out in the contract price). Correct method: unify the base, align the spending scope, and judge on three levels - priced into the works, accrued by the enterprise, actually spent.
- ←
Why the 'statutory withdrawal coefficient' of the work safety levy and the fee rates of pricing bases differ: the hierarchy of Work Safety Law article 23, the withdrawal standards of Cai Zi [2022] No. 136, and the differences of base, content and function across sector fee schedules
Work Safety Law (2021 revision) article 23 itself sets no percentage - only three duties, to withdraw, to use exclusively and to charge to cost as actually incurred, delegating the rates to the finance and emergency-management departments; the so-called statutory coefficient is in fact article 17 of the Measures for the Administration of Withdrawal and Use of Enterprise Work Safety Expenses (Cai Zi [2022] No. 136): withdrawal on the construction and installation cost of works - mining 3.5%; railway, building and urban rail transit 3%; water conservancy and hydropower, and power 2.5%; smelting, mechanical and electrical installation, chemical and petroleum, and communications 2%; municipal utilities, ports and waterways, and highway 1.5%. The rates in the BOQ pricing standard and sector fee schedules are price standards - how the money enters the contract price and who pays (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 2.0.4 and 3.2.5; statutory safety provisions are non-competitive) - and differ in base and content (cost of works versus labour plus machine costs; work safety expenses versus the wider mandatory HSE provisions including civilised construction, environmental protection and temporary facilities); the two are not on one yardstick and their figures cannot be compared directly; within one sector they mostly agree (TB 10811-2024 clause 2.11.9: 3.0%; JTG 3830-2018: not less than 1.5%).
- ←
Content and pricing methods of preliminaries: the 2024 definition (clause 2.0.3), the listing basis (GB/T 50854-2024 annex R table R.1.1 preliminary items, code 011601), the three pricing methods of unit rate / lump sum / percentage rate and their preferred use (clauses 2.0.10 to 2.0.12, 3.2.1), the completion rules of annex E tables E.3.1 to E.3.4, and the non-competitive rule for statutory safety provisions (clause 3.2.5)
Preliminaries are 'project costs incurred in taking the relevant measures to complete the contract works, related to the cost of the works as a whole and to the performance of the contract, but unrelated to the cost of any individual divisional or sub-divisional work item' (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 2.0.3); their content is listed per annex R table R.1.1 of GB/T 50854-2024 (preliminary items, code 011601). The 2024 edition no longer splits 'lump-sum preliminaries / unit-rate preliminaries'; it prices by three methods - unit-rate pricing (quantity x all-in unit rate), lump-sum pricing (per item) and percentage-rate pricing (charging base x percentage rate) - and 'the pricing of the preliminaries BOQ should adopt the lump-sum method' (clause 3.2.1); special measures whose construction scheme the contract requires to pass expert panel review may instead be unit-rate priced and are then listed in the divisional/sub-divisional BOQ. The statutory safety provisions are a non-competitive item and must be priced per the provisions of the state and of the provincial or sector authorities (clause 3.2.5).
- ←
Whether acceleration cost (for earlier completion) can be claimed when the employer demands acceleration: allocation of responsibility, the claimable net amount (after deducting the mid-term running costs of preliminaries saved by the shortened duration), approval before implementation, and the 28-day claim procedure
Claimable, but only the net amount. GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 8.11.17: where the employer requires earlier completion of the contract works, the resulting earlier-completion costs (acceleration compensation) are borne by the employer; where earlier completion is not required by the employer but is driven by the contractor's own reasons, the added costs are borne by the contractor. The claimable scope is limited to the increment from 'non-economic use of labour, materials and plant' (cl. 2.0.32) and must be reduced by the downward adjustment of the mid-term running costs of preliminaries computed under cl. 8.9.4 for the shortened duration; only shortening on the critical path constitutes a material shortening of the time for completion. Procedurally, a Notice of Claim must be submitted within the period agreed in the contract (28 days if none), followed by the claim report within the same period; late submission may be treated as waiver (cl. 8.11.3), and the employer's failure to reply within 28 days may be treated as deemed acceptance of the claim (cl. 8.11.5).
- ←
The claim path and the net-amount pricing basis for acceleration costs within preliminaries when the employer demands a shorter duration: offsetting the acceleration increment against the downward adjustment of the mid-term running costs of affected preliminaries items, the limits of the lump-sum preliminaries defence, and the approve-before-executing and claim time-limit procedures (GB/T 50500-2024 Articles 8.11.17, 2.0.32, 8.9.4, 8.9.6, 8.11.3 and 8.11.5; GF-2017-0201 clause 7.9.1)
A claim can be made, and in principle the employer bears the cost, but the claimable amount is a net amount: the actual incremental costs incurred by the contractor in the non-economical use of labour, materials and construction plant to meet the employer's demand, minus the reduction in the mid-term running costs of the affected preliminaries items caused by the shorter duration (GB/T 50500-2024 Articles 8.11.17, 2.0.32 and 8.9.4). A lump-sum preliminaries clause excludes only the increments generated by the contractor's own adjustment of its construction method or its self-initiated early completion; it does not exclude acceleration increments responding to the employer's instruction. To overcome the lump-sum defence, the method must be approved before execution (Article 8.9.6) and a Notice of Claim must be issued within the period agreed in the contract (28 days absent agreement) (Article 8.11.3).
- ←
The charging base of the winter and rainy season construction addition (norm labour, or labour plus plant), deciding the winter construction season, rate-based lump-sum charging versus special measures (warm-shed method, steam curing) priced on approved schemes and records, and the no-double-count rule against the night-work addition
Under the building and municipal basis the winter / rainy season addition is a total-price preliminaries item charged as base x rate, lump-sum: the base runs as norm labour or (norm labour + plant) by locality, and rates on different bases never compare; the rate covers only cold, insulation, rain, damp and protection plus crew and plant efficiency loss that leave the technical working process unchanged - warm-shed work, steam curing and like special measures that change the process always price separately on employer-approved winter schemes; nothing adjusts save variations, unforeseeable provisional-sum works and employer-caused preliminaries increases (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 3.3.7). The winter season starts and ends on local multi-year meteorology - 'five consecutive days of mean outdoor temperature steadily below / above 5C' (JGJ/T 104-2011 clause 1.0.3) - never on fixed calendar months.
- ←
Interim payment and final settlement of preliminaries: statutory safety provisions prepayment and recovery points (9.3.2 - at least 50% within 28 days of commencement), progress-payment methods (9.4.4 - agreed breakdown or element-works ratios), the three-stage preliminaries breakdown table (6.2.13, Appendix E Table E.3.3), interim versus final settlement (10.2.7, 10.3.3) and the three-class treatment in settlement review
Statutory safety provisions prepay at not less than 50% of the total within 28 days of commencement, the rest decomposed per the early-arrangement principle and paid with progress payments; computing progress payments never recovers the prepayment - it is recovered once at the final account (9.3.2). Preliminaries progress payments follow the parties' agreed breakdown; absent agreement, by the ratio of cumulative completed work-item list value to the work-item list total, the breakdown resting on Appendix E Table E.3.3 (initial set-up / mid-term running / late dismantling, 6.2.13, 9.4.4). Preliminaries listed in interim settlements serve only interim payment (10.2.7); the final account recomputes all preliminaries of the completed works per clause set 7.3 and chapter 8, including safety-provision adjustments - interim figures are no basis (10.3.3).
- ←
Preliminaries — the "lump sum, no adjustment" principle and the full landscape of adjustable exceptions (GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 3.3.7, 7.3.1)
Under GB/T 50500-2024, the China national pricing standard for BOQ (Code of Valuation with Bill of Quantities of Construction Works), preliminaries follow a lump-sum no-adjustment principle, reflected at three levels: (1) the construction method statement reported at tendering is deemed reasonable and feasible, the cost is priced as a lump sum, and the contractor bears the risk of cost increases arising from adjusting its own method statement (cl. 3.3.7); (2) preliminary items in the priced BOQ shall not be re-measured or adjusted (cl. 7.3.1); (3) preliminaries are not adjusted for changes in costs (cl. 8.7.6 item 3). Exception channels: preliminary works listed as billed (BOQ) items and items the contract requires to be measured (cl. 7.2.1, 7.2.2); statutory safety provisions (per contract); variations (measured per cl. 7.4.4, priced per cl. 8.9); errors and omissions in the BOQ (cl. 8.2.2, 8.2.3); unforeseeable works within provisional sums (cl. 7.7.2); delayed use, removal/re-installation, increase or duplicated provision of the contractor's preliminary items due to the employer, and material changes to the time for completion (costs borne by the employer, cl. 3.3.7). Under re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts, only the statutory safety provisions and BOQ-listed formwork/temporary works etc. are adjustable for BOQ errors and omissions (cl. 8.2.2). Adjustments require "submitting the method statement for confirmation before implementation" (cl. 8.9.6); late submission is deemed waiver, and the other party's late confirmation is deemed acceptance (cl. 8.9.7).
- ←
Difference between unit-rate preliminary items and lump-sum preliminary items, and the rules for adjusting preliminaries on a variation
GB/T 50500-2024 no longer uses the "unit-rate preliminary items / lump-sum preliminary items" dichotomy, classifying instead by three pricing methods — unit-rate pricing, lump-sum pricing and percentage-rate based pricing — and preliminary items should preferably be priced on a lump-sum basis (§2.0.10, 3.2.1); lump-sum preliminary items are price-locked and are generally not subject to measurement adjustments (§7.3.1, only five exceptions); unit-rate preliminary items follow quantities with the rate varying, adjusted per the variation all-in unit rate rules (§8.9.1); adjusting preliminaries on a variation requires submitting a scheme for confirmation before implementation (§8.9.6), and late submission is deemed waiver of the right (§8.9.7).
- ←
Whether rate-priced mandatory HSE provisions (statutory safety provisions) adjust at settlement: three adjustment doors (quantity-linked base, legal and policy change, major variation or raised standards), the rate-lump-sum principle regardless of actual spend, and the settlement base plus the 2013/2024 edition gap
Mandatory HSE provisions (railway: work safety funds; GB/T 50500-2024: statutory safety provisions) are non-competitive: settlement value = settlement base x prescribed rate, lump-sum, never rising or falling with the contractor's actual spend. Only three doors open: (1) the base (finally confirmed work-item costs) - GB 50500-2013 clause 9.6.3 adjusts rate or single-price preliminaries both ways with quantity; (2) legal and policy change after the contract base date - 2013 clause 11.2.3 and 2024 clause 8.8.1 adjust when the authorities revise the standards mid-works; (3) variation or employer-raised site standards - scheme confirmed before execution (2013 9.3.2; 2024 8.9.6), silence forfeits. Settlement review recomputes all preliminaries per 10.3.3; interim-listed figures are no basis.
- ←
Dividing preliminaries liability when site conditions change: site conditions contemplated at tender as lump-sum risk versus employer-changed sites during construction adjusting through variation and claims
GB/T 50500-2024 clause 3.3.7 draws the line: the preliminaries scheme bid 'shall be deemed reasonably practicable and meeting actual construction requirements; its cost is lump-sum, and the contractor bears the risk of increases from adjusting its own scheme'; save variations, unforeseeable provisional-sum works, and 'employer-caused extended use, reworking, addition or re-provision of preliminaries' adjusting under chapter 8, nothing adjusts. So: site conditions shown at tender and priced in the bid are the contractor's lump-sum risk; employer-changed or restricted sites, late handover and disturbed order are employer liability, adjusting upward through variation (8.9) or claims (8.11) - 8.11.10 lists profit among claimables - subject to pre-execution scheme confirmation; silence forfeits.
- ←
Recognising preliminaries costs of repeated scaffold erection and dismantling caused by the employer (instructions changing construction sequence): lump-sum exceptions, measurement anchors, pricing methods and procedural requisites (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 3.3.7, 7.3.1, 7.4.4, 8.9.4~8.9.7, 8.11.10; GB/T 50854-2024 Appendix R, code 011601)
Preliminaries are lump-sum and unadjusted in principle, but clause 3.3.7 lists the exception: 'employer-caused extended use, reworking, addition or re-provision of preliminaries increasing their cost adjusts under chapter 8' - scaffolds re-erected after an employer instruction changing the sequence fall squarely under 'reworking' and 're-provision', with no need to prove excess over the bid scheme's assumptions, though a bid-versus-instructed scheme comparison must show the instruction caused it. Increments measure per 7.4.4 on the employer-approved scheme or actual content (extended use of existing preliminaries and management on non-critical paths never measures); material duration changes price per 8.9.4 as 'extended (shortened) duration x mid-term running costs', new plant and temporary works per 8.9.5; the scheme must be confirmed before execution (8.9.6), silence forfeiting (8.9.7). Codes: GB/T 50854-2024 Appendix R preliminaries run 011601 (scaffolds 011601001, unit 'item', no area rules at BOQ level); 011701 is the 2013 code - area / vertical-projection bases now serve only as increment pricing anchors, never to re-measure the whole scaffold list.
- ←
Contract price adjustment caused by missing items in the tender bill of quantities: the clause chains of the three entries of GB 50500-2013 section 9.5 (9.5.1 to 9.3.1, 9.5.2 / 9.5.3 to 9.3.2), the four-tier valuation of all-in unit rates for new divisional and sub-divisional works items, the three-tier determination of new preliminaries, the itemisation test between unit-rate and lump-sum preliminaries, and the distinction from the quantity-deviation preliminaries linkage trigger path of clause 9.6.3
GB 50500-2013 splits 'missing BOQ items' into three mutually non-substitutable clause chains: 9.5.1 (missing divisional and sub-divisional items) fixes the rate under the four tiers of 9.3.1; 9.5.2 (new works items bringing changes to preliminaries) adjusts under 9.3.2 after the implementation plan is approved; 9.5.3 (missing preliminaries items themselves) both fixes rates under 9.3.1 and adjusts preliminaries under 9.3.2, and the plan must be submitted to the employer for approval first. The three tiers of 9.3.2: mandatory HSE provisions are calculated per 3.1.5; unit-rate preliminaries have their rates set per 9.3.1; lump-sum (or factor-based) preliminaries follow the actual adjustment amount x the contractor's quoted-price fluctuation rate. Failure to submit the plan in advance is deemed no adjustment of the preliminaries or waiver of the right to adjust. Missing items go through 9.5 / 9.3; only quantity deviations of original BOQ items over 15% (exclusive) go through 9.6.2 to adjust the all-in unit rate, with 9.6.3 adjusting factor-based or single lump-sum preliminaries up or down - the two paths must not be mixed.
- ←
Within preliminaries: the composition, charging method and calculation bases of mandatory HSE provisions (statutory safety provisions), temporary works and site establishment costs, and the additional cost of night work, compared; plus the clause basis of the non-competitive status of mandatory HSE provisions and the item listing rules
Mandatory HSE provisions comprise four heads - environmental protection, site order, safe construction, and temporary works and site establishment (Jian Ban [2005] No. 89 article 4 citing Jian Biao [2003] No. 206); temporary works cost is thus a sub-head and must not be listed again as a separate item and double charged. GB/T 50500-2024 clause 3.2.5 makes statutory safety provisions a non-competitive item, and GB 50722-2011 clause 5.2.9 provides that mandatory HSE provisions and work injury insurance for migrant workers must not be treated as competitive costs: the tenderer may not require a discount on them and tenderers may not subject them to market competition. All three heads are lump-sum preliminaries not readily measurable, charged as calculation base x percentage rate; the base for mandatory HSE provisions is the quota base price (norm-based elemental works cost plus measurable preliminaries), the norm-based labour cost, or the norm-based labour cost plus norm-based plant cost; the additional cost of night work is charged on the base of the labour and plant costs incurred for the night work, and only where night work actually occurs under technologically required continuous construction or an approved night work plan may it be charged (statutory night runs 22:00 to 6:00 the next day).
- ←
Re-decomposition and re-pricing of cost when a design variation moves wire-in-conduit wiring to cable-tray wiring: choosing the variation valuation clause (2013 edition clause 9.3.1 four tiers / 2024 edition clauses 8.9.1~8.9.3 five tiers); the deduction basis for the original conduit and wiring quantities; itemisation and measurement of tray, supports and hangers, and wiring; attribution of demolition of work already done and material write-off, and the rework confirmation procedure
Changing wires from conduit to cable tray is a change of 'item description + construction method': the original conduit rate does not apply to the tray (under the 2013 edition, clause 9.4.2 first re-determines the all-in unit rate on the description actually built, then the four tiers of clause 9.3.1 apply - the contract rate where an applicable item exists, an analogous rate by reference where a similar one exists, and where neither exists the contractor proposes a rate built from published price information and its tender float rate for employer confirmation, or from market-enquiry prices where the published information lacks the item); conduit and wiring quantities are recalculated from the variation instruction and the drawings as actually built and set against the original BOQ for deduction (conduit deducted by length, the length occupied by junction boxes not deducted); the added tray is measured by length (m); whether supports and hangers are listed separately depends on the consumption standard applied (DB11/T 2382-2024 includes support erection, fabrication of non-finished supports being listed separately; SJG 111.3-2022 expressly excludes support fabrication and erection); wiring is recalculated as single-wire length including reservations; demolition and material write-off for rework must rest on a rework confirmation sheet or site instruction record raised within the contractually agreed time - borne by the employer where the cause is not attributable to the contractor, and serving as the basis for rework pricing under chapter 8; raised late, the work is deemed to have caused no rework and is not measured.
- ←
Where the work safety liability insurance (Anze Xian), employer's liability insurance and work injury insurance for migrant workers belong in pricing: inclusion in the mandatory HSE provisions (the statutory work safety levy under railway rules), how they are taken at tender and settlement, and how the three relate
The work safety liability insurance is in principle disbursed within the mandatory HSE provisions / statutory work safety levy without a separate heading: railway TB 10801-2024 Table 3.11.11 category 9 is 'work safety liability insurance expenditure'; the highway guide says it 'may be disbursed from the work safety costs'; some provincial fee norms for building and municipal works list it within the mandatory HSE provisions. Taking basis: at tender / tender price ceiling it is taken at the non-competitive percentage rate, at settlement adjusted to the amount actually paid (policy and contract plus premium receipts / technical service deliverables). Employer's liability insurance is the contractor's commercial cover carried in overheads, not disbursed from the work safety levy. Work injury insurance for migrant workers is social insurance - carried separately, non-competitive, paid in one lump sum by the main contractor before commencement - running parallel to, not replacing, the work safety liability insurance.
- ←
Whether preliminaries adjust after a construction plan (project execution plan) changes: the lump-sum boundary, adjustable situations, measurement and pricing methods, and supporting records
After a plan (project execution plan) change, preliminaries follow lump-sum-no-adjustment as the principle (GB/T 50500-2024 Article 3.3.7): the contractor's tendered measures plan is deemed reasonable and feasible, preliminaries are priced lump-sum, and the contractor bears the risk of increases caused by his own plan changes; only three exceptions - variations, works within provisional sums not fully foreseen or detailed, and employer-caused extended use, dismantling, addition or duplicated provision of measures - adjust under Chapter 8; costs of changing an unworkable plan or one beyond the contractor's capability are his own. Time effects adjust only for substantive critical-path extension or reduction (8.9.4), non-critical items unmeasured; cost fluctuation is no ground (8.7.6), while laws and policy changes are a separate channel (8.8.1); measurement adjustment is a closed list under 7.3.1; varying preliminaries requires the plan approved and confirmed before execution, silence forfeiting the right (8.9.6, 8.9.7).
- ←
The definition of preliminaries and its two charging bases: measurable preliminaries (priced like divisional-work costs) and comprehensively charged preliminaries (a rate on divisional-work costs plus measurable preliminaries)
Preliminaries defined (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 2.0.3): the costs of the technical, welfare, work-safety and environmental-protection items arising in construction preparation, construction and acceptance - tied to the works as a whole and to contract performance, not to any single divisional-work item. At budget stage two bases apply (GB/T 51095-2015 clause 5.3.10; DB42/T 823-2021 clause 6.3.10): measurable preliminaries price by the same method as divisional-work costs (clauses 5.3.8 / 5.3.9; 6.3.8 / 6.3.9); comprehensively charged preliminaries = (the unit work's divisional-work costs + measurable preliminaries) x the rate. At final account the preliminaries are recomputed as the full preliminaries of the completed works per GB/T 50500-2024 clause 10.3.3 - interim listings do not bind.
- ←
Deciding the settlement of tower-crane base, erection-and-dismantling and off-site transport charges (including where the tower crane was never installed): three charges kept in separate accounts + the "charge as actually incurred" principle + recomputation of preliminaries at final account under BOQ pricing
The tower-crane base is a plant machine-shift "separately computed charge" - in neither the machine-shift rate nor the erection-and-dismantling charge - measured on the physical work actually completed. Erection-and-dismantling is a one-off charge per erection and dismantling (including trial running), counted per actual set-ups and not counted where none occurred. Off-site transport is counted per set-up and generally once per project location. Piling under the base, ground improvement and floor strengthening are outside the items and follow the construction method statement or actual occurrence. At final account of BOQ-priced works the preliminaries are recomputed per GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 10.3.3 and 10.2.7, charging only "the full preliminaries contained in the completed works"; amounts listed in interim (process) settlements do not bind and adjust up or down on recomputation - where the tower crane was never installed, the corresponding preliminaries are reduced.
- ←
Prepayment and payment rules for statutory safety provisions (GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 9.3.2, 9.3.3): not less than 50% prepaid within 28 days of commencement, paid alongside progress payments, recovered in one lump sum at final account
Under Clause 9.3.2 of GB/T 50500-2024, the China national pricing standard for BOQ, the employer shall, within 28 days after commencement, prepay to the contractor not less than 50% of the total statutory safety provisions; the remainder shall be broken down on the "arrange in advance" principle and paid alongside progress payments; for multi-year major works the prepaid total may be broken down by reference to the annual programme of works. When computing progress payments due, the prepaid safety provisions shall not be recovered; they are recovered in one lump sum at final account. Clause 9.3.3: where the employer fails to pay by the agreed time, the contractor may give notice; if payment is still not made within the agreed period after such notice, the contractor is entitled to suspend the works and the employer bears liability for breach of contract; where a safety accident occurs because the employer failed to pay the statutory safety provisions on time, the employer bears the corresponding responsibility.
- ←
Checking tender prices for omitted taxes and duties, statutory levies and fees, and preliminaries (edition basis → tax back-calculation → levy rates → preliminaries comparison)
Four-step check for omitted taxes and duties / statutory levies and fees / preliminaries: ① confirm the pricing edition basis first (2013: five costs listed separately vs 2024: statutory levies and fees embedded in all-in unit rates, only VAT listed separately); ② taxes and duties — check the rate and the base (work items + preliminaries + bill of provisional sums and other charges, net of provisional sums for nominated specialist subcontract works), and verify by back-calculation: total price ÷ 1.09; ③ statutory levies and fees — check completeness of the listed items and consistency of percentage rates (non-competitive; must exactly match the tender documents / provincial rates); ④ preliminaries — compare item by item against the project execution plan (construction methodology and site organization), with a dedicated check on the non-competitive mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions; under the 2024 edition a cost-breakdown table must be submitted with the tender.
- ←
Checking drawing-BOQ contradictions (bill of quantities defects) before bid pricing, and responsibility boundaries (GB/T 50500-2024)
Drawing-BOQ contradictions are "BOQ defects" (extra items/omissions/mismatched characteristics/quantity deviations, Article 2.0.27). Responsibility by pricing mode: unit-rate contracts—work-item BOQ by the tenderer (Article 6.1.6, defects adjusted at settlement per Section 8.2); lump-sum contracts—by the bidder (Article 6.1.7, may supplement the priced BOQ and bears the difference); preliminaries always the bidder's (Article 6.1.5); per-item pricing is lump sum, unadjusted at settlement (Article 6.2.3). Check by risk order: item characteristics, quantities, completeness of items, units and measurement rules, work-content interfaces, drawing versions, preliminaries, provisional sums.
- ←
Charging the cost of fine-decoration show flats (model rooms): classifying by nature to determine the cost-attribution path (process → measure costs / delivery → divisional works / display → other-item costs or separate award)
Show-flat costs are charged by first classifying nature, then setting the path: workmanship show flats → preliminaries or amortized into all-in unit rates; delivery-standard show flats → formally listed into divisional-works costs; marketing display show flats → other-item costs (provisional sums etc.) or separately awarded. Show flats are a mandatory pre-procedure of decoration (GB 50210-2018 Clause 3.3.8), and cost attribution follows the GB/T 50500-2024 framework + contract agreement.
- ←
Estimating and apportioning the protection-of-finished-work cost (protection cost of completed works and equipment): two paths — the percentage-rate method and the actual-cost method
The protection-of-finished-work cost belongs to preliminaries (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 3.2.6). Two estimating paths: (1) the percentage-rate method = base to which percentage rates are applied × percentage rate — under the BOQ basis, on the base of divisional-works costs at range percentage rates from local quota norms; under the railway basis it is merged into construction preliminaries and calculated at (base-period labour cost + base-period plant and small tools cost) × percentage rate (TB 10801-2024 Section 3.6); (2) the actual-cost method = Σ(protection quantity × unit price) + guarding labour + demolition and removal, item by item per the protection scheme, with materials amortized over turnovers. Apportionment may merge into preliminaries for unified charging, be a separately billed item, or amortize into the all-in unit rates of the protected objects; the basis must be agreed in advance in the tender contract.
- ←
Costing temporary access roads (temporary bridges) during road construction: preliminary items listing and three rate build-up paths
Temporary access roads are preliminaries: municipal works list them as "item" per GB/T 50857-2024 Appendix M (041201008 access road / 041201009 temporary bridge), with rate build-up quantities per the approved project execution plan (construction methodology and site organization); three paths — applying quota items (highway JTG/T 3832-2018 7-1-1 truck access road per 1 km, maintenance per 1 km-month charged separately), quantity takeoff (earthwork + pavement + drainage + maintenance + removal and restoration), percentage rate fallback (no special scheme: charge as incurred per the project execution plan; some regional standards allow 2% of the total of the divisional and subdivisional works); temporary bridges amortized with recoverable-material credits; maintenance is the most easily missed.
- ←
Screening double counting in budget documents: five high-frequency duplication scenarios and judgment principles
The general principle for judging double counting: content already included in the work content must not be charged again, separately listed items must not be recomputed, and mutually exclusive items can be taken only once. High-frequency duplication falls into five classes: ① between quota line items (cast-in-place concrete already includes formwork — no separate formwork item; auxiliary content such as machinery relocation and material transport already included); ② between preliminaries and work-sections (vertical transport covers only large machinery, the rest already being in the work-sections; costs of separately listed preliminary items must not be double-counted); ③ within preliminaries (comprehensive vs. individually priced scaffolds — choose one; birdcage (full-area) scaffold and wall-finishing scaffolding are mutually exclusive; height-increase fee keyed to work points above 25 m); ④ other-item fees (provisional sums reduced at settlement by price adjustments; claims carry taxes and duties only); ⑤ fee accrual and taxes and duties (the base to which percentage rates are applied and taxation of free-issue materials (by the employer) must not be duplicated).
- ←
Three-dimensional cost analysis method for billed (BOQ) items: quantity, price, and fee (quantity recheck → price reasonableness → fee composition)
Split the cost of a single billed (BOQ) item into three independent dimensions for review — quantity (recheck of quantities), price (three-layer review of the all-in unit rate), and fee (verification of costs outside the unit rate): the quantity dimension re-quantifies from drawings and compares with the BOQ quantities, checking missing items and duplicate listings; the price dimension reviews consumption, prices, and rates under the all-in unit rate = labour cost + material cost + plant and small tools cost + management fee + profit + risk cost within the agreed range (excluding VAT, GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 2.0.9, 3.1.6) and identifies unbalanced rates / rate loading; the fee dimension verifies the completeness of preliminaries, non-competitive costs, provisional sums and specified-material/nominated-works provisional sums, and arithmetic checks. Based on the nine items of tender review and normalization in GB/T 51095-2015 Clause 6.3.2.
- ←
Determining a reasonable reduction scope in budget review: defining the review boundary, judging whether the reduction magnitude is reasonable, and non-reducible red lines
The reduction scope has two meanings: ① the review coverage is bounded by the consultancy contract, with the contract as the minimum review unit; the submitted documents undergo the "three-way check" (contract documents, software, explanatory notes of the estimate) to detect omissions and over-inclusions, and the reviewer's recheck ratio is generally not below 10%; ② the reduction magnitude is the result of review findings, not a target — no standard prescribes a fixed reduction rate, every reduction must be substantiated (drawings + quota norms + calculation formulas), non-competitive costs such as mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions (called the statutory work safety levy on railway projects) must not be reduced, and omissions and under-computations should be reviewed upward, not only downward.
- ←
Cost attribution and estimation of temporary hoarding, gates, and wheel-wash facilities on site (basis of mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions)
Hoarding, gates, and wheel-wash facilities belong respectively to the site housekeeping and appearance fee, the temporary works and site establishment costs / site monitoring fee, and the dust pollution prevention fee sub-items of mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions (a Chinese non-competitive fee; the literal loan translation is misleading, so an institutional note is required); in regions with lump-sum percentage rates they must not be listed separately again; in regions where costs are itemised on an actual basis, estimate by "quantity × unit price" applying quota items + equipment price enquiries; on the railway basis this corresponds to the statutory work safety levy (earmarked funds) + preliminaries, with minor temporary works cost included in preliminaries and heavy temporary works priced by applying quota items on an actual basis.
- ←
Risk allocation and adjustment rules for preliminaries (measure) costs: GB 50500-2013 vs GB/T 50500-2024 (omitted items, scheme changes, lump sum plus exceptions)
The 2024 edition restructures preliminaries as "lump sum plus exceptions": completeness/accuracy of the preliminaries list is the contractor's responsibility under both unit-price and lump-sum contracts (3.1.8); omitted items are no longer adjustable except the safety-measures cost and formwork/temporary works listed in the work-item list (8.2.2/8.2.3), whereas under 2013 list omissions were the tenderer's liability (4.1.2, mandatory) and missing preliminaries could be added via an approved scheme (9.5.3). "All preliminaries risk on the contractor" is inaccurate - exceptions like variations, unforeseen provisional-sum works, and employer causes still cost the employer (3.3.7), but only via "submit scheme before execution + mutual confirmation" (8.9.6/8.9.7), failing which the right is forfeited.
- ←
Overheads (company and site) within the all-in unit rate vs. site management fee within lump-sum preliminaries: distinction and prevention of duplicate charging
Overheads (company and site) are on-costs (indirect costs) in nature and enter the all-in unit rate (labour cost + materials cost + plant and small tools cost + overheads (company and site) + profit + agreed risk, excluding value added tax (VAT)), and are settled with the quantities; the legacy 'site management fee' belonged to preliminaries and was lump-summed per item. Since Jian Biao [2003] No. 206, the site management fee has been merged into overheads (company and site), and most provinces no longer list it separately within lump-sum preliminaries; the same management outlay can be charged only once — in preparation and audit review, check that the local quota norm percentage rate basis and the item listing are consistent with each other.
- ←
In-process settlement linked to final account: preliminaries and main-contract service fees are interim payments that must be recalculated at final settlement (GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 10.2.3/10.2.7/10.3.3)
For projects with in-process settlement, preliminaries costs (and main-contract service fees) must be recalculated at final account - amounts listed in in-process settlements are only "interim payments", not a final-account basis, and are adjusted up or down per the recalculation (GB/T 50500-2024 10.2.3, 10.2.7, 10.3.3). But recalculation does not mean repricing: all preliminaries of the completed works (incl. safety-measures adjustments) are recalculated per Section 7.3 and Chapter 8 against the priced-list amounts, checking the five exceptions of 7.3.1 - absent exceptions, the result still equals the priced-list amount. Substantively consistent with GB 50500-2013's "lump-sum preliminaries per the priced list"; 2024 merely hard-codes the in-process-to-final linkage procedure.
- ←
Measurement and cost adjustment rules for changes to preliminary items caused by design changes (variations) under GB/T 50500-2024
Preliminaries take 'no adjustment' as the principle and 'change-induced' as the exception (GB/T 50500-2024 §7.3.1): first determine the adjustment method by the three nature classes (entity-related / competitively independent / percentage-rate composite); measurement follows the employer-approved implementation scheme and what actually occurred (§7.4.4); for substantive duration changes, preliminaries are adjusted up (down) per §8.9.4 and additional preliminary items are priced per §8.9.5; the disadvantaged party must submit its scheme for confirmation before implementation (§8.9.6), and late submission is deemed waiver of the adjustment right (§8.9.7).
- ←
Full workflow of agreeing and paying construction advance payments (GB/T 50500-2024 Section 9.2): nature, proportion, procedure, guarantee, and recovery
The construction advance payment (materials advance) is paid by the Employer before commencement for the Contractor's materials preparation - earmarked and interest-free. For labour-and-material contracts, the payment proportion should not be less than 10% of the signed contract price (net of provisional sums, dayworks and provisional sums for nominated specialist subcontract works) and should not exceed 30% of the signed contract price (for major multi-year projects, prepaid annually at the same proportion in accordance with the annual plan). The Contractor applies -> the Employer reviews and pays (an equal-value guarantee may be agreed); recovery is made as agreed in the contract, or, if not agreed, in one or more instalments; on termination of the contract, any unrecovered portion is recovered in full.
- ←
Methods and liability basis for ensuring completeness of the bill of preliminaries at construction main (general) contracting tender stage (GB/T 50500-2024)
Per GB/T 50500-2024 clause 6.1.5, whether a re-measurable (unit-rate) or lump-sum contract is used, the completeness and accuracy of the bill of preliminaries are the bidder's (contractor's) responsibility, and the bidder bears the risk of the reasonableness of its tender price; preliminary items not priced as required may be deemed included in the all-in unit rates, totals and tender total of other billed (BOQ) items, with no re-pricing or adjustment at construction payment settlement (3.5.4). The contractor should guard against omissions via the six-category 'including but not limited to' framework in 3.2.6 + three cross-checks (bill of preliminaries vs project execution plan (construction methodology and site organization)/tender documents/similar projects) + site inspection + written clarification; statutory safety provisions are non-competitive (3.2.5) and must not be omitted or priced at zero.
- ←
GB/T 50500-2024 pricing and settlement adjustment of main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions: per-item risk-inclusive pricing, percentage-rate based adjustment, interim settlement by construction stage, and recomputation at final account
Where the fee is priced per item, it is risk-inclusive except for deductions or adjustments under Clauses 8.4.8, 8.5.1-8.5.3 and 8.5.5, and shall not be adjusted at final account; where percentage-rate based and the contract is silent or unclear on the pricing basis, adjust per those clauses and compute at settlement from the contract prices of specialist subcontract works, of directly-let specialist works, and of employer-supplied (free-issue) material supply contracts; interim settlement by construction stage takes each specialist subcontract's cumulative completed price as a proportion of its contract price, multiplied by the adjusted total of the provisions; the final account shall recompute the whole of the provisions per Section 8.5 — amounts listed in stage settlements during construction are not a basis for the final account.
- ←
GB 50500-2013 -> GB/T 50500-2024: changes to the clauses on statutory levies and fees, taxes and the mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions — mandatory provisions withdrawn, the bills restructured into four parts, and the item renamed statutory safety provisions
2013 Clause 3.1.6, “statutory levies and fees and taxes must be calculated in accordance with the provisions of the state, provincial or industry construction authorities and shall not be treated as competitive costs” (a mandatory provision), disappears entirely from GB/T 50500-2024: the 2024 edition is a recommended GB/T standard with no mandatory provisions anywhere; under Clause 3.1.2 the bills become four parts (work items / preliminaries / provisional sums and other charges / VAT), statutory levies and fees are no longer a separate billed item, and taxes are renamed VAT (Clause 3.2.11: the tax base is the total of work items + preliminaries + other items, less the provisional sum for nominated specialist subcontract works, multiplied by the tax rate). The mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions are renamed “statutory safety provisions” (Clause 3.2.5), and their “non-competitive” character is expressly retained (“is a non-competitive item”), but the wording is softened from “must ... shall not be treated as competitive costs” to “shall be priced in accordance with the relevant provisions of the state and provincial or industry authorities”. GB/T 50500-2024 takes effect on 1 September 2025, and GB 50500-2013 is repealed at the same time.
- ←
Definition and pricing rules for preliminary items that cannot be measured precisely (Jing Jian Fa [2021] No. 11: class with issued management documents vs class without such documents)
Preliminary items that cannot be measured precisely = preliminary items whose quantities cannot be computed precisely from the dimensions shown on the construction drawings, whose cost is directly related to the construction method statement and/or the duration of input, and which are generally priced as a lump sum per item (Jing Jian Fa [2021] No. 11). Such items not covered by the "cost indicators" in the published construction cost information for Beijing fall into two classes: a) those with issued management documents (mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions, acceleration measure increase costs, and off-site haulage and disposal of construction waste) are governed by those documents, and the cost must not fall below the floor cost standards; b) those without corresponding management documents (e.g. secondary handling, protection of completed works and equipment, night-work increase costs) should preferably be added as separately billed items with clearly defined scope of work and calculation rules, and reasonably determined by the contractor's own estimation on market-based pricing principles in accordance with the method statement. For protection of completed works: Beijing has no official percentage rate, so a percentage-rate approach has no documentary basis; the actual-cost method plus a separately billed item should be used.
- ←
Estimating traffic diversion (traffic relief) costs of municipal works: pricing attribution and two estimation paths
Traffic diversion cost is a preliminary item charged in the bill of preliminaries. Two estimation paths: (1) scheme-quantity method (mainstream) — item-by-item quantity take-off and pricing per the approved project execution plan/special diversion scheme (temporary roads, temporary bridges, hoarding, signs, markings, separation, signal lights, traffic wardens, efficiency loss, removal and restoration, etc.); (2) percentage-rate fallback — without a specific scheme, charge traffic management provisions as a percentage of the divisional-work BOQ total per local rules. GB/T 50903-2013 Clause 6.7.1 requires compiling traffic organization measures, which underpin the estimation.
- ←
Statutory boundaries of what a "lump-sum price" actually covers: dual quantity-and-price lump sums and non-lumpable events (GB/T 50500-2024 / GB/T 50875-2013)
In practice a "lump-sum price" corresponds to a fixed total price, whose core is the "dual lump sum of quantities and price": quantity risk within the drawings, cost fluctuation within the agreed band (5% absent agreement), and the contractor's own management risks are self-borne; but variations, changes in laws and policies, fluctuation beyond the band, owner-caused events, force majeure and government-priced materials are not waived by the word "lump sum". The standard prohibits clauses imposing uncapped risk allocation to one party, such as "all risks" (GB/T 50500-2024 Article 3.3.1).
- ←
Design change overview: authority to propose, classification and grading, approval and implementation, three-tier pricing, settlement and disputes across six links (with variation concept cross-links and FIDIC mapping)
The design-change full chain: any of four parties may propose; only the original designer issues the document (Survey and Design Administration Regulations, art. 28); the chief supervising engineer must sign it off before construction; approve first, then construct; price on the three-tier ladder; settle on the documents. Procedural red lines: verbal instructions are no pricing voucher (unless construction per them is proven); the supervisor's emergency verbal instruction must be confirmed in writing within 24 hours (local supervision codes); emergency-rescue works proceed first with formalities completed within 10 working days. Pricing runs the ladder "identical — contract rate; analogous — converted; different — negotiated" (GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 8.9.1), with quantities beyond ±15% re-rated (down for increases, up for decreases) and the preliminaries scheme to be submitted before execution or the adjustment forfeited. Claims run the double 28-day limit, forfeited on default; the variation price takes the ninth head of the final account, disputes assessed across five tiers by instructions, drawings and confirmations.
- ←
Nature and pricing rules of statutory safety provisions (GB/T 50500-2024: non-competitive item, whole-process constraints, and the change in normative force)
GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 3.2.5 states that the statutory safety provisions in the bill of preliminaries "shall be priced per the relevant provisions of the state, provincial, and industry authorities" and "are a non-competitive item" — their standard is not formed by market competition. Clause 2.0.4 defines them as the special fee safeguarding construction production safety; Clauses 5.2.5/6.2.6/9.3.1/9.3.4 enforce "compliance with authority provisions + ring-fenced (earmarked) use of funds, no diversion" across the tender price ceiling, tenders, and interim payments. The old GB 50500-2013 Clause 4.1.5 (mandatory provisions of codes: "must... shall not be a competitive fee") lost its mandatory force when the standard changed to a recommended GB/T; current binding force rests on administrative documents of the authorities and tendering supervision practice.
- ←
Variance analysis between the construction-drawing based budget (pre-tender estimate) and the winning tender budget: a five-step method (total price → cost composition → item-by-item all-in unit rates → attribution → conclusions)
The two budgets share the same quantities (both measured per the tender BOQ); differences concentrate in all-in unit-rate composition and cost levels — the main battleground is the unit-rate and percentage-rate layers. Analyze in five steps: ① total price comparison to size the difference (the winning tender price may not be below cost nor above the tender price ceiling); ② four-block cost composition positioning (work sections / preliminaries / other items / statutory levies and fees plus taxes and duties); ③ item-by-item all-in unit rate comparison to spot unbalanced rates / rate loading and labour, materials and machinery anomalies; ④ attribution into reasonable / noteworthy / non-compliant; ⑤ issue conclusions (focus = tender pricing level and unbalanced rates / rate loading).