Whether a below-cost tender price renders a construction contract void -- the validity transmission chain from evaluation-stage rejection (Bidding Law Art. 33; Implementation Regulations Art. 51) to void award (Art. 41) to void contract (Construction Contract Interpretation I Art. 1; Civil Code Art. 153), a scenario comparison, and price compensation after invalidity
A below-cost offer is in itself only a ground for rejection at the evaluation stage (Bidding Law Art. 33; Implementation Regulations Art. 51(5)); it does not of itself render the construction contract void. Invalidity requires three-step transmission: below cost -> the evaluation committee must reject the bid (or the bidder is nonetheless awarded) -> the award is void for failing Bidding Law Art. 41(2) ('the lowest evaluated tender price, except those below cost') -> the construction contract is void under Construction Contract Interpretation I Art. 1(3) ('the award is void') and Civil Code Art. 153(1). Where the bidder is not awarded, no contract is formed; where below-cost cannot be proven, the contract is valid; where the contract is void but the works pass acceptance, the contractor is compensated by reference to the agreed contract price (Civil Code Art. 793).
Applicable Codes
- 《中华人民共和国招标投标法》(主席令第21号)第33条、第41条
- 《中华人民共和国招标投标法实施条例》(国务院令第709号,2019修订)第51条
- 《建筑工程施工发包与承包计价管理办法》(住建部令第16号,2014年2月1日施行)第10、11条
- 《评标委员会和评标方法暂行规定》(七部委令第12号,2013修改)第21条
- 《工程建设项目施工招标投标办法》(七部委令第30号)第86条
- 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(一)》(法释〔2020〕25号)第1条
- 《最高人民法院关于审理建设工程施工合同纠纷案件适用法律问题的解释(二)》(法释〔2026〕12号)第23条
- 《中华人民共和国民法典》第153条第1款、第793条
- 《中华人民共和国民事诉讼法》(2023修正)第67条
Positioning
Answers whether a below-cost tender directly renders a construction contract void: a below-cost price is in itself only a rejection ground at the evaluation stage, and invalidity arises only through the transmission 'bid rejected -> (award nonetheless made or award found void) -> void award -> breach of a mandatory validity provision -> void contract'; conclusions and statutory bases are given scenario by scenario.
Core conclusion
1. Conclusion: not directly. A below-cost offer is an evaluation-stage rejection rule (an administrative norm); it is neither equivalent to a 'void award' nor does it automatically trigger contract invalidity. Every link must be present: if the bid was rejected at evaluation and not awarded, no contract was ever formed and no validity question arises; only where, on a project subject to mandatory tendering, that bidder was nonetheless determined as the winner (or the award is found void) does the chain 'void award -> void construction contract' run.
2. The four-link chain of validity, with statutory texts
- Prohibition -- Tendering and Bidding Law of the PRC (here 'Bidding Law') Art. 33: 'Bidders shall not compete with offers below cost, bid in the name of another person, or obtain the award by impersonation or other fraudulent means.'
- Rejection at evaluation: Implementation Regulations for the Tendering and Bidding Law (here 'Implementation Regulations') Art. 51: 'The evaluation committee shall reject a bid under any of the following circumstances: ... (5) the tender price is below cost or above the tender price ceiling set in the tender documents ...'. MOHURD Decree No. 16 Art. 10: 'The tender price shall be neither below the cost of the works nor above the tender price ceiling.' Art. 11: 'Where the tender price is below the cost of the works or above the total of the tender price ceiling, the evaluation committee shall reject the bidder's bid. On objections as to whether a price is below the cost of the works, the evaluation committee may evaluate by reference to the relevant provisions issued by the housing and urban-rural development authorities of the State Council and of the provinces, autonomous regions and municipalities directly under the Central Government.'
- Void award -- Bidding Law Art. 41: 'The winning bid shall satisfy one of the following conditions: (1) it maximises satisfaction of the comprehensive evaluation criteria specified in the tender documents; (2) it meets the substantive requirements of the tender documents and its evaluated tender price is the lowest; except that a tender price below cost is excluded.' (A below-cost bid fails the statutory conditions for award, and an award determined on it is void.)
- Void contract -- SPC Interpretation on Issues Concerning the Application of Law in the Trial of Construction Contract Dispute Cases (I) (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25) Art. 1: 'A construction contract shall be found void under Article 153(1) of the Civil Code where: (1) the contractor has not obtained a construction enterprise qualification or exceeds its qualification grade; (2) an actual constructor without qualification borrows the name of a qualified construction enterprise; (3) a project that must be tendered under law was not tendered, or the award is void.' Civil Code Art. 153(1): 'A civil juristic act performed in violation of the mandatory provisions of laws or administrative regulations is void, except where that mandatory provision does not render the act void.'
Key distinction: what serves as the entry into Civil Code Art. 153(1) as a 'mandatory provision affecting validity' is the 'void award' (Interpretation I Art. 1(3)), not the pricing obligation in Bidding Law Art. 33 itself.
3. Consequences of a void award (original text of Art. 86 of Seven-Ministry Decree No. 30): 'Where a project subject to mandatory tendering under law violates the law and the award is void, the winning bidder shall be redetermined from the remaining bidders according to the statutory award conditions, or the tender shall be re-run according to law. Where the award is void, the notice of award issued and the contract signed have no legal binding force from the beginning, but this does not affect the validity of the clauses in the contract that independently concern methods of dispute resolution.'
4. How 'below cost' is determined -- the bidder's individual cost, not the social average cost Provisional Provisions on Tender Evaluation Committees and Evaluation Methods (Seven-Ministry Decree No. 12, 2013 revision) Art. 21: 'During evaluation, where the evaluation committee finds that a bidder's price is manifestly lower than the other bid prices or, where a benchmark price has been set, manifestly below the benchmark price, so that its tender price may be below its individual cost, it shall require the bidder to give a written explanation and provide relevant supporting materials. Where the bidder cannot give a reasonable explanation or provide the relevant materials, the evaluation committee shall find that the bidder has competed with an offer below cost and shall reject its bid.' Hence below the benchmark price, below the social average cost or below the quota-based price does not by itself amount to 'below cost'; the test is the bidder's individual cost, procedurally: written explanation plus evidence first, then the finding. Where the party alleging below-cost cannot prove it, under Civil Procedure Law Art. 67 ('a party has the responsibility to provide evidence for its own claims'), its invalidity claim is unlikely to be supported.
5. Scenario comparison table (scenario x conclusion x basis)
| Scenario | Conclusion | Basis |
|---|---|---|
| Project subject to mandatory tendering; below-cost bid rejected at evaluation but the bidder nonetheless awarded, or the award found void | Construction contract void | Bidding Law Arts. 33, 41(2); Implementation Regulations Art. 51(5); Interpretation I Art. 1(3); Civil Code Art. 153(1); Seven-Ministry Decree No. 30 Art. 86 |
| Project subject to mandatory tendering; bid rejected at evaluation, not awarded | No contract formed; no invalidity question (culpa in contrahendo or bid security disputes may arise) | Implementation Regulations Art. 51(5); Decree No. 16 Art. 11; Seven-Ministry Decree No. 12 Arts. 21, 27 |
| Low bid awarded, but the alleging party cannot prove it is below the enterprise's individual cost | Contract valid | Civil Procedure Law Art. 67; Seven-Ministry Decree No. 12 Art. 21 (individual cost + written-explanation procedure) |
| Project not subject to mandatory tendering (voluntary tendering or direct contracting) with a low bid | Contract valid; not void merely for being 'below cost' | Application of Bidding Law Arts. 33 and 41 presupposes a tendering procedure and a statutory scope of mandatory tendering |
| Only below the benchmark price by a reasonable margin, or below the social average cost / the quota-based price, but not below its individual cost | Does not constitute 'below cost' under Art. 33; contract valid | Bidding Law Art. 33; Seven-Ministry Decree No. 12 Art. 21 |
| Below-cost bid wins, contract found void, but the works pass acceptance | Still void, but the contractor may be compensated by reference to the agreed contract price of the works | Civil Code Art. 793(1) |
| Works fail acceptance | Repaired and passing: the employer may claim the repair costs from the contractor; repaired and still failing: the contractor has no right to compensation by reference to the agreed contract price; an employer at fault for the loss from the unqualified works bears corresponding liability | Civil Code Art. 793(2) |
| Below cost accompanied by collusion, fraud or bribery | Void award -> void contract (an independent and clearer ground of invalidity) | Bidding Law Art. 33 second part; Implementation Regulations Art. 51(7); Seven-Ministry Decree No. 12 Art. 20 |
(Civil Code Art. 793(1): 'Where a construction contract is void but the construction works have passed acceptance, the contractor may be compensated by reference to the agreement on the price of the works.' Paragraph 2: 'Where a construction contract is void and the construction works have failed acceptance, the following applies: (1) where the works pass acceptance after repair, the employer may request the contractor to bear the repair costs; (2) where the works still fail acceptance after repair, the contractor has no right to request compensation by reference to the agreement on the price of the works. Where the employer is at fault for losses caused by the unqualified works, it shall bear corresponding liability.')
6. Time cut-off between the old and new rules (original text of Art. 23 of Fa Shi [2026] No. 12): 'This Interpretation takes effect on 30 June 2026. For first-instance construction contract dispute cases newly accepted by the people's courts after this Interpretation takes effect, this Interpretation applies. After this Interpretation takes effect, where earlier judicial interpretations of the Supreme People's Court are inconsistent with it, this Interpretation prevails.' Hence first-instance cases newly accepted after 30 June 2026 apply Interpretation II, which prevails over Interpretation I where inconsistent; cases accepted earlier remain governed by Interpretation I. The scope of price compensation after invalidity (amount, pricing method, payment time, adjustment method, settlement method) is determined by the interpretation applicable at the time of acceptance.
Scope and limits
- The 'void' conclusions on this card apply only to projects subject to mandatory tendering where invalidity is transmitted through a 'void award'; projects not subject to mandatory tendering and directly contracted projects are not void for a below-cost price.
- What is negated is the 'void award' link, not the pricing obligation of Art. 33 itself; invoking Art. 33 alone to claim invalidity is generally not supported.
- 'Below cost' means below the bidder's individual cost, to be established through the evaluation committee's written-explanation-plus-evidence procedure; below the benchmark price, below the social average cost or below the quota-based price does not automatically mean below cost.
- Awarded but contract not yet signed: a void award means there is no contract, and the only routes are redetermining the winner from the remaining bidders or re-tendering. Where a signed contract is found void and the works pass acceptance, compensation follows Civil Code Art. 793 by reference to the contract -- not settlement on actual costs or re-pricing on the quota manuals.
- A below-cost price is not a ground for later 'price adjustment': where a low price is validly awarded because it is not below cost, the contract price may not later be adjusted on grounds of loss (see the companion card on omitted-item adjustment after low-price awards).
Further reading
Tendering and Bidding Law (Presidential Decree No. 21) Arts. 33, 41; Implementation Regulations for the Tendering and Bidding Law (State Council Decree No. 709, 2019 revision) Art. 51; Measures for the Administration of Pricing in Construction Letting and Contracting (MOHURD Decree No. 16) Arts. 10-11; Provisional Provisions on Tender Evaluation Committees and Evaluation Methods (Seven-Ministry Decree No. 12, 2013 revision) Art. 21; Measures for the Tendering of Construction Project Works (Seven-Ministry Decree No. 30) Art. 86; Interpretation I (Fa Shi [2020] No. 25) Art. 1; Interpretation II (Fa Shi [2026] No. 12) Art. 23; Civil Code Arts. 153(1), 793; Civil Procedure Law (2023 amendment) Art. 67. For the exact boundaries of mandatory tendering see the Provisions on Projects Subject to Mandatory Tendering (NDRC Decree No. 16) Arts. 2-5 and the Provisions on the Scope of Infrastructure and Public Utility Projects Subject to Mandatory Tendering.
Keywords
- 投标报价低于成本
- 中标无效
- 建设工程施工合同无效
- 招标投标法第33条
- 招标投标法第41条
- 民法典153条
- 建工解释一第一条
- 个别成本