Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-25

Re-decomposition and re-pricing of cost when a design variation moves wire-in-conduit wiring to cable-tray wiring: choosing the variation valuation clause (2013 edition clause 9.3.1 four tiers / 2024 edition clauses 8.9.1~8.9.3 five tiers); the deduction basis for the original conduit and wiring quantities; itemisation and measurement of tray, supports and hangers, and wiring; attribution of demolition of work already done and material write-off, and the rework confirmation procedure

Changing wires from conduit to cable tray is a change of 'item description + construction method': the original conduit rate does not apply to the tray (under the 2013 edition, clause 9.4.2 first re-determines the all-in unit rate on the description actually built, then the four tiers of clause 9.3.1 apply - the contract rate where an applicable item exists, an analogous rate by reference where a similar one exists, and where neither exists the contractor proposes a rate built from published price information and its tender float rate for employer confirmation, or from market-enquiry prices where the published information lacks the item); conduit and wiring quantities are recalculated from the variation instruction and the drawings as actually built and set against the original BOQ for deduction (conduit deducted by length, the length occupied by junction boxes not deducted); the added tray is measured by length (m); whether supports and hangers are listed separately depends on the consumption standard applied (DB11/T 2382-2024 includes support erection, fabrication of non-finished supports being listed separately; SJG 111.3-2022 expressly excludes support fabrication and erection); wiring is recalculated as single-wire length including reservations; demolition and material write-off for rework must rest on a rework confirmation sheet or site instruction record raised within the contractually agreed time - borne by the employer where the cause is not attributable to the contractor, and serving as the basis for rework pricing under chapter 8; raised late, the work is deemed to have caused no rework and is not measured.

Applicable Codes

  • GB 50500-2013 建设工程工程量清单计价规范 第9.3.1条、第9.3.2条、第9.3.3条、第9.4.2条、第9.6.2条、第9.6.3条、第9.14.1条、第9.14.4条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第3.3.7条、第7.3.1条、第7.4.1条、第7.4.2条、第7.6.1条、第7.6.3条、第7.6.4条、第7.6.5条、第8.9.1~8.9.8条
  • GB/T 50856-2024 通用安装工程工程量计算标准 App. D Table D.12.1(配管、配线,code 030412)
  • DB11/T 2382-2024 建设工程施工消耗量标准 第6.4.103条、第6.4.106条、第6.4.111条、第6.4.112条
  • SJG 111.3-2022 城市地下综合管廊工程消耗量标准(Vol. 3 附属设施安装工程)第2.1.17条
  • https://zjt.jiangxi.gov.cn/jxszfhcxjst/wjtz/pc/content/content_1946029306944364544.html

Topic scope

Re-decomposing and re-pricing cost after a design variation moves 'wires in conduit' to 'wires on cable tray': choosing the applicable variation clause (2013 edition clause 9.3 versus 2024 edition clause 8.9), deducting the original conduit and in-conduit wiring quantities, itemising and measuring the new tray, supports and hangers, and wiring, the attribution and confirmation procedure for demolishing work already done and writing off materials, and the knock-on adjustment of preliminaries.

Core conclusions

I. Characterisation: a change of 'item description + construction method', not a mere quantity change

Conduit (listed under the conduit and wiring items, see GB/T 50856-2024 table D.12.1, code 030412) and cable tray are two different BOQ items: conduit splits by material, diameter and laying method; tray splits by material, type, size and laying location (trunking and tray are likewise separate items). Changing the laying method from 'in conduit' to 'on tray' changes both the item description (material, construction method) and the construction conditions. The commentary to GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.9.1 lists 'change of material' and 'change of construction method' among the price-influencing changes of item description, and protection of finished works, access restrictions, transport mode and plant usage among the changes of construction conditions. 2013-edition path: clause 9.4.2 first - where the description of any item in the design drawings (variations included) does not match the tender BOQ and moves that item's cost, the all-in unit rate is re-determined per the relevant provisions of clause 9.3 on the description of the item actually built and the contract price adjusted; the rate determination of clause 9.3.1 then applies.

II. Choosing the pricing clause

  • 2013 edition, clause 9.3.1, four ascending tiers (substance): (1) where the BOQ contains an item applicable to the varied works, use that item's rate; but where the quantity deviation exceeds 15%, adjust the rate per clause 9.6.2; (2) where none is applicable but a similar item exists, refer to the similar item's rate within a reasonable range; (3) where neither applies, the contractor proposes a rate from the variation documents, the measurement rules and pricing method, the published price information of the cost administration agencies and its own tender float rate, for the employer to confirm before adjusting; (4) where neither applies and the published price information lacks the item, the contractor proposes a rate from lawfully based market prices obtained by market enquiry, for the employer to confirm before adjusting.
  • Application here: the original conduit rate does not apply to the tray item (description and construction method both changed) and must not be converted into a tray rate by a bare factor; if the original BOQ already holds a tray item of the same material, specification and laying location, tier (1) hits and the contract rate applies; different material, specification or location, or only trunking in the BOQ, leaves tier (2), referring to the similar item's rate with the differing elements converted (trunking is not tray - no direct application); with no tray or similar item in the BOQ, re-build the rate under tier (3) for employer confirmation; where the published price information omits the tray (or that size), tier (4) applies with market-enquiry prices, keeping the enquiry records.
  • 2024 edition, clause 8.9.1, five ascending tiers: (1) same construction conditions + same item description -> use the corresponding contract rate; (2) same conditions + similar description, or similar conditions + same description -> the similar item's contract rate converted and adjusted; (3) same conditions + different description, or different conditions + same description -> negotiate a market-reasonable all-in rate informed by similar items' contract-rate rules and the tender level; (4) different conditions + different description -> negotiate by analogy with similar items of comparable works; (5) where a variation reducing or cancelling items materially changes the construction conditions during execution, negotiate the rate from the actual execution, market prices, the contract-rate rules and the tender level. Where the BOQ quantity change stays within 15% (inclusive), clause 8.9.1 applies; beyond 15% (exclusive), clause 8.9.2: for added items and quantities, reasonably lower the contract and new rates in light of the procurement discounts from larger volumes; for reduced items and quantities, reasonably raise them in light of the lost procurement discounts.
  • Lump-sum contracts: 2024 edition clause 8.9.3 - where the contract provides that contract rates apply to variation pricing, adjust per clauses 8.9.1 and 8.9.2; where it provides otherwise, the employer and contractor negotiate the all-in rate from the actual execution and market prices, informed by the priced BOQ rules and the tender level.

III. Deducting the original conduit and in-conduit wiring quantities

  • 2024 edition clauses 7.4.1 and 7.4.2: in unit-rate and lump-sum contracts alike, compare the variation instruction issued or confirmed by the employer and the drawings as actually built against the contract drawings; the differing measured-works items are the variation items, measured under the contractually agreed national and industry quantity take-off standards and the supplementary rules; under unit-rate contracts the items and quantities are recalculated from the variation instruction and the drawings as actually built and compared with the BOQ items and quantities as corrected for BOQ errors, to fix the added and deducted items and quantities (a mismatch between contract drawings and the BOQ is a BOQ error - corrected under unit-rate contracts, not adjusted under lump-sum contracts). 2013-edition projects deduct by comparing the cancellation scope fixed by the variation order or instruction against the priced BOQ, under the contractually agreed measurement rules.
  • Length deduction wording: the conduit quantity is the length per the design drawings, without deducting the lengths occupied by junction boxes, lighting boxes, switch boxes, socket boxes and junction cabinets in the run (DB11/T 2382-2024 clause 6.4.103); the tray and trunking quantity is the design-shown length, without deducting bends and tees (clauses 6.4.106 and 6.4.111). Conduit is therefore deducted whole along the laying route, boxes counted separately by the piece, not deducted through their bodies; junction boxes and cabinets are counted by the design-shown number.
  • The wiring quantity is the single-wire length per the design drawings (reservations included); where design and codes are silent, the reserve for incoming and outgoing wires at boards, boxes and cabinets follows the table: height + width for panels, cabinets and boards (by panel-face size); 0.30 m per wire for standalone starters and busway joint boxes and the like (from the centre of the installed item); 1.00 m from the pipe outlet at ground level to a power junction box (at the pipe mouth); 1.50 m for connections between the supply and the wires in conduit; 1.50 m for service wires leaving the building (all at the pipe mouth). Once the change to tray reroutes the wires, their bends and reservations change too: the wiring quantity follows the new route and must not be carried over from the old pulling quantity; wiring in trunking or tray follows the corresponding items (wiring in trunking; multi-core flexible wires laid in trunking, tray or on supports).

IV. Decomposition of the added content (enumeration)

  1. Tray body: length (m) per the design drawings, items split by material, type (steel / GRP / aluminium / mesh; channel / ladder / tray), specification and laying location.
  2. Tray supports and hangers: whether listed separately turns on the consumption standard applied and the contract - DB11/T 2382-2024 clause 6.4.106 includes support erection in the trunking and tray installation consumption, fabrication of non-finished supports being listed separately under clause 6.4.135 of that standard; SJG 111.3-2022 clause 2.1.17 states that the tray installation items include assembling, welding, hole cutting, fitting of dividers and covers, earthing, accessories and repairs, excluding fabrication and erection of tray supports, which are charged separately. No double counting under either: where supports sit inside the tray installation item, no separate support-erection charge (the fabrication of non-finished supports listed per the standard).
  3. Wiring (wires): single-wire length including reservations, split by lighting or power circuits, cable type and core count / cross-section; lighting-circuit wires over 4 mm2 run under the power-circuit items.
  4. Junction boxes and junction cabinets: counted by the design-shown number, by type and surface or flush mounting; two-, three- and four-gang boxes follow the corresponding items with construction consumption factors of 1.50, 2 and 2.50 (DB11/T 2382-2024 clause 6.4.109).
  5. Where conduit is laid without wires, a separate wire-drawing item applies (clause 6.4.108) - after the change to tray this usually falls away on the converted sections and is cancelled with the deduction.
  6. Material and specification factors: steel tray with a main-structure design thickness greater than 3 mm runs under the steel-tray installation items with labour and plant x 1.20; stainless-steel tray runs under the steel-tray items with labour and plant x 1.10 (DB11/T 2382-2024 clause 6.4.106; SJG 111.3-2022 clauses 3 and 4 to the same effect); trough boxes run by material and size under the channel-tray items with labour and plant x 1.08 (SJG 111.3-2022 clause 5); ladder tray is compiled without covers, and with covers it runs under the channel-tray items. The factors differ by the standard in force - take them from the consumption standard named in the contract.
  7. If cables (not wires) move from conduit to tray: use the cable-laying items, mind the core-count conversion (compiled for five cores: single-core x 0.30, two-core x 0.48, three-core x 0.75, four-core x 0.90, six-core x 1.10) and aluminium conductors at labour and machines x 0.70 (SJG 111.3-2022 clauses 7 and 8).

V. Demolition of work already done and material write-off: boundaries and attribution

  • Attribution: where the design variation is instructed by the employer and is not attributable to the contractor, rework and write-off fall on the employer; contractor-caused cases (unauthorised work, work not per instruction) fall on the contractor. 2013 edition: clause 9.14.1 (for sundry items outside the contract or events not attributable to the contractor, the employer shall promptly issue a written instruction and provide the information, and the contractor shall promptly raise a record request on receipt) and clause 9.14.4 (where the contractor starts work on a recordable matter without the employer's certification, the cost is the contractor's unless the employer agrees in writing).
  • 2024-edition procedure (clause 7.6.1): where a variation or an employer-responsibility event causes rework of part or all of the completed works, or write-off or scrapping of purchased or processed materials, the contractor shall raise a rework confirmation request in writing within the time agreed in the contract and provide the supporting documents; raised late, it is deemed that no rework or material write-off or scrapping occurred - the rework quantity is not measured and the related cost is not compensated.
  • Content of the rework confirmation sheet (clause 7.6.3): (1) where the rework quantity can be measured from the construction drawings or the variation instruction, the sheet shall state which drawings or instruction govern the calculation; (2) where it cannot be measured from drawings or the instruction, the employer and contractor shall fix the rework items and their quantities on the sheet; (3) for written-off or scrapped purchased and processed materials, the sheet shall fix the material name, specification, brand, quantity, unit or total price and the disposal method. Save as otherwise agreed, the unit price of written-off or scrapped materials is the main-material cost inside the contract rate; scrapped materials may be valued by recovery or discount.
  • Attribution and measurement (clause 7.6.4): where the cause is a variation or employer responsibility, the rework items and quantities and the written-off or scrapped materials and quantities in the sheet are the measured quantities of the rework works and the basis for pricing the rework works under chapter 8; where the cause is contractor responsibility, the rework quantities are not measured, the cost is borne by the contractor, and the sheet cannot serve to compute rework compensation. Where rework materially changes the contract period, the preliminaries may be computed per clause 8.9.4 (clause 7.6.5).
  • Boundary: conduit already laid (and wires already drawn) within the cancellation scope confirmed by the variation instruction can claim rework demolition and write-off, subject to three conditions: 'variation instruction or employer confirmation + rework confirmation sheet or site instruction record + disposal method (recovery / discount / scrapping)'; recoverable conduit and wires are offset at recovery or discount value, the unrecoverable part counted as scrap loss; work demolished or continued without an employer instruction is at the contractor's cost. Where the employer omits the original work without making good the contractor's cost and gain under another payment item or substitute work, claim under 2013 edition clause 9.3.3 (compensation of cost and profit) / 2024 edition clause 8.9.8 (compensation of loss cost and reasonable expected gain).

VI. Knock-on adjustment of preliminaries

  • 2013 edition clause 9.3.2: where a variation changes the construction method and thereby the preliminaries, the contractor shall submit the proposed method to the employer beforehand, explaining the changes from the original method; once confirmed, adjust on three lines - the mandatory HSE provisions computed per clause 3.1.5 on the preliminaries actually changed; preliminaries priced by unit rate follow clause 9.3.1; preliminaries priced by lump sum (or factor) follow the actual adjustment amount multiplied by the contractor's tender float rate. Without prior submission and confirmation, the variation is deemed not to affect the preliminaries, or the contractor to have waived adjustment. Clause 9.6.3: where the quantity change of clause 9.6.2 drives related preliminaries, preliminaries priced by factor or single lump sum rise with added quantities and fall with reduced ones.
  • 2024 edition clause 8.9.6: where a variation touches the contract scope, period, quality or specifications materially and changes the preliminaries, the disadvantaged party proposing adjustment shall submit its proposed method to the other for review before execution, detailing the comparison; once confirmed, adjust per clauses 8.9.4 and 8.9.5; clause 8.9.7 sets the late-claim forfeiture and deemed-approval rules. Clause 8.9.4: where a variation or employer-responsibility event extends or shortens the contract period materially (critical path), compute the preliminaries increase (decrease) from the period impact, the time-related running costs of preliminaries following the cost breakdown table of clause 6.2.13; delayed use and extra staff on non-critical paths are deemed included in the contract price. Clause 8.9.5: extra preliminaries needed to complete the variation (plant absent from site measured by actual type, count and machine-shifts and priced at the corresponding dayworks plant rates, or per clause 8.6.3 where no dayworks list exists; temporary works absent from site measured by type, count and duration and priced at reasonable market rates agreed by the parties). Under clause 3.3.7, where preliminaries are priced on a lump-sum basis the contractor carries the risk of preliminaries rising from its own method changes, adjustable only for variations, works under provisional sums not fully foreseen, or employer causes; under clause 7.3.1, preliminaries in the priced BOQ are in principle not re-measured or adjusted, one exception being preliminaries changed by a variation, handled per clause 7.4.4.
  • Practical upshot: scaffolding, temporary site power, secondary handling and the like do not rise automatically because the wires moved to tray; only where the variation materially changes the preliminaries (a material period extension, extra lifting platforms or high-level access equipment) is a pre-execution submission and confirmation required, failing which adjustment is deemed waived.

Applicable boundaries

  • Version premise: projects tendered or contracted before 2025-09-01, or contracting for GB 50500-2013, run on clauses 9.3 / 9.4 / 9.6 / 9.14; GB/T 50500-2024 takes effect on 1 September 2025 and is a voluntary (GB/T) standard whose mandatory application rests on the contract or local rules - its wording must not be applied straight onto 2013-edition contracts.
  • Contract type: the pricing and deduction logic above assumes unit-rate contracts; for lump-sum contracts, whether contract rates serve variation pricing depends on the contract (2024 edition clause 8.9.3), and BOQ errors are not adjusted in lump-sum contracts (clause 7.4.1).
  • Measurement and consumption wording must follow the standard named in the contract: DB11/T 2382-2024 and SJG 111.3-2022 differ on whether tray installation includes support erection and on the cantilever factors - mixing them across regions double-counts or omits the supports and hangers.
  • Wires and cables must not be conflated: if the medium moved to tray is a cable, price under the cable-laying items with the core-count conversion, never under the wiring items.
  • This card covers pricing and measurement rules only, not rate levels; a re-built rate still needs employer confirmation to take effect.

Further reading

  • GB 50500-2013 clauses 9.3.1 (with the tender float rate formula), 9.3.3, 9.4.2, 9.6.2, 9.6.3, 9.14.1 and 9.14.4, with their commentaries.
  • GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 7.4.1~7.4.2 (variation measurement), 7.6.1~7.6.5 (rework confirmation sheets and material write-off), 8.9.1~8.9.8 (variation pricing and preliminaries adjustment), 3.3.7, 7.3.1 and 6.2.13 (preliminaries cost breakdown table).
  • GB/T 50856-2024 Appendix D table D.12.1 'conduit and wiring (code 030412)': item setting, description and measurement rules.
  • DB11/T 2382-2024 clauses 6.4.103~6.4.114 (conduit, wiring, trunking and tray measurement, and the reservation length table 6.4.112); SJG 111.3-2022 volume 3 clause 2.1.17 (notes of the power distribution and cable laying works: tray, trough box and cable-laying factors).
  • The provincial circular forwarding the 2024 edition's effective date and application requirements (Jiangxi Provincial Department of Housing and Urban-Rural Development): https://zjt.jiangxi.gov.cn/jxszfhcxjst/wjtz/pc/content/content_1946029306944364544.html

Keywords

Cited By