The claim path and the net-amount pricing basis for acceleration costs within preliminaries when the employer demands a shorter duration: offsetting the acceleration increment against the downward adjustment of the mid-term running costs of affected preliminaries items, the limits of the lump-sum preliminaries defence, and the approve-before-executing and claim time-limit procedures (GB/T 50500-2024 Articles 8.11.17, 2.0.32, 8.9.4, 8.9.6, 8.11.3 and 8.11.5; GF-2017-0201 clause 7.9.1)
A claim can be made, and in principle the employer bears the cost, but the claimable amount is a net amount: the actual incremental costs incurred by the contractor in the non-economical use of labour, materials and construction plant to meet the employer's demand, minus the reduction in the mid-term running costs of the affected preliminaries items caused by the shorter duration (GB/T 50500-2024 Articles 8.11.17, 2.0.32 and 8.9.4). A lump-sum preliminaries clause excludes only the increments generated by the contractor's own adjustment of its construction method or its self-initiated early completion; it does not exclude acceleration increments responding to the employer's instruction. To overcome the lump-sum defence, the method must be approved before execution (Article 8.9.6) and a Notice of Claim must be issued within the period agreed in the contract (28 days absent agreement) (Article 8.11.3).
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第8.11.17条、第2.0.32条、第8.9.4条、第8.9.6条、第8.11.3条、第8.11.5条、第7.4.4条、第6.2.13条
- GF-2017-0201 建设工程施工合同(示范文本)第7.9.1项、第7.9.2项
- 建设工程质量管理条例(国务院令第714号,2019修订)第十条
- 中华人民共和国民法典 第八百零三条、第八百零四条、第五百八十四条
- GB 50500-2013 建设工程工程量清单计价规范 第9.11节(已废止,旧合同对照)
Scope
This card answers: when the employer demands a shorter contract duration (early completion) and preliminaries costs rise, on what basis the contractor claims, how much it can claim (the net-amount basis), whether a lump-sum preliminaries clause can be overcome, and what procedure to follow. Basis: GB/T 50500-2024, the China national pricing standard for BOQ, Articles 8.11.17, 2.0.32, 8.9.4, 8.9.6, 8.11.3 and 8.11.5; clause 7.9.1 of the GF-2017-0201 model construction contract; Article 10 of the Regulations on Quality Management of Construction Projects; Civil Code Articles 803, 804 and 584.
Key conclusions
1. Allocation of responsibility: if the employer asks, the employer pays
GB/T 50500-2024 Article 8.11.17: 'For works claims arising from early completion (acceleration) events, the employer and the contractor may bear the corresponding costs on the following principles and adjust the contract price and the duration: 1. where the employer requires early completion of the contract works, the contractor shall formulate reasonable measures to accelerate progress and revise the programme, implement them after the employer's consent, and the resulting early completion costs (acceleration compensation) shall be borne by the employer; 2. where early completion is not required by the employer and the contractor completes early for its own reasons, the employer's consent shall be obtained and the resulting additional costs shall be borne by the contractor.'
Same article: 'Where the employer requires early completion (acceleration) of the contract works, the employer shall bear the additional costs incurred by the contractor in using non-economical labour, materials and construction plant.'
Article 2.0.32 (term): 'Acceleration cost: in the course of implementation of the works, the cost that the employer must additionally pay to the contractor because the contractor, at the employer's request, adopted measures to accelerate progress and thereby shortened the contract duration of the contract works or of phased completion works (including extensions of duration approved by the employer). Acceleration cost includes the additional costs incurred by the contractor in adopting, at the employer's request, measures of non-economical use of labour, construction plant or materials in order to achieve the shorter duration.'
The decisive factor is who initiated the acceleration instruction and where responsibility lies, not 'who benefits': the existence of an employer demand (including an early completion instruction issued through the supervising engineer) is the first requirement of the claim; where the contractor accelerates on its own initiative, or to make up a delay caused by itself, the incremental costs are borne by itself.
2. Amount basis: a net amount, not a one-sided addition
Article 8.9.4: 'Where a variation or an employer-responsibility event causes a material extension or shortening of the contract duration, the employer and the contractor may calculate the upward (downward) adjustment of preliminaries affected by the contract duration using the following formula'; in the formula, the 'extension (shortening) of duration' is calculated under Article 7.4.4, and the 'mid-term running costs of preliminaries items' are calculated under the preliminaries cost breakdown schedule of Article 6.2.13 as the total mid-term running costs of all affected preliminaries items in the contract BOQ.
Accordingly, the claimable amount = the acceleration increment costs of the non-economical labour, material and plant measures taken at the employer's demand (measured as incurred: additional crew wages and overtime, additional machine-shifts and their mobilisation, demobilisation, assembly and dismantling, accelerated amortisation of formwork and other cycled materials, night work, temporary facilities and traffic provisions, each supported by an approved method, process measurement records and site instruction records, and calculation schedules) minus the reduction in the mid-term running costs of the affected preliminaries items caused by the shorter duration (verified per the breakdown schedule). The net amount after offsetting enters the adjustment of the contract price and the duration. Claiming only the increment while ignoring the downward adjustment is the main opening for a global cut at settlement verification.
3. The watershed for overcoming the 'lump-sum preliminaries' defence
- Acceleration increments responding to the employer's instruction: these fall under Article 8.11.17(1), 'the resulting early completion costs (acceleration compensation) shall be borne by the employer', and are outside the preliminaries the contractor must cover under the lump sum.
- Increments from the contractor's own adjustment of its construction method or its self-initiated early completion: borne by the contractor (Article 8.11.17(2)); inside the lump sum.
The procedural precondition for overcoming the defence is in Article 8.9.6: 'Where a variation involves changes to substantive content such as the scope, duration, quality or specifications of the contract works and causes preliminaries items to change, the disadvantaged party proposing to adjust the preliminaries cost shall, before implementation, submit the method it proposes to implement to the other party for review and explain in detail the changes compared with the preliminaries items of the original method. Where the proposed method is confirmed by the employer and the contractor and then executed, the preliminaries cost may be adjusted under Articles 8.9.4 and 8.9.5 of this standard.' The same article also requires 'the contractor to submit in writing the implementation method for the relevant variation, and its requirements for the extension of duration and the additional preliminaries costs arising from the variation, to the employer for review; the employer and the contractor shall calculate and adjust the contract price on the implementation method approved by the employer'.
That is: issue the method first with a comparison against the original -> confirmation by both parties (or approval by the employer) -> implementation -> measurement-based adjustment on the approved method. A late claim, or one without a method comparison, will generally not get past the lump-sum defence or the 'already included in the contract price' defence.
4. Superior law and contract text basis
Regulations on Quality Management of Construction Projects (State Council Order No. 714, 2019 revision) Article 10: 'An awarding entity for a construction project may not force the contractor to bid below cost, and may not arbitrarily compress the reasonable construction duration. The employer may not expressly or implicitly instruct the design unit or the works contractor to violate the mandatory standards for construction projects or to reduce the quality of the construction project.'
GF-2017-0201 clause 7.9.1: 'Where the employer requires the contractor to complete early, the employer shall issue an early completion instruction to the contractor through the supervising engineer, and the contractor shall submit an early completion proposal to the employer and the supervising engineer; the proposal shall include the implementation method, the time to be saved, the additional contract price and other content. Where the employer accepts the proposal, the supervising engineer shall, after consultation with the employer and the contractor, adopt measures to accelerate the progress of the works and revise the construction programme, and the resulting additional costs are borne by the employer. Where the contractor considers the early completion instruction impossible to execute, it shall raise a written objection to the supervising engineer and the employer, and the employer and the supervising engineer shall reply within 7 days after receiving the objection. In no case may the employer compress the reasonable construction duration.' Clause 7.9.2: an early completion bonus may be agreed in the particular conditions.
Civil Code Article 803: 'Where the employer fails to provide raw materials, equipment, the site, funds or technical data at the agreed times and requirements, the contractor may extend the construction period and claim compensation for losses from suspension and idle labour and plant.' Article 804: 'Where the project is suspended or slowed mid-way for reasons attributable to the employer, the employer shall take measures to remedy or reduce the loss and compensate the contractor for losses from suspension, idle labour and plant, re-handling, relocation of machinery and equipment, accumulation of materials and components, and other losses and actual costs.' Article 584: damages 'shall equal the loss caused by the breach, including the interests obtainable after performance of the contract, but may not exceed the loss that the breaching party foresaw or should have foreseen at the time of concluding the contract' - used to frame the causation and foreseeability of the acceleration increment.
5. Procedural time limits (default values absent contractual agreement)
Article 8.11.3: (1) within the period agreed in the contract (28 days absent agreement) after the claim event occurs, submit a written works Notice of Claim stating the cause and the claim intention; (2) within the period agreed in the contract (28 days absent agreement) after the Notice of Claim is issued, submit a written works claim report detailing the cause, the contractual clauses relied on, the costs claimed and/or the days of extension sought, with the necessary records, supporting materials and a cost calculation schedule; (3) claims involving both cost increases and extension of duration shall be raised together; (4) for continuing effects, submit continuing Notices of Claim at the periods agreed in the contract (not exceeding 28 days absent agreement) or at reasonable intervals, listing the cumulative costs and/or days; (5) after the continuing effect ends, submit the final works claim report within the period agreed in the contract (28 days absent agreement). Final paragraph: 'Where the aggrieved party fails to make a claim within the agreed time after the claim event occurs, then except as otherwise agreed in the contract or provided by laws and regulations, it may be deemed to have waived the relevant works claim.'
Article 8.11.5: where the employer considers supplementation necessary, it shall raise a written request for further materials within the period agreed in the contract (14 days absent agreement) after receiving the Notice of Claim, and reply in writing with its position within the period agreed in the contract (28 days absent agreement) after receiving the claim report or the supplementary materials, 'where the employer replies late or makes no reply, the matter may be handled as agreed in the contract, and absent agreement the works claim requested by the contractor may be deemed approved'; once the claim cost is agreed through negotiation, it is paid at the contractual payment percentage in the current progress payment or the interim settlement by construction stage, with the remainder paid in the final account.
Application boundaries
- GB/T 50500-2024 is a recommended standard (GB/T) and is not automatically mandatory where the contract does not invoke it; where the contract still invokes GB 50500-2013, cite Section 9.11 (9.11.1-9.11.3), not 8.11.17.
- The preliminaries adjustment under Article 8.9.4 requires a material extension or shortening of the contract duration on the critical path; the same article states that 'a material extension or shortening of the contract duration caused by a variation or an employer-responsibility event means on the critical path; the additional costs of extended use of existing preliminaries items and of existing construction management personnel arising on non-critical paths shall be deemed included in the preliminaries cost within the contract price'. An acceleration claim must likewise demonstrate a material effect on the critical path and the overall duration.
- At tender stage, 'the compressed duration may not exceed 20% below the quota-based duration' (GB 50500-2013 Article 9.11.1, still citable for older contracts) and the coefficient-based estimation methods of local or association standards (where compression exceeds 20% below the quota-based duration, the labour-material-plant base x the sector coefficient) are methodological references only and cannot replace measurement of actual costs during construction; the coefficients have sectoral and regional scope and may not be applied across regions.
- Where the employer made no demand and the contractor completed early on its own initiative, the incremental costs are borne by the contractor, and the employer's prior consent was required.
- The 28-day notice and report limits and the employer's 14-day supplementation and 28-day reply periods are default limits absent agreement; contractual agreement prevails; they are procedural forfeiture periods, not the limitation period (three years, Civil Code Article 188).
Further reading
- GB/T 50500-2024: Articles 8.11.17, 2.0.32, 8.9.4, 8.9.5, 8.9.6, 7.4.4, 6.2.13, 8.11.3, 8.11.5.
- GF-2017-0201 model construction contract: clauses 7.9.1, 7.9.2.
- Regulations on Quality Management of Construction Projects Article 10; Civil Code Articles 803, 804, 584.
- Old rules and their evolution: GB 50500-2013 Section 9.11 (9.11.1 compression cap of 20% below the quota duration; 9.11.2 cost allocation for employer-required early completion; 9.11.3 daily compensation amount and settlement listing; repealed, referenced for older contracts).
- Regional bases: duration quotas and acceleration cost provisions follow the current pricing documents of the provincial housing and urban-rural development authority where the project is located; verify document numbers and effective dates item by item; coefficients may not be applied across regions.
Keywords
- 赶工措施费
- 提前竣工费用
- 赶工补偿
- 措施项目中期运行费用
- 措施项目费包干
- 压缩工期
- 非经济性人工材料施工机具
- 工程索赔意向通知书