Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-25

Boundary determination and clause routing among quantity deviation, variation and omitted BOQ items: sections 9.4/9.5/9.6 of the 2013 edition are merged into 'BOQ errors' in GB/T 50500-2024, sorted by three comparison tests (contract drawings vs contract BOQ; contract drawings vs actual construction drawings; inside vs outside the contract works scope), with an anti-double-counting rule that one matter goes through one route only

The routing test is unique: a difference between the contract drawings (including the contract specifications) and the priced BOQ equals BOQ errors; a difference between the contract drawings and the actual construction drawings (including variation instructions issued or confirmed by the employer) equals a variation; physical works outside the contract works scope and the completion delivery requirements are additional works. GB/T 50500-2024 has merged 2013 edition Section 9.4 (item description mismatch), Section 9.5 (omitted BOQ items) and Section 9.6 (quantity deviation) into 'BOQ errors' (Clause 2.0.27), with quantity differences tiered at 15%: up to and including 15% goes to Clause 8.9.1, above 15% (exclusive) goes to Clause 8.9.2. The key anti-duplication procedure: varied quantities must be determined by comparison with the BOQ items and quantities 'after the BOQ errors have been corrected' -- the same quantity difference must not be adjusted once as an error correction and again as a variation increase or decrease.

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 50500-2024 第2.0.27条(工程量清单缺陷)
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第2.0.28条(工程变更)
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第2.0.30条(新增工程)
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第7.2.1条、第7.3.1条、第7.4.2条(计量与缺陷/变更分野)
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第8.1.2、8.1.3条(价款调整程序)
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第8.2.1条、第8.2.3条(清单缺陷与15%分档)
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第8.9.1~8.9.3条、第8.9.6条(变更计价与措施费)
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第8.10.1、8.10.3、8.10.5条(新增工程计价)
  • GB 50500-2013 第9.3.1、9.3.2条(工程变更估价与措施项目费)
  • GB 50500-2013 第9.4.2条(项目特征不符)
  • GB 50500-2013 第9.5.1~9.5.3条(工程量清单缺项)
  • GB 50500-2013 第9.6.2、9.6.3条(工程量偏差15%调价)
  • GB/T 50319-2013 第6.3.3条(监理确定变更价款)
  • T/ZBD 100.4-2023 第4.8.2、4.8.3条(新增工程定性与计价)

Scope of the topic

Answers which price-adjustment route a site fact falls under (quantities grew, drawings changed, the item is not in the BOQ), which clause to cite and which valuation path to take, and how to stop the same matter being adjusted twice. It also maps GB 50500-2013 Sections 9.3/9.4/9.5/9.6 against GB/T 50500-2024 Sections 8.2/8.9/8.10, for switching calibre between legacy-contract accounts and newly signed contracts.

Core conclusions

1. Fix the edition first. Sections 9.3 variation, 9.4 item description mismatch, 9.5 omitted BOQ items and 9.6 quantity deviation make up Chapter 9 of GB 50500-2013, Code of Valuation with Bills of Quantities for Construction Works. GB/T 50500-2024, Standard for BOQ-based Pricing of Construction Works, moves contract price adjustment wholesale into Chapter 8 and turns Chapter 9 into interim payment of the contract price; the numbering '9.3 variation / 9.5 omission / 9.6 quantity difference' no longer exists. Citing 9.x clauses under a 2024-edition contract lands in the payment chapter and misses.

2. The 2024 restructuring: three sections merged into one 'errors' route. Clause 2.0.27 reads: 'BOQ errors (bills of quantities errors): differences in itemisation, item description and quantities between the items listed in the work-item BOQ and the items required by the corresponding contract drawings and contract specifications. They include over-listed items, erroneous or omitted items, item description mismatches, quantity deviations and other similar cases.' The 2024 edition therefore has only three routes -- 'errors / variation / additional works': the 2013 item description mismatch, omitted BOQ items and quantity deviation merge into 'errors', tiered by the 15% threshold into Clause 8.9.1 / Clause 8.9.2.

3. Three comparison tests (hard clauses in the 2024 edition). Clause 7.2.1: 'For works under a unit-rate contract, differences between the work-item BOQ of the contract BOQ and the contract drawings are BOQ errors and may be adjusted under the provisions on BOQ errors; differences between the contract drawings and the actual construction drawings are variations and shall be adjusted under the provisions on variations.' Clause 7.4.2: 'Whether the works adopt a unit-rate or a lump-sum contract, comparing the variation instructions issued or confirmed by the employer and the actual construction drawings against the contract drawings, the work-item BOQ for the differing part constitutes variation items... differences between the contract drawings and the contract BOQ are BOQ errors: works under unit-rate contracts shall correct their BOQ errors per the relevant provisions, while BOQ errors of works under lump-sum contracts shall not be adjusted.' This yields the routing table:

Comparison Nature of the difference Route
Contract drawings (incl. contract specifications) vs the priced BOQ Drawings have what the BOQ omits (omitted items), BOQ description conflicts with the drawings, quantity mismatch, over-listed items BOQ errors (2013 edition split into 9.4 description mismatch + 9.5 omission + 9.6 quantity difference)
Contract drawings vs actual construction drawings (+ variation instructions issued or confirmed by the employer) Drawings / specifications / positions and dimensions / construction sequence / construction conditions altered Variation (2013 edition Section 9.3; 2024 edition Section 8.9)
Drawings and BOQ both unchanged, only the measured completed quantity differs from the BOQ quantity Pure quantity deviation 2013 edition Section 9.6; 2024 edition merged into errors (Clause 2.0.27 expressly lists 'quantity deviations')
Outside the contract works scope and (or) the completion delivery requirements Additional physical works outside the scope Additional works (2024 edition Section 8.10; no standalone section in the 2013 edition)

Two defining clauses frame the 'variation' and 'additional' boundary -- Variation (Clause 2.0.28): 'changes approved by the employer to the working content of the contract works, the contract drawings, the contract specifications, positions and dimensions, construction sequence and timing, construction conditions, contract terms or other characteristics, including additions, reductions, cancellations and substitutions to the contract works and changes to the materials used.' Additional works (Clause 2.0.30): 'physical works requested by the employer and accepted by the contractor that fall outside the contract works scope and (or) its completion delivery requirements.' One-line mnemonic: a variation stays within this contract's scope; additional works have stepped outside it.

4. Governing clauses and valuation paths per route.

  1. Quantity deviation (2013 edition Section 9.6 / the quantity-difference tier within 2024 errors)
  • 2013 edition Clause 9.6.2: 'For any tender BOQ item, where quantity deviation caused by the quantity deviation specified in this section and by the variations specified in Section 9.3 exceeds 15%, adjustment may be made. Where the quantity increases by more than 15%, the all-in unit rate for the increased portion of the quantity shall be reduced; where the quantity decreases by more than 15%, the all-in unit rate for the remaining portion after the decrease shall be increased.' Clause 9.6.3: where the change causes changes to preliminary items, those priced by coefficient or as a single lump sum increase with greater quantity and decrease with lesser quantity.
  • 2024 edition Clause 8.2.1: where errors cause BOQ item changes (items added or removed), or the BOQ quantity increases or decreases by no more than 15% (15% inclusive) of the quantity contained in the contract BOQ for the corresponding item, adjustment is calculated under Clause 8.9.1; increases or decreases exceeding 15% (15% exclusive) are adjusted under Clause 8.9.2.
  • Key point: in the 2013 edition the 15% test is the switch for 'whether to adjust the rate'; in the 2024 edition it is the tiering switch between 'Clause 8.9.1 or Clause 8.9.2'. The threshold is identical in both (at exactly 15% no up or down adjustment triggers; only beyond 15% does it), but the clauses it hangs on differ.
  1. Variation (2013 edition Section 9.3 / 2024 edition Clauses 8.9.1 to 8.9.3)
  • 2013 edition three-tier valuation (Clause 9.3.1): (1) 'where the priced BOQ contains an item applicable to the varied work, the rate of that item shall be adopted; but where the variation changes the quantity of that BOQ item and the quantity deviation exceeds 15%, the rate of that item shall be adjusted per Clause 9.6.2 of this code'; (2) 'where no applicable but similar items to the varied work exist, the rates of similar items may be referenced within a reasonable range'; (3) 'where no applicable or similar items exist, the contractor shall propose a rate for the varied work from the variation documents, the measurement rules and pricing methods, the published price information issued by the construction cost administration and the contractor's quotation floating rate, to be adjusted after confirmation by the employer' -- the contractor's quotation floating rate is computed two ways for tendered and non-tendered works; (4) 'where no applicable or similar items exist... and the published price information of the construction cost administration lacks a price, the contractor shall propose a rate for the varied work from the variation documents, the measurement rules, the pricing methods and lawfully based market prices obtained through market surveys, to be adjusted after confirmation by the employer'.
  • The 2024 edition replaces 'applicable / similar' with a two-dimensional 'item description x construction conditions' test: Clause 8.9.1 has five tiers -- same conditions and same description, use the contract rate; same conditions with a similar description, or similar conditions with the same description, use the all-in unit rate obtained by converting the contract rate of a similar BOQ item; same conditions with a different description or different conditions with the same description, and different conditions with different description, each call for a negotiated market-reasonable all-in unit rate; items reduced or cancelled that materially change construction conditions are negotiated. Where the quantity change exceeds 15%, increased quantities are priced 'after reasonably reducing the contract rate and the new all-in unit rate, taking account of the labour and material procurement discounts arising from the increased quantity', and decreased quantities 'after reasonably increasing... taking account of the loss of such discounts' (Clause 8.9.2).
  • Lump-sum contracts (Clause 8.9.3): where the contract provides that contract unit rates apply to pricing variations, adjust under Clauses 8.9.1 and 8.9.2; where they do not apply, the all-in unit rate is negotiated by the parties from the execution conditions and market prices, read with the priced BOQ pricing rules and the tender level.
  • The supervision side mirrors the three tiers (GB/T 50319-2013 Clause 6.3.3): where the contract already has an applicable price, use the contract price; where a similar price exists, reference it; where neither exists, the chief supervising engineer consults both parties, and failing agreement a reasonable rate is fixed on a cost-plus-profit basis, with objections handled under the contract dispute procedure.
  1. Omitted BOQ items (2013 edition Section 9.5) -> merged into errors in the 2024 edition
  • 2013 edition Clause 9.5.1: 'During contract performance, where new work-item BOQ items arise from omissions in the tender BOQ, the rate shall be determined per Clause 9.3.1 of this code and the contract price adjusted.' Omission is thus an independent adjustment event, but valuation borrows the 9.3.1 hierarchy (applicable rate -> reference similar -> derive a new rate and obtain employer confirmation).
  • Clause 9.5.2: where new work-item BOQ items cause changes to preliminary items, adjustment follows Clause 9.3.2 after the execution plan submitted by the contractor is approved by the employer. Clause 9.5.3: where preliminary items are missing from the tender BOQ, after the contractor submits the execution plan for the new preliminary items and the employer approves it, adjust under Clauses 9.3.1 and 9.3.2.
  • Item description mismatch (2013 edition Clause 9.4.2): where the design drawings (including design changes) conflict with the item description of any tender BOQ item and cost rises or falls, the all-in unit rate is re-determined per Section 9.3 on the item description as actually built and adjusted.
  • Under the 2024 edition all three situations fall under 'errors'; rate determination goes through Clause 8.9.1 / 8.9.2, and liability and adjustability split by contract type: errors are adjustable under unit-rate contracts, while for lump-sum contracts 'the contract price and contract time shall not be adjusted for BOQ errors' -- only provisional-quantity unit-priced items agreed in the contract may be adjusted under Clauses 7.2.1 and 8.2.1 (Clause 8.2.3).
  1. Additional works (2024 edition Section 8.10)
  • Clause 8.10.1: the price of additional works may be calculated using the itemisation requirements, calculation rules and contract unit rates agreed in the contract, read with the tender pricing level, or the measurement and pricing rules for the additional works may be renegotiated and an additional-works contract or supplementary agreement signed; preliminary costs shall include the costs of preliminaries used beyond schedule or newly added.
  • Clause 8.10.3: where additional works use contract unit rates, four difference corrections are required -- differences between labour, material and plant unit rates and reasonable market prices at execution, the effect of bulk or small-quantity procurement on labour and material costs, correction of contract unit rates that are too low or too high, and the difference between competitive tender prices and negotiated prices.
  • Clause 8.10.5: 'the provisions of Clauses 8.2.2 and 8.2.3 of this standard are not suitable for pricing additional works' -- additional works no longer go through the error-adjustment channel.
  • Construction cost expert assessment position (T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Clause 4.8.3): where a supplementary agreement sets the pricing principles, it governs; absent a supplementary agreement or explicit pricing principles, 'the pricing principles and methods of the original contract do not necessarily apply' -- additional works are works outside the contract, not bound by the original contract price terms, priced in principle at unit rates negotiated by the parties, with the contractor bearing the burden of proof and explanation for the adjusted rate. Clause 4.8.2: even where the employer issues the instruction as a variation order, unless the contractor accepts it as a variation and there is no dispute over the pricing principle, the assessor shall judge from scientific, reasonable and industry-practice standpoints whether it is additional works and price it as such.

5. Anti-duplication tests: 'one matter, one route'.

  1. Correct errors first, then compute variations -- the sequence is written into the standard. Clause 7.4.2: variations under unit-rate contracts 'shall have the work-item BOQ items and quantities recalculated from the variation instructions issued or confirmed by the employer and the actual construction drawings, and compared with the BOQ items and quantities after the BOQ errors have been corrected, to determine the varied items added or removed and their quantities'. The baseline is 'the BOQ as corrected', not the original BOQ; using the original BOQ as the variation baseline would adjust the same quantity difference once as an error and again as a variation -- double counting.
  2. Under the 2013 edition, omission and quantity difference must not both count: omission (9.5) means 'the BOQ lacks the item'; quantity difference (9.6) means 'the item exists but the quantity mismatches'. The same BOQ item cannot be found both omitted (new rate built per 9.3.1) and quantity-deviant (original rate adjusted per 9.6.2); only after an omitted item is added do later quantity changes fall back to the 15% rule of 9.6.
  3. The 15% threshold only decides 'which pricing clause applies'; it is not a second adjustment event: Clause 8.2.1 routes errors to Clause 8.9.1 or 8.9.2 -- two computation calibres for one and the same adjustment, never to be computed twice and stacked.
  4. Under lump-sum contracts the routes narrow: Clause 8.2.3 fixes that neither the contract price nor the time adjusts for BOQ errors (provisional-quantity unit-priced items excepted), so 'errors' is not an independent adjustment route there -- only 'variation + additional works' remain.
  5. Additional works, variations and errors are mutually exclusive: Clause 8.10.5 excludes Clauses 8.2.2 and 8.2.3 from pricing additional works, which are re-itemised and priced or given negotiated rules under Clause 8.10.1 without error correction; T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Clause 4.8.2 further requires characterising the work first (variation or additional), then choosing the pricing principle.
  6. Preliminaries are not a third route: preliminary items move in step with work-item adjustments -- Clause 7.3.1 confirms that priced preliminary items are in principle not re-measured, with only five exceptions (preliminary works itemised within the work items, statutory safety provisions, preliminary changes caused by variations, preliminary changes caused by BOQ errors, and preliminary changes for unforeseen works covered by provisional sums). Where a variation materially changes the contract works scope, time, quality, contract specifications and the like and alters preliminary items, the disadvantaged party must 'submit the proposed plan to the other party for review before implementation, detailing the changes against the preliminary items of the original plan'; execution follows joint confirmation, then adjustment under Clauses 8.9.4 and 8.9.5 (Clause 8.9.6); the 2013 edition Clause 9.3.2 further provides that failing to submit the plan in advance is deemed not to cause adjustment of preliminaries or a waiver of the right to adjust.
  7. One unified procedure: whichever route is taken, under Clause 8.1.2 the contractor measures per Chapter 7, prices per Sections 8.2 to 8.11 and submits within the agreed time, and under Clause 8.1.3 the employer verifies -- written notice if confirmed, written reply with checking comments if not; silence without comments is deemed approval.

Applicable boundaries

  • Applies to unit-rate and lump-sum contracts priced on a BOQ basis; the 2013-edition clauses apply only to contracts and accounts drafted under the 2013 code, and newly signed contracts should cite Chapter 8 of GB/T 50500-2024 (GB/T 50500-2024 has replaced GB 50500-2013).
  • GB/T 50500-2024 is a recommended national standard; where the contract expressly provides otherwise for pricing variations, error adjustment or risk allocation, the contract prevails; where the contract provides that contract unit rates do not apply to pricing variations, Clauses 8.9.1 and 8.9.2 do not apply (Clause 8.9.3).
  • The 15% rule turns on inclusion: up to and including 15% go to Clause 8.9.1, above 15% (exclusive) go to Clause 8.9.2; the 2013 Clause 9.6.2 likewise adjusts only beyond 15%, with exactly 15% not triggering.
  • Not covered: adjustment for cost fluctuation (2024 edition Section 8.7), determination of actual prices for provisional-priced items (Section 8.4), changes in laws and policies (Section 8.8), force majeure, claims; nor work items priced per 'item' (not to be re-measured or adjusted, Clause 7.2.1).
  • Routing rests on the measurement standards and supplementary calculation rules agreed in the contract; different measurement calibres (measured in place vs drawing dimensions) directly change the quantity-difference outcome.

Further reading

  • GB/T 50500-2024: Clause 2.0.27 (BOQ errors), Clause 2.0.28 (variation), Clause 2.0.30 (additional works); Clause 7.2.1 (re-measurement under unit-rate contracts and the errors/variation divide), Clause 7.3.1 (preliminaries not re-measured, five exceptions), Clause 7.4.2 (variation measurement and the 'after error correction' comparison baseline); Clauses 8.1.2 and 8.1.3 (submission and verification procedure), Clause 8.2.1 (errors tiered at 15%), Clause 8.2.3 (no adjustment for errors under lump-sum contracts), Clauses 8.9.1 to 8.9.3 (five-tier all-in unit rates / up-and-down adjustment beyond 15% / variation pricing under lump-sum contracts), Clause 8.9.6 (procedure for adjusting preliminaries), Clauses 8.10.1, 8.10.3 and 8.10.5 (pricing additional works and excluding the error clauses).
  • GB 50500-2013: Clause 9.3.1 (three-tier variation valuation and the contractor's quotation floating rate), Clause 9.3.2 (adjustment of preliminaries), Clause 9.4.2 (item description mismatch), Clauses 9.5.1 to 9.5.3 (omitted BOQ items), Clauses 9.6.2 and 9.6.3 (quantity deviation 15% up/down adjustment and the preliminaries linkage).
  • GB/T 50319-2013 Clause 6.3.3 (the supervising engineer determining variation prices: contract price -> similar price -> cost plus profit).
  • T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Clauses 4.8.2 and 4.8.3 (characterising and pricing additional works; works outside the contract do not necessarily follow the original contract's pricing principles).

Keywords

Cited By