Bid-price clarification or explanation mechanism in GB/T 50500-2024 (Section 3.5): seven arithmetic-error correction rules and omitted/unpriced items, vs GB 50500-2013 Clauses 6.1.4/6.2.7
GB/T 50500-2024 adds Section 3.5 "clarification or explanation of bid prices": between opening and award, bidders may be asked to clarify arithmetic errors, minor deviations, price reasonableness, and completeness (omissions), but the total bid and substantive contents are locked (no change to scope, duration, contract conditions, total price, or bid duration). 3.5.2 gives seven arithmetic-correction rules (words over figures, total over list sum, prime sums per the tender list, unit price over amount, etc.); 3.5.4 provides that omissions in lump-sum/preliminaries/per-item lists are deemed included in other items and the total, while unit-price work-item omissions may be clarified and added with the amount deducted from the preliminaries total - replacing 2013's coarse treatment under 6.1.4 (mandatory) and 6.2.7 ("reject the bid, or deem included with no settlement adjustment").
Applicable Codes
- GB/T 50500-2024 建设工程工程量清单计价标准 第3.5.1~3.5.4条
- GB 50500-2013 建设工程工程量清单计价规范 第6.1.4条、第6.2.7条
- 中华人民共和国招标投标法实施条例 第52条
Topic Positioning
The new "clarification or explanation of bid prices" mechanism of Section 3.5 of GB/T 50500-2024: procedures and correction rules for four problem classes - arithmetic errors, minor deviations, reasonableness doubts, and omissions (incl. the seven 3.5.2 rules) - compared with GB 50500-2013 6.1.4 (mandatory) and 6.2.7, answering "did 2024 add a post-opening clarification mechanism, and how exactly are errors corrected".
Core Conclusions
Procedural frame (3.5.1): clarification/explanation occurs between bid opening and award. (1) For bids not substantially responsive, the report shall list the non-responsive contents and deviations for the evaluation (or award) committee to decide invalidity per the tender documents; "the process may not require bidders to convert non-responsive bids into responsive ones by confirmation or withdrawal". (2) For responsive bids, clarification may be requested on arithmetic errors, minor deviations, reasonableness, and completeness (omissions), but "the works scope, duration requirements, and contract conditions set by the tender documents may not be changed, nor may the total bid price or bid duration be modified". (3) The process shall be documented in writing as a report for the committee's reference. (4) Clarification targets the price only; responsiveness, completeness, and detailed evaluation remain with the committee.
Arithmetic correction (3.5.2, seven rules): general rule - "arithmetic errors and minor deviations may be corrected as follows, but the total bid price shall not be adjusted in any way; the corrected summed total shall equal the total in the bid letter":
- Words vs figures in the bid letter: words prevail; correct the figures.
- Total vs accumulated list prices: the total prevails; correct the list sum.
- Provisional sums and prime sums in the bid vs the tender BOQ: the tender BOQ amounts prevail; if not invalidated, correct the bid accordingly.
- Item amount vs quantity x unit rate: the unit rate prevails; but if amount/quantity matches the same item's rate elsewhere, or the rate has an obvious decimal error, the amount prevails and the rate is corrected.
- Item rate vs rate-analysis sheet: the priced BOQ's item rate/price prevails; correct the analysis sheet.
- VAT is recomputed on the corrected arithmetic totals of the work-item, preliminaries, and other-items lists (excluding specialist prime sums) times the rate.
- If the corrected total still differs from the bid letter, the difference is apportioned onto work-item rates and amounts in proportion to their share of the work-item list total (excluding material prime-sum items); the corrected rates may serve as the basis for progress-payment and variation pricing, with material prime sums inside the rates still per the tender list.
Reasonableness (3.5.3): clarification may be requested where (1) item rates with material prime sums are unreasonably low/high versus similar items; (2) rates for employer-supplied materials installed by the contractor are unreasonably high/low; (3) work-item rates deviate unreasonably from competitive market prices of similar works (proof of not below cost may be demanded). Bidders may also be asked to provide, without changing the total, corrected reasonable rates for quantity changes and variations, for the committee's reference.
Omissions (3.5.4): (1) unpriced lump-sum work-item items are deemed included in other items and the total, with no re-pricing or adjustment at settlement; (2) unpriced preliminaries or per-item work items, likewise; (3) unpriced unit-price work items may be clarified, the added amount deducted from the preliminaries total without affecting the contractor's preliminaries obligations or lump-sum nature; if the preliminaries total is insufficient, the shortfall is apportioned onto work-item rates and amounts. Closing: corrected rates may be used during performance but do not substantially change the total bid.
Versus 2013: 6.1.4 (mandatory): "Bidders must price per the tender BOQ; codes, names, characteristics, units, and quantities must match." 6.2.7: "All items requiring unit rates and amounts shall be priced with exactly one price each; unpriced items are deemed included in other priced items and may not be re-priced or adjusted at settlement." 2013 gave no concrete arithmetic-correction rules - practice defaulted to rejection or "deemed included, no adjustment". 2024 concretizes the clarification mechanism of Implementation Regulations Article 52 into pricing rules, defining the clarifiable scope and the seven rules, with the total still locked and substantive contents unchanged.
Applicable Boundaries
- Only for the evaluation/award stage between opening and award; pre-deadline bid modifications are outside it.
- Clarification is limited to the four classes; no change to scope, duration, contract conditions, total price, or bid duration.
- Non-responsive bids cannot be converted by confirmation or withdrawal; invalidity is for the committee to decide per the documents.
- 3.5.2 corrections presuppose "no adjustment of the total"; the corrected total must match the bid letter; apply the rule matching each error type.
- Corrected rates may be used in performance but must not substantially change the total.
- 2013 6.1.4 was mandatory; 2024 is recommended (GB/T) - documents and contracts may impose stricter terms; execution follows the tender documents.
Further Reading
- GB/T 50500-2024 Section 3.5.1-3.5.4 (Chapter 3 basic provisions).
- GB 50500-2013 6.1.4 (mandatory), 6.2.7 (Chapter 6 bid pricing).
- Statutory basis: Implementation Regulations Article 52 - the committee may seek written clarification of ambiguous contents and obvious textual or computational errors, without exceeding the bid's scope or changing its substance.
Keywords
- 投标报价澄清
- 算术误差
- 细微偏差
- 漏报
- 投标总价
- GB/T 50500-2024
- 清单计价标准
- 3.5节