Price adjustment findings for 'mismatching item descriptions' under GB 50500-2013 Section 9.4: the elements of cl. 9.4.1/9.4.2, re-determining the all-in unit rate per the as-executed item description using the cl. 9.3 method, and the clause mapping after the 2024 edition merged this event into 'errors and omissions in the BOQ'
GB 50500-2013 cl. 9.4.2 provides: where, during performance, the design drawings (including design changes) mismatch the item description of any item in the tender BOQ and that change causes an increase or decrease in the cost of the item, the all-in unit rate shall be re-determined per the item description as actually executed, under the relevant clauses of Section 9.3, and the contract price adjusted. The four findings elements are: the comparison base is the pair of tender drawings / tender BOQ; any item; a cost increase or decrease is caused; pricing per the actual description with the method borrowed from Section 9.3. The responsibility basis is cl. 4.1.2 (a mandatory provision of codes): the accuracy and completeness of the tender BOQ are the tendering employer's responsibility. The 2013 edition has been superseded by GB/T 50500-2024, which merges mismatching item descriptions, erroneous and omitted items and quantity deviations into 'errors and omissions in the BOQ' (cl. 2.0.27), entering through cl. 8.2.1 and priced through cl. 8.9.1/8.9.2.
Applicable Codes
- GB 50500-2013 第9.4.1条
- GB 50500-2013 第9.4.2条
- GB 50500-2013 第9.4节说明
- GB 50500-2013 第4.1.2条(强制性条文)
- GB 50500-2013 第9.3.1条
- GB 50500-2013 第9.6.2条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第2.0.27条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第2.0.28条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第8.2.1条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第8.9.1条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第8.9.2条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第3.1.8条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第4.1.4条
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023 第4.4.4条
What This Card Covers
This card parses the original text, findings elements, responsibility basis and re-pricing path of 'mismatching item descriptions' -- a stand-alone price adjustment event -- under GB 50500-2013 Section 9.4, and maps where that section now sits in the current GB/T 50500-2024, so that live contracts and settlement documents cite the right clause numbers and apply the right edition.
Core Conclusions
1. Original clause text (GB 50500-2013)
Cl. 9.4.1: 'The item descriptions given by the employer in the tender BOQ shall be assumed accurate and comprehensive and consistent with the actual requirements of execution. The contractor shall execute the contract works per the tender BOQ provided by the employer, the content of the item descriptions and the related requirements, until the item is changed.'
Cl. 9.4.2: 'The contractor shall execute the contract works per the design drawings provided by the employer. If, during performance, the design drawings (including design changes) mismatch the item description of any item in the tender BOQ and that change causes an increase or decrease in the cost of the item, the all-in unit rate of the corresponding BOQ item shall be re-determined per the item description as actually executed and under the relevant clauses of Section 9.3 of this code, and the contract price adjusted.'
Key points of the Section 9.4 commentary: the item description embodies the essential value-defining features of a BOQ item, and the level of the unit rate is necessarily tied to it; hence the item descriptions given by the employer in the tender BOQ are assumed accurate and comprehensive and consistent with actual execution requirements -- otherwise the contractor cannot price.
2. The four findings elements of cl. 9.4.2 (all indispensable; disputes mostly stick on the last two)
- The comparison is between the 'design drawings (including design changes)' and the 'item descriptions of the tender BOQ' -- the base pair is tender drawings against tender BOQ, not as-built drawings against tender BOQ;
- 'Any item' -- not limited to major or high-value items; any item whose description mismatches reality can be claimed;
- 'Causes an increase or decrease in the cost of the item' -- under the 2013 edition this is a precondition for adjustment: a mismatch without a cost change triggers no cl. 9.4.2 adjustment and can only be a record / clarification / register matter;
- The pricing basis is re-determining the all-in unit rate 'per the item description as actually executed', with the method borrowed from Section 9.3 -- the mismatch itself is a stand-alone price adjustment event, and Section 9.3 is merely the source of its pricing method.
3. The pricing method borrowed from cl. 9.3.1 (key points of the original text) 1 Where the priced BOQ contains a rate applicable to the varied work, that rate shall be adopted; but where the variation changes the quantity of that BOQ item and the quantity deviation exceeds 15%, the rate shall be adjusted per cl. 9.6.2; 2 Where there is no applicable but an analogous item exists, the rate of the analogous item may be referenced within a reasonable range; 3 Where there is neither an applicable nor an analogous item, the contractor proposes a rate for the varied work based on the variation documents, the measurement rules and pricing methods, the published price information issued by the government construction cost administration and the contractor's price fluctuation rate, adjusted after the employer confirms (the fluctuation rate has two formulas, for tendered and non-tendered works); 4 Where there is neither, and the published price information lists no price, the contractor proposes a rate based on the variation documents, the measurement rules, the pricing methods and market prices with a lawful basis obtained through market enquiry, adjusted after the employer confirms. The quantity boundary connects to cl. 9.6.2: 'Where the quantity increases by more than 15%, the all-in unit rate for the increased quantity shall be adjusted down; where the quantity decreases by more than 15%, the all-in unit rate for the remaining quantity after the decrease shall be adjusted up.'
4. Responsibility basis for erroneous item descriptions (GB 50500-2013 cl. 4.1.2, a mandatory provision of codes) 'The tender BOQ must form part of the tender documents, and its accuracy and completeness shall be the tendering employer's responsibility.' 'The tendering employer is responsible for the accuracy and completeness of the tender BOQ it compiles, and tenderers price on the basis of the tender BOQ.' 'This is a mandatory provision and must be strictly enforced.' Together with cl. 9.4.1's 'shall be assumed accurate and comprehensive', it forms the basis that the risk of inaccurate or incomplete item descriptions falls on the employer.
5. Position in the current standard (GB/T 50500-2024) The 2024 edition no longer keeps the clause number 9.4; it merges the 2013 clauses 9.4 (mismatching item descriptions), 9.5 (omitted items) and 9.6 (quantity deviation) into 'errors and omissions in the BOQ'. Cl. 2.0.27 defines it: 'differences in BOQ itemisation, item description and quantity between the items listed in the BOQ of divisional and sub-divisional works items and the BOQ items required by the corresponding contract drawings and contract specifications, including over-listed items, erroneous and omitted items, mismatching item descriptions, quantity deviations and other similar.' Adjustment path: cl. 8.2.1 is the entry (for unit-rate contracts re-measure per cl. 7.2.1; 'erroneous or omitted BOQ items, mismatching item descriptions and quantity deviations are errors and omissions in the BOQ, and the contract price adjustment they cause shall be calculated') -> pricing under cl. 8.9.1 (change no more than 15%, inclusive) / cl. 8.9.2 (above 15%, exclusive). The responsibility basis shifts from 'always the tendering employer' to a split by contract pricing type: cl. 3.1.8, 6.1.6, 6.1.7 and 4.1.4.
Key difference: the 2024 edition no longer sets the precondition of 'causing an increase or decrease in the cost of the works' -- a mismatch itself constitutes a defect and the adjustment is calculated under the defect rules; the 2013 wording 'a cost change is required' holds only under contracts that adopt the 2013 edition.
Applicability Boundaries
- The Section 9.4 clause numbers apply to legacy contracts still governed by GB 50500-2013 (tender documents / contracts pricing per the 2013 edition); GB 50500-2013 has been superseded by GB/T 50500-2024 Standard for Valuation of Construction Works by Bills of Quantities, and contracts signed after 2024 follow the 2024 Sections 8.2 and 8.9 -- documents must no longer assert the existence of a 'Section 9.4'.
- This section resolves price adjustment only: it does not directly adjust time and does not replace the variation procedure (whether to issue a variation instruction or submit a scheme for approval is judged separately under the contract and procedural clauses such as cl. 8.9.6).
- Unit-rate contracts are the main field of application; under lump-sum contracts the contractor is responsible for the accuracy and completeness of the priced BOQ, BOQ defects other than items priced at provisional quantities do not adjust the contract price, and a mismatch cannot invoke cl. 9.4.2 to claim adjustment.
- Where the mismatch arises from the contractor's detailing design, its own choice of execution method or its own causes, it is outside this section.
- Construction cost expert assessment has its own practice guideline: T/ZBD 100.4-2023 cl. 4.4.4 item 3 -- 'where tendering and construction use the same edition of drawings and the tender BOQ mismatches the item description as actually executed, the all-in unit rate shall be adjusted per the contract'; item 4 applies likewise to quantity deviation. Its commentary notes: with the same edition of drawings, mismatching descriptions and quantity deviations may be treated as defects of that one edition; with two editions, the expert must first analyse whether the matter is a variation or detailing design, and in general mismatches and quantity deviations between two editions constitute a variation.
Further Reading
- GB 50500-2013 Code for Valuation of Construction Works by Bills of Quantities: Section 9.4 (9.4.1, 9.4.2 and the section commentary), Section 9.3 (9.3.1, the three-tier rate build-up), Section 9.6 (9.6.2, the 15% quantity adjustment), Chapter 4 (4.1.2, the mandatory provision).
- GB/T 50500-2024 Standard for Valuation of Construction Works by Bills of Quantities: cl. 2.0.27 (errors and omissions in the BOQ), cl. 2.0.28 (variation), cl. 7.2.1 (re-measurement under unit-rate contracts), cl. 7.4.2 (measurement of variations), cl. 8.2.1 (defect adjustment entry and the 15% divide), cl. 8.9.1 / 8.9.2 (determination of the all-in unit rate and the 15% boundary), cl. 3.1.8 and 4.1.4 (responsibility split by contract type).
- T/ZBD 100.4-2023 Practice Guideline for Construction Cost Expert Assessment, cl. 4.4.4 (technical requirements for adjusting the all-in unit rate under unit-rate contracts).
Keywords
- 项目特征不符
- GB 50500-2013 第9.4节
- 9.4.1
- 9.4.2
- errors and omissions in the BOQ
- 综合单价重新确定
- 第4.1.2条 强制性条文
- 按实际施工的项目特征