Liability for errors or omissions in the tender BOQ: GB 50500-2013 vs GB/T 50500-2024 (2013 Clause 4.1.2 mandatory provision vs 2024 Clause 3.1.8 split by unit-rate/lump-sum contract)
GB 50500-2013, Clause 4.1.2 (mandatory provision): 'the tender BOQ must form part of the tender documents, and its accuracy and completeness shall be the tenderer's responsibility.' GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 3.1.8, instead splits liability by the contract pricing method: for unit-rate contracts, the accuracy and completeness of the divisional and elemental BOQ rest with the employer (tenderer) - bidders may not alter it on their own, defects adjust the price per Section 8.2, with a 15% quantity change as the threshold; for lump-sum contracts they rest with the contractor, who may supplement the list, and per 8.2.3 the contract price and time are not adjusted for BOQ defects (except unit-priced items with provisional quantities); the item-priced measure list is in all cases the contractor's responsibility. The 2024 edition was approved by MOHURD Announcement No. 212 of 2024, is effective from 1 September 2025 with GB 50500-2013 repealed simultaneously, and changed from a mandatory (GB) to a recommendatory (GB/T) national standard.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第3.1.8、4.1.4、6.1.6、8.2.1、8.2.3条
- GB 50500-2013 · Code of Valuation with Bill Quantity of Construction Works 第4.1.2条(已废止)
- 住房城乡建设部公告2024年第212号(2024-11-26,www.mohurd.gov.cn)
Topic Positioning
The normative evolution of liability allocation when the tender BOQ contains miscalculations or omissions (BOQ defects): comparison between GB 50500-2013, Clause 4.1.2 (mandatory provision; the tenderer is responsible for the accuracy and completeness of the list) and GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 3.1.8 (liability split by unit-rate/lump-sum contract), plus the price-adjustment path for BOQ defects. Applies to works procured by BOQ pricing under the GB/T 50500 series standards.
Core Conclusions
- 2013 edition (the source of the saying 'BOQ errors are the tenderer's problem'): GB 50500-2013, Code for Valuation with Bills of Quantities for Construction Works, Clause 4.1.2: 'The tender BOQ must form part of the tender documents, and its accuracy and completeness shall be the responsibility of the tenderer (employer).' This was a mandatory provision to be strictly enforced, allocating liability uniformly to the tenderer regardless of contract type.
- The 2024 edition has changed this - liability split by contract pricing method: GB/T 50500-2024, Standard for Valuation of Construction Works with Bills of Quantities, Clause 3.1.8:
- For works under unit-rate contracts, the accuracy and completeness of the divisional and elemental work BOQ rest with the employer; bidders may not alter the list when bidding.
- For works under lump-sum contracts, the accuracy and completeness of the priced divisional and elemental work BOQ rest with the contractor; bidders may supplement BOQ items and price them on their own based on the tender drawings and technical standards.
- Under both unit-rate and lump-sum contracts, the completeness and accuracy of the item-priced measure list rest with the contractor, and bidders may decide at their own discretion whether to add items and prices.
- Edition history: approved by MOHURD Announcement No. 212 of 2024 as a national standard, effective from 1 September 2025, with the former national standard GB 50500-2013 repealed simultaneously; the 2024 edition moved from a mandatory national standard (GB) to a recommendatory one (GB/T).
- Consequence chain for BOQ defects:
- Clause 4.1.4: where the tender BOQ is used for a unit-rate contract, defects in the divisional and elemental BOQ are borne by the employer and adjusted per Section 8.2; where used for a lump-sum contract, the contractor bears the responsibility of supplementing and completing the list, and per Clause 6.1.7 no adjustment is made.
- Clause 6.1.6: unit-rate bidders shall verify the list within the prescribed time and raise written queries for clarification per the tender documents; 'regardless of whether the bidder has raised queries or objections, the completeness and accuracy of the divisional and elemental work BOQ are the responsibility of the tenderer (employer)'; where defects exist, the price and contract total are adjusted per Section 8.2.
- Clause 8.2.1 (unit-rate contracts): re-measure per the contract drawings; where BOQ defects cause changes of list items (additions or deletions), or the bill quantity increases or decreases by not more than 15% (inclusive) of the contract quantity of the corresponding item, the contract price is adjusted per Clause 8.9.1; where the change exceeds 15% (exclusive), per Clause 8.9.2.
- Clause 8.2.3 (lump-sum contracts): 'the contract price and contract time shall not be adjusted for contract-list defects', except items whose divisional quantities are expressly priced as provisional quantities, which may be adjusted per Clauses 7.2.1 and 8.2.1.
- Practical conclusion: under unit-rate contracts (the majority in practice), the right to adjust for BOQ omissions and miscalculations remains with the contractor and the liability with the tenderer; under lump-sum contracts the risk shifts to the contractor. Before compiling a budget or bid, first confirm the contract pricing method, then determine who bears BOQ defects and under which rules they are handled.
Applicable Boundaries
- This card applies only to works tendered and contracted under the BOQ pricing mode; liability allocation presupposes a clearly defined pricing method (unit-rate/lump-sum) - the same list carries entirely opposite defect risk under different contract types.
- The 2024 edition is a recommendatory national standard (GB/T); its liability provisions take effect through incorporation by the tender documents and the contract, and actual execution follows the tender documents and contract clauses; the 2013 edition (mandatory national standard) has been repealed since 1 September 2025 and no longer applies.
- The completeness and accuracy of the measure list do not change with contract type - always the contractor's responsibility; 'provisional quantity' unit-priced items are the sole exception to the lump-sum no-adjustment principle.
- This card covers liability allocation and the adjustment procedure, not the computation of adjusted amounts (unit-price adjustment rules within and beyond the 15% threshold - see Clauses 8.9.1/8.9.2 and the related card).
Further Reading
- 2024 edition: GB/T 50500-2024, Standard for Valuation of Construction Works with Bills of Quantities - Clause 3.1.8 (basic provisions, BOQ liability), Clause 4.1.4 (BOQ compilation), Clause 6.1.6 (bid pricing, verification and clarification), Clauses 8.2.1 and 8.2.3 (price adjustment, BOQ defects), Clauses 8.9.1/8.9.2 (adjustment computation).
- 2013 edition: GB 50500-2013, Code for Valuation with Bills of Quantities for Construction Works, Clause 4.1.2 (mandatory provision).
- Basis of edition history: MOHURD Announcement No. 212 of 2024 (26 November 2024) publishing the Standard for Valuation of Construction Works with Bills of Quantities; the standard is published on the MOHURD website (www.mohurd.gov.cn).
Keywords
- bill of quantities (BOQ)
- errors and omissions in the BOQ
- 招标人责任
- 清单准确性完整性
- GB/T 50500-2024
- GB 50500-2013
- re-measurable (unit-rate) contract
- lump-sum contract
Cited By
- ←
Deciding claims to adjust the contract price for omitted items in the tender BOQ (BOQ errors) during performance: risk is allocated by the contract pricing method and the BOQ section in which the omission falls - omission from the work-section bills under a unit-rate contract may rest with the employer and be adjusted under section 8.2; a lump-sum contract is in principle not adjusted (except provisional quantity items); the bill of preliminaries is always the contractor's responsibility - with judicial limits and points of procedure and proof
Whether adjustment is possible depends not on the omission itself but on the contract pricing method and the BOQ section in which the omission falls: GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 3.1.8 provides that under a unit-rate contract the accuracy and completeness of the work-section BOQ rest with the employer (adjustment by re-measurement under section 8.2 may be claimed, with a 15% increase or decrease in quantities as the divide between cl. 8.9.1 and 8.9.2); under a lump-sum contract they rest with the contractor, and save for unit-priced items in provisional quantities the contract price and contract time are not adjusted for BOQ errors (cl. 6.1.7 and 8.2.3); the bill of preliminaries compiled on a per-item basis is always the contractor's responsibility, with only statutory safety provisions and similar exceptions adjustable. Where the contract provides settlement at a fixed price and adjustment is claimed for major changes in labour cost or key material prices, the court will not support it (Article 9 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12).
- ←
The boundary and pricing routes between BOQ errors and omissions and variations: distinguished by the two comparison benchmarks 'contract BOQ vs contract drawings' and 'contract drawings vs actual construction drawings', mapping respectively to BOQ-error price adjustment under Section 8.2 and variation valuation under Section 8.9 of GB/T 50500-2024
GB/T 50500-2024 Article 7.2.1 draws the line by benchmark: 'a discrepancy between the divisional and sub-divisional work item lists in the contract BOQ and the contract drawings constitutes an error or omission in the bill of quantities' (routed to Section 8.2 - under a re-measurable contract, re-measure under Article 8.2.1 and adjust under Articles 8.9.1/8.9.2 at the 15% threshold; under a lump-sum contract, no adjustment under Article 8.2.3), while 'a difference between the contract drawings and the actual construction drawings constitutes a variation' (quantities computed under Article 7.4.2 and priced under Section 8.9, unaffected by the lump-sum no-adjustment rule for BOQ errors). Mis-characterisation derails both the claim route and the adjustment basis; and once a BOQ error is corrected, no preliminary items other than statutory safety provisions and those under Article 7.2.1(2), and no contract period, shall be adjusted.
- ←
Tender BOQ versus priced BOQ - relationship and effect compared: preparing and pricing parties, document status, content differences, accuracy responsibility (2013 edition clause 4.1.2 versus 2024 edition clause 3.1.8 split by unit-rate and lump-sum contracts), benchmark role in settlement (quantity variance under 9.6.2, variation valuation under 9.3.1), effect of unilateral amendment, and the order of precedence of contract documents
The two bills are not two documents but two stages of one bill: the tender BOQ is prepared by the tendering employer stating 'quantities and item descriptions' and issued with the tender documents as the common basis of tender pricing (GB 50500-2013 clauses 2.0.2, 4.1.2 (mandatory provision) and 4.1.3); the priced BOQ is the priced version in which the bidder enters all-in unit rates and lump sums and which becomes part of the contract documents after award (2013 edition clause 2.0.3; the 2024 edition calls it the 'contract bill of quantities', clauses 2.0.18 and 3.4.5), its all-in unit rates being the contract unit rates used for settlement and contract price adjustment. Responsibility follows the basic split 'quantities by the tendering employer (employer), prices by the bidder': clause 4.1.2 of the 2013 edition puts it on the tendering employer in all cases; GB/T 50500-2024 clause 3.1.8 changes course - under unit-rate contracts the employer answers for the measured-works bill (bidders may not alter it; defects are repriced under section 8.2), under lump-sum contracts the contractor answers, and preliminaries are always the contractor's. In settlement, quantity variance follows clause 9.6.2 of the 2013 edition (deviation beyond 15%: the all-in unit rate is lowered for the portion of quantity increase above 15%, and raised for the remaining portion after a decrease beyond 15%), and variation valuation follows the three-tier cascade of clause 9.3.1 (applicable -> analogous by reference -> a rate proposed by the contractor from the pricing methods and published price information combined with the tender price fluctuation rate, submitted to the employer for confirmation).
- ←
Full workflow for preparing the tender bill of quantities: preparing entity and object, the seven bases of preparation, itemisation with the five elements and item description, the four-part BOQ composition, deliverables and appendix forms, error liability, and the interface with the tender price ceiling
Chapter 4 of GB/T 50500-2024 provides: the bill of quantities is prepared by a tenderer with preparation capability or by a construction cost consultant commissioned by it (4.1.1); it is itemised with the contract object or a single project or individual structure as the object and forms part of the tender documents (4.1.2); the deliverables comprise the cover, signature page, explanatory notes of the estimate, notes on measurement rules, and the BOQ and pricing forms (4.1.3), in forms B.1.1, C.1.1, D.4.1, E.1.1/E.2.1/E.2.3/E.3.1/E.4.1 to E.4.5/E.5.1 and G.1.1. The BOQ is prepared and priced in four parts -- the work-item BOQ, the preliminaries BOQ, the other items BOQ and VAT (3.1.2) -- and the current edition no longer carries a statutory levies and taxes section; the all-in unit rate and the sum are fully inclusive pre-tax prices excluding VAT, tax is entered under VAT, and the provisional sum for nominated specialist subcontract works already includes VAT and must not be taxed again (3.1.6).
- ←
Re-examination of compilation errors in the tender price ceiling (renamed the maximum acceptable tender price in GB/T 50500-2024), bidder objections and complaint handling: the GB 50500-2013 route of '5-day complaint + order to rectify when the error exceeds +/-3%' versus the GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 5.3.3 and 5.3.4 route of objection - referral - re-publication
GB 50500-2013: a bidder which, on re-check, considers that the tender price ceiling was not compiled in accordance with the code shall complain to the tendering and bidding supervision authority and the construction cost administration institution within 5 days after publication (Clause 5.3.1); where the re-examination result differs from the published price by more than +/-3%, the tenderer shall be ordered to rectify (Clause 5.3.8). GB/T 50500-2024 removes the fixed percentage and the fixed day count: where the re-examination conclusion deviates significantly from the published maximum acceptable tender price, the tenderer shall explain and revise (Clause 5.3.3); a bidder may object in writing to the tenderer within the prescribed time, and where the tenderer fails to correct it reasonably, the bidder may refer the matter to the administrative supervision and administration department, and the price must be re-published under that department's procedures (Clause 5.3.4).
- ←
Determining missing items not listed in the BOQ appendices and setting supplementary items: the three-element comparison search path, the discipline-code + B coding rule (from 01B001), the five required accompanying elements, the tender-document explanation / filing requirements, and the boundary of error when fitting near-match items
Under GB/T 50854-2024 Clause 4.1.4, for items not covered in Appendices A~R the compiler may add supplementary items, coded with this standard's code 01 plus B and three Arabic numerals, numbered sequentially from 01B001, and must attach the item name, item description, unit of measurement, quantity take-off rule and work content (for preliminaries that cannot be measured: name, work content and scope of inclusion). The determination is a three-element comparison (item description + work content + unit of measurement with calculation rule): so long as any element can be carried by an existing appendix item, the existing item must be applied forward and the difference expressed in the item description, and no supplementary code may be created; work content lists only principal operations, auxiliary content such as plant movement and material transport is deemed included, and operations may not be split out and listed separately unless specifically stated. The 2024 editions (GB/T series) say 'may add' and no longer require filing; instead GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 3.1.3 requires the supplementary basis to be explained in the tender and contract documents; the 2013 compulsory national standards required 'shall add + file with the provincial or industry construction cost administration institution', and local standards may still retain the filing requirement.
- ←
Contract price adjustment caused by missing items in the tender bill of quantities: the clause chains of the three entries of GB 50500-2013 section 9.5 (9.5.1 to 9.3.1, 9.5.2 / 9.5.3 to 9.3.2), the four-tier valuation of all-in unit rates for new divisional and sub-divisional works items, the three-tier determination of new preliminaries, the itemisation test between unit-rate and lump-sum preliminaries, and the distinction from the quantity-deviation preliminaries linkage trigger path of clause 9.6.3
GB 50500-2013 splits 'missing BOQ items' into three mutually non-substitutable clause chains: 9.5.1 (missing divisional and sub-divisional items) fixes the rate under the four tiers of 9.3.1; 9.5.2 (new works items bringing changes to preliminaries) adjusts under 9.3.2 after the implementation plan is approved; 9.5.3 (missing preliminaries items themselves) both fixes rates under 9.3.1 and adjusts preliminaries under 9.3.2, and the plan must be submitted to the employer for approval first. The three tiers of 9.3.2: mandatory HSE provisions are calculated per 3.1.5; unit-rate preliminaries have their rates set per 9.3.1; lump-sum (or factor-based) preliminaries follow the actual adjustment amount x the contractor's quoted-price fluctuation rate. Failure to submit the plan in advance is deemed no adjustment of the preliminaries or waiver of the right to adjust. Missing items go through 9.5 / 9.3; only quantity deviations of original BOQ items over 15% (exclusive) go through 9.6.2 to adjust the all-in unit rate, with 9.6.3 adjusting factor-based or single lump-sum preliminaries up or down - the two paths must not be mixed.
- ←
Price adjustment findings for 'mismatching item descriptions' under GB 50500-2013 Section 9.4: the elements of cl. 9.4.1/9.4.2, re-determining the all-in unit rate per the as-executed item description using the cl. 9.3 method, and the clause mapping after the 2024 edition merged this event into 'errors and omissions in the BOQ'
GB 50500-2013 cl. 9.4.2 provides: where, during performance, the design drawings (including design changes) mismatch the item description of any item in the tender BOQ and that change causes an increase or decrease in the cost of the item, the all-in unit rate shall be re-determined per the item description as actually executed, under the relevant clauses of Section 9.3, and the contract price adjusted. The four findings elements are: the comparison base is the pair of tender drawings / tender BOQ; any item; a cost increase or decrease is caused; pricing per the actual description with the method borrowed from Section 9.3. The responsibility basis is cl. 4.1.2 (a mandatory provision of codes): the accuracy and completeness of the tender BOQ are the tendering employer's responsibility. The 2013 edition has been superseded by GB/T 50500-2024, which merges mismatching item descriptions, erroneous and omitted items and quantity deviations into 'errors and omissions in the BOQ' (cl. 2.0.27), entering through cl. 8.2.1 and priced through cl. 8.9.1/8.9.2.
- ←
Judging the synonymy of the tender price ceiling and the maximum tender price ceiling, the rejection rule for tender offers above the ceiling, and the item-by-item comparison of the compilation bases of the three and the division of their roles in tender evaluation and contract price formation
The tender price ceiling (GB 50500-2013 Clause 2.0.45) and the maximum tender price ceiling (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 2.0.19) are one and the same thing renamed: the 2013 definition itself uses 'maximum tender price ceiling' as the genus, and the 2024 definition matches item by item in compiling entity, compilation basis elements and the function of capping tender offers. The tender offer (2013 Clause 2.0.46: the lump total stated after summing the priced BOQ) is the bidder's autonomous responsive price and must fall between the cost line and the ceiling line: under Article 51 item (5) of the Implementation Regulations for the Tendering and Bidding Law (State Council Decree No. 709, 2019 revision), where a tender offer is below cost or above the maximum tender price ceiling set in the tender documents, the tender evaluation committee shall reject the bid; the corresponding pricing-standard clauses are GB 50500-2013 Clause 6.1.5 and GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 6.1.3.
- ←
Composition of the tender bill of quantities: the five parts of GB 50500-2013 (bill of divisional and elemental work items, bill of preliminaries, bill of provisional sums and other charges, bill of statutory levies, bill of taxes and duties) with the itemisation rules of each, and the composition contrast under GB/T 50500-2024
GB 50500-2013 Clause 4.1.4: the tender bill of quantities shall be compiled with the individual work (or project) as the unit and shall consist of the bill of divisional and elemental work items, the bill of preliminaries, the bill of provisional sums and other charges, and the bills of statutory levies and of taxes and duties. Under Clause 4.4.1 the bill of other charges contains provisional sums, provisional prices (provisional unit prices for materials, provisional unit prices for permanent plant, provisional prices for nominated specialist works), dayworks, and the main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions; under Clause 4.5.1 statutory levies cover social insurance contributions (old-age, unemployment, medical, work-injury and maternity), the housing provident fund, and the works pollution discharge fee; under Clause 4.6.1 taxes and duties cover business tax, city maintenance and construction tax, the education surcharge and the local education surcharge. GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 3.1.2 instead compiles and prices the bill of divisional and elemental work items, the bill of preliminaries and the bill of other charges together with value added tax (the statutory levies and tax bills are no longer set up; the tax becomes value added tax, computed per Clause 3.2.11 by multiplying the total of the three bills, after deducting the provisional prices of nominated specialist works, by the VAT rate).
- ←
The source definition, pricing basis and final account aggregation of the three kinds of quantities (contract BOQ quantities / variation quantities / dayworks record quantities), including the comparison baselines for BOQ errors - variation - additional works and the one-gateway-only rule against double measurement (GB/T 50500-2024 clauses 7.2, 7.3, 7.4, 7.5, 8.2, 8.6, 8.9, 8.10, 8.11, 10.3; compared with GB 50500-2013 clauses 9.3, 9.14, 11.2)
Clause 7.4.1 of GB/T 50500-2024 draws the boundary with three comparison baselines: the difference between the contract drawings and the contract BOQ = errors and omissions in the BOQ (corrected under unit-rate contracts, not adjusted under lump-sum contracts); the difference between the contract drawings and 'variation instructions + as-executed drawings' = variation; work outside the contractual scope of works completed at the employer's request = additional works (8.10.1); sundry items and events not attributable to the contractor are measured on dayworks vouchers (7.5.3 to 7.5.6). In-contract quantities are re-measured under 7.2.1 (BOQ items priced per item are not re-measured or adjusted); deviations within 15% (inclusive) go to 8.9.1 and beyond 15% to 8.9.2, the rate progressing 'contract rate -> converted similar rate -> negotiated market-reasonable all-in unit rate'; dayworks take the contract dayworks all-in unit rate under 8.6.2, or where no such BOQ item or no applicable rate exists the published price information under 8.6.3 and, failing that, the contractor's purchase price as confirmed by both parties, the rate already covering the sporadic extra costs and preliminaries of dayworks (8.6.4). Settlement aggregates in the 13-item order of 10.3.2, with preliminaries and the main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions recalculated at final account (10.3.3). No double measurement: variation quantities are determined only after comparison with 'the BOQ items and quantities as corrected for BOQ errors' (7.4.2), and what has already been adjusted under 8.2 to 8.10 may not be claimed again under the claims provisions (8.11.1).
- ←
Section order of Chapter 9 'adjustment of the contract price' in GB 50500-2013 mapped to the clause numbers of GB/T 50500-2024: dayworks 9.7 -> 8.6, provisional prices 9.9 -> 8.4, claims 9.13 -> 8.11, provisional sums 9.15 -> 8.3
GB 50500-2013 (withdrawn) Chapter 9 runs: 9.2 changes in laws and regulations, 9.3 variations, 9.4 mismatch of item descriptions, 9.5 BOQ omissions, 9.6 quantity deviations, 9.7 dayworks, 9.8 changes in costs, 9.9 provisional prices, 9.10 force majeure, 9.11 earlier completion (acceleration compensation), 9.12 delay damages, 9.13 claims, 9.14 site instruction records, 9.15 provisional sums. GB/T 50500-2024 consolidates these price-adjustment events into Chapter 8: BOQ errors 8.2, provisional sums 8.3, provisional prices 8.4, dayworks 8.6, changes in costs 8.7, variations 8.9, additional works 8.10, claims 8.11; the final account items are listed in Clause 10.3.2 (provisional sums item 3, provisional prices item 4, dayworks item 6, claims item 11). The common miscitations 'provisional prices 9.8, dayworks 9.9, claims 9.14' all fail against the actual section order of both editions.
- ←
Rate build-up basis and confirmation procedure when a BOQ omission or new item has neither an applicable nor an analogous rate: GB 50500-2013 Section 9.5 (citing the four tiers of cl. 9.3.1) mapped against GB/T 50500-2024 Sections 8.2/8.9/8.10, plus the time limits for adjustment reports
GB 50500-2013 cl. 9.5.1 provides that 'where, during performance, new divisional and sub-divisional works BOQ items arise because of omissions in the tender BOQ, the unit rates shall be determined per cl. 9.3.1 of this code and the contract price adjusted'. Tier 3 of cl. 9.3.1 reads 'where the priced BOQ contains neither an applicable nor an analogous item for the varied work, the contractor shall propose a unit rate for the varied work based on the variation documents, the measurement rules and pricing methods, the published price information issued by the government construction cost administration and the contractor's price fluctuation rate, and adjustment follows employer confirmation'; tier 4 switches, where the published price information lists no price, to a rate based on 'market prices with a lawful basis obtained through market enquiry and other means', again subject to employer confirmation -- so published price information comes first and a lawful market price only fills gaps, and tier 3 must carry the contractor's price fluctuation rate. GB/T 50500-2024 no longer has a stand-alone 'omission' section: erroneous and omitted items are folded into 'errors and omissions in the BOQ' (cl. 8.2.1 -> cl. 8.9.1/8.9.2), additional works outside the contract scope follow Section 8.10 (cl. 8.10.2 requires the contractor to submit the project execution plan or execution scheme, the programme and the priced offer to the employer for review and approval before executing the additional works), the adjustment procedure is unified as 'submission, checking, re-checking, review and confirmation' (cl. 8.1.2 to 8.1.4), and employer silence past the time limit counts as deemed approval of the contractor's report.
- ←
Handling the mismatch between construction-drawing quantities and tender BOQ quantities: measurement of actually completed quantities under GB 50500-2013 Chapter 8 and the 15% deviation price adjustment of Section 9.6 (including the divergence between the two lump-sum contract regimes of Clauses 8.3.1/8.3.2), against GB/T 50500-2024 Sections 7.2/8.2/8.9 routing the rules by contract type
GB 50500-2013 Clause 8.2.1 (a mandatory provision) requires that 'quantities shall be determined by the quantities of the contract works that the contractor has completed and that are to be measured'; the quantities stated in the tender BOQ are only estimated quantities and the common basis for tender pricing, and the final account quantities are determined by the quantities actually completed and to be measured, calculated by the contractor under the calculation rules of the current national measurement standards, not by the BOQ quantities. Clause 8.3.1 provides that for lump-sum contracts formed by tendering on a bill of quantities basis the quantities are still calculated under Section 8.2 (i.e. quantity differences remain adjustable), which diverges from Clause 8.3.2: for lump-sum contracts formed by letting the works on the basis of construction drawings and budgets examined and approved, except for variations, the BOQ quantities are the final settlement quantities. GB/T 50500-2024 instead routes the rules by contract type: for unit-rate contracts the employer bears the BOQ defects, the works are re-measured under Clause 7.2.1 and the price adjusted via Clause 8.2.1 (15% as the boundary) and then Clauses 8.9.1/8.9.2; for lump-sum contracts Clause 7.2.2 allows no re-measurement, and Clause 8.2.3 provides that 'the contract price and the time for completion shall not be adjusted for defects in the contract bill of quantities' (except items priced at provisional quantities). Directional rule for quantity deviations beyond 15%: where the increase exceeds 15%, the all-in unit rate of the increased portion is adjusted downwards; where the decrease exceeds 15%, the all-in unit rate of the remaining portion after the decrease is adjusted upwards.
- ←
Boundary determination and clause routing among quantity deviation, variation and omitted BOQ items: sections 9.4/9.5/9.6 of the 2013 edition are merged into 'BOQ errors' in GB/T 50500-2024, sorted by three comparison tests (contract drawings vs contract BOQ; contract drawings vs actual construction drawings; inside vs outside the contract works scope), with an anti-double-counting rule that one matter goes through one route only
The routing test is unique: a difference between the contract drawings (including the contract specifications) and the priced BOQ equals BOQ errors; a difference between the contract drawings and the actual construction drawings (including variation instructions issued or confirmed by the employer) equals a variation; physical works outside the contract works scope and the completion delivery requirements are additional works. GB/T 50500-2024 has merged 2013 edition Section 9.4 (item description mismatch), Section 9.5 (omitted BOQ items) and Section 9.6 (quantity deviation) into 'BOQ errors' (Clause 2.0.27), with quantity differences tiered at 15%: up to and including 15% goes to Clause 8.9.1, above 15% (exclusive) goes to Clause 8.9.2. The key anti-duplication procedure: varied quantities must be determined by comparison with the BOQ items and quantities 'after the BOQ errors have been corrected' -- the same quantity difference must not be adjusted once as an error correction and again as a variation increase or decrease.
- ←
Adjusting all-in unit rates at the +/-15% quantity boundary: GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 8.9.1-8.9.3 and the reading of the wording change from repealed GB 50500-2013 Clause 9.6.2's "tiered pricing"
Under GB/T 50500-2024 (unit-price contracts): within 15% (inclusive) per 8.9.1's five tiers (same characteristics + same conditions -> contract rate; similar -> converted; different -> negotiated market rate); beyond 15% per 8.9.2, "accounting for the purchase-price discounts gained by increased quantities (or lost when decreased), reasonably lower (or raise) the contract rate and new composite rates" - more quantity lowers the rate, less raises it. The repealed 2013 Clause 9.6.2 explicitly said "the rate of the increased portion shall be lowered; the rate of the remaining portion after decrease shall be raised" (tiered: within +/-15% unchanged); 2024 drops "portion" and does not say whether the tiered or whole-quantity repricing applies - a genuine ambiguity; being a recommended standard, contract terms govern - lock the tiered basis in the special conditions.
- ←
Choice criteria for re-measurable / lump-sum / cost-plus contracts under GB/T 50500-2024, the coverage of lump sums, and the precedence between contract drawings and the BOQ on inconsistency (Articles 3.4.2, 3.4.6)
Per GB/T 50500-2024 Article 3.4.2, the employer chooses the pricing mode per the design depth of tender drawings, technical difficulty, scale, implementation plan, BOQ compilation time and pricing risk: works with clear requirements, controllable measurement and pricing and low fluctuation risk suit lump-sum contracts; unclear requirements, high difficulty and many uncontrollables suit re-measurable (unit-rate) contracts; particularly urgent or complex, high-risk works suit cost-plus. Article 3.4.6: the lump sum covers all costs of completing the contract works per the drawings and specification under the tender documents; the priced BOQ merely reflects the price build-up, BOQ-defect prices deemed included, its unit rates usable for pricing variations and additional works, provisional-quantity items priced under re-measurable rules; on inconsistency during performance, the re-measurable contract follows the BOQ, the lump-sum contract the drawings and specification.
- ←
Quantity basis for cost estimation when BOQ quantities are overstated: costs follow actual quantities (taken off from the drawings) rather than BOQ quantities, and the effect of overstated BOQ quantities on the contract price (re-measurement and adjustment under re-measurable contracts / no adjustment under lump-sum contracts)
Cost estimation must be based on actual quantities (the drawing-based quantities calculated from the dimensions shown on the design drawings under the measurement rules agreed in the contract), not on the bill of quantities (BOQ) quantities - BOQ quantities are provisional (estimated) figures on the revenue/tendering basis, whereas cost follows actual resource consumption; the two sets of accounts must be kept separately, with the difference carried as a separate quantity variance. This rests on Article 17 of the Cost Management Regulations for State-Owned Enterprises (Guo Fa [1984] No. 34) - costs must be accounted for from actual consumption and actual prices, and enterprises must not substitute planned cost, estimated cost or norm-based cost for actual cost - and on Article 4.1.5 of GB/T 50500-2024, under which quantities of work-item BOQ entries under a re-measurable (unit-rate) contract are provisional quantities to be determined by re-measurement. The effect of overstated BOQ quantities on revenue depends on the contract type: under a re-measurable (unit-rate) contract the works are re-measured against the actual construction drawings, so the inflated portion earns no payment (it is an error in the BOQ, rectified and repriced under Articles 7.2.1 and 8.2.1, with 15% as the threshold); under a lump-sum contract the work-item BOQ need not be re-measured and BOQ errors are not adjusted (Articles 7.2.2, 4.1.6 and 8.2.3), so an overstated BOQ quantity against less work actually done yields a quantity variance gain. The only opening is BOQ entries whose item description states a provisional quantity: under both contract types they are re-measured and adjusted under the re-measurable-contract rules.
- ←
May quantities cut by design variation be listed as negative BOQ items: the contract BOQ itself never goes negative - increases and decreases fall to the "variation increase-and-decrease price" item at final account; under lump-sum (fixed-price) contracts BOQ defects do not adjust, only differences between as-built and contract drawings form priceable variations (GB/T 50500-2024)
Quantity cuts from design variations must never be written as negative quantities in the original contract BOQ - BOQ quantities compute on design-shown dimensions and, under lump-sum contracts, divisional BOQ quantities need no re-measurement (clause 7.2.2); the cuts land at the settlement adjustment layer, item 9 of GB/T 50500-2024 clause 10.3.2, "variation increase-and-decrease price" (which may be negative), the contract-BOQ-total line standing unchanged. Under lump-sum contracts only the difference between as-built and contract drawings constitutes a priceable variation (clause 7.4.3); contract-drawing versus contract-BOQ differences are BOQ defects and never adjust (7.4.2, 8.2.3). Variation pricing splits on whether contract rates apply: applying, adjust under 8.9.1 (quantity change within 15%, inclusive) or 8.9.2 (over 15%, exclusive - cuts reasonably raise rates); not applying, the parties negotiate the all-in rates (8.9.3).
- ←
Reviewing tender bills of quantities: methods and criteria for detecting omissions, errors, and duplications
Check the BOQ against four baselines—tender documents, construction drawings, measurement standards, and the pricing standard: omissions via drawing cross-check + standard appendix tick-off + item description derivation + preliminaries check; errors via codes (twelve digits, no duplicate codes within one project), item descriptions (standard, concise, accurate, complete), units and quantities, and work-content attribution (operations must not be split); duplications via duplicate codes, substantively identical items, split-out operations, and overlaps between work items and preliminaries. Per GB/T 50500-2024 Article 4.1.4: BOQ defects are borne by the employer under unit-rate contracts (adjusted per Section 8.2) and by the contractor under lump-sum contracts (not adjusted per Article 6.1.7).
- ←
Overview of bills of quantities: composition, compilation, item descriptions and handling of errors/omissions (GB/T 50500-2024)
A bill of quantities comprises four sections — trade items, preliminaries, other items and VAT; the five BOQ elements (code/name/item description/unit of measurement/quantity) are compiled per the national and industry measurement standards. Division of responsibility: under unit-rate contracts the trade-items BOQ is the employer's responsibility, under lump-sum contracts the contractor's, and the bill of preliminaries is always the contractor's. BOQ defects are per definition 2.0.27; unit-rate contracts re-measure under section 8.2 with price adjustment at the 15% boundary; lump-sum contracts are generally not adjusted except provisional-quantity items.
- ←
Handling tender document vs construction drawing inconsistencies in bidding: statutory objection/clarification deadlines and contractual pricing risk allocation
Objections to tender documents must be raised in writing at least 10 days before the bid deadline; the tenderer replies within 3 days, suspending the process until reply (Implementation Regulations Article 22); clarifications/modifications affecting bid preparation must be notified in writing at least 15 days before the deadline, or the deadline is extended (Article 21). On substance per GB/T 50500-2024 3.4.5/3.4.6: unit-rate contracts—BOQ prevails over drawings, BOQ defects on the tenderer, price adjusted per Section 8.2; lump-sum contracts—contract drawings and specifications prevail, defects borne by the contractor; preliminaries and per-item priced items are always the contractor's regardless of contract type. Not objecting before bidding does not change this allocation.
- ←
Checking drawing-BOQ contradictions (bill of quantities defects) before bid pricing, and responsibility boundaries (GB/T 50500-2024)
Drawing-BOQ contradictions are "BOQ defects" (extra items/omissions/mismatched characteristics/quantity deviations, Article 2.0.27). Responsibility by pricing mode: unit-rate contracts—work-item BOQ by the tenderer (Article 6.1.6, defects adjusted at settlement per Section 8.2); lump-sum contracts—by the bidder (Article 6.1.7, may supplement the priced BOQ and bears the difference); preliminaries always the bidder's (Article 6.1.5); per-item pricing is lump sum, unadjusted at settlement (Article 6.2.3). Check by risk order: item characteristics, quantities, completeness of items, units and measurement rules, work-content interfaces, drawing versions, preliminaries, provisional sums.
- ←
Drainage-pipe testing caliber and pricing inclusion boundary: gravity pipes take leakage-tightness tests (water/air) not pressure tests/disinfection-flushing; tests are included in the pipe BOQ item, norm items listed separately != separate BOQ items, with a four-step omitted-item test for settlement
Drainage pipes are gravity pipes; their functional test is the leakage-tightness test (water test/air test) — there is no "pressure test" caliber and no water-supply disinfection-flushing: sewage, combined, and storm pipes in collapsible/expansive/quicksand soils must pass tightness tests before use (GB 50268-2008, 9.1.11, mandatory). At BOQ level the test is inside the pipe item (GB/T 50856-2024 Table K.1.1 note 9; GB/T 50857-2024 Annex E and 4.1.2 "shall not be split into separate items"); at norm level separate test items may price it (e.g., SJG 181.4-2024), but a separate norm item != a separate BOQ item. "Drainage-pipe disinfection-flushing/pressure test" in settlements is a wrong item — strike it.
- ←
Pricing rules for prime-sum estimates (provisional sums) of specialist works: GB/T 50500-2024 VAT-inclusive, lump-sum per item, deduction from the VAT base, and substitution on adjustment (compared with GB 50500-2013)
GB/T 50500-2024 defines the prime-sum estimate of specialist works as "specialist-work costs estimated VAT-inclusive where requirements and price cannot be fixed at tendering" (2.0.15, excluding works directly awarded by the employer), listed under the other-items list, priced by lump-sum per item (3.2.7); the VAT base is the total of work-item, preliminaries, and other-items lists (excluding the specialist prime sum), so VAT is not charged on it again (3.1.6, 3.2.11); on adjustment, mandatory-tender items are wholly replaced by the winning VAT-inclusive subcontract price (8.4.1), others may be priced VAT-inclusive per Section 8.10 or jointly tendered by both parties (8.4.7). Compared with GB 50500-2013's vague "comprehensive prime sum including management fee and profit other than fees and taxes" (Section 4.4), the rules are refined in price basis, pricing-mode classification, VAT treatment, and substitution.
- ←
Bid-price clarification or explanation mechanism in GB/T 50500-2024 (Section 3.5): seven arithmetic-error correction rules and omitted/unpriced items, vs GB 50500-2013 Clauses 6.1.4/6.2.7
GB/T 50500-2024 adds Section 3.5 "clarification or explanation of bid prices": between opening and award, bidders may be asked to clarify arithmetic errors, minor deviations, price reasonableness, and completeness (omissions), but the total bid and substantive contents are locked (no change to scope, duration, contract conditions, total price, or bid duration). 3.5.2 gives seven arithmetic-correction rules (words over figures, total over list sum, prime sums per the tender list, unit price over amount, etc.); 3.5.4 provides that omissions in lump-sum/preliminaries/per-item lists are deemed included in other items and the total, while unit-price work-item omissions may be clarified and added with the amount deducted from the preliminaries total - replacing 2013's coarse treatment under 6.1.4 (mandatory) and 6.2.7 ("reject the bid, or deem included with no settlement adjustment").
- ←
Scope of GB/T 50500-2024: state-funded works shall use BOQ pricing (compulsion now carried by MOHURD Order No. 16), others should/may choose freely, compared with GB 50500-2013
Per GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 3.1.1: works invested with fiscal or state-owned funds "shall" prepare BOQs per national and industry measurement standards and use BOQ pricing; non-state-funded works "should", and may choose other methods (3.1.5 allows percentage-fee and other pricing where unit-price/lump-sum pricing is unsuitable, provided the pricing requirements and adjustment rules are stated in tender and contract documents). The 2024 edition changed from a mandatory GB (50500-2013) to recommended GB/T - "must" became "shall", mandatory provisions repealed - but the practical rule "state-funded works must use BOQ pricing" is not relaxed: compulsion is carried by Article 6 of the "Measures for pricing of construction contracting" (MOHURD Order No. 16): such works "shall adopt BOQ pricing".
- ←
Risk allocation and adjustment rules for preliminaries (measure) costs: GB 50500-2013 vs GB/T 50500-2024 (omitted items, scheme changes, lump sum plus exceptions)
The 2024 edition restructures preliminaries as "lump sum plus exceptions": completeness/accuracy of the preliminaries list is the contractor's responsibility under both unit-price and lump-sum contracts (3.1.8); omitted items are no longer adjustable except the safety-measures cost and formwork/temporary works listed in the work-item list (8.2.2/8.2.3), whereas under 2013 list omissions were the tenderer's liability (4.1.2, mandatory) and missing preliminaries could be added via an approved scheme (9.5.3). "All preliminaries risk on the contractor" is inaccurate - exceptions like variations, unforeseen provisional-sum works, and employer causes still cost the employer (3.3.7), but only via "submit scheme before execution + mutual confirmation" (8.9.6/8.9.7), failing which the right is forfeited.
- ←
GB/T 50500-2024 replacing GB 50500-2013: what GB becoming GB/T means, expiry of the 2013 mandatory provisions, and the 2025-09-01 effective date
MOHURD Announcement (No. 212 of 2024, issued 2024-11-26) approved the "Standard for measure and valuation of construction work with bills of quantities" as national standard GB/T 50500-2024, effective 1 September 2025, repealing GB 50500-2013 simultaneously. GB = mandatory national standard, GB/T = recommended (Standardization Law, 2017 revision, Article 2: mandatory standards must be executed; adoption of recommended standards is encouraged); all 2013 mandatory provisions expire with the standard, and the 2024 edition sets no mandatory provisions. Typical contrast: 2013 Clause 3.1.1 (mandatory) "works contracted with state-owned funds must use BOQ pricing" becomes 2024 3.1.1 with fiscal/state-funded works "shall" and others "should" use BOQ pricing. The binding force of a recommended standard is realized through incorporation in tender documents and contracts.
- ←
Item description vs method of measurement in the BOQ: the item description column must not stipulate the method of measurement; supplementary rules belong in the BOQ calculation-rules statement and apply as contractual agreement
Item description and method of measurement are two parallel, independent elements of the bill of quantities (BOQ): the item description must be drafted in accordance with the annexes to the measurement standard and the actual works, its function being to fix the all-in unit rate; quantities must be computed under the method of measurement prescribed in the annexes (mandatory provisions of codes) — the item description column must not stipulate the method of measurement. Where supplementary rules are genuinely required, they must be set out in the BOQ calculation-rules statement (naming the national and industry standards adopted, with their titles and numbers, or setting out the detailed supplementary rules) and made part of the tender documents/contract documents, applying as "contractual agreement". Hierarchy of measurement bases: contractual agreement -> national standard matching the contract type -> industry/local standard.
- ←
Framework for distinguishing quantity risk from price risk in contracts: risk objects, responsible parties, and quantified trigger lines (GB/T 50500-2024)
Quantity risk governs "how much is built" (BOQ defects, quantity changes and item additions/deletions from changes); price risk governs "how much per unit" (input prices and all-in unit-rate levels). On allocation, Article 3.3.2 lists owner risks (unit-rate BOQ defects, erroneous source data, approved changes, legislative changes, beyond-band fluctuations); Article 3.3.3 lists contractor risks (preliminaries lists, total-price BOQ defects, own technical/management risks, within-band fluctuations). Quantified triggers: quantity change 15% (8.9.1/8.9.2); price fluctuation 5% or the contract-agreed band (8.7.2/8.7.6).
- ←
Methods and liability basis for ensuring completeness of the bill of preliminaries at construction main (general) contracting tender stage (GB/T 50500-2024)
Per GB/T 50500-2024 clause 6.1.5, whether a re-measurable (unit-rate) or lump-sum contract is used, the completeness and accuracy of the bill of preliminaries are the bidder's (contractor's) responsibility, and the bidder bears the risk of the reasonableness of its tender price; preliminary items not priced as required may be deemed included in the all-in unit rates, totals and tender total of other billed (BOQ) items, with no re-pricing or adjustment at construction payment settlement (3.5.4). The contractor should guard against omissions via the six-category 'including but not limited to' framework in 3.2.6 + three cross-checks (bill of preliminaries vs project execution plan (construction methodology and site organization)/tender documents/similar projects) + site inspection + written clarification; statutory safety provisions are non-competitive (3.2.5) and must not be omitted or priced at zero.
- ←
Can a practice omitted from the BOQ (missing item) but mandatorily required by codes be deducted at the final account? - the judgment chain of contract type x pricing classification (GB/T 50500-2024) and the judicial approach to missing-item risk
A practice omitted from the BOQ but mandatorily required by codes is not automatically deductible: under a unit-rate contract the completeness of the divisional-item BOQ is the client's responsibility (GB/T 50500-2024 Clauses 3.1.8, 6.1.6) - a genuine omission already constructed is adjusted as a BOQ defect under 8.2.1 and repriced per 8.9.1 at up to the 15% boundary; under a lump-sum contract the priced divisional-item BOQ is the contractor's responsibility and, in principle, the contract price is not adjusted for BOQ defects (6.1.7, 8.2.3); practices that are per-item measures items, or already contained in the work content of BOQ items such as doors/windows and curtain walls, are deductible (3.1.8, 6.1.5, 8.2.2); where the contractor failed to perform a mandatory obligation, rectification comes first (at its own cost) and deduction at the final account is well-founded (10.3.13). Judicially, where missing items exceed a reasonable range and both parties are at fault, the loss may be apportioned per fault and the principle of good faith.
- ←
No price adjustment for BOQ defects in lump-sum contracts (BOQ quantities below drawings): the four-layer rule of GB/T 50500-2024 and the reversal of the 2013 edition's Clause 8.3.1 measure-and-value rule
Under GB/T 50500-2024 (effective 2025-09-01; GB 50500-2013 simultaneously repealed), BOQ quantities in lump-sum contracts below the drawings constitute a "BOQ defect" and are not adjusted during performance: 2.0.7 bars using changes in BOQ items/quantities as an adjustment basis; 3.4.6 deems defect prices included in the lump sum with contract drawings and specifications governing; 4.1.6 disallows adjustment for defect-induced price changes; 7.2.2 allows no re-measurement of the BOQ; 7.4.1 defines drawing-vs-BOQ differences as defects not adjustable. The 2013 Clause 8.3.1 (an ordinary clause, not among that edition's 15 mandatory ones) allowing measure-and-value for BOQ-tendered lump-sum contracts has been deleted and reversed. Only two openings remain: (1) items marked "provisional quantities" re-measured per unit-price rules (4.1.6, 7.2.2 item 2); (2) differences between contract drawings and as-built drawings are variations measured under 7.4.3 (7.2.2 item 3) - unchanged drawings with undercounted BOQs are no variation.
- ←
GB/T 50500-2024, China's BOQ pricing standard: positioning, 2024-vs-2013 changes, chapter map and card-group navigation
GB/T 50500-2024, the China national pricing standard for BOQ-based pricing (MOHURD Announcement No. 212 of 2024, approved 26 November 2024), came into force on 1 September 2025 and repealed GB 50500-2013. Its status shifted from a partly mandatory code to a recommended national standard (GB to GB/T), aiming to regularise pricing rules and let the market form construction costs. It governs pricing activity in tendering, contracting and execution for construction works; EPC and other general-contracting models apply it by reference, and the requirement that state-funded projects use BOQ pricing is carried by a MOHURD ministerial order. Nine headline revisions (per the foreword): risk scope and allocation rules by contract form; a new bid clarification mechanism; revised pricing of preliminaries; the 'contract price agreement' chapter replaced by contract selection and requirements; revised measurement and adjustment rules; site visas abolished and additional-works pricing introduced; interim settlement by construction stage added; dispute resolution revised; the cost-expert-assessment chapter deleted. The structure was rebuilt from 16 chapters into 12 chapters plus annexes: 'tender control price' renamed tender price ceiling; completion settlement and contract-termination settlement merged into 'works settlement and payment' (absorbing stage settlement); dispute resolution and expert assessment merged; pricing tables moved to annexes (with a new Annex G, schedule of price-adjustable key materials).