Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-25

Bills of quantities errors (item description mismatches, wrong or missing items, quantity deviations): determination, attribution of responsibility and the quantity-then-price adjustment sequence, including the split between unit-rate and lump-sum contracts and the 15% threshold rule

Where the BOQ and the drawings are inconsistent, the sequence is 'decide which prevails -> attribute the defect -> remeasure and adjust the price': under a unit-rate contract the BOQ prevails, under a lump-sum contract the contract drawings and specifications prevail (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 3.4.7); for unit-rate contracts, BOQ errors in the schedule of divisional work items lie with the employer - remeasure per clause 7.2.1, band the change per clause 8.2.1 at the 15% boundary (15% inclusive), and where not exceeded set the all-in unit rate adjustment per clause 8.9.1; for lump-sum contracts BOQ errors lie with the contractor, and the contract price is not adjusted except for items described as 'provisional quantities' (clauses 4.1.4, 4.1.6 and 6.1.7).

Applicable Codes

  • GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第2.0.27、3.3.2、3.4.7、4.1.4、4.1.6、6.1.7、7.2.1、8.2.1、8.9.1条
  • GB/T 50319-2013 建设工程监理规范 第6.3.3条
  • T/ZBD 100.4-2023 建设工程造价鉴定作业指引 第4.4.4条
  • GB/T 51262-2017 建设工程造价鉴定规范 第5.3.3条

Topic positioning

During contract performance, where the priced BOQ is inconsistent with the contract drawings, item descriptions or quantity bases (bills of quantities errors), the matter is handled in the sequence 'decide which prevails -> attribute the defect -> remeasure and adjust the price'. It applies to settlement checking, variations and construction cost expert assessment under both unit-rate and lump-sum contracts.

Core conclusions

1. Term definition (GB/T 50500-2024 clause 2.0.27) Bills of quantities errors: 'differences between the items listed in the schedule of divisional work items of the BOQ and the items required by the corresponding contract drawings and contract specifications, in itemisation, item descriptions and quantities; including surplus items, wrong or missing items, item description mismatches, quantity deviations and the like.' The commentary further defines this as the differences between the tender BOQ and the design documents at tender stage (for non-tendered works, the design documents at contract signature).

2. Which prevails when drawings and BOQ conflict (clause 3.4.7) 'Where, during performance of a unit-rate contract, the contract drawings are inconsistent with the tender schedule of divisional work items, the BOQ prevails; where, during performance of a lump-sum contract, the contract drawings and contract specifications are inconsistent with the priced BOQ, the contract drawings and contract specifications prevail.' The same clause adds: under a cost-plus contract the contract total is provisional - the works items and quantities are determined as executed and multiplied by the item cost rates to give the works cost, and the contract total is adjusted after adding the fee and VAT as agreed.

3. Risk attribution: unit-rate contracts to the employer, lump-sum contracts to the contractor

  • Clause 3.3.2: risks to be borne by the employer, which the contractor may leave out of account in tendering, include: '1 under unit-rate contracts, bills of quantities errors in the schedules provided by the employer other than the bill of preliminaries; 2 errors in the source data and reference documents for the works provided by the employer; 3 variations approved by the employer; 4 acceleration, early completion, suspension or postponement of the works required by the employer; 5 changes in laws, regulations and policy; 6 cost changes and fluctuation ranges beyond the risk scope and band the tender documents assign to the contractor...; 7 other matters for which the employer is responsible.'
  • Clause 4.1.4: where the BOQ is used for a lump-sum contract, 'its items and quantities are deemed to conform to the tender drawings and the technical standards; where bills of quantities errors exist, the contractor bears the responsibility of supplementing and completing them... without adjustment'; where used for a unit-rate contract, 'the itemisation, the work content of the item descriptions and the quantities are deemed to conform to the tender drawings and the technical standards; where errors exist in the schedule of divisional work items, the employer bears the responsibility for the relevant BOQ errors', adjusted per section 8.2.
  • Clause 6.1.7: after review, a tenderer under a lump-sum contract 'may supplement, complete and price items within the schedule of divisional work items of the priced BOQ, and is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of that priced schedule... except where the tender BOQ describes items as provisional quantities priced at unit rates, the contract price shall not be adjusted for bills of quantities errors.'
  • Clause 4.1.6: 'for a BOQ used under a lump-sum contract, price changes caused by BOQ errors are deemed included in the contract total and are not adjusted during performance; but items in the schedule of divisional work items described as provisional quantities, and their quantities, are remeasured under the unit-rate pricing rules of this standard, and the contract prices of the related items and the contract total are adjusted accordingly.'

4. Remeasurement and price adjustment path for unit-rate contracts

  • Clause 7.2.1: unit-rate priced items in the schedule of divisional work items are remeasured against 'the actual construction drawings of the works provided by the employer and the variation instructions issued and confirmed'; 'differences between the items and quantities measured from the contract drawings and the items and quantities in the priced BOQ are bills of quantities errors, and the contract price is adjusted per section 8.2 of this standard, but items priced per item in the schedule of divisional work items are neither remeasured nor adjusted'; differences between the contract drawings and the actual construction drawings are variations, adjusted as variations.
  • Clause 8.2.1 banding: item changes (additions or omissions) or quantity changes not exceeding 15% (15% inclusive) of the quantity carried in the priced BOQ for the corresponding item -> adjust per clause 8.9.1; changes exceeding 15% (15% exclusive) -> adjust per clause 8.9.2.
  • Clause 8.9.1, five tiers for setting the all-in unit rate: (1) the same item description implemented under the same construction conditions -> the corresponding contract rate applies; (2) a similar item description or similar construction conditions -> the all-in rate converted and adjusted from the contract rate of a similar item; (3) a different item description or different construction conditions -> a market-reasonable all-in unit rate negotiated with reference to the pricing rules and pricing level of similar contract rates; (4) a different item description implemented under different construction conditions -> negotiated with reference to the all-in unit rates of similar items in comparable works; (5) a variation reducing or cancelling items that significantly changes the construction conditions during implementation -> negotiated per the circumstances of implementation, market prices, the contract-rate pricing rules and the pricing level. Price-influencing factors fall into two groups: item descriptions (material changes, construction method changes, effects on other divisional items, other description changes) and construction conditions (foundations, building height, member sizes, construction season, protection of completed areas, site access restrictions, material transport modes, plant usage, the attendance charge within main contractor's attendance and coordination provisions, other condition changes).

5. Sequence for settling variation prices where not agreed (GB/T 50319-2013 clause 6.3.3) '1 Where the contract already contains a price applicable to the varied works, the contract price is changed at that existing price. 2 Where the contract contains a price analogous to the varied works, the contract price may be changed by reference to that analogous price. 3 Where the contract contains neither an applicable nor an analogous price, the chief supervising engineer should negotiate fully with the employer and the contractor to reach agreement on the variation price; failing agreement, the chief supervising engineer determines a reasonable rate or price for the variation on a cost-plus-profit basis, and any objection is handled under the dispute procedure agreed in the construction contract.'

6. Construction cost expert assessment basis

  • T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.4.4: where, on the same drawing revision, the actual work as built does not match the item descriptions of the tender BOQ -> adjust the all-in unit rate as agreed in the contract; where a quantity deviation exceeds the band agreed in the contract -> the all-in unit rate of the excess portion may be adjusted, and where no band is agreed, adjustment follows the national standard or industry practice. Note: the same drawing revision is a 'description mismatch / quantity deviation' situation; with two drawing revisions, first analyse whether it is a variation or design development - generally, description mismatches and quantity differences across two revisions both constitute variations.
  • GB/T 51262-2017 clause 5.3.3: where the contract is unclear on the pricing basis or method, the expert assessor must establish the facts of performance - if the contract was performed as written, assessment is proposed on that basis; if not, the assessor may propose 'assessing by reference to the pricing bases and methods applicable at the location of the assessed project at the same period, and the market price data at contract signature', and assessment follows the instructing party's decision.

Boundaries of application

This card assumes the GB/T 50500-2024 pricing system; where the contract adopts GB 50500-2013 or another system (highway, water conservancy and other industry schedules), the corresponding standard clauses must be checked - the 2024 clause numbers and the 15% band must not be applied directly. Under lump-sum contracts, items described as 'provisional quantities' are the only exception open to remeasurement. Adjustments for description mismatches and quantity deviations are limited to what the contract leaves unagreed or unclear; where the contract expressly freezes the all-in unit rate, the agreement prevails (unless the clause is held invalid with other requirements applying). Items priced per item on a lump basis are not remeasured. This card does not address the ranking of measurement bases themselves (that question is handled as 'contract agreement -> the national measurement standard matching the contract category -> industry or local standards').

Further reading

GB/T 50500-2024 clause 2.0.27 (definition of BOQ errors), clause 3.3.2 (employer risk events), clause 3.4.7 (drawings-versus-BOQ conflicts), clauses 4.1.4 and 6.1.7 (defect responsibility at preparation and tender stages), clause 4.1.6 (no adjustment under lump-sum contracts and the provisional quantities exception), clause 7.2.1 (remeasurement under unit-rate contracts), section 8.2 (price adjustment for BOQ errors, including the 15% boundary in 8.2.1), clauses 8.9.1 and 8.9.2 (all-in unit rate adjustment rules); GB/T 50319-2013 clause 6.3.3; T/ZBD 100.4-2023 clause 4.4.4; GB/T 51262-2017 clause 5.3.3.

Keywords

Cited By