Engineering Knowledge Cards.
Confidence HighUpdated 2026-10-25

Handling the mismatch between construction-drawing quantities and tender BOQ quantities: measurement of actually completed quantities under GB 50500-2013 Chapter 8 and the 15% deviation price adjustment of Section 9.6 (including the divergence between the two lump-sum contract regimes of Clauses 8.3.1/8.3.2), against GB/T 50500-2024 Sections 7.2/8.2/8.9 routing the rules by contract type

GB 50500-2013 Clause 8.2.1 (a mandatory provision) requires that 'quantities shall be determined by the quantities of the contract works that the contractor has completed and that are to be measured'; the quantities stated in the tender BOQ are only estimated quantities and the common basis for tender pricing, and the final account quantities are determined by the quantities actually completed and to be measured, calculated by the contractor under the calculation rules of the current national measurement standards, not by the BOQ quantities. Clause 8.3.1 provides that for lump-sum contracts formed by tendering on a bill of quantities basis the quantities are still calculated under Section 8.2 (i.e. quantity differences remain adjustable), which diverges from Clause 8.3.2: for lump-sum contracts formed by letting the works on the basis of construction drawings and budgets examined and approved, except for variations, the BOQ quantities are the final settlement quantities. GB/T 50500-2024 instead routes the rules by contract type: for unit-rate contracts the employer bears the BOQ defects, the works are re-measured under Clause 7.2.1 and the price adjusted via Clause 8.2.1 (15% as the boundary) and then Clauses 8.9.1/8.9.2; for lump-sum contracts Clause 7.2.2 allows no re-measurement, and Clause 8.2.3 provides that 'the contract price and the time for completion shall not be adjusted for defects in the contract bill of quantities' (except items priced at provisional quantities). Directional rule for quantity deviations beyond 15%: where the increase exceeds 15%, the all-in unit rate of the increased portion is adjusted downwards; where the decrease exceeds 15%, the all-in unit rate of the remaining portion after the decrease is adjusted upwards.

Applicable Codes

  • GB 50500-2013 · Code of Valuation with Bill Quantity of Construction Works 第4.1.2、4.1.3、6.1.4、6.2.2、8.1.1、8.2.1、8.2.2、8.3.1、8.3.2、9.5.1、9.6.1、9.6.2、11.2.1、11.2.2、11.2.6条
  • GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第3.1.8、3.2.2、3.3.2、3.3.3、4.1.4、6.1.6、6.1.7、7.1.1、7.1.8、7.2.1、7.2.2、8.2.1、8.2.3、8.9.1、8.9.2条
  • 住房城乡建设部公告 2024 年第 212 号(GB/T 50500-2024 发布,2025-09-01 实施,GB 50500-2013 同时废止)

Scope and purpose

Answers how a mismatch between the quantities computed from the construction drawings and the quantities listed in the tender bill of quantities is handled at the tender pricing stage and at the final account stage, and how the rules of GB 50500-2013 and GB/T 50500-2024 differ. Applicable to rate checking, final account review and quantity-difference disputes on works tendered and let on a BOQ basis.

Key conclusions

1. Characterisation: first tell a 'BOQ defect' from a 'variation'

Where the drawings are unchanged but the BOQ under-quantifies or miscalculates (erroneous or omitted items, non-matching item descriptions, quantity deviations), the difference is a defect in the bill of quantities; where the drawings themselves are modified (contract drawings differing from those actually built to), it is a variation. The former follows the BOQ defect rules (attribution depends on contract type), the latter the measurement and valuation rules for variations, which allow adjustment under both contract types. GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 7.2.1 states: 'differences between the work item list of the contract BOQ and the contract drawings are defects in the bill of quantities ... differences between the contract drawings and the drawings actually used for construction are variations.'

2. Tender stage: price against the tender BOQ as issued; do not alter quantities

  • GB 50500-2013 Clause 6.1.4 (a mandatory provision, to be strictly enforced): 'Tenderers must fill in prices against the tender BOQ. The item coding, item names, item descriptions, units of measurement and quantities must be identical with the tender BOQ.' That is, at tender stage quantities may not be altered and items may not be added or deleted; the tenderer may only build up its own rates; objections to quantities go through written requests for clarification. Clause 4.1.2 (mandatory) provides that 'the tender BOQ must form part of the tender documents, and its accuracy and completeness shall be the responsibility of the employer', and Clause 4.1.3 identifies the BOQ as 'one of the bases for preparing the tender price ceiling, the tender, calculating or adjusting quantities, claims, etc.'
  • How quantity-difference risk enters the all-in unit rate: GB 50500-2013 Clause 6.2.2 requires the all-in unit rate to include 'the scope of risk and its costs allocated to tenderers in the tender documents; where the tender documents are silent, the employer should be asked to clarify', and provides that 'during construction, where the risk events and their scope (band) that arise fall within the ranges agreed in the contract, the contract price shall not be adjusted' - that is, quantity-difference risk within the agreed band is embedded in the all-in unit rate; only amounts beyond the agreed band (or falling within BOQ defect liability where the contract is silent) are adjusted separately.
  • GB/T 50500-2024 converts to the same position: Clause 6.1.6 (unit-rate contracts) requires tenderers to check the BOQ and raise written queries, but 'whether or not the tenderer has raised questions or objections, the completeness and accuracy of the work item list is the responsibility of the employer'; Clause 6.1.7 (lump-sum contracts) allows the tenderer, after checking, to supplement and complete the item listings, item descriptions and quantities in its priced BOQ and to price them, taking responsibility for the completeness and accuracy of the priced BOQ; Clause 3.2.2 requires the all-in unit rate of work items to include 'the costs needed where defects in the bill of quantities arise under a lump-sum contract' and 'risk costs within the scope and band agreed in the contract and prescribed in Section 3.3 of this standard'.

3. Settlement stage - GB 50500-2013 basis (where the contract or tender documents cite the 2013 edition)

  1. Basis of the measurement rules: Clause 8.1.1 (mandatory): 'quantities must be calculated in accordance with the quantity take-off rules of the current national measurement standards applicable to the relevant works.'
  2. Measurement of what was actually completed: Clause 8.2.1 (mandatory): 'quantities must be determined by the quantities of the contract works that the contractor has completed and that are to be measured.' The commentary explains that the quantities in the tender BOQ are estimated quantities, the common basis of tender pricing and a common platform for evaluation; 'the quantities for the final account between the employer and the contractor shall be determined by the quantities actually completed and to be measured, calculated by the contractor under the quantity take-off rules of the current national measurement standards, and not by the quantities stated in the tender BOQ.'
  3. Missing items, deviations and variations all follow completed quantities: Clause 8.2.2 (unit-rate contracts): 'where measurement during construction reveals missing items in the tender BOQ, quantity deviations, or quantity increases or decreases caused by variations, the quantities shall be the quantities of the works completed by the contractor in performing its contractual obligations.'
  4. Opposite outcomes for the two kinds of lump-sum contract (the key divergence in the 2013 edition):
    • Clause 8.3.1: 'for lump-sum contracts formed by tendering on a bill of quantities basis, the quantities shall be calculated in accordance with Section 8.2 of this standard.' The commentary gives the reason: as the quantities are provided by the employer (see Clause 4.1.2), differences between them and the works as executed are to be adjusted, hence measurement under Section 8.2 - for a lump-sum contract formed through BOQ tendering, quantity differences remain adjustable.
    • Clause 8.3.2: 'for lump-sum contracts formed by letting the works on the basis of construction drawings and budgets examined and approved, except for the quantity increases and decreases prescribed for variations, the quantities of each item of the lump-sum contract shall be the final quantities used by the contractor for settlement.' The commentary calls this 'the most essential difference from unit-rate contracts'.
  5. The price-adjustment chain for quantity differences: Clause 9.5.1 (work items newly added to the BOQ for missing items): 'the unit rate shall be determined in accordance with Clause 9.3.1 of this standard and the contract price adjusted'; Clause 9.6.1: 'where the actual quantities to be calculated deviate from the tender BOQ and the conditions of Clauses 9.6.2 and 9.6.3 of this standard are met, the employer and the contractor shall adjust the contract price'; Clause 9.6.2: 'for any tender BOQ item, where the quantity deviation exceeds 15% due to the quantity deviations specified in this section and the variations specified in Section 9.3, adjustment may be made. Where the quantity increases by more than 15%, the all-in unit rate of the increased portion of the quantity shall be adjusted downwards; where the quantity decreases by more than 15%, the all-in unit rate of the remaining portion of the quantity after the decrease shall be adjusted upwards.'
  6. Organisation of settlement: Clause 11.2.1 lists seven bases of settlement (this standard; the construction contract; the quantities confirmed by both parties during performance and the contract prices settled for them; the contract price additions (deductions) after confirmed adjustments; the design documents and related information; the tender documents; other bases) and states that settlement should 'use the records measured, priced and certified by the employer and the contractor during performance of the contract, without re-measuring and re-pricing everything'; Clause 11.2.2: 'unit-rate items within the work items and the preliminaries shall be calculated from the quantities confirmed by the parties and the all-in unit rates in the priced BOQ; where adjustments have occurred, from the adjusted all-in unit rates confirmed by the parties'; Clause 11.2.6: 'measurement results and contract prices already confirmed by the parties during performance of the contract shall enter the final account directly.'

4. Settlement stage - GB/T 50500-2024 basis

  1. Object of measurement: Clause 7.1.1: 'the contract works shall be measured by the works that the contractor has completed as required by the contract and that are to be measured', quantities being calculated under the national and industry quantity take-off standards and supplementary rules agreed by the parties; Clause 7.1.8: 'measurement results signed and confirmed by the employer and the contractor shall serve as the basis for adjusting the contract price and for settling the works' (unless the contract provides otherwise, expressly limits them to a basis for progress payments, or the results are rough estimates).
  2. Unit-rate contracts: Clause 7.2.1 requires re-measurement against the contract drawings and the issued and confirmed variation instructions, under the agreed calculation rules, as the basis for pricing; differences between the BOQ items and quantities measured from the contract drawings and the priced BOQ are defects in the bill of quantities, adjusted under Section 8.2, 'but work items priced as a whole item shall not be re-measured or adjusted'. Clause 8.2.1: where BOQ items increase or decrease, or the quantities increase or decrease by no more than 15% (15% included) of the quantities contained in the contract BOQ for the corresponding item, the adjustment is calculated under Clause 8.9.1; beyond 15% (15% excluded), under Clause 8.9.2.
  3. Lump-sum contracts: Clause 7.2.2: 'the work item list need not be re-measured, and the contract price shall not be adjusted for defects in the work item bill of quantities'; unit-rate priced items stated in the tender BOQ as provisional quantities are measured under Clause 7.2.1 paragraph 1; variations are measured under Clause 7.4.3. Clause 8.2.3: 'for works adopting lump-sum contracts, the contract price and the time for completion shall not be adjusted for defects in the contract bill of quantities. Where the work item list contains items stated as provisional quantities priced at unit rates as agreed in the contract, adjustment may be made under Clauses 7.2.1 and 8.2.1 of this standard.'
  4. Adjustment methods and direction: Clause 8.9.1 (increases or decreases not exceeding 15%) proceeds in order - the corresponding contract unit rate for identical item descriptions under identical construction conditions; for similar item descriptions or similar construction conditions, the all-in unit rate converted and adjusted from the contract unit rate of a similar BOQ item; for different item descriptions or different construction conditions, a market-reasonable all-in unit rate negotiated by reference to the pricing rules and tendered rate levels of similar items; where a reduction or cancellation of BOQ items significantly changes the construction conditions, by negotiation on actual conditions and market prices. Clause 8.9.2 (beyond 15%): for added BOQ items and quantities, priced 'after reasonably lowering the contract unit rate and the new all-in unit rate, taking into account the effect of purchasing-price discounts for labour and materials caused by the increased quantities'; for reductions, priced after reasonably raising the contract unit rate and the new all-in unit rate, taking into account the effect of purchasing-price discounts for labour and materials caused by the decreased quantities.

5. Quick reference: key differences between the two editions

Item GB 50500-2013 GB/T 50500-2024
Liability for BOQ accuracy and completeness Clause 4.1.2, mandatory: always the employer's Clause 3.1.8 splits by contract type: employer for unit-rate contracts, contractor for lump-sum contracts; preliminaries compiled per item always the contractor's
Settlement measurement Clause 8.2.1, mandatory: determined by the quantities actually completed by the contractor and to be measured Clauses 7.1.1, 7.2.1 and 7.2.2 distinguish by contract type whether re-measurement applies
Quantity differences in lump-sum contracts formed through BOQ tendering Clause 8.3.1: still measured under Section 8.2 (adjustable) Clauses 7.2.2 and 8.2.3: no re-measurement, no adjustment for BOQ defects (except provisional-quantity items)
Lump-sum contracts let on construction drawings and budgets Clause 8.3.2: the BOQ quantities are the final settlement quantities Absorbed into the general lump-sum rule of Clause 7.2.2
15% deviation Clause 9.6.2: beyond 15% adjustable, the rate lowered for the increased portion and raised for the remaining portion after a decrease Clauses 8.2.1 and 8.9.1/8.9.2: 15% (inclusive/exclusive) selects the adjustment method, with rates likewise lowered/raised beyond the threshold

Applicability boundaries

  • Applies only to works let on a bill of quantities basis; the conclusions do not apply to contracts priced by quota norms or by other pricing methods.
  • Which edition applies follows the contract (tender documents): GB 50500-2013 was a compulsory national standard and has been replaced by GB/T 50500-2024 (approved by Ministry of Housing and Urban-Rural Development Announcement No. 212 of 2024, effective from 1 September 2025, when GB 50500-2013 is repealed at the same time); with GB changed to the recommendatory GB/T, it binds only when cited in the tender documents or the contract. Works contracted before 2025-09-01 remain governed by the 2013 edition.
  • The conclusions presuppose that the cause of the quantity difference is clear: differences with unchanged drawings follow the BOQ defect rules; drawing modifications follow the variation rules and are not exempted from adjustment by contract type (variations are adjustable under both contract types).
  • 'No adjustment' under lump-sum contracts is not absolute: items priced at provisional quantities, variations and price-adjustment events agreed in the contract remain adjustable; nor may 'uncapped risk, all risks' be agreed. For the clause chain blocking price adjustment for BOQ defects under lump-sum contracts, see the dedicated card cited by this card.
  • Under unit-rate contracts, work items priced as a whole item are not re-measured or adjusted, and the completeness and accuracy of the bill of preliminaries lies with the contractor; neither may be asserted for adjustment as a BOQ defect.
  • This card answers only 'whether adjustment is possible, under which rules, and in which direction'; the tiered calculation formulas for the 15% deviation (the Q0/Q1 comparison, the 1.15Q0 threshold, the linkage with preliminaries) and the clause system blocking lump-sum adjustment are covered in the specialist cards cited, not repeated here.

Further reading

  • 2013 edition: GB 50500-2013, Code for Valuation of Construction Works on a Bill of Quantities Basis, Clauses 4.1.2 and 4.1.3 (BOQ composition and bases), 6.1.4 and 6.2.2 (tender pricing), 8.1.1, 8.2.1, 8.2.2, 8.3.1 and 8.3.2 (measurement of the works, including the divergence between the two lump-sum contract regimes), 9.5.1, 9.6.1 and 9.6.2 (contract price adjustment and the 15% deviation), 11.2.1, 11.2.2 and 11.2.6 (bases of the final account and confirmed results entering settlement directly).
  • 2024 edition: GB/T 50500-2024, Standard for Valuation of Construction Works on a Bill of Quantities Basis, Clause 3.1.8 (BOQ liability split by contract type), 3.2.2 (composition of the all-in unit rate), 3.3.2 and 3.3.3 (lists of employer and contractor risk events), 4.1.4 (BOQ preparation and defect liability), 6.1.6 and 6.1.7 (tender checking and clarification), 7.1.1, 7.1.8, 7.2.1 and 7.2.2 (measurement of the contract works), 8.2.1 and 8.2.3 (price adjustment for BOQ defects), 8.9.1 and 8.9.2 (adjustment methods and adjustment beyond 15%).
  • Related extensions: the evolution of BOQ defect liability, the basis for determining settlement quantities, time limits for handling drawing-BOQ conflicts at tender stage, the formulas for adjusting all-in unit rates for 15% deviations in either direction, the clause chain blocking price adjustment for BOQ defects under lump-sum contracts, and the quantity and price risk boundaries of lump-sum, unit-rate and cost-plus contracts - see the cards cited by this card.

Keywords

  • errors and omissions in the BOQ
  • 按实际完成工程量计量
  • 工程量偏差15%
  • 综合单价调低调高
  • 总价合同量差不调整
  • GB 50500-2013 第8章 工程计量
  • GB/T 50500-2024 第7.2节 合同工程计量
  • 竣工结算工程量

Cited By