No price adjustment for BOQ defects in lump-sum contracts (BOQ quantities below drawings): the four-layer rule of GB/T 50500-2024 and the reversal of the 2013 edition's Clause 8.3.1 measure-and-value rule
Under GB/T 50500-2024 (effective 2025-09-01; GB 50500-2013 simultaneously repealed), BOQ quantities in lump-sum contracts below the drawings constitute a "BOQ defect" and are not adjusted during performance: 2.0.7 bars using changes in BOQ items/quantities as an adjustment basis; 3.4.6 deems defect prices included in the lump sum with contract drawings and specifications governing; 4.1.6 disallows adjustment for defect-induced price changes; 7.2.2 allows no re-measurement of the BOQ; 7.4.1 defines drawing-vs-BOQ differences as defects not adjustable. The 2013 Clause 8.3.1 (an ordinary clause, not among that edition's 15 mandatory ones) allowing measure-and-value for BOQ-tendered lump-sum contracts has been deleted and reversed. Only two openings remain: (1) items marked "provisional quantities" re-measured per unit-price rules (4.1.6, 7.2.2 item 2); (2) differences between contract drawings and as-built drawings are variations measured under 7.4.3 (7.2.2 item 3) - unchanged drawings with undercounted BOQs are no variation.
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第2.0.7条/3.4.6条/4.1.6条/7.2.2条/7.4.1条/7.4.3条
- GB 50500-2013 建设工程工程量清单计价规范 第8.3.1条/8.3.2条(已废止)
- 住建部发布公告:https://www.mohurd.gov.cn/gongkai/zc/wjk/art/2024/art_6186304e164c4c4982904f8734983235.html
Topic Positioning
Under GB/T 50500-2024 (effective 1 September 2025), the four-layer set of clauses blocking price adjustment for BOQ defects in lump-sum contracts (typically bid-listed quantities below contract drawings), and the substantive reversal from GB 50500-2013 Clause 8.3.1's measure-and-value path - for judging "can quantity differences in lump-sum contracts support adjustment claims" and the remaining openings.
Core Conclusions
I. The new edition's four-layer blockade:
- Clause 2.0.7 (term, lump-sum contract): "where the contract drawings and conditions do not change, neither party may use changes in the contract BOQ's items or quantities as a basis for price adjustment" - quantity difference alone is no ground.
- Clause 3.4.6 (basic rules): "the priced BOQ only reflects the price composition of the lump sum; where BOQ defects occur, their price is deemed included in the lump sum"; "where the contract drawings/specifications are inconsistent with the priced BOQ, the drawings/specifications govern" - the BOQ is a price breakdown; the drawings are the datum.
- Clause 4.1.6 (BOQ preparation): "price changes from BOQ defects are deemed included in the lump sum and not adjusted during performance"; tenderers must list and measure accurately from tender drawings and standards, and where drawings cannot support accurate measurement, mark the item's characteristics as "provisional quantities" with the quantity stated - actual quantities then adjust per unit-price rules.
- Clause 7.2.2 (measurement): "work-item lists need not be re-measured, and the contract price shall not be adjusted for BOQ defects in the lists." Clause 7.4.1 draws the line: "differences between contract drawings and the contract BOQ are BOQ defects... not adjustable in lump-sum works" - "BOQ less than drawings" is precisely such a difference, now classified as a defect: no adjustment.
II. Substantive reversal from 2013: GB 50500-2013 Clause 8.3.1 (ordinary, not mandatory): "for lump-sum contracts formed by BOQ tendering, quantities shall be calculated per Section 8.2", with commentary that quantities are provided by the tenderer and differences during implementation are adjusted; Clause 8.3.2 locked quantities only for lump-sum contracts formed from approved drawings and budgets. So under 2013, BOQ-tendered lump-sum contracts could claim measure-and-value. The 2024 edition deletes and reverses this - effective 1 September 2025, with GB 50500-2013 repealed (MOHURD announcement), the normative basis for "measure-and-value in lump-sum contracts" no longer exists.
III. The only two openings:
- Provisional-quantity items: work items whose characteristics state "provisional quantities" are re-measured per unit-price rules, adjusting the item price and the total (4.1.6; 7.2.2 item 2).
- Variations: differences between contract drawings and as-built drawings are variations, measured under 7.4.3 (7.2.2 item 3); unchanged drawings with undercounted BOQs are no variation.
Applicable Boundaries
- Only lump-sum contracts (priced from contract drawings and specifications); unit-price contracts follow Section 8.2 re-measurement, with the BOQ governing over drawings on inconsistency (3.4.6).
- The 2024 edition is a recommended GB/T standard - its force depends on contractual reference; but with 2013 repealed, no mandatory "measure-and-value" basis exists either way.
- Contracts signed before 2025-09-01 may still invoke 2013 Clause 8.3.1 (noting that judicial practice on lump-sum quantity differences was already split).
- Provisional quantities require explicit marking in the tender BOQ characteristics - unmarked items cannot invoke them.
Further Reading
- GB/T 50500-2024: Clauses 2.0.7 (term), 3.4.6 (basic rules), 4.1.6 (BOQ preparation), 7.2.2, 7.4.1, 7.4.3 (contract measurement and variation measurement).
- GB 50500-2013 Clauses 8.3.1-8.3.2 (repealed; for old/new comparison only).
- MOHURD announcement publishing GB/T 50500-2024 and repealing GB 50500-2013: https://www.mohurd.gov.cn/gongkai/zc/wjk/art/2024/art_6186304e164c4c4982904f8734983235.html
Keywords
- lump-sum contract
- errors and omissions in the BOQ
- 清单量差
- GB/T 50500-2024
- GB 50500-2013
- 按实计量
- provisional quantities
- variation