Whether rate-priced mandatory HSE provisions (statutory safety provisions) adjust at settlement: three adjustment doors (quantity-linked base, legal and policy change, major variation or raised standards), the rate-lump-sum principle regardless of actual spend, and the settlement base plus the 2013/2024 edition gap
Mandatory HSE provisions (railway: work safety funds; GB/T 50500-2024: statutory safety provisions) are non-competitive: settlement value = settlement base x prescribed rate, lump-sum, never rising or falling with the contractor's actual spend. Only three doors open: (1) the base (finally confirmed work-item costs) - GB 50500-2013 clause 9.6.3 adjusts rate or single-price preliminaries both ways with quantity; (2) legal and policy change after the contract base date - 2013 clause 11.2.3 and 2024 clause 8.8.1 adjust when the authorities revise the standards mid-works; (3) variation or employer-raised site standards - scheme confirmed before execution (2013 9.3.2; 2024 8.9.6), silence forfeits. Settlement review recomputes all preliminaries per 10.3.3; interim-listed figures are no basis.
Applicable Codes
- GB 50500-2013 · Code of Valuation with Bill Quantity of Construction Works 第3.1.5、9.3.2、9.6.2、9.6.3、11.2.3条
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第3.2.5、7.3.1、8.2.2、8.8.1~8.8.5、8.9.6、8.10.4、10.3.3条
- 建办〔2005〕89号《建筑工程安全防护、文明施工措施费及使用管理规定》
- DB 61/T 5126-2025《建设工程工程量清单计价标准》(省级费用规则配套依据)
- 《陕西省建设工程费用规则》(2025 版)
- 《湖北省建筑安装工程费用定额》(2024 版)
- TB 10801-2024 第3.11.11条(铁路安全生产费口径)
- https://zfcxjs.tj.gov.cn/xxgk_70/
- https://zfcxjs.tj.gov.cn/ztzl_70/jjjgcjjjyth/jjbz/gcjjzyjt/202301/W020230131622951597349.pdf
Positioning
Whether rate-priced mandatory HSE provisions can adjust at settlement, through which doors, and on what base - for settlement review, interim settlement, disputes and audit - with the GB 50500-2013 versus GB/T 50500-2024 gap.
Core conclusions
1. Pricing nature: non-competitive does not mean on-actuals
GB 50500-2013 clause 3.1.5 (mandatory): 'Safety and civilised-construction provisions must be priced per state or provincial / sectoral rules and never compete.' The commentary: the tenderer may not seek discounts nor the bidder compete it (per Jian Ban [2005] No. 89, under mandatory standards management). GB/T 50500-2024 clause 3.2.5 continues: 'priced per state and provincial / sectoral rules; non-competitive'. Hence settlement value = settlement base x prescribed rate - neither the discounted bid nor the actual outlay. Non-competition binds pricing; earmarked on-actuals use binds fund management - two dimensions; actual spend never overturns base x rate. Local fee norms confirm: priced at tender per the rate, and at settlement 'only the work safety liability insurance computes on actuals, the rest stays on rate' - the rare on-actuals opening.
2. Door one: base change -> two-way quantity linkage
GB 50500-2013 clause 9.6.3: 'Where quantities change per 9.6.2 and preliminaries change accordingly, rate- or single-price preliminaries increase with quantity growth and decrease with reduction.' Three requisites: (1) a quantity deviation over 15% per 9.6.2; (2) causation - the preliminaries actually respond (hoarding length, temporary works scale, safety staffing, machine-shifts); (3) pricing form - rate or single-price. Adjustment = (settled minus contracted work-item cost) x contract rate, signed. Edition gap: 2024 narrows full linkage - 7.3.1: 'priced preliminaries shall not be measured or adjusted save as agreed and as follows: 1 work-item-listed preliminaries and contractually measurable items (7.2.1, 7.2.2); 2 statutory safety provisions per contract; 3 variation-caused changes (7.4.4); 4 BOQ-error changes (8.2.2, 8.2.3); 5 unforeseeable provisional-sum works (7.7.2)'. And 8.2.2: after BOQ-error correction, 'save statutory safety provisions and 7.2.1(2) items, the preliminaries list and contract duration shall not adjust', with a safety-provision formula. Under 2024, quantity gaps link only statutory safety provisions and measurable preliminaries - night work, double handling, winter / rainy additions no longer follow.
3. Door two: legal and policy change -> new standards
2013 clause 11.2.3: total-price preliminaries settle on the priced list, 'safety and civilised-construction provisions per 3.1.5'; commentary: 'where the authorities adjust them during the works, the provisions adjust accordingly' - the anchor for retro-adjustment, keyed to the authority's rate document and its effective date, never locked by the bid. 2024 clause 8.8.1: enactments, amendments, repeals and interpretive changes after the base date adjust per the published rules. During extended durations the direction splits by fault (8.8.2~8.8.4): contractor delay - no rise, falls apply; employer delay - no fall, rises apply; neither party - on actuals save agreement. 8.8.5: overheads and profit never adjust on policy grounds. Local rules often freeze some total-price preliminaries (winter / rainy, night work, double handling, surveying) against BOQ errors, policy change, variations and site records - but the same rules keep HSE provisions on rate and base, so policy rate changes still pass this door.
4. Door three: major variation / employer-raised standards
2013 clause 9.3.2: on variation changing the scheme and preliminaries, the bidder submits the intended scheme to the employer beforehand, detailing the changes; after confirmation: '1 safety and civilised-construction provisions recompute per 3.1.5 on the changed items' (never the bid-float factor); '2 unit-priced preliminaries per 9.3.1'; '3 total- or rate-priced preliminaries adjust on the changed items x the float factor'. Silence forfeits adjustment. 2024 clause 8.9.6 mirrors: before execution, submit the intended scheme with comparisons; adjust per 8.9.4-8.9.5 after confirmation. Additional works (8.10.4) add: plant (extended and new), temporary works, safety / civilised-construction / environment provisions, site management, and other necessary preliminaries - statutory safety provisions per the rules. Policy-raised standards (door two, with an authority document) differ from employer-driven excellence / smart-site / green standards (door three, needing instruction or contract clause and a pre-approved scheme). Local norms often leave award-driven upgrades on actuals when agreed.
5. Fixing the settlement base
- The base is the finally confirmed work-item cost (plus contractually measurable preliminaries or norm labour / labour + plant per the local fee norm) - not the bid list, not the submitted draft; taken after 7.1-7.2 measurement.
- The final account recomputes preliminaries: 10.3.3 - 'recompute interim preliminaries and attendance... all preliminaries of the completed works per 7.3 and chapter 8, including statutory safety adjustments; interim-listed figures are no basis'.
- Recomputation never reopens the lump sum: still bound by 7.3.1's bar and its five exceptions; safety provisions enter only via the 8.2.2 formula, variation rules or policy adjustment.
- Three checks: the cited edition (2013 full linkage vs 2024 limited); the rate current and post-base-date; the base consistent with settled quantities (re-priced 15%-plus items shift it).
Applicable boundaries
- For BOQ-priced building and municipal works; sectoral works follow their own rules (railway: TB 10801-2024 clause 3.11.11).
- 2024 contracts take the narrowed linkage; being recommended, particular conditions prevail.
- This card prices: it neither negates earmarked-use supervision nor supports 'actuals above rate' claims (save locally insured items).
- Price-fluctuation adjustment (8.7 and Appendix A) and provisional-price fixing (8.4) are separate mechanisms - they never change base x rate.
- Retro-adjustment follows the authority's effective date; absent retroactive terms, never back-apply to finished work.
Further reading
- GB 50500-2013 clauses 3.1.5, 9.3.2, 9.6.2-9.6.3, 11.2.3.
- GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 3.2.5, 7.3.1, 8.2.2, 8.8.1~8.8.5, 8.9.6, 8.10.4, 10.3.3.
- Jian Ban [2005] No. 89; provincial fee rules (Shaanxi with DB 61/T 5126-2025; Hubei 2024 with on-actuals insurance); railway TB 10801-2024 clause 3.11.11 and TB 10811-2024 rates; Tianjin publication pages for verification.