Tender BOQ versus priced BOQ - relationship and effect compared: preparing and pricing parties, document status, content differences, accuracy responsibility (2013 edition clause 4.1.2 versus 2024 edition clause 3.1.8 split by unit-rate and lump-sum contracts), benchmark role in settlement (quantity variance under 9.6.2, variation valuation under 9.3.1), effect of unilateral amendment, and the order of precedence of contract documents
The two bills are not two documents but two stages of one bill: the tender BOQ is prepared by the tendering employer stating 'quantities and item descriptions' and issued with the tender documents as the common basis of tender pricing (GB 50500-2013 clauses 2.0.2, 4.1.2 (mandatory provision) and 4.1.3); the priced BOQ is the priced version in which the bidder enters all-in unit rates and lump sums and which becomes part of the contract documents after award (2013 edition clause 2.0.3; the 2024 edition calls it the 'contract bill of quantities', clauses 2.0.18 and 3.4.5), its all-in unit rates being the contract unit rates used for settlement and contract price adjustment. Responsibility follows the basic split 'quantities by the tendering employer (employer), prices by the bidder': clause 4.1.2 of the 2013 edition puts it on the tendering employer in all cases; GB/T 50500-2024 clause 3.1.8 changes course - under unit-rate contracts the employer answers for the measured-works bill (bidders may not alter it; defects are repriced under section 8.2), under lump-sum contracts the contractor answers, and preliminaries are always the contractor's. In settlement, quantity variance follows clause 9.6.2 of the 2013 edition (deviation beyond 15%: the all-in unit rate is lowered for the portion of quantity increase above 15%, and raised for the remaining portion after a decrease beyond 15%), and variation valuation follows the three-tier cascade of clause 9.3.1 (applicable -> analogous by reference -> a rate proposed by the contractor from the pricing methods and published price information combined with the tender price fluctuation rate, submitted to the employer for confirmation).
Applicable Codes
- GB 50500-2013 建设工程工程量清单计价规范 第2.0.2、2.0.3、4.1.2、4.1.3、9.3.1、9.6.2条
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第2.0.18、3.1.8、3.4.5、6.1.6、6.1.7、6.1.9、7.2.1条、第8.2节、第8.9节
- GF-2017-0201 建设工程施工合同(示范文本) 通用合同条款第1.5款
- 中华人民共和国民法典 第四百六十五条
- 中华人民共和国招标投标法 第四十六条
- 中华人民共和国招标投标法实施条例 第五十七条
- DBJ/T 15-115-2016 广东省建设工程交易规范 第6.7.2条
Positioning
Sorts out the relationship between the tender bill of quantities (tender BOQ) and the priced bill of quantities (priced BOQ): they are not two independent bills but two states of one bill - the tender-stage state (unpriced; the tendering employer issues the quantities and item descriptions) and the bid-and-award-stage state (priced; the bidder enters the rates and the bill becomes a contract document). This card compares the two bills, sets out the benchmark role of the priced BOQ in settlement (the two routes of quantity variance and variation valuation), the effect of unilateral amendment, and the order of precedence when the bill conflicts with the drawings.
Core conclusions
1. Verbatim definitions
- Tender BOQ (GB 50500-2013 clause 2.0.2): 'a bill of quantities prepared by the tendering employer on the basis of the national standard, the tender documents, the design documents and the actual conditions of the site, issued with the tender documents for tender pricing, including its notes and schedules.'
- Priced BOQ (GB 50500-2013 clause 2.0.3): 'a bill of quantities in the bid documents, forming part of the contract documents, in which prices have been entered, arithmetic errors (if any) have been corrected and which the contractor has confirmed, including its notes and schedules.'
- The 2024 counterpart, the 'contract bill of quantities' (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 2.0.18): 'the priced bill of quantities in which the contractor entered at tender the accepted tender total price, lump sums and all-in unit rates, with prices corrected through bid clarification or explanation, used to show the detailed build-up of the contract total price reported by the contractor and the analysis of the all-in unit rates, including its notes and schedules.' It further provides: 'the contract bill of quantities shall form part of the documents of a unit-rate contract; the all-in unit rates and/or lump sums in the contract bill of quantities may form part of the documents of a lump-sum contract, but the billed items and quantities of the bill of quantities are not part of a lump-sum contract, and the risk of any defect in the bill of quantities is borne by the contractor.'
2. The two bills compared
| Dimension | Tender BOQ | Priced BOQ (called the contract bill of quantities in the 2024 edition) |
|---|---|---|
| Preparing / pricing party | Prepared by the tendering employer (or the construction cost consultant it commissions): quantities and item descriptions, no prices | The bidder enters the all-in unit rates, lump sums and total price (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 6.1.9: the bidder must 'fully enter ... the all-in unit rates of all billed items and the prices of lump-sum and/or total-price items, and each billed item shall carry one price only'; entries not made as required may be clarified under clause 3.5.4, the relevant prices being deemed included in the tender total price) |
| Document status and role | Part of the tender documents and the common basis of pricing (clause 4.1.2 of the 2013 edition is a mandatory provision: 'the tender BOQ must form part of the tender documents, and its accuracy and completeness shall be the responsibility of the tendering employer'; clause 4.1.3: it is the basis of BOQ-based pricing, and one of the bases for preparing the tender price ceiling and the tender price, for calculating or adjusting quantities, for claims, etc.) | Part of the bid documents; after award it becomes part of the contract documents (2024 edition clause 3.4.5: 'the priced BOQ shall form part of the contract documents, and the contract unit rates may be used for pricing adjustments of the contract price' - save that per-item priced measured-works and preliminary items follow the lump-sum contract rules); the contract unit rate is the pricing benchmark for settlement and adjustment |
| Content differences | Item codes, item names, item descriptions, units of measurement, quantities + notes and schedules (quantities and descriptions only) | Adds the all-in unit rates, lump sums and tender total price on top of all the above (including prices corrected through bid clarification or explanation); quantities are not re-determined |
| Accuracy / completeness responsibility | Clause 4.1.2 of the 2013 edition: always the tendering employer's. Clause 3.1.8 of the 2024 edition splits by contract type: for unit-rate contracts, completeness of item listing, accuracy of descriptions and accuracy of quantities of the measured-works bill rest with the employer (tendering party), and bidders may not alter them at tender; for lump-sum contracts the contractor answers, and bidders may supplement billed items from the tender drawings and technical standards and price them | The pricing risk rests with the bidder: under unit-rate contracts the bidder must still check the bill (clause 6.1.6), and BOQ defects are handled by adjusting the price and the contract total under section 8.2; under lump-sum contracts the bidder may supplement the item listing, descriptions and quantities and price them, and answers for the completeness and accuracy of the priced BOQ - save for unit-rate measured-works items stated as provisional quantities, the contract price is not adjusted for BOQ defects (clause 6.1.7); completeness of listing and accuracy of pricing of the bill of preliminaries are the contractor's responsibility under both unit-rate and lump-sum contracts (clause 3.1.8) |
3. The benchmark role of the priced BOQ in settlement
- Quantity variance is referred to it (GB 50500-2013 clause 9.6.2): 'for any tender BOQ item, adjustment may be made where the quantity deviation exceeds 15% owing to the quantity deviations provided in this section or the variations provided in section 9.3. Where the quantity increases by more than 15%, the all-in unit rate of the increased portion of quantity shall be reduced; where the quantity decreases by more than 15%, the all-in unit rate of the remaining portion after the decrease shall be increased.' Section 9.6 gives two adjustment ranges (Q1 > 1.15Q0 and Q1 < 0.85Q0); the parameters mean: S the settled price of the measured works after adjustment, Q1 the final quantity completed, Q0 the quantity stated in the tender BOQ, P1 the re-adjusted all-in unit rate, P0 the all-in unit rate entered by the contractor in the bill of quantities; quantity changes carry corresponding increases or decreases of preliminary items priced by coefficient or as a single lump sum.
- Variation valuation applies its all-in unit rates in tiers (GB 50500-2013 clause 9.3.1): (1) where the priced BOQ contains a rate applicable to the varied works, that rate applies; but where the variation changes the quantity of that item with a deviation beyond 15%, the rate is adjusted under clause 9.6.2; (2) where there is no applicable but a similar item, the rate of the similar item may be referenced within a reasonable range; (3) where there is neither an applicable nor a similar item, the contractor proposes a rate for the varied works from the variation documents, the measurement rules and pricing methods, the published price information issued by the construction cost administration bodies and the contractor's tender price fluctuation rate, and adjustment follows upon the employer's confirmation (the fluctuation rate being computed by the formula of that clause for invited-tender and non-invited-tender works); (4) where there is neither, and the published price information carries no price, the contractor proposes a rate on the basis of the variation documents, the measurement rules, the pricing methods and lawful market prices obtained by market survey, and adjustment follows upon the employer's confirmation.
- The corresponding 2024 route (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 7.2.1): the measured-works bill of a unit-rate contract is re-measured from the actual construction drawings provided by the employer and the issued and confirmed variation instructions; differences between the contract-drawing measurement and the priced BOQ are 'BOQ defects', and the contract price is adjusted under section 8.2; differences between the contract drawings and the actual construction drawings are variations, adjusted under the variation rules; measured-works items priced per item are neither re-measured nor adjusted.
4. Effect of unilateral amendment of the priced BOQ
Once the priced BOQ is awarded together with the bid documents it forms part of the contract documents, and its prices are substantive contract content which neither party may alter unilaterally: a contract formed according to law is protected by law (Article 465 of the Civil Code), and amendment requires the consent of both parties; Article 46 of the Bidding and Tendering Law and Article 57 of its Implementation Regulations require the principal terms - subject matter, price, quality, performance period - to be consistent with the tender and bid documents, and 'the tendering employer and the winning bidder may not thereafter conclude any other agreement that departs from the substantive content of the contract'; local trading rules state accordingly that a contract signed after award for tasks beyond the tender documents, or amending the substantive working content of the bid, departs from the substantive content and is void (DBJ/T 15-115-2016, clause 6.7.2 and its commentary).
5. Order of precedence when the bill conflicts with the drawings
- Order of precedence of the contract documents (GF-2017-0201, General Conditions, clause 1.5): unless the particular conditions provide otherwise, the sequence is: (1) the contract agreement; (2) the letter of acceptance; (3) the letter of tender and its appendices; (4) the particular conditions and attachments; (5) the general conditions; (6) the technical standards and requirements; (7) the drawings; (8) the priced BOQ or the budget - that is, the drawings prevail over the priced BOQ.
- The substantive rule in the pricing standard (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 3.4.5): in a unit-rate contract, where during performance the contract drawings are inconsistent with the tender measured-works item list, the bill of quantities prevails (and the contract price is adjusted under section 8.2); in a lump-sum contract, where the contract drawings and the contract specification are inconsistent with the priced BOQ, the contract drawings and the contract specification prevail.
- The two do not conflict: the order of precedence settles the hierarchy between the contract documents (alterable by the particular conditions), while clause 3.4.5 settles which side bears the quantity-variance risk of a unit-rate contract; the two apply in combination.
Application boundaries
- The clause numbers of this card span two systems: 2.0.2, 2.0.3, 4.1.2, 4.1.3, 9.3.1 and 9.6.2 belong to GB 50500-2013 (superseded by GB/T 50500-2024, the China national pricing standard for BOQ, the current 2024 edition); 2.0.18, 3.1.8, 3.4.5, 6.1.6, 6.1.7, 6.1.9 and 7.2.1 belong to the 2024 edition. Under a 2024 lump-sum contract the 2013 conclusion that 'the bill is in all cases the tendering employer's responsibility' yields the opposite result - confirm the pricing method of the contract and the applicable edition before citing (where the contract provides for the old edition, that agreement governs).
- 'Quantities by the tendering employer (employer), prices by the bidder' is the default split for the measured-works bill and does not apply to the bill of preliminaries - under both unit-rate and lump-sum contracts, completeness of listing and accuracy of pricing of preliminaries are the contractor's responsibility.
- The 15% deviation adjustment addresses only unit-rate priced measured-works items; per-item (lump-sum) measured-works and preliminary items, and items stated as provisional quantities, follow other rules.
- The drawing-versus-bill order of precedence is subject to the particular conditions; clause 1.5 of the model forms is the default order 'unless otherwise agreed in the particular conditions' - check the particular conditions first.
- This card does not deal with specific sums, fluctuation-rate values or regional percentage rates; actual adjustment must follow the contract and the pricing basis at the location of the works.
Further reading
- GB 50500-2013: clauses 2.0.2 and 2.0.3 (terms), 4.1.2 and 4.1.3 (preparation of the bill of quantities), 9.3.1 (price adjustment for variations), section 9.6 (quantity deviation and adjustment formulas).
- GB/T 50500-2024: clause 2.0.18 (contract bill of quantities), clause 3.1.8 (split of responsibility for accuracy and completeness of the bill), clause 3.4.5 (contract type and treatment of drawing/bill inconsistency), clauses 6.1.6, 6.1.7 and 6.1.9 (checking and completion of the bid), clause 7.2.1 (measurement of the works), section 8.2 (BOQ defects), section 8.9 (variation pricing).
- GF-2017-0201 model construction contract, General Conditions clause 1.5 (order of precedence of the contract documents).
- Civil Code of the PRC, Article 465; Bidding and Tendering Law of the PRC, Article 46; Implementation Regulations for the Bidding and Tendering Law, Article 57.
- DBJ/T 15-115-2016 (Guangdong construction project trading code), clause 6.7.2 (no other agreement departing from the substantive content) and its commentary.
Keywords
- 招标工程量清单
- 已标价工程量清单
- 合同清单
- errors and omissions in the BOQ
- 合同文件解释顺序
- 工程变更估价
- 工程量偏差15%
- pricing on a bill of quantities basis