Judging the synonymy of the tender price ceiling and the maximum tender price ceiling, the rejection rule for tender offers above the ceiling, and the item-by-item comparison of the compilation bases of the three and the division of their roles in tender evaluation and contract price formation
The tender price ceiling (GB 50500-2013 Clause 2.0.45) and the maximum tender price ceiling (GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 2.0.19) are one and the same thing renamed: the 2013 definition itself uses 'maximum tender price ceiling' as the genus, and the 2024 definition matches item by item in compiling entity, compilation basis elements and the function of capping tender offers. The tender offer (2013 Clause 2.0.46: the lump total stated after summing the priced BOQ) is the bidder's autonomous responsive price and must fall between the cost line and the ceiling line: under Article 51 item (5) of the Implementation Regulations for the Tendering and Bidding Law (State Council Decree No. 709, 2019 revision), where a tender offer is below cost or above the maximum tender price ceiling set in the tender documents, the tender evaluation committee shall reject the bid; the corresponding pricing-standard clauses are GB 50500-2013 Clause 6.1.5 and GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 6.1.3.
Applicable Codes
- GB 50500-2013 · Code of Valuation with Bill Quantity of Construction Works 第 2.0.45、2.0.46、5.1.1、5.1.4、5.1.6、5.2.1、6.1.5、6.2.1 条
- GB/T 50500-2024 · Standard for bills of quantities and valuation for construction works 第 2.0.19、5.1.1、5.2.1、5.2.8、6.1.2、6.1.3、6.2.1 条
- 《中华人民共和国招标投标法实施条例》(国务院令第 709 号,2019 修订)第二十七条、第五十条、第五十一条
- 《建设工程质量管理条例》第十条
- 《中华人民共和国政府采购法》第三十六条
- GB/T 50875-2013 · Standard glossary of project costs 招标控制价术语条
Topic positioning
Judges whether the 'tender price ceiling' and the 'maximum tender price ceiling' are one and the same thing (with the term and clause-number mapping across the two editions), clarifies the rejection boundary between the tender offer and the ceiling, and compares item by item the compilation bases of the three and divides their roles in tender evaluation and contract price formation.
Core conclusions
I. Synonymy judgment: tender price ceiling = maximum tender price ceiling
- GB 50500-2013 Clause 2.0.45, 'tender price ceiling': 'the maximum tender price ceiling of the tendered works, compiled by the tenderer under the pricing bases and methods issued by the national or provincial or sectoral construction authorities, the tender documents as proposed and the tender BOQ, and in light of the specific conditions of the works.'
- GB 50500-2013 Clause 2.0.46, 'tender offer': 'the lump total stated by the bidder in response to the tender documents after summing the priced BOQ.'
- GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 2.0.19, 'maximum tender price ceiling': 'the highest price capping the bidders' tender offers, compiled by the tenderer under the laws and regulations of the state and the relevant standards, the provisions of the construction authorities, the tender documents as proposed and the tender BOQ, in light of the actual conditions of the works and as provided in this standard.' The commentary adds: 'the maximum tender price ceiling means the highest tender price that the tenderer can accept in response to the tender requirements.'
- Three reasons the mapping holds: (1) the 2013 definition itself uses 'maximum tender price ceiling' as its genus - the substance named 'tender price ceiling' is that ceiling; (2) the 2024 definition matches the 2013 one item by item - the compiling entity is the same (the tenderer or the cost consultant entrusted by it; 2013 Clause 5.1.2 and 2024 Clause 5.1.2 align), the basis elements are the same (tender documents + tender BOQ + pricing provisions + actual conditions of the works), the function is the same (capping the tender offer); (3) what changed is the price formation mechanism (from 'pricing quota manuals plus published cost information' to the market-oriented 'works price information, cost data and indices'), not the subject matter itself.
- Rule of use: after the 2024 edition came into force, the standard term in newly issued tender documents is 'maximum tender price ceiling'; earlier executed contracts, projects under construction and local documents still reading 'tender price ceiling (maximum tender price ceiling)' speak of the same thing, which must not be counted twice or treated as two sums on account of the renaming.
II. Compilation bases compared item by item
The maximum tender price ceiling (tender price ceiling) side:
- GB 50500-2013 Clause 5.2.1, eight items: 1 this code; 2 the pricing quota manuals and pricing methods issued by the national or provincial or sectoral construction authorities; 3 the design documents of the works and related material; 4 the tender documents as proposed and the tender BOQ; 5 the standards, codes and technical material related to the project; 6 the site conditions, the characteristics of the works and the conventional construction scheme; 7 the construction cost information published by the cost administration, or, where it publishes none, market prices by reference; 8 other relevant material. Three points are made explicit: the pricing standards and pricing policies used must be the quota manuals and related policy provisions issued by the national or provincial or sectoral construction authorities; the material prices must be the unit rates published through cost information by the cost administration, or, if unpublished, determined by market survey; charges and charge standards follow the provisions where provisions exist.
- GB 50500-2013 Clause 5.1.4: the tender price ceiling is compiled under Clause 5.2.1 and shall not be adjusted upward or floated downward (per Article 10 of the Regulations on Quality Management of Construction Works: 'the letting party of a construction work must not force the contractor to bid below cost').
- GB 50500-2013 Clause 5.1.6: the tenderer publishes the tender price ceiling when issuing the tender documents and files it, with the related material, to the cost administration at the place of the works or of the sectoral authority having jurisdiction over the works, for inspection; unlike the pre-tender estimate it requires no confidentiality.
- GB 50500-2013 Clause 5.1.1 (a mandatory provision): for construction works invested with state-owned funds put to tender, the tenderer must compile a tender price ceiling.
- GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 5.1.1: where a tender sets a maximum tender price ceiling, it is compiled under the relevant national provisions, and the ceiling together with its compilation basis is published when the tender documents are issued; it is compiled by a capable tenderer or a cost consultant entrusted by it under this standard, the national and sectoral measurement standards and the other relevant provisions, publishing the total price together with the basis and method of compilation.
- GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 5.2.1, eight items: 1 this standard and the national and sectoral measurement standards for the works concerned; 2 the tender documents (tender BOQ, contract terms, tender drawings, technical standards and the like) with their addenda, clarifications or modifications; 3 the measurement and pricing provisions issued by the national, provincial or sectoral construction authorities, and the supplementary measurement rules added as the works require; 4 the technical standards related to the tendered works; 5 the characteristics of the works and its delivery standard, the ground and hydrological data, the site conditions; 6 the reasonable construction period and the conventional processes and sequences; 7 the works price information and cost intelligence, the cost data and indices; 8 other relevant material. Compilation may also proceed from market price information and cost data in light of the actual conditions of the project, its delivery standard and the effect of the planned period on prices.
- GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 5.2.8 gives six price sources for the ceiling: (1) the prices of maximum tender price ceilings, construction-drawing budgets, design estimates or cost estimates of similar works completed recently; (2) the reasonable competitive tender unit rates recently obtained for similar works on the market; (3) the settled unit rates of similar BOQ items recently determined; (4) the contract prices of similar works recently signed; (5) the reasonable works prices for labour, materials, plant and BOQ items obtained through market price enquiry; (6) the recent market prices of labour, materials and plant in use, and the related price indices or tender price indices.
The tender offer side:
- GB 50500-2013 Clause 6.2.1, nine items: 1 this code; 2 the pricing methods issued by the national or provincial or sectoral construction authorities; 3 the contractor's in-house norms, together with the pricing quota manuals and pricing methods issued by the national or provincial or sectoral construction authorities; 4 the tender documents, the tender BOQ, and the supplementary notices and the minutes of clarification; 5 the design documents of the works and related material; 6 the site conditions, the characteristics of the works and the project execution plan or construction method statement proposed at tender; 7 the standards, codes and other technical material related to the project; 8 the market price information or the construction cost information published by the cost administration; 9 other relevant material.
- GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 6.2.1, eight items: 1 this standard and the national and sectoral measurement standards for the works concerned; 2 the tender documents (tender BOQ, contract terms, tender drawings, technical standards and the like) with their addenda, answers to queries, clarification of objections or corrections; 3 the measurement and pricing provisions issued by the national, provincial or sectoral construction authorities and the supplementary measurement rules; 4 the technical standards and other technical material related to the tendered works; 5 the characteristics of the works and its delivery standard, the ground and hydrological data and the site walk-down findings; 6 the bidder's works execution plan and tender period; 7 the bidder's in-house norms, cost data, market price information and price expectations, plant and management capability, cost intelligence; 8 other relevant material. Bidders are also required to set a tender offer that 'both reflects their own level of productivity and remains competitive'.
- GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 6.1.2: the bidder may set its tender offer autonomously under Section 6.2, is answerable for the consistency and reasonableness of the prices entered in the priced BOQ, and bears the risks of an unreasonable offer and of BOQ errors under lump-sum contracts. Clause 6.1.3: the tender offer must not be below cost and must not exceed the maximum tender price ceiling published by the tenderer; the cost of the works may be reasonably determined by reference to similar projects.
The differences in sum: (1) on the ceiling side, the basis moves from 'pricing quota manuals and methods plus cost information (market prices where none is published)' to 'works price information and cost intelligence, cost data and indices', expressly allowing compilation from similar-work cost outputs, reasonable competitive market rates, settled rates, contract prices, market enquiries and price indices (2024 Clause 5.2.8) - price formation turns market-oriented; (2) the 2024 ceiling compilation adds 'delivery standard', 'reasonable construction period and conventional processes and sequences', 'ground and hydrological data' and 'supplementary measurement rules'; (3) on the offer side both editions pair the contractor's in-house norms with the government pricing quota manuals and methods, while 2024 stresses cost data, price expectations, plant and management capability, and recasts 'project execution plan or construction method statement' as 'the bidder's works execution plan and tender period'; (4) 2024 adds the responsibility clauses - the bidder answers for consistency and reasonableness and bears BOQ-error risk under lump-sum contracts.
III. The rejection of tenders above the ceiling (clause numbers verified)
- The direct statutory basis (administrative regulation): Implementation Regulations for the Tendering and Bidding Law of the People's Republic of China (State Council Decree No. 709, 2019 revision), Article 51: 'The tender evaluation committee shall reject a bid where: (1) the tender documents are not stamped by the bidder and signed by the person in charge of the bidder; (2) a bidding consortium fails to submit the joint bidding agreement; (3) the bidder does not meet the qualification conditions set by the state or by the tender documents; (4) one and the same bidder submits two or more different tender documents or tender offers, save where the tender documents call for alternatives; (5) the tender offer is below cost or above the maximum tender price ceiling set in the tender documents; (6) the tender documents fail to respond to the substantive requirements and conditions of the tender; (7) the bidder has colluded in bidding, acted fraudulently, offered bribes or otherwise broken the law.'
- The counterparts in the pricing standards: GB 50500-2013 Clause 6.1.5, 'a tender offer above the tender price ceiling shall be rejected' (commentary: for state-invested works the tender price ceiling is the tenderer's procurement budget, may not exceed the approved estimate, and is the highest offer the tenderer can accept at tendering; the legislative spirit of Article 36 of the Government Procurement Law - 'where all offers exceed the procurement budget and the purchaser cannot pay, the bid is rejected' - is cited); GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 6.1.3, 'the tender offer must not be below cost and must not exceed the maximum tender price ceiling published by the tenderer'.
- Hierarchy note: the legal basis for rejecting a bid is Article 51 of the Implementation Regulations (administrative-regulation level); the pricing standard clauses bind compilation and contract price discipline - plead the rejection under the Implementation Regulations number.
IV. The distinct roles of the three in evaluation and contract price formation
- The maximum tender price ceiling (tender price ceiling) = the control line: the cap set by the tenderer, published with the tender documents, not confidential, not adjustable upward or floatable downward; mandatory for state-funded projects and in principle not exceeding the approved investment estimate.
- The tender offer = the responsive price (the object compared at evaluation): set autonomously by the bidder, who answers for its consistency and reasonableness; it must fall between the cost line and the ceiling line - below cost or above the ceiling is a statutory ground for rejection. The pre-tender estimate (where one is set) is but an evaluation reference: proximity to it may not be made a condition of award, nor may departure from its float range be made a ground for rejection.
- The basis of the contract price: the successful bidder's tender offer (the priced BOQ), after the letter of acceptance and the signing of the contract, forms the basis of the contracted price; the ceiling itself never enters the contract price, it only caps it.
Boundaries of applicability
- GB/T 50500-2024 is a voluntary standard: contractual agreements and local mandatory provisions consistent with it are followed as agreed. GB 50500-2013 has been replaced by the 2024 edition; projects whose tender documents were issued or whose contracts were signed before the 2024 edition still follow the 2013 clauses - clause numbers of the two editions must not be cited across.
- 'The tender price ceiling shall not be adjusted upward or floated downward' is the express provision of GB 50500-2013 Clause 5.1.4; Chapter 5 of GB/T 50500-2024 carries no counterpart, so on 2024 projects the plea must rest on Article 27 of the Implementation Regulations (a tenderer that sets a maximum tender price ceiling shall state in the tender documents the ceiling or the method of calculating it) and on local cost regulations - the 2013 clause number cannot be cited directly.
- GB/T 50500-2024 Clause 5.1.1 is worded conditionally ('where a maximum tender price ceiling is set') and drops the 2013 Clause 5.1.1 mandatory line 'state-funded projects must compile one'; whether a ceiling must be set is judged under the tendering and bidding regulations and the local rules.
- Rejection attaches only to the two price situations, 'above the maximum tender price ceiling' and 'below cost'; Article 27 of the Implementation Regulations expressly provides that 'the tenderer may not set a minimum tender price ceiling' - a bid may not be rejected for falling below a minimum ceiling, and findings of below-cost bidding carry their own evidentiary demands.
- The tender price ceiling (maximum tender price ceiling) differs from the pre-tender estimate: the tenderer may decide for itself whether to compile one; one tender project may have but one pre-tender estimate; it must be kept confidential (Implementation Regulations Article 27); where one is set it is announced at bid opening and serves only as an evaluation reference - proximity to it may not be a condition of award, nor may departure from its float range be a ground for rejecting a bid (Article 50 of those Regulations).
Further reading
- GB 50500-2013, code for BOQ pricing of construction works: Clauses 2.0.45 and 2.0.46 (terms); 5.1.1, 5.1.4, 5.1.6 and 5.2.1 (tender price ceiling); 6.1.5 and 6.2.1 (tender offer).
- GB/T 50500-2024, standard for BOQ pricing of construction works: Clause 2.0.19 (term); 5.1.1, 5.2.1 and 5.2.8 (compiling the maximum tender price ceiling); 6.1.2, 6.1.3 and 6.2.1 (compiling the tender offer).
- Implementation Regulations for the Tendering and Bidding Law of the People's Republic of China (State Council Decree No. 709, 2019 revision): Article 27 (pre-tender estimate and maximum tender price ceiling; no minimum ceiling), Article 50 (announcement of the estimate and its reference role), Article 51 (grounds for rejecting bids).
- Regulations on Quality Management of Construction Works, Article 10 (no forcing bidders below cost); Government Procurement Law of the People's Republic of China, Article 36 (offers exceeding the procurement budget are rejected).
- For terminology, see GB/T 50875-2013, standard for construction cost terminology, entry 'tender price ceiling' - the same definition as in the 2013 pricing code.
Keywords
- tender price ceiling
- tender (priced offer)
- 否决投标
- 废标
- GB 50500-2013
- GB/T 50500-2024
- 招标投标法实施条例第五十一条