After winning at a low price: can the contract price be adjusted for omissions, miscalculations or pricing errors - liability and adjustment rules for three scenarios
A low price alone is no ground for adjustment; what matters is what was omitted, who is liable, and the contract pricing form: (i) a lawful low bid at or above cost is valid and cannot be adjusted for losses - bidding below cost leads to invalidity of the award rather than price adjustment; (ii) tenderer-side BOQ omissions: adjustable under unit-rate contracts (Section 8.2), not adjustable under lump-sum contracts; (iii) the bidder's own miscalculations or pricing errors: in principle no adjustment (omitted costs are deemed included in other items and are not repriced at settlement).
Applicable Codes
- 《招标投标法》第33条
- GB/T 50500-2024 第3.5.2/3.5.4/6.1.6/8.1.1/8.2.1/8.2.3/8.9.2条
- 《招标投标法实施条例》第57条
- 《工程建设项目施工招标投标办法》第53条
- 《民法典》第147、151条
Topic Positioning
Answers 'after winning at a low price, can the contract price be adjusted for omissions, miscalculations or pricing errors': first distinguish whether the omission lies in the tenderer's BOQ or in the bidder's pricing, then allocate liability by the contract pricing form - the rules of the three scenarios differ entirely.
Core Conclusions
(i) The low bid itself: a low price not below the enterprise's individual cost is a lawful and valid competitive outcome; the contract price is fixed at the award price and may not be raised on the ground of 'losses'; the legal consequence of bidding below cost is invalidity of the award, not price adjustment, and proving the cost is extremely difficult, so such claims are rarely supported in practice. (ii) Tenderer-side BOQ omissions or miscalculations (BOQ defects): under unit-rate contracts, the completeness and accuracy of the divisional list items, descriptions and quantities are the tenderer's responsibility, and defects adjust the contract price per Section 8.2 (deviations within 15% at the original all-in unit rate; the portion beyond 15% adjusted per Clause 8.9.2); under lump-sum contracts they are the bidder's responsibility and, except items marked 'provisional quantity', the contract price does not adjust for BOQ defects. (iii) The bidder's own miscalculations or pricing errors: arithmetic errors at evaluation are corrected per the rules (where figures and words are inconsistent, words prevail; where unit price multiplied by quantity mismatches the total, the unit price prevails; obvious decimal-point misplacement is corrected per the total), but the total tender price may not be adjusted; after award, the costs of omitted items are deemed included in the all-in unit rates of the other BOQ items and in the tender total, and are neither repriced nor adjusted at settlement. Rescission of the contract for major misunderstanding or obvious unfairness (Civil Code, Articles 147 and 151) is practically unavailing in the tendering context - bidding is a professional act and the price is a substantive term of the tender documents. (iv) Signing another agreement after award that departs from the substantive terms of the awarded contract, such as its price (yin-yang contracts), is void; settlement is still executed per the awarded contract.
Applicable Boundaries
Applies to projects tendered under the BOQ pricing mode (after implementation of GB/T 50500-2024; the GB 50500-2013 rules are structurally identical). Not applicable to: lawful low-price competition at or above cost (no room for adjustment); portions of lump-sum contracts that the bidder has itself supplemented and completed in its pricing; contracts with other express agreements, which prevail. Losses after a low award should be recovered through statutory adjustment events - variations, new works, price and legal changes, provisional price determination, claims - not by demands to adjust because 'we bid at a loss'.
Further Reading
Tendering and Bidding Law, Article 33; GB/T 50500-2024, Clause 3.5.2 (arithmetic error correction), Clause 3.5.4 (treatment of omitted items), Clause 6.1.6 (unit-rate BOQ liability), Clauses 8.1.1, 8.2.1, 8.2.3 and 8.9.2 (defect price adjustment); Implementation Regulations of the Tendering and Bidding Law, Article 57 (no departure from the substantive terms of the awarded contract); Measures for Tendering and Bidding of Construction Project Works, Article 53; Civil Code, Articles 147 and 151.
Keywords
- 低价中标
- adjustment of the contract price
- 清单漏项
- 报价漏算
- 报价错误
- below-cost tendering
- 中标价
- 漏报项目