Checking drawing-BOQ contradictions (bill of quantities defects) before bid pricing, and responsibility boundaries (GB/T 50500-2024)
Drawing-BOQ contradictions are "BOQ defects" (extra items/omissions/mismatched characteristics/quantity deviations, Article 2.0.27). Responsibility by pricing mode: unit-rate contracts—work-item BOQ by the tenderer (Article 6.1.6, defects adjusted at settlement per Section 8.2); lump-sum contracts—by the bidder (Article 6.1.7, may supplement the priced BOQ and bears the difference); preliminaries always the bidder's (Article 6.1.5); per-item pricing is lump sum, unadjusted at settlement (Article 6.2.3). Check by risk order: item characteristics, quantities, completeness of items, units and measurement rules, work-content interfaces, drawing versions, preliminaries, provisional sums.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准
Topic Positioning
An operational framework for checking "drawing vs BOQ" contradictions before bid pricing: first allocate BOQ defect responsibility by contract pricing mode, then check key contradiction points in risk order with handling strategies, per GB/T 50500-2024 Standard for Measurement and Valuation of Construction Works by Bills of Quantities.
Core Conclusions
"Drawing-BOQ contradiction" is the term "BOQ defect" (Article 2.0.27): extra items, omissions/misdescriptions, mismatched item characteristics, and quantity deviations. Responsibility by pricing mode: under unit-rate contracts the completeness and accuracy of work-item BOQs rest with the tenderer (Article 6.1.6), defects adjusted at settlement per Section 8.2—the bidder still reviews to price reasonably and keep the adjustment channel open; under lump-sum contracts the bidder is responsible (Article 6.1.7)—may request written clarification, or supplement and price the priced BOQ itself, bearing quantity gaps and omissions; preliminaries are always the bidder's under either mode (Article 6.1.5); per-item priced items are lump sums, unadjusted at settlement (Article 6.2.3)—their work content must be checked item by item against drawings. Check in risk order: (1) item characteristics vs drawing details; (2) quantities vs recalculation (spot-check large-volume items like earthwork/concrete/rebar); (3) completeness of items (omissions/extra items); (4) units and measurement rules (per national and industry measurement standards); (5) work content and construction interfaces (embedded parts, additional layers, terminations); (6) drawing versions and changes (check version numbers against the drawing index, review opinions, Q&A minutes); (7) preliminaries supplemented per one's own construction scheme; (8) provisional sums/provisional totals copied unchanged—specialty work interfaces and coordination-fee basis.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to pre-pricing review of BOQ tenders under the GB/T 50500-2024 system. Lump-sum review is the bidder's own risk defense line—the most urgent; unit-rate review serves reasonable pricing and the settlement adjustment channel. Exception: unit-priced items stated as "provisional quantities" (not adjusted for defects). Where tender documents or sector rules provide otherwise, those prevail.
Further Reading
See GB/T 50500-2024: Article 2.0.27 (terminology), Article 4.1.4 (BOQ compilation matching contract mode), Articles 6.1.5-6.1.7 (bidder review and responsibility), Article 6.2.3 (per-item lump-sum pricing), Section 8.2 (price adjustment for BOQ defects under unit-rate contracts); building measurement rules per GB/T 50854-2024.
Keywords
Related Cards
- →
Preliminaries bid at zero - can an increase be claimed at final account? (principle-plus-exception framework, with clarification of Clause 10.3.3)
Ordinary preliminaries bid at zero constitute a lump-sum price and are not reimbursed at final account (GB/T 50500-2024, 6.2.3, 6.1.5, 7.3.1); judicial practice treats this as a concession. 'Recalculation and determination' at final account under 10.3.3 only means recalculating all preliminaries contained in the executed works under Section 7.3 and Chapter 8 - amounts listed in interim settlement by construction stage are not a basis, and the zero bid remains effective. However, a zero bid for mandatory health, safety and environmental (HSE) provisions (railway term: statutory work safety levy (earmarked funds)) violates the non-competitive rule (3.2.5) and must be topped up at the standard rate; substantive changes caused by variations (7.4.4, implementation plan subject to employer approval) or employer-caused deferred use, dismantling/re-erection, addition or re-provision of preliminary items (3.3.7) may be adjusted through the prescribed procedure.
- →
Quantity-price risk boundaries compared across lump-sum, unit-rate (re-measurable) and cost-plus contracts
The three contract types form a gradient of quantity and price risk transferred from contractor to employer: lump sum = both quantity and price fixed (the contractor bears quantity variances and cost fluctuations within the agreed range, except variations, changes in laws and regulations, and force majeure); unit-rate (re-measurable) = unit rate fixed, quantities measured as executed (BOQ errors / omissions and quantity variances lie with the employer); cost-plus = costs reimbursed as actually incurred (nearly all quantity and price risk lies with the employer). Basis: MOC Decree No. 107, Article 12; GB/T 50500-2024, Clauses 3.3.1-3.3.8; GB/T 50875-2013, Clauses 3.3.6-3.3.8.
- →
Four-tier progressive identification of high-risk bid-pricing clauses in tender documents (rejection clauses -> substantive requirements -> price locking -> performance funding)
Read tender documents as risk-allocation contracts: (1) rejection clauses (the seven statutory grounds of Implementation Regulations Article 51 as baseline, sector measures expand with catch-all clauses; below-cost is the hidden trap); (2) substantive requirement clauses ("must/shall/shall not" wording + deviation tables—non-response is statutory rejection); (3) price-locking clauses (GB/T 50500-2024: risk-scope clarification, three elements of price adjustment, lump-sum by total, lump-sum per item, preliminaries responsibility, unbalanced bidding); (4) performance funding clauses (Article 3.4.8 14-item checklist, performance deposit <=10%, seven quality-reserve agreements).
- →
Unbalanced bidding: definition, common tactics, risks for both employer and contractor, and response paths
Unbalanced bidding is a tender-pricing method that adjusts the unit prices of BOQ items after the total tender price is fixed in order to maximize returns ('total unchanged, unit prices mismatched'); it is lawful in itself. Common tactics: front-loading, quantity gaming, and high pricing of provisional items. The employer bears cash-flow occupation, settlement overruns and audit exposure; the contractor bears blowback from quantity misforecasting, locked-in all-in unit rates and compliance risks. The normative hedge: clear evaluation criteria in the tender documents plus organized adjustment at the bid-clarification stage (without changing the total price, confirmed by both parties).
- →
Risk allocation for incomplete item descriptions in the BOQ (BOQ errors and omissions): employer responsible under re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts, contractor responsible under lump-sum contracts, contractor always responsible for the bill of preliminaries
Per GB/T 50500—2024, an incomplete item description is an "error or omission in the BOQ": under re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts the employer (tenderee) is responsible for the completeness of billed items, the accuracy of item descriptions and the accuracy of quantities, and at settlement the all-in unit rate is re-rated on the basis of the characteristics actually constructed to adjust the contract price; under lump-sum contracts the contractor is responsible and no adjustment is made except for provisional quantities; for the bill of preliminaries, the contractor is responsible under both re-measurable and lump-sum contracts.
- →
Liability for errors or omissions in the tender BOQ: GB 50500-2013 vs GB/T 50500-2024 (2013 Clause 4.1.2 mandatory provision vs 2024 Clause 3.1.8 split by unit-rate/lump-sum contract)
GB 50500-2013, Clause 4.1.2 (mandatory provision): 'the tender BOQ must form part of the tender documents, and its accuracy and completeness shall be the tenderer's responsibility.' GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 3.1.8, instead splits liability by the contract pricing method: for unit-rate contracts, the accuracy and completeness of the divisional and elemental BOQ rest with the employer (tenderer) - bidders may not alter it on their own, defects adjust the price per Section 8.2, with a 15% quantity change as the threshold; for lump-sum contracts they rest with the contractor, who may supplement the list, and per 8.2.3 the contract price and time are not adjusted for BOQ defects (except unit-priced items with provisional quantities); the item-priced measure list is in all cases the contractor's responsibility. The 2024 edition was approved by MOHURD Announcement No. 212 of 2024, is effective from 1 September 2025 with GB 50500-2013 repealed simultaneously, and changed from a mandatory (GB) to a recommendatory (GB/T) national standard.
Cited By
- ←
Deciding claims to adjust the contract price for omitted items in the tender BOQ (BOQ errors) during performance: risk is allocated by the contract pricing method and the BOQ section in which the omission falls - omission from the work-section bills under a unit-rate contract may rest with the employer and be adjusted under section 8.2; a lump-sum contract is in principle not adjusted (except provisional quantity items); the bill of preliminaries is always the contractor's responsibility - with judicial limits and points of procedure and proof
Whether adjustment is possible depends not on the omission itself but on the contract pricing method and the BOQ section in which the omission falls: GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 3.1.8 provides that under a unit-rate contract the accuracy and completeness of the work-section BOQ rest with the employer (adjustment by re-measurement under section 8.2 may be claimed, with a 15% increase or decrease in quantities as the divide between cl. 8.9.1 and 8.9.2); under a lump-sum contract they rest with the contractor, and save for unit-priced items in provisional quantities the contract price and contract time are not adjusted for BOQ errors (cl. 6.1.7 and 8.2.3); the bill of preliminaries compiled on a per-item basis is always the contractor's responsibility, with only statutory safety provisions and similar exceptions adjustable. Where the contract provides settlement at a fixed price and adjustment is claimed for major changes in labour cost or key material prices, the court will not support it (Article 9 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12).
- ←
Tender BOQ versus priced BOQ - relationship and effect compared: preparing and pricing parties, document status, content differences, accuracy responsibility (2013 edition clause 4.1.2 versus 2024 edition clause 3.1.8 split by unit-rate and lump-sum contracts), benchmark role in settlement (quantity variance under 9.6.2, variation valuation under 9.3.1), effect of unilateral amendment, and the order of precedence of contract documents
The two bills are not two documents but two stages of one bill: the tender BOQ is prepared by the tendering employer stating 'quantities and item descriptions' and issued with the tender documents as the common basis of tender pricing (GB 50500-2013 clauses 2.0.2, 4.1.2 (mandatory provision) and 4.1.3); the priced BOQ is the priced version in which the bidder enters all-in unit rates and lump sums and which becomes part of the contract documents after award (2013 edition clause 2.0.3; the 2024 edition calls it the 'contract bill of quantities', clauses 2.0.18 and 3.4.5), its all-in unit rates being the contract unit rates used for settlement and contract price adjustment. Responsibility follows the basic split 'quantities by the tendering employer (employer), prices by the bidder': clause 4.1.2 of the 2013 edition puts it on the tendering employer in all cases; GB/T 50500-2024 clause 3.1.8 changes course - under unit-rate contracts the employer answers for the measured-works bill (bidders may not alter it; defects are repriced under section 8.2), under lump-sum contracts the contractor answers, and preliminaries are always the contractor's. In settlement, quantity variance follows clause 9.6.2 of the 2013 edition (deviation beyond 15%: the all-in unit rate is lowered for the portion of quantity increase above 15%, and raised for the remaining portion after a decrease beyond 15%), and variation valuation follows the three-tier cascade of clause 9.3.1 (applicable -> analogous by reference -> a rate proposed by the contractor from the pricing methods and published price information combined with the tender price fluctuation rate, submitted to the employer for confirmation).
- ←
Bills of quantities errors (item description mismatches, wrong or missing items, quantity deviations): determination, attribution of responsibility and the quantity-then-price adjustment sequence, including the split between unit-rate and lump-sum contracts and the 15% threshold rule
Where the BOQ and the drawings are inconsistent, the sequence is 'decide which prevails -> attribute the defect -> remeasure and adjust the price': under a unit-rate contract the BOQ prevails, under a lump-sum contract the contract drawings and specifications prevail (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 3.4.7); for unit-rate contracts, BOQ errors in the schedule of divisional work items lie with the employer - remeasure per clause 7.2.1, band the change per clause 8.2.1 at the 15% boundary (15% inclusive), and where not exceeded set the all-in unit rate adjustment per clause 8.9.1; for lump-sum contracts BOQ errors lie with the contractor, and the contract price is not adjusted except for items described as 'provisional quantities' (clauses 4.1.4, 4.1.6 and 6.1.7).
- ←
Handling the mismatch between construction-drawing quantities and tender BOQ quantities: measurement of actually completed quantities under GB 50500-2013 Chapter 8 and the 15% deviation price adjustment of Section 9.6 (including the divergence between the two lump-sum contract regimes of Clauses 8.3.1/8.3.2), against GB/T 50500-2024 Sections 7.2/8.2/8.9 routing the rules by contract type
GB 50500-2013 Clause 8.2.1 (a mandatory provision) requires that 'quantities shall be determined by the quantities of the contract works that the contractor has completed and that are to be measured'; the quantities stated in the tender BOQ are only estimated quantities and the common basis for tender pricing, and the final account quantities are determined by the quantities actually completed and to be measured, calculated by the contractor under the calculation rules of the current national measurement standards, not by the BOQ quantities. Clause 8.3.1 provides that for lump-sum contracts formed by tendering on a bill of quantities basis the quantities are still calculated under Section 8.2 (i.e. quantity differences remain adjustable), which diverges from Clause 8.3.2: for lump-sum contracts formed by letting the works on the basis of construction drawings and budgets examined and approved, except for variations, the BOQ quantities are the final settlement quantities. GB/T 50500-2024 instead routes the rules by contract type: for unit-rate contracts the employer bears the BOQ defects, the works are re-measured under Clause 7.2.1 and the price adjusted via Clause 8.2.1 (15% as the boundary) and then Clauses 8.9.1/8.9.2; for lump-sum contracts Clause 7.2.2 allows no re-measurement, and Clause 8.2.3 provides that 'the contract price and the time for completion shall not be adjusted for defects in the contract bill of quantities' (except items priced at provisional quantities). Directional rule for quantity deviations beyond 15%: where the increase exceeds 15%, the all-in unit rate of the increased portion is adjusted downwards; where the decrease exceeds 15%, the all-in unit rate of the remaining portion after the decrease is adjusted upwards.
- ←
Choice criteria for re-measurable / lump-sum / cost-plus contracts under GB/T 50500-2024, the coverage of lump sums, and the precedence between contract drawings and the BOQ on inconsistency (Articles 3.4.2, 3.4.6)
Per GB/T 50500-2024 Article 3.4.2, the employer chooses the pricing mode per the design depth of tender drawings, technical difficulty, scale, implementation plan, BOQ compilation time and pricing risk: works with clear requirements, controllable measurement and pricing and low fluctuation risk suit lump-sum contracts; unclear requirements, high difficulty and many uncontrollables suit re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts; particularly urgent or complex, high-risk works suit cost-plus. Article 3.4.6: the lump sum covers all costs of completing the contract works per the drawings and specification under the tender documents; the priced BOQ merely reflects the price build-up, BOQ-defect prices deemed included, its unit rates usable for pricing variations and additional works, provisional-quantity items priced under re-measurable rules; on inconsistency during performance, the re-measurable contract follows the BOQ, the lump-sum contract the drawings and specification.
- ←
Quantity basis for cost estimation when BOQ quantities are overstated: costs follow actual quantities (taken off from the drawings) rather than BOQ quantities, and the effect of overstated BOQ quantities on the contract price (re-measurement and adjustment under re-measurable contracts / no adjustment under lump-sum contracts)
Cost estimation must be based on actual quantities (the drawing-based quantities calculated from the dimensions shown on the design drawings under the measurement rules agreed in the contract), not on the bill of quantities (BOQ) quantities - BOQ quantities are provisional (estimated) figures on the revenue/tendering basis, whereas cost follows actual resource consumption; the two sets of accounts must be kept separately, with the difference carried as a separate quantity variance. This rests on Article 17 of the Cost Management Regulations for State-Owned Enterprises (Guo Fa [1984] No. 34) - costs must be accounted for from actual consumption and actual prices, and enterprises must not substitute planned cost, estimated cost or norm-based cost for actual cost - and on Article 4.1.5 of GB/T 50500-2024, under which quantities of work-item BOQ entries under a re-measurable (unit-rate) contract are provisional quantities to be determined by re-measurement. The effect of overstated BOQ quantities on revenue depends on the contract type: under a re-measurable (unit-rate) contract the works are re-measured against the actual construction drawings, so the inflated portion earns no payment (it is an error in the BOQ, rectified and repriced under Articles 7.2.1 and 8.2.1, with 15% as the threshold); under a lump-sum contract the work-item BOQ need not be re-measured and BOQ errors are not adjusted (Articles 7.2.2, 4.1.6 and 8.2.3), so an overstated BOQ quantity against less work actually done yields a quantity variance gain. The only opening is BOQ entries whose item description states a provisional quantity: under both contract types they are re-measured and adjusted under the re-measurable-contract rules.
- ←
Handling tender document vs construction drawing inconsistencies in bidding: statutory objection/clarification deadlines and contractual pricing risk allocation
Objections to tender documents must be raised in writing at least 10 days before the bid deadline; the tenderer replies within 3 days, suspending the process until reply (Implementation Regulations Article 22); clarifications/modifications affecting bid preparation must be notified in writing at least 15 days before the deadline, or the deadline is extended (Article 21). On substance per GB/T 50500-2024 3.4.5/3.4.6: unit-rate contracts—BOQ prevails over drawings, BOQ defects on the tenderer, price adjusted per Section 8.2; lump-sum contracts—contract drawings and specifications prevail, defects borne by the contractor; preliminaries and per-item priced items are always the contractor's regardless of contract type. Not objecting before bidding does not change this allocation.
- ←
Linking the five document types — contract, drawings, BOQ, site instructions / variation records, settlement — and managing the settlement chain of evidence
Using unified codes as the bond, lineage relations attached via linking fields, on-the-spot linkage in the workflow, and a basis for settlement ledger as the master index, build contract, drawings, BOQ, site instructions / variation records, and settlement into a traceable chain of evidence: every settlement amount must be able to state which contract clause it relies on, which BOQ item it corresponds to, which drawing it comes from, and which site instruction / variation record triggered it; only when the four elements are complete and certification and sign-off are complete is it included in settlement.
- ←
Determining quantities where drawing dimensions are incomplete: three-tier fallback plus provisional quantities at the tender/preparation stage; re-measurement plus five-tier progressive determination at the settlement stage
Where drawings are incomplete, quantities are determined along two tracks. At the preparation stage, values are taken by the three-tier fallback "design documents -> approved project execution plan (construction methodology and site organization) -> code/quota norm measurement rules"; where accurate measurement remains impossible, the item description (work item specification) notes "provisional quantities" and an estimated quantity is provided (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 4.1.4, 4.1.6). At the settlement/dispute stage, re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts are re-measured against the final construction drawings (not the as-built drawings); where the drawings cannot reflect the work, determination follows the five-tier progression from certification and sign-off to site inspection (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clauses 4.3.5, 4.3.6).
- ←
Methods and liability basis for ensuring completeness of the bill of preliminaries at construction main (general) contracting tender stage (GB/T 50500-2024)
Per GB/T 50500-2024 clause 6.1.5, whether a re-measurable (unit-rate) or lump-sum contract is used, the completeness and accuracy of the bill of preliminaries are the bidder's (contractor's) responsibility, and the bidder bears the risk of the reasonableness of its tender price; preliminary items not priced as required may be deemed included in the all-in unit rates, totals and tender total of other billed (BOQ) items, with no re-pricing or adjustment at construction payment settlement (3.5.4). The contractor should guard against omissions via the six-category 'including but not limited to' framework in 3.2.6 + three cross-checks (bill of preliminaries vs project execution plan (construction methodology and site organization)/tender documents/similar projects) + site inspection + written clarification; statutory safety provisions are non-competitive (3.2.5) and must not be omitted or priced at zero.
- ←
Statutory boundaries of what a "lump-sum price" actually covers: dual quantity-and-price lump sums and non-lumpable events (GB/T 50500-2024 / GB/T 50875-2013)
In practice a "lump-sum price" corresponds to a fixed total price, whose core is the "dual lump sum of quantities and price": quantity risk within the drawings, cost fluctuation within the agreed band (5% absent agreement), and the contractor's own management risks are self-borne; but variations, changes in laws and policies, fluctuation beyond the band, owner-caused events, force majeure and government-priced materials are not waived by the word "lump sum". The standard prohibits clauses imposing uncapped risk allocation to one party, such as "all risks" (GB/T 50500-2024 Article 3.3.1).
- ←
No price adjustment for BOQ defects in lump-sum contracts (BOQ quantities below drawings): the four-layer rule of GB/T 50500-2024 and the reversal of the 2013 edition's Clause 8.3.1 measure-and-value rule
Under GB/T 50500-2024 (effective 2025-09-01; GB 50500-2013 simultaneously repealed), BOQ quantities in lump-sum contracts below the drawings constitute a "BOQ defect" and are not adjusted during performance: 2.0.7 bars using changes in BOQ items/quantities as an adjustment basis; 3.4.6 deems defect prices included in the lump sum with contract drawings and specifications governing; 4.1.6 disallows adjustment for defect-induced price changes; 7.2.2 allows no re-measurement of the BOQ; 7.4.1 defines drawing-vs-BOQ differences as defects not adjustable. The 2013 Clause 8.3.1 (an ordinary clause, not among that edition's 15 mandatory ones) allowing measure-and-value for BOQ-tendered lump-sum contracts has been deleted and reversed. Only two openings remain: (1) items marked "provisional quantities" re-measured per unit-price rules (4.1.6, 7.2.2 item 2); (2) differences between contract drawings and as-built drawings are variations measured under 7.4.3 (7.2.2 item 3) - unchanged drawings with undercounted BOQs are no variation.
- ←
A seven-step process for systematically checking BOQ errors and omissions (BOQ defects) and defect-liability handling
With tender drawings, the calculation-standard appendices, and the tender documents as three benchmarks, check in seven steps: "procedure check -> five-element verification -> item completeness -> preliminary items -> other items -> data format -> check records": prevent omissions using drawing back-check + construction-process walk-through + appendix comparison; any item listed without a drawing basis is a surplus item. After finding defects: clarify and correct via tender query and clarification at the compilation stage; under re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts the employer bears liability and adjusts per GB/T 50500-2024 Section 8.2; under lump-sum contracts the contractor bears liability and no adjustment is made.