Deciding claims to adjust the contract price for omitted items in the tender BOQ (BOQ errors) during performance: risk is allocated by the contract pricing method and the BOQ section in which the omission falls - omission from the work-section bills under a unit-rate contract may rest with the employer and be adjusted under section 8.2; a lump-sum contract is in principle not adjusted (except provisional quantity items); the bill of preliminaries is always the contractor's responsibility - with judicial limits and points of procedure and proof
Whether adjustment is possible depends not on the omission itself but on the contract pricing method and the BOQ section in which the omission falls: GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 3.1.8 provides that under a unit-rate contract the accuracy and completeness of the work-section BOQ rest with the employer (adjustment by re-measurement under section 8.2 may be claimed, with a 15% increase or decrease in quantities as the divide between cl. 8.9.1 and 8.9.2); under a lump-sum contract they rest with the contractor, and save for unit-priced items in provisional quantities the contract price and contract time are not adjusted for BOQ errors (cl. 6.1.7 and 8.2.3); the bill of preliminaries compiled on a per-item basis is always the contractor's responsibility, with only statutory safety provisions and similar exceptions adjustable. Where the contract provides settlement at a fixed price and adjustment is claimed for major changes in labour cost or key material prices, the court will not support it (Article 9 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12).
Applicable Codes
- 《建设工程工程量清单计价标准》GB/T 50500-2024 第3.1.8、3.5.4、4.1.4、6.1.6、6.1.7、8.1.3、8.2.1、8.2.2、8.2.3、8.9.1、8.9.2条
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第五百一十条、第五百三十三条、第七百九十三条
- 最高人民法院法释〔2020〕25号《关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》第十九条、第二十二条
- 最高人民法院法释〔2026〕12号《关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》第九条、第十一条、第二十三条
- 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第六十七条、第七十九条
- 《中华人民共和国仲裁法》(2025修订)第五条、第十条
Subject Positioning
This card decides the question 'where the tender BOQ omits items, can adjustment of the contract price be claimed during performance of the construction contract': risk attribution is set first by the contract pricing method and the BOQ section in which the omission falls, then quantified under sections 8.2 and 8.9 of GB/T 50500-2024, and finally the limiting conditions at the judicial and procedural levels of proof are addressed. It applies to omission disputes arising where tenders are invited on BOQ-based pricing, during performance or at settlement.
Core Conclusions
1. The test in one sentence
An omitted BOQ item is in law a question of allocating the risk of 'BOQ errors'; the outcome is not decided by the omission itself. GB/T 50500-2024 cl. 3.1.8 reads: 'For works adopting a unit-rate contract, the accuracy and completeness of the work-section BOQ shall be the responsibility of the employer; for works adopting a lump-sum contract, the accuracy and completeness of the priced work-section BOQ shall be the responsibility of the contractor. Whether the works adopt a unit-rate contract or a lump-sum contract, the completeness and accuracy of the bill of preliminaries compiled on a per-item basis shall be the responsibility of the contractor.' The clause further makes clear: 'For works adopting a unit-rate contract, the completeness of the itemisation of the work-section BOQ, the accuracy of the item descriptions and the accuracy of the quantities shall be the responsibility of the employer, and tenderers shall not alter them of their own accord at tendering. For works adopting a lump-sum contract... they shall be the responsibility of the contractor, and tenderers may add BOQ items and price them of their own accord according to the tender drawings and the technical standards. Whether a unit-rate contract or a lump-sum contract is adopted, the completeness of the itemisation and the accuracy of the pricing of the bill of preliminaries shall be the responsibility of the contractor; the tenderer may decide at tendering whether to add items and price them, bearing the risk of its own pricing.'
2. Affirmative scenarios (adjustment may be claimed)
- Omitted or mis-stated items in the work-section BOQ under a unit-rate contract. Cl. 6.1.6: 'Whether or not the tenderer has raised questions or objections, the completeness and accuracy of the work-section BOQ are the responsibility of the employer; where BOQ errors exist in the BOQ items or in the corrected items (if any), the relevant prices and the total contract price shall be adjusted under section 8.2 of this standard.' The tenderer should review within the prescribed time after receiving the tender documents, raise written requests for clarification where it has questions or objections as prescribed by the tender documents, and price against the corrected BOQ after the employer verifies and corrects it.
- Quantification rule (cl. 8.2.1): under a unit-rate contract, all BOQ items and quantities in the work-section bills are re-measured against the contract drawings under cl. 7.2.1, and the contract price is adjusted as prescribed for the differences from the priced BOQ caused by BOQ errors - (a) where the error causes a change of BOQ items (items added or omitted), or the quantities increase or decrease and the change 'does not exceed 15% (inclusive) of the quantity contained in the contract BOQ for the item concerned', adjustment is calculated under cl. 8.9.1; (b) where the increase or decrease 'exceeds 15% (exclusive) of the quantity contained in the contract BOQ for the item concerned', adjustment is calculated under cl. 8.9.2.
- At no more than 15%, the all-in unit rate is determined in five tiers (cl. 8.9.1): the same item description executed under the same construction conditions -> the corresponding contract rate applies; a similar item description under the same conditions, or the same item description under similar conditions -> the all-in unit rate converted and adjusted from the contract rate of the analogous BOQ item; a different item description under the same conditions, or the same item description under different conditions -> a market-reasonable all-in rate may be negotiated in light of the execution of the works, the rate build-up rules and the pricing level of analogous items; a different item description under different conditions -> may be negotiated by reference to the all-in rates of analogous BOQ items of similar works; where a variation reducing or omitting BOQ items materially changes the construction conditions of the works in execution -> the all-in rate may be negotiated in light of the circumstances of the executed works, market prices, the contract rate rules and the pricing level.
- Above 15% (cl. 8.9.2): where BOQ items and their quantities increase, pricing is made after a reasonable reduction of the contract rate and the new all-in rates, taking into account the effect of purchase-price discounts on labour and materials brought by the increased quantity; where BOQ items and their quantities decrease, pricing is made after a reasonable increase of the contract rate and the new all-in rates, taking into account the loss of such discounts brought by the decreased quantity.
- Unit-priced items in provisional quantities under a lump-sum contract: cl. 8.2.3: 'where the work-section BOQ agreed in the contract contains items whose quantities are provisional and which are priced per unit, adjustment may be made under cl. 7.2.1 and cl. 8.2.1 of this standard.' Cl. 4.1.4 is to the same effect - where the tender drawings cannot satisfy the needs of accurate itemisation and measurement, the item description of the items concerned shall state 'provisional quantities', provisional quantities shall be given together with the tender drawings, and the actual quantities may be adjusted under the provisions applicable to unit-rate contracts.
- Where the omission is in fact works outside the contract added by the employer's revised drawings or instructions: it is no longer dealt with as a BOQ error but under the valuation of variations - under cl. 8.9.1 and 8.9.2, the all-in rate is determined and priced on the changed quantities confirmed under sections 7.1, 7.2 and 7.4.
3. Negative scenarios (no adjustment claimable)
- Omission from the work-section BOQ under a lump-sum contract (not provisional quantities): cl. 4.1.4: 'its BOQ items and quantities are deemed to conform to the tender drawings and the technical standards; where BOQ errors exist, the contractor shall bear the responsibility of supplementing and completing them, and the BOQ errors shall not be adjusted, under cl. 6.1.7 of this standard.' Cl. 6.1.7: 'where the tenderer considers on review that the tender BOQ or, as corrected (if any), the work-section BOQ contains BOQ errors, it may supplement and complete them in the priced work-section BOQ and is responsible for the completeness and accuracy of the priced work-section BOQ... save for work-section items stated in the tender BOQ as unit-priced in provisional quantities, the contract price shall not be adjusted for the existence of BOQ errors.' Cl. 8.2.3: 'for works adopting a lump-sum contract, the contract price and the contract period shall not be adjusted for BOQ errors in the contract BOQ.'
- Omission from the bill of preliminaries (the same under both contract types): cl. 8.2.2: 'where the BOQ errors have been rectified under cl. 8.2.1 of this standard, save for the statutory safety provisions and the preliminary items provided in cl. 7.2.1(2) of this standard, neither the preliminaries in the contract BOQ nor the contract period shall be adjusted.' That is, apart from statutory safety provisions (calculated as agreed in the contract) and the formwork works, temporary works and preliminary items which the contract requires to be measured and which are listed in the work-section bills, the other preliminaries are not adjusted for BOQ errors.
- The tenderer's own omission or failure to fill in prices (where the BOQ itself lists the items): cl. 3.5.4 - where the all-in rates and amounts of work-section items in a lump-sum contract, or the prices of preliminaries items or of per-item work-section items, are not filled in as required, the costs 'may be deemed to be included in the all-in rates, amounts and the tender total of the other BOQ items, and are not re-priced or adjusted at settlement of the works'; where the all-in rates and amounts of work-section items in a unit-rate contract are not filled in as required, the tenderer may be required to clarify or explain, and the increased amount of the items concerned so confirmed is deducted from the preliminaries tender total, with any shortfall apportioned pro rata to the all-in rates and amounts of the work-section items.
- Agreement to settle at a fixed price plus claims of major changes in labour cost or main building material prices: Article 9 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12: 'Where the construction contract provides that the works price is to be settled at a fixed price and a party claims adjustment of the works price on the ground of major changes in labour cost or the prices of main building materials occurring within the agreed construction period, the people's court shall not support the claim, unless the parties agree otherwise or Article 533 of the Civil Code on change of circumstances applies.'
- The contract or tender documents expressly provide that the risk of omission is wrapped up in the contractor's price: the agreed terms prevail; GB/T 50500-2024 is a recommended national standard and, unless incorporated by the tender documents or the contract, does not of itself bind a specific project.
4. Interface with adjudication and procedure
- The agreed pricing basis prevails: Article 19 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25: 'Where the parties have agreed on the pricing standard or pricing method for the construction works, the works price is settled according to the agreement. Where a design change causes a change in the quantities or the quality standard of the works and the parties cannot agree on the price of that part, the works price may be settled by reference to the pricing method or pricing standard published by the local construction administration authority at the place of the works at the time the construction contract was signed.'
- The tender documents prevail: Article 22 of Fa Shi [2020] No. 25: 'Where the construction contract signed by the parties is inconsistent with the tender documents, the bid or the letter of acceptance as to the scope of the works, the construction period, the quality of the works or the price of the works, and a party requests that the tender documents, the bid or the letter of acceptance be taken as the basis for settling the works price, the people's court shall support the request.'
- Gap-filling where the agreement is unclear: Article 510 of the Civil Code: 'After the contract takes effect, where the parties have not agreed, or have unclearly agreed, on quality, price or remuneration, place of performance and the like, they may conclude a supplementary agreement; failing which, the matter is determined by the relevant clauses of the contract or by trade usage.'
- Contract void but works accepted: Article 793(1) of the Civil Code: 'where the construction contract is void but the construction works have passed acceptance, the contractor may be compensated by reference to the agreement in the contract on the works price'; Article 11 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12 makes clear that that 'agreement' 'includes reference to the amount of the works price agreed in the construction contract, the pricing method, the payment time, the adjustment method and the settlement method' - that is, the adjustment and settlement methods for omissions are equally within the scope of the reference.
- Temporal dividing point between the old and new interpretations: Article 23 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12: 'This Interpretation takes effect on 30 June 2026. For first-instance construction contract dispute cases newly accepted by the people's courts after this Interpretation takes effect, this Interpretation applies. Where judicial interpretations previously issued by the Supreme People's Court are inconsistent with this Interpretation, this Interpretation prevails.' The line is drawn by the date of acceptance at first instance; cases accepted earlier are governed by the former interpretations such as Fa Shi [2020] No. 25.
- Adjustment procedure: cl. 8.1.3 - after receiving the contract price adjustment report and the related materials, the employer shall verify within the agreed time; where it confirms, it shall notify the contractor in writing; where it does not confirm, it shall reply in writing with its checking comments; 'where it neither confirms nor raises checking comments, the contract price adjustment report submitted by the contractor is deemed accepted by the employer'; adjustment matters follow the procedure of submission, checking, review, re-examination and confirmation.
- Proof and expert assessment: Civil Procedure Law (2023 amendment) Article 67, 'a party has the responsibility to provide evidence for its own claims'; Article 79 permits application for expert assessment of the special questions for ascertaining facts, the assessor being agreed by the parties or, failing agreement, appointed by the court. The party alleging the omission must therefore prove 'in the drawings but not in the BOQ' with the tender drawings, the technical standards, the priced BOQ, the clarification correspondence and the measurement records.
- Dispute resolution: Arbitration Law (2025 revision) Article 5 - where the parties have reached an arbitration agreement and one party sues in the people's court, the court shall not accept the case (unless the arbitration agreement is invalid or the law provides otherwise); Article 10 - arbitration applies finality on one award.
Scope of Application
- Premised on the contract pricing method and the BOQ section in which the omission falls being clearly determinable; the same BOQ allocates the risk of errors in exactly opposite ways under a unit-rate and a lump-sum contract, and where the pricing method is not stated it must first be determined from the contract and the tender documents.
- GB/T 50500-2024 is a recommended national standard (effective 1 September 2025, replacing GB 50500-2013); its responsibility clauses bind a specific project only where incorporated by the tender documents or the contract; clause 4.1.2 of the 2013 edition (a mandatory provision: 'the accuracy and completeness of the tender BOQ... shall be the responsibility of the party inviting tenders') assigned the matter across the board to the tendering employer, and projects contracted before 1 September 2025 are judged by the edition then in force and the contractual agreement.
- Not covered by this card: the specific handling of other defect types such as mismatched item descriptions and quantity deviations (see the related cards); nor the arithmetic of any particular adjustment.
- The 15% test takes 'the quantity contained in the contract BOQ for the item concerned' as its base, compared item by item; at exactly 15%, cl. 8.9.2 is not triggered.
Further Reading
- GB/T 50500-2024 Standard for BOQ Pricing of Construction Works: cl. 3.1.8 (attribution of responsibility for BOQ completeness), cl. 3.5.4 (treatment of omitted or unfilled tender pricing), cl. 4.1.4 (BOQ preparation and the consequences of defects under lump-sum and unit-rate contracts), cl. 6.1.6 (tender review and clarification under unit-rate contracts), cl. 6.1.7 (tender review, supplementation and the no-adjustment principle under lump-sum contracts), cl. 8.1.3 (adjustment verification procedure and deemed acceptance), cl. 8.2.1 (defect adjustment under unit-rate contracts and the 15% divide), cl. 8.2.2 (exceptions for preliminaries), cl. 8.2.3 (no adjustment under lump-sum contracts and the provisional quantities exception), cl. 8.9.1 (five tiers of all-in rates at no more than 15%), cl. 8.9.2 (rate reduction or increase above 15%).
- Civil Code of the PRC Articles 510, 533 (change of circumstances) and 793.
- Fa Shi [2020] No. 25, SPC Interpretation (I) on Construction Contract Disputes, Articles 19 and 22.
- Fa Shi [2026] No. 12, SPC Interpretation (II) on Construction Contract Disputes, Article 9 (fixed price and major price changes), Article 11 (reference to the contractual agreement includes adjustment and settlement methods), Article 23 (effective 30 June 2026, applying to newly accepted first-instance cases).
- Civil Procedure Law of the PRC (2023 amendment) Articles 67 and 79; Arbitration Law of the PRC (2025 revision) Articles 5 and 10.