Re-measurement and price adjustment rules after quantity changes caused by variations or BOQ errors: recalculating from the variation instruction and the actual construction drawings, the separate track for BOQ errors, the 15% banded unit-rate adjustment, and the scheme-approval precondition for pricing preliminaries and new preliminary items (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 7.4.2-7.4.4, 8.2.1, 8.9.1-8.9.2; GB 50500-2013 clauses 9.3.1, 9.3.2, 9.6.2)
Re-measurement after a variation takes as its basis the quantities recalculated from 'the variation instruction issued or confirmed by the employer and the actual construction drawings', compared with the BOQ quantities after the BOQ errors have been corrected, to determine the added or deleted variation items and their quantities; differences between the contract drawings and the contract BOQ are BOQ errors (corrected under unit-rate contracts, not adjusted under lump-sum contracts). Where the quantity difference is within 15% (15% inclusive), the unit rate is set under GB/T 50500-2024 clause 8.9.1; beyond 15% (exclusive), clause 8.9.2 adjusts downward on increase and upward on decrease in light of labour and material purchase concessions (the 2013 edition corresponds to the four tiers of clause 9.3.1 and clause 9.6.2). Preliminaries adjustment requires prior submission of the proposed scheme confirmed by the employer and the contractor; failure to submit is deemed to cause no preliminaries adjustment or a waiver of the right to adjust. New preliminary items take the added temporary works and plant machine-shifts priced from the approved scheme; the added cost of extended use of existing preliminaries and supervisory staff from variations off the critical path need not be measured.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第7.4.2条、第7.4.3条、第7.4.4条、第8.2.1条、第8.9.1条、第8.9.2条、第8.9.4条、第8.9.6条、第8.9.7条
- GB 50500-2013 · Code of Valuation with Bill Quantity of Construction Works 第9.3.1条、第9.3.2条、第9.6.2条
- GF-2017-0201《建设工程施工合同(示范文本)》第10.4条
- DB11/T 2382-2024 · Standard for Construction Consumption of Construction Works (Beijing) 第6.1.2条、第6.4.103~6.4.114条
- SJG 111.4-2022 · Consumption Standard for Urban Utility Tunnel Works (Volume 4) (Shenzhen) 第3.2.1条
- GB/T 50856-2024 · Standard for measurement of general mechanical, electrical, plumbing and fire services 第3.0.10条
Topic positioning
The operational chain of 'how much to recalculate and how to adjust price and quantity' after a variation (including tray routing, length and level changes after coordinated MEP layout): the basis of re-measurement, the separate track from BOQ errors, the 15% banded unit-rate adjustment, the pricing preconditions for preliminaries and new preliminary items, the re-measurement basis for tray-type items, and the work-height efficiency loss that follows level changes. It answers 'how to adjust'; liability for 'whether to adjust' is in the companion card.
Core conclusion
1. Basis of re-measurement (original text of GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 7.4.2 and 7.4.3) Unit-rate contracts: 'For a variation under a unit-rate contract, the work items and quantities shall be recalculated from the variation instruction issued or confirmed by the employer and the actual construction drawings, and compared with the work items and quantities of the BOQ after its errors have been corrected, to determine the added or deleted variation items and their quantities.' Lump-sum contracts (clause 7.4.3): 'The variation instruction issued or confirmed by the employer and the actual construction drawings shall be compared with the contract drawings; the work item list of the differing part constitutes the variation items.' General statement: 'Whether the works adopt a unit-rate contract or a lump-sum contract, comparing the variation instruction issued or confirmed by the employer and the actual construction drawings with the contract drawings, the work item list of the differing part constitutes the variation items, and the variation shall be measured under the national and industry quantity take-off standards agreed in the contract and any supplementary measurement rules. Differences between the contract drawings and the contract BOQ are BOQ errors: unit-rate contract works shall correct their BOQ errors as provided, and the BOQ errors of lump-sum contract works shall not be adjusted.' -> Practical point: trays are recalculated segment by segment for length and level from the confirmed varied drawings and compared with 'the BOQ quantities after error correction' to obtain the difference; the original tender BOQ quantities must not be used directly as the comparator (otherwise the error quantities leak into the variation quantities), nor may error quantities be priced as variations. For quantity changes caused by BOQ errors, clause 8.2.1 likewise uses 15% as the line: within 15% (inclusive) clause 8.9.1 applies, beyond 15% (exclusive) clause 8.9.2.
2. The 15% bands and the unit-rate adjustment Clause 8.9.1 (change not exceeding 15%, inclusive): set the all-in unit rate tier by tier under 'same construction conditions x same item description' - (1) same conditions and same item description: the applicable contract rate; (2) same conditions with a similar item description, or similar conditions with the same item description: the contract rate of an analogous BOQ item, converted and adjusted; (3) same conditions with a different item description, or different conditions with the same item description: a market-reasonable all-in unit rate negotiated with reference to analogous pricing rules and the tender level; (4) different conditions and different item description: negotiated with reference to the all-in unit rates of analogous BOQ items of similar works; (5) where the deletion or cancellation of BOQ items materially changes the construction conditions: negotiated per the specific circumstances, market prices, the contract pricing rules and the tender level. The adjustable elements fall into two classes: item-description class (material changes, construction method changes, effects on other work sections and the like) and construction-condition class (foundations, heights of works, element sizes, construction season, protection of completed areas, access restrictions, material transport modes, plant usage, attendance within main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions and the like). Clause 8.9.2 (exceeding 15%, exclusive): where BOQ items and quantities increase, the contract rates and the new all-in unit rates may be reasonably reduced under clause 8.9.1 combined with the effect of 'price concessions on labour and material purchases brought by the increased quantities'; where they decrease, the rates may be reasonably increased for the loss of such concessions. GB 50500-2013 counterparts (where the contract adopts the old edition): clause 9.3.1 four tiers - 1 where an applicable item exists, its rate applies, but where the quantity deviation exceeds 15% the rate of that item is adjusted under clause 9.6.2; 2 where no applicable item exists but an analogous one does, refer to the analogous rate within a reasonable range; 3 where neither exists, the contractor proposes a rate for the varied item from the variation documents, the measurement rules and pricing methods, the published price information issued by the cost authorities and its tender discount factor, adjusted after confirmation by the employer (separate discount factor formulas for tendered and non-tendered works); 4 where the published price information lacks the item, the contractor proposes a rate from lawfully based market prices obtained by market survey, adjusted after confirmation by the employer. Clause 9.6.2: 'Where the quantities increase by more than 15%, the all-in unit rate of the increased part of the quantities shall be reduced; where the quantities decrease by more than 15%, the all-in unit rate of the remaining part of the quantities shall be increased.'
3. Precondition for the preliminaries adjustment (GB 50500-2013 clause 9.3.2; 2024 edition clauses 8.9.6 and 8.9.7 to the same effect) Original text: 'Where a variation changes the construction scheme and thereby changes the preliminaries, a contractor claiming adjustment of the preliminaries shall submit the scheme it proposes to implement to the employer beforehand and explain in detail the changes compared with the preliminaries of the original scheme. The proposed scheme is implemented after confirmation by the employer and the contractor,' adjusting as provided: 1 the mandatory HSE provisions are computed for the actually changed preliminary items under clause 3.1.5; 2 preliminaries priced on unit rates follow clause 9.3.1 for the unit rates of the actually changed items; 3 preliminaries priced as lump sums (or on percentages) adjust for the actually changed items, taking the contractor's tender discount factor into account, i.e. the adjustment equals the actual adjustment multiplied by the contractor's tender discount factor under clause 9.3.1. 'If the contractor fails to submit the scheme it proposes to implement to the employer for confirmation beforehand, the variation shall be deemed not to cause any adjustment of the preliminaries, or the contractor shall be deemed to have waived the right to adjust the preliminaries.'
4. Measurement of new preliminary items (composite supports etc.) (2024 edition clause 7.4.4) 'Changes to preliminaries caused by a variation shall be measured, under the scheme prepared by the contractor specifically for the variation and approved by the employer or the content actually occurring, for the additional construction supervisory staff, the additionally erected temporary works and the other added construction measures (works) quantities required by the variation'; added temporary works are measured by the type fixed in the approved scheme, the actual quantities and the duration of use; added plant by type, number of units and machine-shifts consumed; where the variation changes the contract period, adjustment follows clause 8.9.4. 'The added cost of extended use of existing preliminaries and supervisory staff caused by variations off the critical path need not be measured, and may be treated as already included in the preliminaries within the contract price.' The build-up of new composite support costs should be decomposed by the working content of the line items (to avoid double counting): support fabrication is by kg, with labour, materials and plant including flat steel, welding rods, anti-rust paint and welding machines (see the metal support fabrication items); where support erection and painting are already within the working content of the tray/pipe installation items (the tray installation working content covers 'assembly, erection, fixing, bends, tees or crosses, covers, separators, accessories and support-and-hanger erection, earthing'), they must not be priced again per set; proprietary seismic supports are billed separately 'per set/pair', with main materials including anchor bolts and undercut anchors; equipment, pipe and accessory installation items already include the fabrication, erection and painting of supports, hangers and base steel (GB/T 50856-2024 clause 3.0.10), listed separately under Annex N or Annex M only where special design requirements exist.
5. Re-measurement basis for tray-type items Tray/wireway bodies are measured in m of length against the design drawing dimensions, and 'the quantity shall not deduct the length occupied by bends and tees' (DB11/T 2382-2024 clauses 6.4.106 and 6.4.111); the cost of bend fittings is already in the tray installation items and must not be priced again per piece; conduit 'shall not deduct the length occupied by the junction boxes, lighting boxes, switch boxes, socket boxes and junction cabinets in the run, and is measured by length against the design drawing dimensions' (clause 6.4.103), with boxes/cabinets counted as pieces against the drawings; supports 'are measured in kilograms by single-piece weight as shown on the drawings; single-piece weight means the weight of one bracket arm or one upright' (SJG 111.4-2022 clause 3.2.1). -> Suggested breakdown table: four columns 'original BOQ quantity / quantity after variation / reduction / addition', decomposed item by item as 'straight lengths (banded by size) + bends and tees (no extra length, no extra erection) + supports (kg) + seismic supports (per set/pair) + fire compartment penetration sealing (measured separately)', never lumped into a single 'tray m'.
6. Consequences of level changes: work-height efficiency loss Where raised levels change the installation working height, besides recalculating the length/routing, the labour consumption adjusts under the work-height provisions: 'where equipment or materials are installed at heights above 6 m, the labour efficiency loss caused by excess height is calculated by multiplying the labour consumption of the corresponding items by the excess-height coefficient' - coefficients 0.10 up to 10 m, 0.20 up to 30 m, 0.50 up to 50 m (DB11/T 2382-2024 clause 6.1.2; to the same effect in note 7 of Volume 4 of the Jing Jian Fa [2021] No. 201 budget consumption standard for general installation). This is a labour consumption adjustment and still presupposes a liability finding: level changes caused by the contractor's own coordinated layout must not be claimed on this basis.
Applicability boundaries
- Version premise: GB/T 50500-2024 has replaced GB 50500-2013 (the 2013 edition repealed/replaced). Contracts agreeing the 2013 edition follow clauses 9.3.1, 9.3.2 and 9.6.2; contracts agreeing the 2024 edition follow sections 7.4, 8.2 and 8.9; the tests are the same, but the 2013 edition uses the 'contractor's tender discount factor' as an element of variation rates and of lump-sum preliminaries adjustment while the 2024 edition does not present it in the same formula - confirm the contract edition and particular conditions before applying.
- The measurement premise is 'a variation instruction issued or confirmed by the employer / confirmed detailed design drawings'; unconfirmed variations made on the contractor's own initiative are not measured (the evidentiary substitute rules for variations without records are in the companion card).
- The two 15% bands are mutually exclusive: within 15% (inclusive) goes to clause 8.9.1, beyond 15% (exclusive) to clause 8.9.2; 15% itself falls in the 8.9.1 band.
- The preliminaries adjustment requires 'submission of the scheme before implementation and confirmation by the employer and the contractor' to preserve the right; late submission is generally unsupported; the cost of extended use of existing preliminaries from off-critical-path variations need not be measured.
- The item measurement bases include local and industry standards (DB11/T 2382-2024, SJG 111.4-2022); projects in other regions follow the local current consumption/measurement standards; BOQ measurement follows the national and industry quantity take-off standards agreed in the contract (for example GB/T 50856-2024).
Further reading
- GB/T 50500-2024 'Standard for BOQ Pricing of Construction Works' clauses 7.4.2 and 7.4.3 (variation measurement, unit-rate/lump-sum contracts), clause 7.4.4 (measurement of preliminaries caused by variations), clause 8.2.1 (BOQ errors), clause 8.9.1 (five tiers of rate setting within 15%), clause 8.9.2 (rate adjustment beyond 15%), clause 8.9.4 (variation period), clauses 8.9.6-8.9.7 (prior scheme approval for preliminaries and the consequences of failure to submit).
- GB 50500-2013 'Code for BOQ Pricing of Construction Works' clause 9.3.1 (four tiers of variation rates + the contractor's tender discount factor formulas), clause 9.3.2 (preliminaries adjustment and waiver of the right to adjust), clause 9.6.2 (repricing on the 15% quantity difference).
- GF-2017-0201 'Model Construction Contract' clause 10.4 (variation valuation principles, 14-day submission / 7-day review / 14-day approval time limits, silence beyond the limit deemed approval).
- DB11/T 2382-2024 'Consumption Standard for Construction Works' clauses 6.4.103-6.4.114 (conduit, wiring, wireways and trays measurement and the reservation table), clause 6.1.2 (excess-height coefficient table); SJG 111.4-2022 clause 3.2.1 (supports by single-piece weight in kg); GB/T 50856-2024 clause 3.0.10 (equipment and pipe installation items include the fabrication, erection and painting of supports, hangers and base steel).
Keywords
- 工程变更计量
- 重新计量
- errors and omissions in the BOQ
- 15%工程量偏差
- 承包人报价浮动率
- 措施项目费调整
- 桥架工程量
- 超高降效